2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 138
We talked about the plan. Implementing the plan is one of the most important pieces, too, so that you can reduce that deficit. Don't use the onetime money for ongoing expenditures. I mean, this has kind of been a recurring theme tonight. Um, but use that FHR to prioritize the areas. And I would start in that very front section. I think page eight and nine is what we talked about, the material weaknesses. Okay? You may not be able to conquer every single note. All right? But those are the ones I would tackle first, right? Because those are the ones that we've identified as an organization that definitely increases you you your risk the most. And then you can make a plan for the others. But I would definitely focus on those. Um so so that's one way that's something that you can do. Uh what was I going to say?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 139
I apologize. I lost my train of thought. I I I just want to reiterate it one more time though. Um the FH is a great tool. You can do it yourself. You guys can, you know, you get a few months down the line, you can go ahead and plug in your answers and see if those have changed. You definitely want to try to get every single You want to try to get enough nos into to yeses that it brings you down into the low risk range. All right. We don't see the district as going off the cliff right now. That's That's not We do some of these and we're on the phone going, "Oh my gosh, we have a district up north that just went insolvent, Bloomish Unified, and that happened quickly." And it was a phone call and within probably three months they were asking for an emergency appropriation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 140
And so we see districts like that that are ready to go off the cliff. We really don't feel like Apple Valley is that district. No. Do you guys have some things you need to work on? Absolutely. Is it going to take the people in this room working together? Absolutely. But you got to figure out a way to get there. Okay. Otherwise, your kids are going to lose out. I do want to go back to uh questions. Do you have your questions? Okay. Hand me yours. >> No, that's okay. All right. So, we had in the previous presentation, before I get to any additional questions here, in the previous uh presentation, I just want to make sure we answered all the questions. We left some of them out because we thought that this answered it, but I'm just going to ask them one more time and make sure that you're comfortable with what we presented.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 141
So, under risk level set assessment, how does FCMAT rate current risk level? I think we talked about that. So, I think you're probably good there. Yes. Uh if the ratings moderate or high, what steps? Steps would be taking a look at the nos, right? Especially the material weaknesses and see if you can get those two yeses. Definitely. Um, did I answer everything? I think I did. I'm going back through them. Recommend. I think we did. Did you have any others outstanding that I did not answer between our last presentation and this one? I apologize. >> The only one that you didn't answer and you explained why was the staffing. >> Okay, there you go. Okay. I just wanted to make sure we'd hit all of them. there is one of yours that we couldn't get to a a a number, but we're going to get with you and we're going to answer that question for you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 142
Okay? We'll do that individually. All right. Any questions that anybody has? >> I'll start with a question here. Um appreciate the first off appreciate the time and effort you guys put into this. >> So on page 11, summary of current conditions, deficit spending is increasing. >> Yes. I I heard uh is there any other districts uh do they set is there some way do they set policy stating that uh they will not ever deficit spend a board a board sets a policy you know such as we have a 5% rule for reserves three but >> would that be something that you've seen in the past I mean >> I personally have not have you seen any >> yeah set a policy that they're not deficit spending I haven't seen that. >> Okay. >> I've never seen a district do that. I think you have so many variables that I think sometimes there can be unplanned deficit spending.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 143
But >> that's why the question would be Yeah, there's always something that's going to happen. >> There there can be you want to do your best to avoid that. Yeah. Right. Absolutely. Just like with a personal finance at home, you do your best to avoid it, but there can be something that comes up and you could have all your ducks in a row and something can come up. that yes, you want to plan for no deficit spending. That should be the plan. >> Okay. So, and also you wrote there is no board approved plan to reduce and or eliminate deficit spending. So, if your recommendations, if this board wants to move forward with >> putting a plan together to reduce that, would you start with like a budget workshop where it's just strictly we're going to just hammer down on this this issue and is that that would be the way to begin it?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 144
>> I I think you know what we talked about before in terms of like a budget advisory committee, it has to be coming together. There has to be a >> there has to >> be some stakeholders involved. >> Stakeholders. Yeah. Educational partners um across the board. There has to be a level of understanding first though. So, you're going to have to lay a foundation that people in the room have a basic understanding, which means you're going to have to educate them and walk them through and and so that everybody has an understanding of what that means, what those numbers mean, >> and then start the process of trying to prioritize things within the district, things that you definitely want to keep, things that they may recommend that you're going to make cuts to programs or to staffing or things like that, and they would come forward with recommendations to do.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 145
I think you covered that earlier that that would be the way to go forward. >> Yeah, I think that that's >> like there's no sacred towels allowed. >> I know. I'm sorry about that line. [laughter] >> Okay, great. Thank you. Any uh are there board members questions? >> Yeah, I do. I have a question. >> Oh, Maria. Yeah, go ahead. >> Okay. >> Um, of course, my question always comes from the packet that you sent to us. So, I'm not going to deal with the packet because I think we are going to have to um visit the packet differently and all of us will have the opportunity to look at all of the lines that you brought up in your packet. The packet that >> are you talking about the sax document packet? >> The document you sent us. Uh but what I'm looking at is do we as a board do we as a board need to um Oh, yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 146
Made a copy. I don't have paper. Um, do we as a board need to um have an approved calendar to be able to have know exactly when each of these items must occur? >> It is that's one of the things that we did have in there. Um, we didn't necessarily highlight it, but yes, we would we would expect every district to have a budget calendar as well as a governance calendar, right? So you as a board should have a governance calendar of what you're covering when. For the budget cycle, there should be a calendar so that all all the the people involved. You are going to need um attendance. You are going to need uh to talk to food service, to talk to transportation to see if there's any specific needs that they can identify that needs to be built into the budget. So, so you can have so it talks about it'll put things on the calendar in terms of conversations in terms of when things are due so that everyone that is involved in has to offer pieces to the district of information that they would use to build that budget on everybody's aware of that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 147
So, yeah, that's one of the things. >> Shayen, one of the things you shared with us in the exit interview was um uh position control. Yes, >> we do position control on a regular basis, but we don't have it calendared to as an event in the district. And so we're working through that as a topic of it doesn't matter who's sitting in that role. This is our calendar. This is when we do it and everybody understands that that's >> and that's exactly why you have a calendar because it can be in somebody's brain. And we do that as organizations way too often that one person has all the information. They're doing it. They're doing those things. They know when those things are due. But if that person happens to get, you know, hit by a bus or they don't come back tomorrow, I'm not going to say that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 148
I apologize. [laughter] I didn't mean that. Um, but if they don't if they don't show up for work tomorrow, what I mean, what position would you be in? You'd be scrambling. And we never want districts to have to scramble. We want people to know. We have that in our organization. I'm going to say we're addressing that as an organization that things land in certain people's seats that they own and then we don't cross train and we don't do those things. It needs to happen. Yeah. >> Thank you. I do have questions, but I'm just waiting for anybody else who has a question. >> Okay. No. Okay. Um, coming back to the budget, um, I noticed that in our budget development and adoption, you didn't have um, a lot of concerns. So, I'm wondering if there are no concerns notice noted. Um, and I know you mentioned that if there are things that can happen that are out of the ordinary.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 149
Um but it seems like it's consistently significantly off. Um what are the questions that we need to ask to find out why? >> So So can I just ask when you say it's consistently off what are you talking about in between what what's consistently off? Can you clarify that for me? So, our projected budget, and I look at budgets of other school districts, too, and they don't have the huge discrepancy, and I'm speaking as a member of a of the board, as we're looking at a budget and projecting our spending for the year and understanding what we have coming in and what we can anticipate going out, we're making decisions from that place of knowing. And so, being off by $20 million is significant. you know, we could be um not spending when maybe we did have the money. Um and so that's my that's my question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 150
What are the what are if if nothing is a concern as far as how we're building our budget being off by this much, how can we correct that? because I think it's important for us to be informed >> and I would agree with you and and I think that as board members one of the things that that you need to to do as well is to um to listen to the same information that that the district is listening to. So if the district is going to let's say school services January governor's budget and they go back and they do the May revise and and I think they're moving to um possibly a a virtual format in the future. Um, I know they did it during COVID and then they went back to in person. I would say, do you have to attend that conference? Maybe, maybe not.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 151
If you can't go get your hands on the materials because they're going through the information that is important for school districts to know, board members to know. So, you're looking at that. So, then when the district brings forward the adopted budget, you're looking at the assumptions. You're saying, "Okay, is this matching what's on their dart board?" Right? What are the things that are happening? Um, so it again it comes back to what are the assumptions that that budget is built on? Are they reasonable and um, so I'd be asking for that information. Do you have anything to add to that? I I think I've kind of already talked about it um, in that the budget's always changing and the minute we print it. Okay. So we give you I say we the district brings you first interim December 15th and then the governor's budget comes out January 20th, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 152
And so everything we just put in the assumptions could be different. And so there's big changes, big variances, what have you. The colas could change. So it's impacting your multi-year. Um I think in this situation, honestly, it's just going to be building that trust and building that communication and the transparency in the reports. Um I don't know how the other district made theirs so perfect. If you're if you're comparing their estimated with their unodudited, then then they really do um a really good job of I'm going to say cleaning up the dollars probably from the sites. Um and managing some of their books and supplies and services and what have you. Um again, I'm focusing on more of the unrestricted. So the restricted dollars, the variances over there, I'm not saying they're not important, but there's a lot of reasons for it. There's a lot to understand, which I think the budget advisory will be helpful in understanding how federal dollars work and how those expenditures and that dollars accounted for.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 153
So again, federal dollars, we think we're getting them all and we think we're spending them all. So, we have a million dollars in federal dollars and we're going to spend them all. But you only book at the end of the year what you spent. So, if we didn't spend the million dollars and we only spent a half, your revenues are going to be off a half million dollars. And it's because you cannot claim dollars that you have not spent with the feds. Um, again, there's various programs that are like that. It's a whole indepth thing. Um, I won't go into all of that, but it can cause variances in your revenues. For example, in where the feds federal revenue is tracked. Um, you make a plan to spend it all and sometimes it just doesn't happen. So, I would focus more on the variances and the unrestricted and maybe just kind of ask what's going on in the restricted and again staff's going to be able to tell you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 154
So, I just think because the questions, right, they kind of are focused around that same thing. What's the discrepancies? Why are there big suings? What's why if we're budgeting this, why did we only do this? I I really think that's just again kind of building the relationships and the collaboration and transparency of those reports and working together. And one more thing I would suggest to um we didn't mention this to the district before in our exit interview, but um I'm assuming you're probably a client of school services on the fiscal report. Maybe I would forward those to your board members because a lot of times they will do a fiscal report on things that are coming out or changes that need to be known for districts. That's why they're sending out that fiscal report. I would I would forward those on to your board members so that they get that same information because it's just some really good information about things that change throughout the year too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 155
A lot of times they will highlight those changes. >> Yeah. Um thank you. I do attend all the budget workshops. I'm very active with being informed on the state of our our finances from the federal and the and our state. Um, so I will look to continue to ask questions and make sure that we're making reasonable um, predictions. Thank you for that. Um, I do have a question on your budget monitoring and updates. Um, so when these uh, changes happen throughout the year and I know you talked about um, that's a sign of a healthy budget. Um, it's it's it's going to reflect changes. It's going to be revisited. Um but when these changes are made um and now I'm talking significant changes um it's being done without um board knowledge or approval and my concern is that um if it's not being brought to our attention and I know I brought it up at the last staff meeting um we're not aware of the most current state of what's happening with our budget and and therefore it's not we're not making informed decisions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 156
Correct. Um so is that normal like that boards would be making decisions without be being updated on uh the budget adjustments that are being made consistently over time. So again, in talking with um the district and I think with some of the communication that's happening at these meetings and with the FH, right, um I think there are some changes that can be implemented that can make um the budget process and the revisions more transparent. We've talked with the staff of things they can do. Um, every county is different and so some counties require every budget revision to go to the board. Um, other counties do not. They take them as with their budget cycles. So, adopt the budget first interim and second interm. They consider them their budget revisions and that the boards approved that and therefore everything that's been moved around is okay, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 157
um it's fine, but I would say because we're in this situation, obviously you're wanting more information. And so again, I've already talked with staff. I'm going to give them some examples of what they can do to help bring that transparency to the board level. And so again, kudos to the staff for asking what can we do? And so we're just going to supply them with some samples on what maybe um what can come to the board maybe on a monthly basis of here's the adjustments to the budget so that there's more transparency in it. And so I think the budget monitoring is really hard. Um it's you it's almost like two people are only building it, right? But it's not two people. At my [clears throat] district, it was one one person cannot be responsible for the whole budget. It it that's a lot to carry on your shoulders.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above