2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 158
And so we're not perfect. We can make mistakes. And so I always encouraged everybody to look at the budget and ask me as many questions as possible because I can make a mistake. And so it's got to be in a collaborative manner of working on the budget. And so again, just working as a team and being open and being transparent and trying to build in like I said, Matt reached out to ask what can we do? And so I think those monthly budget revisions will help. You'll see those revisions moving. You'll understand them, right? And so now you'll be able to speak to it if somebody asks, "Hey, why did our salaries move, you know, increase $1 million? Oh, well, we had this, this, and this. It was talked about at this board meeting, this board meeting, and this board meeting." And so, again, it's telling the story and being able to communicate it to all of our educational um partners.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 159
So again, I think it's coming to you at a future board meeting, [laughter] coming soon to a theater near you. >> Wonderful. Thank you. Um, my next question is from number five, charter schools. Um, it seems you have no financial concern for AAE. Um, are are you aware that according to the second interim report that their budget is no longer assuming that the foundation will cover shortfalls of revenues this year? Um, they have historically done so. Um, so that uh note from the county brought some concern to my forefront of my mind. Should there be any concerns about any potential shortfall for our district or any financial responsibility in the event of a potential shortfall. >> So, so here's what I will say to that. The most important thing when you have a charter that you've authorized is that you're providing oversight. Because if you do not provide that oversight, then if that charter happened to fail and had to close their doors, you would be on the hook for their financial outstanding financial debt, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 160
Um so the most important thing is that you're providing your oversight. I will say that the documentation that the district provided to us, you got a pretty robust oversight process. Um it it's much deeper than many districts that we've been into. So, so from our perspective, the district is doing what they need to do to cover themselves in terms of that oversight. Yeah. Okay. >> Um, my next question is from number six and it talks about our collective bargaining agreements. Um, so we have not identified resources that will cover our proposals in the collective bargaining agreements. Um, I think it's essential that we as a board are making informed decisions. Um, this starts with having a clear understanding of our current financial state. So, if we're trying to find out where we have money or if we have money, I know you addressed assets um, and them being related to reserves.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 161
Um, specifically, if we're looking at where the money is, then we're looking specifically at reserves. Whatever we have in reserves, that's the money we have that can go towards our collective bargaining agreement. Yes. Yes. Okay. Um my question on number eight, deficit spending. Um that those figures um thank you for um delineating them for us. Um how did how did we come to those figures? It was it a end of the year comparison between overall um revenues and expenditures? >> Yes. So, it's included in your sax form. So, do you want to try to pull up the sax form here? >> Well, we don't have all the >> We don't, but we can just show it on one of the sax forms. >> Control. >> What do we do? >> Control tab. >> Oh, look. I'm going to try and run this. >> Command tab.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 162
You brought it back. >> Okay. Because we're in display. We we may need some we may need some assistance because we're one of those we're trying to switch because we do have your unodudited actuals loaded on here >> and so we want to pull that form up so that we can speak specifically to that one and I'll show you where we pulled those numbers from. Oh, you just did it. >> Okay. >> I'm sorry. >> No way. >> Sorry, we're not checking. >> I'll try and assist here. I'm going to go ahead and shrink this one. You have the UAS. So the one of the UAS >> this one right here. >> Sure. >> That's 24 25. >> Okay. >> All right. >> 25 UAS. >> Yeah. Can I make it bigger? >> Let's make it bigger. Let's complete that. Close the dots on the side and we can zoom.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 163
>> Oh, there we go. A little bit. >> Awesome. Okay. >> All right. So, is this just un is it just No, this is unrestricted. Unrestricted. All right. >> This is only unrestricted. All right. Let me get there. >> Thank you. Now you're going to in that top. >> Okay. Right there. >> Yeah. Make that big. >> Okay. I'm sorry. Make it bigger >> because you just want the unodudited actual. You don't need the budget. >> Where' it go? >> So, I just wanted to show you which form we're on just so that you know where you are. So, this is your 2425 on audit deductables. And if you come down here, remember we talked about I apologize, not my computer. Um, [laughter] so right here, this line E is going to tell you your net increase decrease in fund balance. >> Yeah. So right here, there's your number that we use because remember we're only looking at the unrestricted in terms of of your deficit spending for this particular question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 164
So So there's the number that is used. Yeah. No, it's not 64 3 801. Yeah, we rounded up. I'm sorry. So, yes. So, that's where we pulled the numbers from. So, we we're going to look at that line on each one of your unodudited actuals. Well, we did unodudited actuals for 23 24 25. And then we looked at that same line for your 2526 adopted budget >> which is right here. Yes. So, your adopted budget is over here on this side. There's your uh I'm restricted. >> Okay, great. Thank you so much. Um, and the next question is um we have been spending down our reserves um significantly as you've noted um because our expenditures are greater than our um revenues. Um as I've been seeing them dropped even prior to joining the board just observing it. Um that was a concern for me. Um, my question is is the spending down of reserves, and correct me if I'm wrong, has to come with a board directive.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 165
Is that correct? >> Not not spending down the reserves as a board directive, but anything that's brought to the board that's approved as an expenditure um and the and the budget gets revised, right, and the new budget comes forward, then your situation changes, right? your your net position changes and so you know if you're approving expenditures and your net position is now deficit spending then >> okay so when we go to give directive to spend on something a good question to ask is where are we spending from and then to look at that fund to see the money there >> correct >> thank you >> yeah is it included already in our budget have we [clears throat] accounted for this, right? Because there are some contracts that you know that you're going to have every year and so you budget for them. And so as the contract comes forward, it I think it usually has a funding source on the board agenda item and so it'll tell you where it's being funded from.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 166
Is this in addition to our current budget or is it already included in our budget would be a question. So then you know how it's going to affect. >> Okay, great. Thank you so much. And um I do have a question. I mean it as you know not note in our um and your time here and I appreciate both of you and all the work you've poured into this um but there is some very real concerns that are being um expressed that are um being brought forward um as part of the discussion as a board. Um I think we definitely want to um address what you guys have talked about and that is something you've noted the distrust the um uncertainty about our financial state. I know also you discussed um as we were going through this um that things we were asking for were maybe more of a detailed um require more of a detailed audit.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 167
um if if we choose as a board and administration to move forward in that direction to try to uh provide more data and reinstill as part of the process of trying to reinstill trust. Um is there something you would recommend maybe something Fickmat offers or something else um that you are aware of? So go into the details as far as >> um looking at more of um the history of our uh spending or being able to look at um the projection of spending like getting a more detailed >> I'm going to tell you that your history is going to be skewed though. So remember those one-time dollars significantly skewed your history. All right. So, so what used to be in COVID years and the years immediately following look different than it does today. So, I would caution you on looking back because that is going to be skewed.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 168
So, you know, >> so I think what I'm hearing is you're wanting more details than just the 194 pages. Correct. >> No. Well, like I think because the fiscal health risk analysis was more of a from what I understand more of an overview >> 30,000 >> correct and so and so in order to provide some sort of assurance or um clarification um like being able to >> we come in and do kind of like a forensic audit type. >> Is that what that would be? >> Yeah, we because I don't think you guys do forensics. >> We don't do forensic audits. No, we don't. Um, >> so I I'm not quite understanding it. So say it for me one more time. Just >> so what would be is there anything that VicMat offers that would be a little more detailed? Give a little more detailed um >> um the in terms of probably the the closest thing that we could offer would be an independent MYP independent multi-year projection.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 169
But here's what we do in those situations. We come in, we again ask the district to upload documents. We already have a lot in our document repository, so would possibly use some of those and then add some additional ones. Uh but we would come in and talk to the district about what assumptions did you use to build your budget. There's always a timing issue because we want to get the most accurate information as we can. So at this point in the year, we would possibly do first interim, right? because we're not going to do it off adopted budget. Lots has happened since then. So, uh, but possibly first interim, which takes place that that should be reported out by December 15th. So, we could come in, but we would talk to the district about what assumptions did you use to build your budget? What's in there?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 170
We use the assumptions that make sense to us. We don't use the ones that make sense. And we may change something based on the knowledge that we have and the information that we have. And then we basically do an analysis and say, "Here's your budget. Here's what we would have done if we were sitting in the seat and we explain the differences. So, is that what you're asking for?" That's probably the closest thing in terms of the kind of work that we do. >> Okay. Thank you. Yes, that does give me some information. Thank you. I appreciate it. And then um I was curious because I know back when we started working with you um there was an um a possibility that you guys might be able to return in six months to see how we're moving along in following your recommendations. Is that something you are able to do?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 171
>> Yeah, there's there's a portion in our study agreement that we already have in place with you that does allow us if the district reaches out within a certain period of time and I believe um Matt I'm just going to say Matt [laughter] don't know that I can say your last name correctly. Um but anyways, but uh Matt's already come to us and asked if that is something that we do and what's the process for doing that. So it the request has to happen within a certain period of time because we want to give you an opportunity to put the recommendations into place, right? So every place that that we put a no, we've gave a brief little narrative as to why it's a no, right? We need a correction. Um so anyways, but we want to give you time to work on those. That's not going to happen overnight.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 172
So, I think I if I'm remembering correctly, I want to say that you request within six to eight months and then we come back within a 12 to 18 months to do a follow-up review actually free of charge. Now, that one is different than this one in the sense that um I'm going we come back and we look at your progress. So, we would be looking for each area that's a no. We're not look going to look at the ones that are a yes. We're going to assume that those stayed the same. So, we look at the ones that are no and we ask the district to provide evidence to us that would make that a yes. If the district can provide evidence and we it's really it it's it's kind of reviewing things um at home and then we usually have to just come and and do like one day of interviews to to clear up anything that can't be seen in the documents if that makes sense.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 173
>> Yes. Thank you so much. >> May I ask just one question with regard to that? Um it'll be fast. um when you would do that follow up, could that change our um score? So instead of being like high risk, we could be like really good. So So what we Yeah. And and I don't I think I forgot to say that even the the highest performing, most efficient functioning district there is is not going to score a zero on FH because everybody has an area that they can improve in. Um, so I'm gonna tell you this. It's a great question. We actually haven't done a follow-up on an FH. We we just haven't we've never been invited back to do that. So, we would have to determine as an organization how we approach that. But in my mind, what makes sense is that we would we would comment on each one of those nos.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 174
I don't think we would redo the tool because we didn't verify that the yeses are still a yes. But what we could do, the district could take it and they could take those because we will report out what has changed and maybe we'll do a little paragraph that says if we put these responses in and assumed all the other yeses stayed yes, here would be your new risk score. I I could see us doing that. >> Does that is that fair? >> That's fair. Thank you so much. >> All right. Well, um thank you so much. We'll we'll just we'll move on if there's any comments that uh we'll I'm going to start by thanking you. Does anybody else have anything other board members any comments they like to make? Anita? >> Um, Mr. Rally, is this our comments or board comments or >> Oh, yeah, we can.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 175
I was just um I didn't know if we wanted to dismiss them. >> Okay. Yeah, >> you guys want to stay? Okay, go ahead. Go. You're up, Mia. >> Okay. These are just my board comments. >> Yeah. >> I I really want to thank the Fitmat team. Uh both of you are amazing and thank you for coming all the way here to share your presentation and recommendations and answer our questions. It really is helpful and I can't thank you enough. Um, I also want to say thank you to our staff, cabinet, board members for taking the time to meet with the team and I know that we all appreciate having the information that we need to help guide our district and ensure that Apple Valley remains fiscally stable. As a board member, I represent oneif of our board. My individ my individual strength lies in working collaboratively with my fellow board members to make the best decisions for our district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 176
And while it has taken some time to reach this point and review the results from the FitMAT team, I am optimistic that we as a board now have information that we need to make the informed decisions and provide leadership and direction that our district deserves. I have visited every site in the district and have witnessed exemplary teaching support and care for our students. We are fortunate to have individuals who consistently go above and beyond for our students and families. Our district serves our students and community well. And now we must make thoughtful and difficult decisions guided by the facts presented in this report to continue to provide exemplary leadership that benefits our student, staff, and community. As a history teacher, I'll admit that math and numbers may not be my strongest area. But as history teaches us, we must learn from the past in order to move forward.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-10-31 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Oct 30, 2025 - Special Meeting / Workshop of the Board of Tr… · passage 177
We must study this report carefully and use its guidance to strengthen and secure our district for the benefit of all our stakeholders. Finally, sitting where I do during our meetings, I often notice the detailed notes and documents that Miss Longshore brings with her. I can't help but appreciate the meticulous calculations, questions, and annotations that she prepares for each and every meeting. Clearly, the result of hours of dedication. She consistently asks the tough questions that help us serve our student, staff, and district and community better. And I'd like to take a moment to thank her for her hard work and commitment. Thank you, Miss Longshore. We appreciate you. Thank you, [applause] >> Renee. >> Yes. Thank you, Trusty [clears throat] Tucker. is very kind. Um, I am just going to take a few minutes because I think it's important as we consider moving forward as a district that I share with you um some things that have been on in my head and on my heart in regards to our district's finances.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above