2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 62
The location I was in is one of them. [clears throat] Um, so this gave the the board president the ability to say, "Hey, we need to cool things down, so we're going to recess 10 minutes. The board's going to exit the room. we can get like let's just get the the the community calm down, the audience calm down and then we can continue. So, >> and the recess can be longer than a few minutes, too. They could recess until tomorrow. >> You can recess as long as you So, you can recess it. You have to start it within the 24-hour period, but you can recess a We could recess today. Come back tomorrow at 9:00 a.m. and pick up the same meeting. Do the same thing. Have the same agenda. ask a question about the um Robert's rules of order says that a routine adjournment doesn't need a vote.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Hampden County, MA YouTube / ELCAT01028 transcript source: youtube field hockey live · passage 62
Trying to make their own identity. They look great today. Over to Denalt. Over to mean Bailey in the circle trying to make something happen. Looks like Denalt comes on trying to pin her against the end line. and does I think that's going to be East Long Ball coming in. Two minutes left. >> Johnny, that game is [snorts] tomorrow at 4:00. >> Determine who we play. >> Right. We just got we just got indication from your friend up here that we will we will know more tomorrow at about 6 p.m. relative to the play in in the next round of the state playoff. Uh that game uh to determine who East LA will play is being played tomorrow. We'll know a lot more tomorrow evening. >> You know that tournament play. You don't It's depends on who wins where what what seed. You never know when you're going to where you're going to go or what time you're going to play.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 63
So if at the end of the meeting if it's a routine adjournment does there still have to be a motion a second and a vote or can the president declare at the end of the meeting if everything is done? Can the the president declare an adjournment without the vote? >> So we don't we don't recommend Robert's rules only because Robert rules is made for large legislative bodies which you are not. Um, but I think whatever it is that you do should be done consistently. So if you've always had a motion, a second, and a vote on adjournment, >> Do it the same way every time. And that is the thing um that we've also been talking a lot about, and I know some of you have been to some of our events the past year. We've been talking about consistency and clarity of what this looks like.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Hampden County, MA YouTube / ELCAT01028 transcript source: youtube field hockey live · passage 63
We could play a game tonight at 8:00. Who knows, John? >> I don't think. >> Yeah, you never know. >> I don't think we can. [snorts] >> Look at this. >> [snorts] >> You could come back for Halloween costume, but we can't play. >> I've been privy to a lot of these state tournaments. One took us over to the island at Marcher's Vineyard. We had it to Gloucester one year. We were at Cape Cod last year at a double overtime shootout. Tough loss there. It takes you all over the state. So luckily, >> listen, if I told you in August that we were going to be playing a home tournament game and take walking away with a five to one victory, >> would you be happy? >> I sure would. Most importantly, I'm happy for these girls. They work together and they work so hard all year long.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 64
So, one of the things that often is um questioned or not sure about is if I have an amendment, when do I offer an amendment? When is the amendment considered? Is the original motion considered first or is the amendment considered first? Okay. So, you have a motion to um >> Adopt a calendar. Okay. that you've had the materials. The motion is to adop adopt the calendar as presented. Someone at the meeting says I want to change the board meetings from Thursdays to the third Thursday to the third Wednesday. So I'd like to amend this to say that the meetings are the third Wednesday, not the Thursday. >> What do you vote on first? The >> amendment. The amendment. >> Right. Some Robert says the amendment goes first. But it doesn't have to because you don't you don't have to do Roberts, right? So whatever you do, you do consistently.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Hampden County, MA YouTube / ELCAT01028 transcript source: youtube field hockey live · passage 64
I'm happy for them. This might be I don't know, my friend. This could be it for us. This could be our last broadcast of the season. If it is, what a pleasure it's been to call these games with you. It really I mean I have had such a good time >> and we're going to close out. 20 seconds left in the game. 12 seconds left and that's going to be a a victory number one. That's the first step you have to take, John. >> Yeah, we we spoke about it at the beginning of the game and as we finish up here [cheering and applause] we have got five, Auburn one. Uh >> it is it has been an absolute blast and Denny is going to take us home. >> So, we'll see when the next game is. Thanks for coming out. >> We'll see where we're going to play next.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 65
So if you vote on the amendment first, that's fine. >> Or you vote on the original motion first, that's fine. Just do it consistently. No matter who the board president is, no matter what the amendments are. Um, and if you have two amendments, you would if you if your practice is to vote on the amendment first, you would take the amendment that was most recently made, vote on that, vote on the amendment before, and then vote on the original motion if those two amendments don't pass. But once you have voted on an amendment and it has passed, you don't have to vote on the original motion because that motion has been amended. So, we had a school I had a school district call me in January and they had their organizational meeting and they had a vote for president and someone nominated a person. There was a motion, a second, a vote.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Hampden County, MA YouTube / ELCAT01028 transcript source: youtube field hockey live · passage 65
But congratulations to Eastman and the coaches and the parents and Auburn. Uh thanks for coming out and uh they played a great game. Have a safe trip home. Goodbye everybody. Happy Halloween. >> That was awesome.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 66
The vote was 32. Then after that someone says well I want to be board president so another person made a motion that that person's board president and someone who voted in the majority here also voted in the majority on the second vote. So it was a mess. Um, but what should have happened, right, it's been it's been voted on and it's gone. There's no there's nothing else. >> Only the people only the people if it was 32 >> only one of the three who voted in favor of that original motion >> change but that >> has to be a motion to reconsider or somebody who voted in the majority >> but one of the other two people can't make a new motion. No, once you vote on a motion, it's over. That's who the board president is. >> It doesn't matter. Roberts, it doesn't matter.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 67
>> Yeah. Roberts is not Yeah. Does Does statute allow a motion to reconsider the way Roberts does or not? >> It there's it's silent. >> Okay. >> So again, there's a lot of silence on the way you run your meetings in the law. That's why you all have to know how you run your meeting. >> Okay. So this is a key point because in all of those uh policies that I put you know in board docs for you to look at. So for this policy then the revised one it has something like this at the top and then it has board considered uh rules. So, in this case, it would be really important for y'all to look at that policy really closely and see if there are any of those suggested rules that you don't want to keep or you want to revise or if you have ones you want to add because this month when we present those is, you know, and you may want to say, you may want to tell Melinda to say, "Okay, let's put this policy in the workshop so we can have a real discussion.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 68
about what it might say. Okay? So, you know, not that we can't have the discussion in meeting because ultimately you're going to decide on the first reading and then but it might be nice to have some suggested changes in it before it's on the agenda for first reading. Okay? So, that's one of the ones that you're really going to want to pay attention to because you have some you have some real leeway to to make it match what you want to do. Okay. And you know what the the and the reason that we're we want to be the the courts are siding on siding on the on the public >> side. So, there's a court case in Florida um that Moms for Liberty brought against River County Public Schools because their meetings from meeting to meeting year to year were being run very differently. So, some things that were stopped during public comment one week were not stopped the next week or motions were made, the voting wasn't done the same way every single time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 69
So, the consistency is really what it's about and you can decide what that looks like. So, if you say we have a motion, we have a second, we vote, it's over. We have a motion. We have an amendment. Do we have a second on the amendment? Yes, we vote on the amendment. So really thinking of that the order in which those things happen is something that is important. And it doesn't have to be in policy. It really can be in kind of your board practices, but you need to have it written down somewhere. >> It could be in it could be in a resolution. >> Yeah, that's usually resolution. I mean in a regulation I'm sorry in a regulation because that's usually the actual procedure >> you use >> regulations do that this is the >> philosophical and legal background >> so we we would have >> well we might >> yeah I don't regulation there may be one >> there might be I don't know >> I don't and I don't know off the top right >> but you could also create a regulation >> you just have to >> so if if we as a or are doing this and then we discovered that we have left something off.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 70
Can we redo a policy time? >> Anytime. >> Yep. >> Just has to have two readings at two meetings. >> Yeah. >> That's one reason that it's really nice that if you want that kind of detail, you put the detail in a regulation >> because remember the regulations can be done in one meeting. They can be approved or changed in one meeting. So if you've got the legal legal stuff on the policy and the procedures that you're using to carry out the policy in a regulation and then you go, "Oh, we forgot." >> So then the regulation can be changed with one more thing. >> Yeah. Yeah. Got it. >> Okay. All righty. Let's go on to E DH. And this doesn't sound like it's a big um issue for you right now. The public comment, public participation. >> I really wish it was more of an issue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 71
>> Yeah. So when you do have calls to the public or public, if you call to the audience >> um you know you again the consistency of this is really important. So, the board president is handling it. No matter who the board president is, they're handling it the same every single time. Um, I had I had a board president say to me, she called me and she said, "You know, when we have a call to the public, I realize that I am thanking some people and not other people." She said, "And it's probably based on whether I agree with them or not." She said, "So, I need to stop that, right?" And I was like, well, I mean, legally you don't, but should you? Yes. Because you don't want to give the impression. So, her policy always was, I'm never going to say thank you because then I won't forget to say thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 72
So, that was her thing. Um, other board presidents have said, "Thank you to every single person. Thank you for your contribution. Thank you for your comments. Thank you for your comments." Like, whatever. U, but again, the consistency is important. And I, you know, if possible, no matter who's president, we do it the same way. I think that is. >> Do we have a limit on our call to the public? >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 73
Three minutes. We've been doing three minutes. >> I mean, total. I mean, >> no, not a total. >> Okay. Just three minutes per person, >> right? And then and the board president then Cass sets a timer. So, she hears the she hears the timer to walk. It's the board president's prerogative to stop it at that moment or not. >> Okay. >> If they're mids sentence, >> you would stop. >> Yeah. >> If the board president doesn't reiterate what the person said, >> not at all. >> Okay. >> And you really should if if I understand what you're saying about in the middle of a sentence, but after the sentence is over, you should stop. >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Um because you don't want to be in a position where you're giving where it appears you're giving more time to some people than you are to others.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 74
>> So it is important that you adhere to that 3 minutes. Some other things that boards have done and these are boards are mostly have had issues with public comment the district I served on included um some districts have said if there's one to 10 people we're going to give everyone three minutes. If there's up to 30 people, you get a minute, >> right? Or whatever. So that so that the public comment doesn't last for three and a half hours. Um because then it's hard to get the business done because you're now you're >> Midnight, right? And you're trying to make decisions and that's something that >> is that something that should be specified in the regulation then? >> It could be speci specified in the regulation >> or procedures, >> right? where you can put it in your you can put it in your policy too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 75
>> Um some boards have added it's 3 minutes or at the discretion of the board president dependent on the number of public comments submitted. >> That's a good way to put it. >> So the board president can say look we have 25 so I want to give each of you a minute and a half. I mean she states it before because she states it before it starts. It's in the policy that the board president has discretion. So, they can put that limit on there. So, there's a lot of different if you look at some other different policies like and I can send you some suggestions like Tempe Union um Paris Valley I think Kyrie has something about the discretion of the board president. So, there's some districts that have already made changes to this um in policy. So when they go look at so when the public looks at the policy they know what >> and then it's Lance reminded me of this not too long ago.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 76
Um uh you all cannot respond >> to what is said. >> Okay. So footnote to that question to you Julie. So I can think of times in the past where somebody has done the call to the public and the board president or a board member has said usually the board president and I don't think this is Melinda. I think this is before but um okay we'll look at putting that on the next agenda. Even saying that probably is not a >> but that's okay. That would be okay. So the two things you could really say are you could direct the superintendent to follow up >> on an issue. Yes. or you could say to the superintendent, please let's include this on the future agenda item. Those are the two things. So, board members can respond to criticism. If you look at item D on here, >> the personal attack >> personal attack, >> right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-01 Mohave County, AZ YouTube / BCSD Board transcript source: youtube BCSD Special Governing Board Retreat 11/01/2025 · passage 77
Now, personal attack isn't calling you an idiot, >> right? An idiot, right? Because that that's not really an attack. or manipulative, evil, right? Evil and manipulative were used words that were used to describe me. Um, not that I would not that's not a personal attack, right? Um, and so a personal attack would be something much more damaging, much more um a line. >> Yeah. just >> so that you have broken the law >> or accuse you of breaking >> accuse you of breaking the law that is something um >> but I'm not sure as a board member I would want to respond to that shooting from the hip so I mean as offended as I would be [laughter] >> well that is my so there is some wisdom in law because the attorney general has said that you have to wait until the end of public comment if you want to respond to a personal attack and in my mind that is giving you the space and time to cool down.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above