2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 121
Thank you. >> Say I don't I don't quite remember. It's been >> I know. I know it was a little higher than four, but okay. 4.22. >> I move that we authorize the payment per the employment agreement. >> There a second. >> I'll second. >> All those in favor? >> I I >> Thank you. >> We're good. Thank you. >> Continue the good work. Okay. Now I can go to discuss elements correspondence. >> One of the uh [clears throat] one of the issues that I have with some of the uh emails that we received uh could weigh heavy into human resources and potential issues when it came to an employes lack of response. So, my response to the individual that was questioning permits, >> an employees lack of response, >> was that something sent to everybody? >> No, it wasn't. No. So I think I think I think the just to kind of backtrack a little bit the the genesis of this is that the emails that are sent to the select board right >> email address that >> um you as chair respond to >> we do not see the responses >> right >> so the thought was that the responses go to Susan so they can be put in our packet so we can just see what >> how things are responding how you're responding responding to things, >> right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 122
>> And and that >> okay, >> you know, like that was the what that >> Yeah. So, I think a couple years ago, actually, after I came on the board, I asked for some way to know what >> right that someone has responded. >> Someone has responded because I'd had the experience, >> right? You've been trying to figure out the best way to do it. >> So, >> yeah. >> Um, in any case, and that was decided that we would receive PDFs of responses. And so I think that this is >> and that could be a violation of open meeting laws if everybody got the same notific the same PDF files to everybody. >> How is that a violation of open meeting law? All you're doing is disseminating information. We're not responding. We're not voting. We're not Who Who told you it could be a violation of open meeting law?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 123
>> It's it's it's a fine line. I thought I thought Lisa had said >> that's what Lisa said to Jeff >> that we could get around open meeting law by putting it in the packet and then making sure we >> Well, if we put it in the packet, it becomes possibly public record, right? >> Well, >> which is fine. >> Yeah. And and that's okay, but um I will ask Lisa again, but she was pretty >> Well, what did Lisa say, Joe? >> She said it's a fine line between an open meeting law violation and >> and potential if >> just talk a little closer to your microphone. >> If the emails that we receive and that I respond to um [clears throat] is a direct result of somebody not happy with the performance of an employee that could end up possibly becoming a human resource.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 124
I think we're talking about two different things here, right? Because you It sounds like you're >> But I'm responding I'm responding to an email from a resident >> but directly to you. >> Yeah. We didn't get >> and the rest of the board did not get copied. >> Okay. And so I think I think what you're trying to get at is the only things that you wanted essentially to be a part of this discussion or you know part of the packet were emails that were sent to the select board in the response the select board email and the response >> even if that response is so like if this would be my suggestion >> okay >> is if an email comes through sometimes the emails need some research and to figure out like you know what the clarification is or how to respond. But my my suggestion would be an email comes through within a certain period of time, a few days or whatever, there's a response to that person that says here's the information you requested or I need to do more research >> or thank you for your email and we'll take it under consideration >> and and like >> so you know we can do and then then those emails however we resolve it get sent to Susan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 125
as part of our information that we get in our backup. >> And it could and and if there's multiple ones, they could be put in the folder as correspondence response, >> right? >> Yeah. >> In the folder. >> Yeah. And it and if there's stuff that's that's sensitive information, obviously like everything else in our packets, it would get redacted before >> things get posted. I mean, I get individual emails from people, but >> Yeah. >> Well, some if somebody's emailing you then >> directly, right, then it's a right. But when it's to the select >> Oh, no. I I agree. I'm just like because Joe's bringing up an email that he received directly to him that none of us >> it was directed as the chair of the board of select. >> Right. Right. So, as the chair, I feel that I'm responsible to provide you folks any and all responses that I provide somebody if it's if it's directed to the chair.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 126
>> And if you don't, >> I think I think that's fine. That's fine. >> Okay. Well, that's what I've been doing. So, as a result of that, I was told that I need to be very careful because it could be it there could be ramifications down the road. >> Yeah, I I think you might want to think about that because that would potentially open up any of your one-on-one or I'll I'll just I don't want to say private, but you know, one-on-one communications. I mean anything >> start with if it was addressed to the select board >> selectboard mass.com >> that's it >> go >> okay >> I mean >> anything in our select board emails right which is why you want to do stuff like that in your select board email not a personal email >> is available right if someone says we want to hear you know all the correspondence you had with Joe Smith about this issue >> Paul Carpenter has access and can go into our town emails Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 127
>> And look for that stuff. >> If there's a public record, >> right? >> Yeah. >> Right. Not just Yeah. >> So, and if there's things that we do need to like discuss, then you know it gets put on an agenda, right? You know, >> right? If there's something >> Okay. So, basically then the correspondences that I have other than um well, again, they're all they all came individually to me except for one >> at this point. Why don't at this point why don't you look through them and see which ones went to all of us >> and then give them to Susan and ask her to forward the ones that went to all of us >> and other ones and if there are other ones that you feel you need to talk to us about >> y >> that we need to be aware of unless they're personnel issues >> well they could become that's the thing >> but that's where we have to be careful because we as select board >> do not have any purview over personality issues.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 128
>> No, I I know that. That's why >> um Okay. So, I think we got a good path. >> I think so, too. I thought before, but >> Yep. >> Okay. >> So, that's it. >> We're good. >> I move that we approve the consent agenda as presented. >> Is there a second? >> All those in favor? >> I. >> No oppos. Thank you for those who have stepped up to >> Yep. >> run. >> Uh, next is the town manager report, update on the Trey board meeting and the housing production plan and municipal improvement act empowerment act, I'm sorry. >> Sure. Um, so yeah, uh, just the update on the tri board meeting. You know, obviously we met um you know, a couple weeks ago, had a good discussion, I think, about the financial situation for 2027 and just kind of the initial outlook and kind of laid out in broad terms how we got to this point and some of the things that we've done to stave off the, you know, predicament that we find ourselves in now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 129
Um and so what came out of that meeting is we're going to assemble again on December 10th and we'll figure out the you know the exact we might have come up with a time. I think we did. I don't remember it. Do you remember it right off the top of your head and I want to say 6:30 >> or was it six? >> You said 6:30 or 7. >> Okay. >> They're going to meet early. >> Correct. >> Okay. And then um so we'll have a discussion then and so I've had an opportunity to talk to each of you uh since that meeting just to ask what you feel like you need for that uh December 10th meeting. And so we you know the majority of you talked about having different options to discuss. And when I talk about options, you know, basically what would it look like if we did go for an override of a certain amount, you know, and what would the consequences be of that, you know, positive and negative?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 130
Um what if we just had something that, you know, covered the deficit, you know, what are the pros and cons of that? And then similarly like let's look at an option where we needed to make cuts and understanding that we needed to talk about that very delicately because obviously no decisions will have been made by this point um you know how to basically talk about some of the consequences and ramifications of of cuts um in enough terms where people could get kind of an understanding of what that means without dealing with hard edge specific specifics. Um, and so that's what we plan on presenting. Um, our, uh, department head budgets are due on November 20th. Um, I'd like to get, uh, the information for the tri board meeting to you uh, the Friday before the tri board meeting. So, um it's going to be a fun holiday season for uh for the finance team as we start putting things together.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 131
Um I will say that I've I've had a couple conversations with Jim since the meeting and um you know he is asking his team to put together a couple of different scenarios as well. Uh so hope I I don't know exactly what the timing is. I think that was still being refined, but you know, we should have some more information there. And um yeah, I I've met with the finance committee since the tribe board meeting. They um um you know, they are obviously very interested in the discussion on the on the 10th as is the school committee. Um, yeah, it's it's going to be interesting. Okay. Um, >> I'm sorry. I'm just I'm just writing down. >> So, let's move on to the housing production plan. >> Okay. >> Um, so I believe in your packet >> uh just was uh some email correspondents about us moving forward and starting our housing production plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 132
Uh we're in a very good situation because um our current plan expires in May of 26. Um and um we are able to work with JM Goldson who has you know been working with us on the comprehensive plan and we're able to really kind of compress the time frame because of the previous work that they've done on the comprehensive plan as well. >> What's the contract cost for this? >> I want to say it is 50. >> Okay. I could be wrong. Don't I don't have that right in front of me. Yeah, definitely. >> Is that Is that a fair assessment on what it would cost to get this done? >> Yeah, I believe it was actually a little bit more when we went with MAPC for the last one. >> Okay. >> Well, I feel like we had to do a little bit more.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 133
>> There was a lot more work to be done. >> I believe it had just expired. Yeah, >> it was during CO and there was some other things that we had to do that made that our second one a little bit more. >> We broke it into two parts too when we did with MAPC, you know. Um >> but um so just to kind of give people a sense of what the housing production plan is and does. Um, you know, the purpose of it is to to stay in safe safe harbor, excuse me, in safe harbor >> um once our 40Bs are possibly permitted and um you know, it allows us to it allows us to to continue to stay in safe harbor as long as we're making progress towards. >> Right. So, take take one step back, right? You create a housing production plan to talk about what you think you're going to be able to do on a yearly basis to get to your 10%.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 134
>> Correct. >> And then once you have that, as long as you're meeting the goals that you've put into your housing production plan, it then allows you to be in safe harbor. >> Thank you, Yoland. >> That was much better than what I said. [laughter] >> So, thank you. Um, >> I've been doing it a little bit longer and so >> well I'm also kind of brain dead at this point tonight. >> Um, so but um you know the housing production plan that we did back in COVID um has you know is only good for five years, right? And then once we get this and this is like a public process, >> there'll be public forums and opportunities for people to weigh in on on things. Are they looking to um utilize a lot of the information that they did on the comprehensive plan? >> Yeah, it's actually we're in I think a really good position because now it's talking about okay really it's going to be focusing on amplifying the strategies that are in the comprehensive plan related to housing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 135
So it it's it's like supercharging that you know that I just had one or two questions unless people of other just general. So you're talking about who's involved. I know in the past we've had we sort of created a committee. Someone from the select board was part of it. Uh do you feel like you don't need that as part of this process or or or you know I saw that there was you've already had a team start working with Goldson it seems like on some of this. So, I'm just I just want to make sure we keep I know I know there's a public meeting scheduled potentially in February. No, in in January. I think we had one or two last year and I mean the last time we did it and the before that we had a couple more. Are we feeling like the one is going to be enough because of how much is coming from the comprehensive plan?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 136
>> Yeah, there there's a lot of lot of stuff in there, a lot of questions. Um so I think you know and to answer your latter one yes you know we feel like there was a lot of so much public participation um you know and a lot of it was focused on housing and opinions on housing. So if definitely feel like we have met that standard. >> Okay. Um, you know, one thing I do want to point out is that, uh, I think part of this process, uh, Goldson will be, um, talk interviewing each of you, would like to interview each of you as part of this, as well as members of the planning board. Um, as well, just to kind of get get your thoughts and take on it. >> Yeah. Um, I'd actually like to get a little bit I I see the phases and what's going to happen in each phase, but I'd actually like to like to see the statement of work or to see exactly what the deliverables are from Golton.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 137
Like what are we expecting them to do as opposed to what our staff will be doing as opposed to what we'll be doing, you know, to support. I just want to be very clear on like what I want to make sure my expectation like what what am I really expecting here from the consultants? And I think it would be helpful. I think I think that level of transparency would be helpful in general just for everybody to know as we embark upon this process. >> Okay. So like what are we getting? >> Yeah. What are we getting through this? >> What are we getting from $50,000? >> But we I think it would be helpful for people to know what effort specifically goes into those sort of things. Um and what we should expect um as we're going through this process >> for sure. >> And I just would like to just kind of review a little history here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 138
So, um, previously we would have if we aren't we had a housing production plan, right? That would have gotten us into safe harbor had we met those goals yeartoear. >> Correct. So, >> but we didn't make them because basically of two projects. >> That is correct. >> Right. So, >> and well, it's interesting. We did get a year of safe harbor out of um you know the UGC >> UGC >> project uh but because it was in litigation it fell off and so we didn't get that extra second year >> right and we would have and the same then with pawn street is that true >> we would have gotten yeah some safe harbor so we had a plan to keep us from being in the situation that we're currently in u in terms of you know, correct unbridled house housing development. Um, and but we weren't able to meet the goals for reasons beyond our none of our beyond Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 139
totally beyond our control. >> We did everything that we could, >> right? >> Um, in order to set ourselves up to better control like development that happens in town. >> Um, it's just the private sector didn't uh follow suit this time. So, but it's interesting, Claudia, you know, it's such a it's such a good tool that communities have. Um, you know, Ashland, for some reason, didn't have one until 2016. Um, and so, you know, that was the first year we did it. Uh, and then we were able to count Cirrus, um, the 10% that we had in Cirrus, that gave us two years of safe harbor. Um, and then you know we did gymnastics. Pete did gymnastics to do >> the last couple years of that first production housing production plan that we did. >> Yeah. So what was going to happen was the UGC project was going to be permitted after our first one had expired.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-06 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board (November 5th, 2025) · passage 140
And so Pete flipped it around to where um he was able to do that and still maintain like full transparency, full hearing process and everything to where we were able to get credit that one-year credit for UGC even though we had hoped to get two. >> And we're still waiting. >> Yeah, we're still waiting on >> we're still waiting for the judge's decision. though it was made in February. We still haven't received a written decision. >> Did Did they make a decision in February? No. They they did more hearings and stuff, but they still haven't made a decision. >> There's been no decision, right? >> That's why we're still waiting >> for UGC. Okay. So, Okay. Um and then um so the last item that's printed I just did have one more after that but um so the Municipal Empowerment Act was refiled by the governor.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above