2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 151
And at which case we give our feedback for them to come back with a definitive subdivision plan. And at that point, that's the plan that if we vote on this plan, a preliminary plan, nothing happens. They still have to come back with a definitive subdivision plan for us to actually approve and record at the registry of deeds. and it gets recorded at the with our assessors downstairs and then we update our assessor's maps and our online GIS maps. A pre a preliminary plan they we could approve this and they may never come back with a definitive subdivision and it it holds no weight. It's just saying we've reviewed this and we say if you would like to apply for the definitive subdivision with what you've shown us, here's the feedback. We think we could approve it based on these conditions or we think we couldn't based on these.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 152
And it's really just them getting the feedback before they spend that much money in engineering to get 70 to 100% drawings done. >> And then if we do approve this preliminary one, they could come back and we could not approve the secondary one. >> Absolutely. There's no there's no um you could approve a preliminary and there's nothing that says if you've approved the preliminary that you absolutely have to approve the definitive. There's no legal binding in anything you do with the preliminary plan. And what if you do not approve a preliminary? What what happens then? What >> they would come forward hopefully with substantive changes with hopefully another preliminary unless they agree and we set forward clear standards that this is why and they felt comfortable coming forward with a definitive subdivision plan based on the feedback. Usually they come back with another preliminary to make sure that >> so even if even if we would vote down this preliminary they could choose to come back with another preliminary or they could choose to come back with a definitive which would be a big leap but they could >> absolutely >> um and and voting this down does not mean that they have to wait a year before they do it again or anything like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 153
>> Right. Unlike a special permit. So, a special permit if you denied they would have to have substantive change or wait two years to reapply. That doesn't apply to land use. >> Okay. I think then even though we don't have anyone here, it's it's in it's in front of us and we may be able to make a decision on it anyway if we >> and and we definitely have some feedback from conservation and from fire which were the two you most important DPW has looked at it as well. They just concurred with conservation. And um >> when you say concurred, you mean with Becca's email of November 3rd? >> Becca and and the fire department's email of >> because I read Becca's November 3rd email, which seems to indicate delineation should happen before we make this decision today. >> That's where I see the fire one.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 154
>> Oh, there. >> What time did that one come through? >> Um that was from Chief Roby. I did not see that one in email at all. >> I did. >> So, did he agree with her that the delineation was necessary? >> Chief Roby gave different feedback. He didn't say about the delination. His was about the uh I was concerned with the driveway length and he said obviously the driveway length is a big issue here. He refers to NFPA1 fire code access requirements saying it is a fire road a fire access road up until it divides into the two driveways and they need to follow access requirements. This would require a turnaround area the proposed culde-sac um under 18.2.3.4.4. Both access points need turnarounds due to distance and it also states a width of 20 feet and it's only proposed to be 18 on the plans.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 155
So they they're concerned with the driveway width to get the fire trucks through. Lastly, the concerns distance to the hydrant. So the nearest hydrant on these plans is pretty substantially far away. It's down here. This is the closest hydrant here. So to get to the houses on this end of Caroline Road, they would like to either see another hydrant be brought in or to have these two houses sprinklered. >> So it's four houses, >> four houses. Each of the red squares is a house and a garage. So they've got they're proposing two culde-sacs as paper roads. They don't want to build these culde-sacs. They want to use these culde-sacs on the plan to create frontage for the lots, but not construct them. and they want to construct these as driveways as it's shown in the red here. Um, fire is saying they would like these culde-sacs built because of the turnaround.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 156
There's no way that fire can come in here. If they pull down here, they have to back all the way out this driveway. Same thing with this driveway up here. To pull in up to this left, you'd have to back all the way down this driveway. This only provides an 18 feet width. They need a minimum of 20 ft width to get the fire trucks through safely. Um, in addition, what conservation had mentioned, each subdivision requires each lot has to have a certain number of square footage of uplands. This requires a minimum um of I believe 25,000 square feet of uplands, but I'll get you that specific number. But conservation is concerned that these wetlands may actually be more restrictive than it shows and that these upland numbers would change if they did an abbreviated notice of resource area delineation, which they recommend before we approve any definitive plans that we make sure that this upland number is in fact what it is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 157
Because if you if you approve the definitive subdivision and then they go and apply for an ANRAD after the fact, you can't resend. >> Well, I think technically Becca is saying before we make the preliminary decision. >> I mean, I think you should know, but certainly before a definitive again, you could take you could take this preliminary and say we approve this with >> Well, we could also listen to Becca and say >> absolutely. No, we'd like another preliminary until we have an >> There is no requirement we approve the preliminary. No, no, not at all. Not at all. >> And I feel the same because there's fire chief's also input that has not been taken into consideration at this point. So, um, not sure what the pressure is to approve it before those comments are addressed. And I can see, I mean, just from >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 158
safety point of view, you can actually see that even though the turnarounds look massive, >> but when you take into account the length of the truck, the width of the truck, even just to make this turn, now they have to back out of that driveway >> during a snowstorm during the winter time. But even if they put a culde-sac there, they're still going to have to >> this this particular driveway, regardless of the culde-sac or not, is too long. And they would either have to reduce the driveway length or sprinkle the house, even if they built the culde-sac with the culde-sacs. The other three houses are not an issue. But this one is a concern with both both designs. >> But we also just need the basics. To me, Becca's email was pretty much I'm done with that meeting. If there's commentary from Concom that there's no delineation, we don't even know what we have a plan versus wetlands.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 159
>> I don't really I'm not going to be approving the preliminary. >> That's my position on this. >> Yeah, apparently they're showing wetlands on there, but they're not verified wetlands. So, it's um um the calculations that they could do on the buildable lots. We don't we can't really do those calculations because the lines they're giving us aren't verified. nor can we comment on the on this as well because there's no delineation. >> So, >> which is extremely premature. >> I want to though um make sure we I want to make sure I offer public comment on this. We have >> I just have some like logistic questions because it's just listed as zero, right? But there's two different entrances and >> so is this the real zero? >> Okay. can if somebody can. >> Um, >> so technically right now this is all one lot.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 160
So their proposal is to divide this into the four lots and we would assign the addresses after. So it would be right now this is one single lot listed as zero. Um I believe it's Caroline, >> but this is like a this is a I'm trying to speak loud. I'm sorry. This is a dead end. >> Yeah. >> What's this? >> That's a dead end as well. Oh, there is a >> So if you wait just a lot. >> So um >> this is just a lot right now that they own. So this is just >> No, they don't they don't own that. That's an easement. >> Easement. >> An ement. Sorry. But there's nothing constructed there right now. This is >> it's grass. >> So uh so to follow our to follow a procedure, you need to state your name and address and then you must can proceed with your comment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 161
Uh, I'm Brian James, 29 Adams Road, Ashley, Mass. Born and raised here 44 years. >> All right. >> So, if you if you come down Elliot Street and you take a left on to Caroline Road, you go down Caroline Road, Caroline Road is a dead end. >> Mhm. >> But it veers left onto Adams and that's when Adams starts and then Adams goes all the way to the end and it's a dead end. My house is the last house on the right side after the Eastman. >> So you're you're this corner right here. >> On that last corner house. Yes. Right there. That's that's my house. There's a there's that's all woods and there's tons and tons of 80 to 100 year old trees. specifically right on the corner right where that the fire hydrant on the there's another house across the street from my that fire hydrant right is at the end of their driveway and as you take that turn onto the eastment it's a very rough corner and there's a hundred-y old oak right there so to get that turn to get a fire truck in it wouldn't even be able to make that turn unless that tree was cut down and several other trees were cut down.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 162
The other fire hydrant at the end of the street is at the at the ver where where you know Caroline turns into Adams. >> So there is a there is a fire hydrant already down somewhere. >> Okay. >> There's two, but they're on the um the the other side of the street. Okay. Not on my side. >> Got it. Okay. They're on the uh even number side of the street, not the odd side. >> So, it's maybe not marked on the other. It seems to be marked here, but it's not marked on that down. >> Yeah. Okay. Great. Thank you. Any other comments? >> Use the microphone. >> Yeah, hold on. We're just going to move the microphone down. >> Thank you. is uh I've been there 53 years. I maintain that show between my house next door where the easement is. There's a line of trees there that goes down and then it goes into his property.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 163
And I'm I'm kind of a I'm just trying to figure out why it's a zero Caroline, but yet we got to come down to Adams to get into to down there. It just doesn't make sense to me. I I I might be wrong, but it's >> What's the easement for? Like, is it like a property between the two houses? Is >> Yeah. In the 1950s, the developer that built all the houses on Adam's Road owned this piece of property or was turned over to the the developer because he ran out of money. So, for all these years since 1955, it's been uh Trombi is is the owner of the land. I don't know if he passed away or whatever. I knew Jimmy pretty well. And I think now that he's gone, the family is trying to get rid of this piece of property that really nobody's been able to build on.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 164
But with the new methods of building and stuff, there might be a way to do it, but it just >> So the easement was to give access to the back of that piece. Yes. >> Okay. Thank you. I have like easements all over my property and some are for like defunct gas companies and stuff. So, >> right. And the Eastman also runs into the sewer. And the sewer line is behind all those houses. >> Yeah. Runs from Sheffield. >> The sewer that was down >> Oh, to my house and up out up to Tri >> goes to Tri Street. >> That's what the SNH is. >> I assume that's what the dashed line with the >> Yeah, that's that's >> Yeah, that's the sewer line >> and that was put in 25 years ago as a part of that. 126 redevelopment project. >> Okay. >> Um any any other comments?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 165
>> There's just a it's it's mostly woods. There's not any field out there to speak of. So I I you know I question if you start tearing down all of the trees how that's going to affect the existing wetland that they've got drawn here. And of course this was all done during a drought. I I'm not conservation, so I don't know how they can tell what is what, but it's it looks dry right now, but it's not. That's all I >> Thank you. >> I I'd also like to make a comment. Uh >> Tyler James, 29 Adams Road. Uh, also for both of the different properties, the especially the one on the right is in a it's very kind of hilly and steep there. So, I don't even know if they'd be able to build those roads because that picture doesn't do the terrain justice and it doesn't do the wetland justice either because it does get a lot wetter there like he said and they've both said and even for for one on the left side too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 166
it. The terrain's also difficult because of that easement that both us and our neighbors to the right of that easement on the left have both kind of like used it over the years almost except for that middle part where there's trees. >> Okay. >> Because >> Yeah. Great. Thank you. I mean I think some of the issues obviously will be um um concom looks at this um as well. >> So concom does not look at a subdivision. So what happens is if they go to if we if you approve the preliminary plan they come back with a definitive subdivision which you would approve and they would record at the point they go to start to construction. And that's the point they would apply to conservation when they go to construct the single family homes. At that point, they would review um the wetlands surrounding the property.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 167
At no point in a subdivision do we It's not a site plan. It's not a special permit. So, we don't look at things like grading, clearing. The only thing we can look at is access, lot size, uplands, buildable area, things of that nature. >> But isn't isn't part of the uplands though especially if we think it's not necessarily could be accurate. Isn't that part of Concom? >> I think >> it is, but you have to you have to remove that. So you cannot look at a plan and deny it because you think it might have wetlands. They're allowed to go to Concom and apply under that. We have to make sure that it has adequate uplands to create the subdivision. But if they do the ANRAD and it comes back and yes, they have appropriate uplands for subdivision requirements, you technically have to approve it by law and then allow it to go to conservation then for them to >> You're talking about the final one?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 168
Yes. I'm talking about definitive. Definitive. Yes. Preliminary. You're not >> There's no We have to approve it. >> Right. Right. There's no >> no requirements for preliminary. That's just if it was definitive. If you approved it, you you have to make sure it has the adequate amount of uplands, but then you have to release it to conservation to review the seex. So, so we're saying we there's no in um in a way there's no way we can verify the amount of uplands because the ANRAD hasn't verified where that wetlands line is. Right. >> And so we can't measure the land properly. Exactly. It can't be measured properly. So it's a guess right now if there's enough land to do this on all the lots like >> Right. >> Some of them are if they need to be what 25,000 >> but the ANRAD would be very separate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 169
So the ANRAD would tell us which is what we would want would tell us the amount of uplands but then they after that even after say that does satisfy all of the requirements if it does get approved they still have to go to conservation to file to build within that area regardless. So the ANRAD isn't like a blanket approval. It just tells you we now we know exactly. >> It's just a deliation. >> Exactly. Exactly. It's not an approval of any kind. It's just saying we're confirming the >> Wis. I'll take the public comment from online. >> Margie, can you state your name and record address for the record, please? >> Margie Gel, 8 Adams Road. I had some concerns about this project, but after hearing the what was said before about the concerns from the fire department and the fact that Becca said that delineation should come before approval and the fact that the applicant isn't here, I don't know why you would give a preliminary approval at this point.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 170
>> Yeah, I'm not sure if there was a miscommunication. I we don't know why the applicant isn't here, so I can't make a a a call on that. >> Well, regardless, I would urge you to wait before you make a decision. >> Right. Thank you. >> Thank you. >> Um, yes. So, it seems like there's two issues. Obviously the unclear on the uplands, the amount of uplands buildable land and obviously the um the the issues from the fire department which need seems significant um and and that this plan does not address those issues. Um so is this does someone have a recommendation that they would like to make? >> I'll make I'll make a motion to deny the preliminary uh subdivision. as we've discussed >> for reasons discussed uh specifically the lack of upline calculations that we can trust. It's essentially a theoretical concept that's not I don't think we have the ability to just in good faith approve it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above