2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 171
So, but to be clear, I'm going to make a motion to deny the preliminary subdivision for Carolina Estates. Second that >> and uh well I should off I should offer opportunity for discussion amongst the board. Do we give them any notes when we send this? You >> I'll write up a memo saying this was denied based on these criteria and it'll be the upland delineate lack of upland wetland delineation. And >> and to Margie's point, I wonder like the applicant is not here. wonder if the applicant was not here because they saw that email and >> it may be it depends on the firm and I don't know this firm but sometimes it is standard practice that they don't go to a preliminary hearing because it is preliminary but it depends on the firm but it's >> and you said the advantage of preliminary is for them to progress >> so that way they can more easily change this design because they haven't gone to things like grading or anything like yet it's very preliminary ary like this just on a flat piece of paper.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 172
So it's a lot easier for them to make changes based on your comments than if they had gone through and done 90% design and they had done the grading work and everything like that. >> So in theory we could have said yes with some conditions basically >> right and then they would come forward with a definitive plan with the NRA and you know response to fire's comments technically. So the reason for that I I first started off with seconding that but then I stopped to think like should we get back to the applicant share our conversations without saying denying the application at this point because it feels like that's >> well they can we can still deny this one they can bring another one next week right it doesn't >> the only thing is there is there's a fee there's an application fee each time but it's up to the board you have the ability to wave any application fee if they so request What does what is the fee used for?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 173
How much is it? Uh >> the fee I could tell you what it is if I look online, but the fee is essentially just administrative costs. It goes it covers the office and the time that we take to do it. >> Have they requested that? If they request it, we can revisit that at our next our next hearing. >> They have not. But >> I don't think we should be inviting that. I think we should just see what they do. >> Is it like 25 bucks or is it like >> No, it's a few hundred. No, it's it's less than a thousand. So, it's less than $1,000. I could tell you in just a minute. I'll look at the cost, but >> I don't think it's rocket science for them to check in with Kong prior to coming to us in light of how messy this property is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 174
So, I for one would have no issue denying it based on Becca's email alone. >> The fire too, right? >> Because you'll give him the notes about the fire ones, right? So, he'll come both. >> Yes, they should have both. >> Yeah, I would forward both emails to the applicant. >> Kind of speaks for itself. or >> yeah I I don't know um I don't know what would be standard to forward emails or to recap what is in the memo >> whatever works for them to generate um >> okay >> whatever works for them to make it clear that perhaps paying a fee again is perfectly reasonable >> all right so we do have a motion uh a motion are you continuing to second okay we have a motion on the table then we'll be looking for a roll call vote Deep Wenit, >> Anna Tesmanit Ike.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 175
I >> and Trisha Kendall I. So the mot the um preliminary >> preliminary subdivision >> subdivision um is not approved is denied. So um that concludes all our major agenda items. We actually do not have there there were no meeting minutes. Is that >> correct? The meeting minutes weren't completed. Usually um Laura has another week. Usually we wouldn't have met until the 13th. That's right. So >> um the >> So um >> preliminary fee is $1,600. I'm sorry. So it is over a thousand. So $1,600 plus $150 per lot created. Um so it would be 150. So that's 600. So would be 22 2200 is the fee. >> So if the applicant seeks a waiver, we can revisit that. >> But just for general in general, if any applicant asks for you to wave the application fee, that's completely your purview. We can't ever wave the public hearing notice fee and the fee for Butters.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 176
But if any applicant ever came to you and said, "I would request for you to wave this application fee." It's entirely the purview of >> And in theory, we could also reduce it. >> You could absolutely. It's It's your fee. It's up to you. You've said it. It's in the bylaw. >> Like, is there a check that I haven't been receiving? I'm just kidding. >> You're going to get the board in trouble there, Scott. >> Um, okay. >> Why don't we see how the applicant reacts to our position and if the applicant seeks some sort of mitigation or reduction, we can revisit it. >> Okay. Surprised that $2,200 didn't show up. >> I mean, Unfortunately, not entirely uncommon. Sometime, especially if they think it's like a slam dunk. >> I can't imagine they would because you you asked those questions about Yeah. So, >> yeah, >> could be an experience.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 177
>> It could be. >> All right. So, we do have a Let's see. Uh where my copy of the agenda is that I've been writing on. It's a mess here at my desk. I think I might have it on my computer if you want it. >> I I think I think I have it mostly. I just wanted to like under reports. >> Yes. So under reports uh the the current one differs from the the one the binders that I kept comprehensive plan on there because I think >> soon we will need to do comprehensive plan um implementation committee perhaps. So we might as well just keep it there as a placeholder. Is there anything to report from CPC or Metro West Regional Collaborative? >> Um, no. CPC, we just got a couple things come into um the town meeting. The um it is confirmed that the uh YMCA is not going to be presenting theirs at the time for the fall.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 178
So maybe in the spring. >> Okay. >> But >> okay. >> Issues to do with easements and fundraising. Deepa, anything from Metro West Regional? >> I believe there's another meeting that's coming up that I just saw an email yesterday. Today, >> yesterday they just sent it out. >> Yeah. >> Um, it's >> like a breakfast meeting. Oh, >> something in person. >> Wealth at 8:30. >> Yeah. >> All right. So, more to come. >> Great. Um, as for planning updates, we will now take the associate member search off the agenda. Yay. I am very I am sorry for the last minute. I literally uh found out on Sunday >> that I got a yes and I've talked to a dozen people about this position and I think she's going to be great. So I um I apologize for all the >> the quickness of it, but I'm thrilled to have her on board.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 179
Um so for our meeting next week, um we have 55 Tilton Avenue. Um this is the one where I will be recusing myself um and I will be chairing that um that project um and um uh >> next time. >> Yes, it's the opening meeting for it and Angel will um >> step in as our as our fifth member. >> Um we will also be hearing the having the in-law bylaw public hearing. Um uh I assume Doug Scott will >> Doug Scott will be joining us via Zoom. Yes, >> we'll be here with that one. Um he is the building. >> He's the building commissioner. Yep. Um >> so and uh to to review that. Um and then um we do have we do have Metro West on because it was continued to the third >> only because it was continued, but they have nothing to present yet.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 180
So they're just going to they gave us an extension until January, but they'll probably be continuing at least until if not December, January as well. >> So does that mean that they will have to um >> they'll have to submit a continuence? >> Continuence, >> but they've so we'll be looking for that as to where they want to continue to >> um Okay. And so the other thing um and and then uh Oregon Road will have to come down to get signed. a few things might need to get signed. Um, YMCA we continued to the 13th because we don't know where else to continue it to. So, if people can look at their schedules again for December, this is kind of the last thing we have to do. I I put this on the 13th, but we might as well talk about it now. Um, we have >> December 11th is our regularly scheduled meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 181
>> Yes. And um you know I I think I put this on the third this is on my little schedule that I sent you about what's going to happen on what date and I said at November 13th at this meeting we will also review December meeting dates. Um, and I think I did that because it's only November 13th and maybe then we will know which of these projects >> will be continued. >> It could only be one. It could only be the YMCA and Tilton >> that need to be talked about and so it could potentially be a one meeting December. I just don't think we know that yet. Could it if it of those dates, the 4th, the 11th, and the 18th, does anyone know of dates that they will not be able um to be here? Oh, and just to you're out the 13th, right, Scott?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 182
So, you will >> I'm gonna try, but >> so you you may very well miss the be that meeting, but that can be your one miss of Tilton. I think it's on the 11th. >> Okay. Just to clarify that. >> I mean, my my preference would be the 11th >> to keep it on the 11th that just do one. >> That's what I would recommend for December. >> I given what we're looking at now and and the things that we got done. The only thing I see is I think the YMCA in Tilton. You don't have anything that you know of that's popping up at the moment? >> Nothing that I know of at the moment. And next Thursday would be the deadline to get anything on for the 11th and I haven't heard of anything coming in. So >> Okay. >> So, uh, YMCA, we said we may be ready to start >> documenting conditions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 183
So, is that one meeting and be done then? We don't meet till January of 2026. >> I doubt it's going to be one I don't think we'll be done in that meeting. >> So, then does that mean December has more than one meeting? Then should it be 4th and 18th versus 11th? >> You know, we it's not something um Thank you you guys for coming. >> Thank you. No problem. >> Um we >> we don't have to decide again November 13th is only halfway through November. So we can hold this discussion >> until after our next meeting and we get a better lay of the land that we can either keep the 11th or we can choose two dates in there. It could be piggyback just like we're doing now. We're doing two dates close together or it could be spreading them out. But maybe maybe it's better to wait to see up to the 13th and then we'll decide what we're going to do in December.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 184
>> Were all of our meeting days for the year public? >> And the >> right they were all listed on our website. >> Yes. >> And the 11th is our standard date. >> Right. >> I'm not clear why we would need to consider two. Is there some sort of sort of statutory requirement where we must have a decision in December on the Y? >> No, it's just more that sometimes, >> you know, like when we were looking at this is one of the reasons we had two meetings. It was just way too much to do in one meeting, >> right? Okay. >> So, I don't anticipate that happen. But why? Maybe. >> So, they don't need the decision by December. >> No. No. >> Okay. >> So, to me, I'm not seeing such great uh volume that we need to do that in December. I also think December is a really bad month for public participation and I personally would not want to vote for the Y in December.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 185
>> Sure. Okay. I would want that vote in January. So, >> so let's keep it at December 11th for now and and if other things pop up, we will revisit it on November 13th to see if we want to make a change. >> Good. >> I think that's reasonable. And I also think December is a tough month for everyone. So, it's not the best time to rush decisions. Yeah. Okay. >> As long as we're making good faith progress on the draft. >> Yeah. >> I'm also not against having a meeting with the Y at the next next week and starting to discuss a draft next week even if they're not prepared with the parking response and the GCG response. I I don't think it's a waste of a meeting with them next week. You know, it could be it could be valuable if we want to start as we've done before that as you two know >> that we actually start to go through all of the listed conditions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 186
>> Exactly. >> And discuss them as a group and take notes and therefore we're creating material to give to Jasmine about what to put in that decision. So that might be a good idea whether the why is here or not. They don't need their team here because we can just start to >> Scott may have trouble accessing. >> Oh yeah, >> it's true. But it's just a draft. It's just it's just for it's just to gain ideas. It's it's it's going to be seen several more times likely. >> Okay. >> So, >> it won't be if he can get on log in it won't be considered as one meeting out, right? >> Because they've already missed the initial meetings for Y. >> Oh, I see what you mean. Like if we discuss that >> I didn't miss any other meetings with the Y. I didn't think you >> No, before you started, we we had presentations from by >> but that wasn't part of the public hearing process.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 187
So that's >> Is that informal? >> That was informal preliminary. Yeah. So it doesn't count. >> We didn't post that. >> If you may have posted it, it doesn't it doesn't apply to the public hearing process because it wasn't we hadn't received this application yet. That was even before I got here >> that they gave their informal presentation. >> Oh. Oh, >> I was in a walk through. >> You were? Yeah. >> Yeah. Okay. Then you haven't missed me. >> Yeah, I don't think you have. >> Wait, is that when we restarted this application? No, I don't think so. >> In June. >> Let's confirm. Let's confirm that that Scott hasn't missed any YMCA meetings >> and then we can see if we want to use that meeting >> just to start going through some conditions. >> The only one would be if it happened before the election.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 188
>> So, did you guys >> And they didn't apply before the election. They haven't applied until after I got here. So, >> double check. Are you sure? >> Yeah, this application didn't come in until after I began. >> No, YMC has come in before you. >> But not they didn't apply. So, it doesn't matter. The It does the timeline doesn't start until I stamp >> meeting with us without an application. >> They had a preliminary >> a preliminary review and the timeline doesn't start until I stamp in >> the application with the clerk and that's when the timeline starts and when we start checking the Mullins rule. >> Interesting. >> Didn't we didn't is that one of on we had to relist though because we lost Camo and >> like one sure one of the projects >> double check >> one of the projects we reposted it and >> that was your fields >> that was the fields was it just one >> book I mean >> didn't he miss more than one then sorry I didn't mean to do that >> he's coming next week you are the one who's coming next >> No but I meant like >> yeah he can't >> was there only was there only one that he >> he's not going to be able to vote in the one >> yeah because he missed there were too many me or he only missed the one Right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 189
Uh >> you can participate in all. >> Yeah, they can discuss but they can't vote >> what >> and well Angel can't vote on the Y. >> It's not she's not No, she it's she's not a person in the five person board. You can vote on the why >> because it >> I am pretty sure because it we restart we republished it. I think we reposted it and you >> It was the field that was reposted, not >> Well, I I think I think Paul missed one meeting and then he watched it on the tape. >> It's one. You're fine. >> There's There's no way we would You're fine. >> Yeah, I'm I'm pretty sure that >> that we are all fine. I don't want to miss any more, but let's double check these two troublemakers to make sure we're >> I've been at every meeting since I've been elected.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-07 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board & Joint Meeting with Select Board (November 6… · passage 190
>> One more. >> I'm going to try next week really hard. You have to get your vacation. >> Darn it, Scott. >> My pin colada out of the >> So when we're drafting the response, >> you have one for me, too. >> New associate member ask questions. >> Of course. >> Absolutely. >> Or offer suggestions. >> Yes. They just can't vote. >> Participation. No vote. >> Associate member has been a very valuable team member once we started >> given her experience. I think she's >> not just not angel but also the ones we have before we had civil engineers who had like amazing input in all our projects. Now, now just so you know, um I I told Ael that we if she wins, we treat the associate member like any other member except obviously they can't vote and she understands that. But given the the time frame, like literally I talked to her Sunday, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above