The board voted unanimously to deny the claim dated October 13, 2025 of Arlene Garcia. >> Okay. Thank you. Okay, brings us to item nine, adoption of the agenda. The board may approve the agenda as is or add or pull items from consent calendar. Do we have a motion to adopt the agenda? Just an adoption. >> So moved >> Second. Maria Apara. >> Anita Tucker. >> Hi. >> Miss Longshore. >> I >> Maria Aquora. >> I. >> Amanda Buchanan. >> I vote I as well. Okay. We don't have any presentations uh discussion item. We'll move on to comments from the public. Kylie, we have some cards. >> Yes, we have uh nine. >> Okay. Okay.
Again, we'll try to limit it to We have quite a few here, so we limit it to the three minutes. Um Jennifer Taylor is up first and after Jennifer will be Jeffrey her. Good evening, superintendent, board members, staff, and colleagues. I am here to speak about behavior I have observed between board members. I have personally witnessed a sorry antagonistic behavior between board members as well as directed to union members. It's very clear one board member is particularly um being singled out. Every request presented by this board member at the last regular meeting were denied and this member was has even been accused of bullying. I am troubled troubled by this behavior as the board steers the direction of our leaders. As teachers, you require us to put a stop to bullying between students. Yet no one on the board intervened when one of their own was being bullied in a public forum.
As a teacher, I tell my students, you don't have to like everyone, but you have to be respectful and civil. You should be setting an example of our core values. How are we as a district supposed to come together and work towards the best for our students and employees if the board member our board cannot behave as a unified front? Please, for the sake of our students, district and community, do better. Thank you. [applause] Jeffrey Warner, not here anymore. Okay. Carlos Calderon. And then after Carlos, it'll be Mr. PE going to put a quick timer in my watch real quick. >> That's okay. I got you right there. >> All right. Um, good [clears throat] evening, president, trustees, and superintendent. My name is Carlos R. Calderon, a retired service member and a father of Camila and Carlos Calderon. All right, seventh grade and third grade.
Um, do I have any uh veterans in this house today? [applause] Thank you. All right. So, thank you for uh serving your your your your country and um and I just want to say so we moved to Apple Valley to establish our new home. All right. While finalizing while final house our our final housing is pending, my children and I are temporarily um staying with my sibling, my my younger brother. I work within ABSU uh district boundaries. I've spoken to uh Miss Castillo and Mr. Patrick about this. Uh, I've denied twice. Denied twice already and I've just spoken to them about what's going on in my situation. I just recently retired. All right. One October and happened to have the government shutdown happened one October. So, I'm still pending my VA. Okay. I spoke to the board members and I spoke to everybody. I have not getting a written request or notice or anything.
I'm tired. I'm desperate. And my children need their education ASAP. Two laws apply. first in the federal Mckin Vental homeless act which I talked to Mr. Patrick correct was me you and Mr. to see it and you came up and said that I wasn't allowed because I wasn't a resident of here and I said I I I purchased my house. I'm in escrow. Okay. And I have a federal act that I invoked and you still deny me, sir. With Miss Castine. Okay. Students who lack fixed irregular adequate nighttime residents, including those doubling with relatives, must be immediately enrolled even if typical documents are missing, which I I brought everything to Mr. Castillo. I miss M Castillo and Mr. Patrick. They still denied my access to get my children enrolled into the district. Okay. Because then second, under California's Allen Bill Law, education code 48204, because I work inside AV AVUSD, my children qualify as residents for ABSD schools.
Yes or no? Yes. It's under your policies. Okay. So, my request specific is enroll my daughter. Okay. It's already almost 9:00 and I'm desperate. I'm here to talk to the public and I'm talking to the board members. Please. All right. As a new resident of the high desert, this is very wrong that you what you guys are doing. As a new member of the community, seeing from the outside looking in, this is my first time here and this is this is disgraceful what you guys are doing to the community and to our children. So, what I want and what I need today is provide the district McKini I I want to invoke the McKini Vento leazison to meet with me which I know is Miss Castillo. Yes or no Patrick? So, if the district still refuses, give me a right ar decision tonight to state the reason and dispute in my complaint in the process.
I brought with a one-page packet with all the documents required to get my children enrolled into school tonight so they could start participating tomorrow where they belong. Thank you, [applause] [cheering] >> Superintendent Nelson. Could we get um just uh like maybe an email update about like what the process is and where Mr. Caleron is at? Thank you. >> Mr. Peak, you're up. And then uh Terry, you're next. Nice to see you all once again, members of the board. Superintendent Nelson. Um, this is my fourth my fourth time being here and I'm kind of being known as the kid who speaks at the board meets and I have to admit it's kind of cool being a celebrity since the last time I was a celebrity. I was a banana at a Green Day concert. So now all I got to do is try to get my teachers on board with extra credit for what I'm trying to accomplish here, especially you English.
Uh, tonight I want to bring to you some further research and data I've worked hard to get this uh this last month. I reached out to many neighboring and not so close but still successful school districts that obey the law SB 328. I asked each school personnel a le a list of same or similar questions. I will share my questions and answers received. I spoke with assistant superintendent Dr. Yei from Victor Valley Union High School District. She kind of answered on the fly and didn't have an exact set of measurable data, but was honest in answering my questions based on word of mouth and experience. She admitted that later start times allowed them to begin to implement programs that have drastically cut down on early morning tardies and absenteeism. I asked, "Has there been a decline or change in morning incidents, traffic violations, or accidents?" And she said, "There has been a lot less suspensions since later start times." So, hey, that's still pretty good.
Um, Dr. Yei said there had really been no effect on extracurriculars or sports. The only real concern they've had is safety for students, especially this time of year since it's dark. And I mean this in the nicest way possible. This is Victorville. So that's probably why their um concern for this was maybe heightened. The main drawback that she had was busing is an expense and she wish that uh Governor Gavin Newsome had thought about that while helping uh school districts with when he passed this law. However, speaking with teachers in San Bernardino City Unified School District at Kahon High School and Indian Springs High School, both of which are accredited international balorate high schools have had wonderful success implementing an 8:30 start time in accordance with the law. Morning tardies are down as well as absenteeism. Student morale and mental health is optimal and while there is really no data to reflect less accidents or traffic violations, traffic getting to school has been noticeably alleviated.
Sports are thriving, often going to CIF. One teacher from Indian Springs High School said, "Any high school not accommodating high school students with later start times is insane." There's such a difference in these districts students since changing the high school start times. I've also talked to Orange County schools and plan to reach out to Lucern and Baker Unified, all of whom who do have later start times. I will forward their data as soon as I get it. And I know I've been a little bit lengthy tonight, but I want to leave you with one final thing. While concluding my conversation with Dr. Yei, she said she's an early riser, so getting up early doesn't really bother her, but she does support an 8 to 8:30 start time. Then she mentioned she doesn't know why a district like ABUSD would not go along with a change like this since they have the resources, which makes me think, does she know something that I don't?
Why would she say something like this? Thank you and good night. >> [applause] >> to repeat. >> That'd be me. Just for the record. >> Greetings, esteemed board, President Raleigh, Superintendent Nelson, and all those watching, and those of you still here, this is a great for change. I always come here in support 100% for Kian and his agenda to change the high school start times. I am beyond proud of his consistency and drive. Can you tell he's the youngest of five driven to be noticed and live life his way? This month, although my topic for public comments very much coincides with Kian's motive, I'd like to question Granite Hills High School and perhaps bring awareness to a newly implemented tardy sweep and consequences. In December 2023, new traffic direction and allowed entrance access was changed and has been an absolute crap show since. I'd like to point out that I censored myself there.
I have gone round and round and round and round with admin at the school, teachers, and the district regarding the issues, especially tardies and student safety that this has caused. I have not been heard or considered in any instance. There is a literal one way in, one way out. That's it for getting students to class. Unless, of course, you dare to take your chances with the demolition speedway through the dirt fields. There are no crossing guards in the streets protecting the students. If you take your chances and go through the student drop off line, which there is no other choice to get through if you want to park in the student parking lot, yet staff seems to be able to park anywhere. All but one entrance to the A building is closed to the students to access their classes. Getting through the student lot is a death maze in itself because everyone's in a hurry.
I have counted many, many times at least 50 to 100 cars still waiting to get in the parking lot between 6:58 and 700 a.m. when school starts at 7:01. This is where I imagine a generous number of tardies are coming from. I have brought this to the brought to the table many suggestions. They complain that tardies take up valuable class time. Yet, first thing in the morning, it takes 10 to 15 minutes just to stand in line and get a tardy slip when most students could just hustle the class being 1 to four minutes late and marked tardy instead of 12 to 18 minutes with a piece of paper saying that they were tardy. The only real response I ever received was from you, Mr. Sloer, and that was in March in 2024 when you said, "Be patient. Give it time to work itself out." It in it in fact has not worked itself out.
This school has transparency and accountability issues with many of its staff being untrustworthy and leaving little faith to me as a parent with a student there. It hasn't done me any good to contact teachers, administration, or the district office about any concerns my family has had there. I recently raised many of these concerns and more a few months ago at a board meeting. I've spoke spoken with Miss Wells with clear questions requesting answers. The air has been radio silent since. My family has gone above and beyond for more than 20 years to make this school district and the schools we've attended within the best within it the best we possibly can. I've spoken of the accomplished list I have on record. Yet still no answers, still no clarity, still no feeling of safety or acknowledgement where my family is concerned. I'm hoping that someone on a deeper level will look at my concerns and get real direction, answers, and assurance for change for not only my student, but for the futures to come.
As I leave here tonight, I feel bad in saying I'm glad we only have one left, one year left to endure this school district and this school. Thank you for your time. Good night. [applause] Up uh next is Eva Beavers. Eva, you here? There she is. And then after Eva will be Stephen Cops. >> Okay. So, you will have to forgive me as I have a mask on. I'm not trying to get cooties everywhere. Okay. But um I wanted to address the board because I am a parent to special needs children. And I want to question why there is not some sort of settlement to resolve the request for competitive pay for our teachers. As I have been blessed as a stay-at-home mom to have been approved by the district to volunteer at my [clears throat] children's school. I take pride in being able to witness firsthand how the dedicated teachers are about providing education to our future community.
They are requesting competitive pay and deserve to make such a request since you the board have maybe never been in or it has been some time since you have ever stepped in a classroom to partake in or have knowledge of what it takes to provide an adequate education to our future teachers, engineers, firefighters, cosmetologists, or even labor workers or possibly even the first female president of the United States. So, we need to pay accordingly since our teachers go through so much such as getting things thrown at them, sometimes getting screamed at for no reason, yet expected to meet such high demands at a very low rate of pay. I would like to request more PARA educators for the special ed classrooms throughout the school districts as more support would be beneficial. I had the opportunity to speak with the members of the board and I was told that the federal funding for special ed classes that was promised has not been received, but I would like to see the proof of that.
As a light has been shined on the district for fraud or budget expenditures have been called into question. Why can't the board members sacrifice some of their pay to provide a competitive pay for our teachers? As Apple Valley is a bigger community than Lassern Valley, yet the teachers over there get paid more than our teachers here. How does that make sense? Um during your comments in C-6, if I'm saying that correctly, it was said that coming from or coming from being a teacher to support a teacher, I find that to be inhumane. There was also mention of millions of dollars, yet there's still no answers. It was said to have patience with the board, yet there's still no accountability. We don't need to lose our dedicated teachers. I'm asking the community to support the teachers and staff because we need them for our children. Thank you.
Have a good night. [applause] >> Stephen, and then after Mr. Cox will be Adrien Forks. >> Well, welcome again. Thanks for letting us speak. Um I stand a little bit just kind of disappointed in uh watching um tonight um when we're being asked to be patient and I feel like we have been patient for quite a while. Um we were told at the last meeting that no votes would happen unless something moved with teachers and yet I'm sure we're going to see votes again tonight moving forward. We have asked for documents the same documents that you guys were talking about about who was hired with onetime money. We haven't got an answer yet um that I know of. So, we've asked for information. The information that we do get seems to come in waves. Uh it's not always accurate. And so, uh so the patience, I think, is has run out.
Normally, I was telling people that I think what happens is about in this time in negotiations, it seems like the district is thinking that we're going to just kind of fold and and we're done. I think you saw tonight the resolve is there. Um, it's getting it's getting heavier and heavier. We had more people this time than last time. And uh I'll be in my classroom, I'm sure, tomorrow morning early. I go an hour early every day. Um, it's just what I do. Um, this week I've been broke up a fight, got hit a few times. Um, smelled a few things in my classroom that I shouldn't have to smell uh in a classroom. um got told f off u this week and that's just in a normal week all with uh the be patient uh be patient's not uh not one of those things that I think is there we sit back and we do I heard it said that um just watching sometimes with the board itself of being able to have the courtesy to each other to listen to each other and I don't even think I see that um and that goes on up here but yet we're being told to be patient to keep going but we don't have any answers yet.
So, um I'm I'm in a loss. I really am trying to lead this as a lead negotiator, but hitting walls at every So, I don't know what the end of this going to be, but I can see that in my department, if there was openings in another district, I'd probably lose half the department right now. They're already talking about it. There's just nowhere to go right now because they've already taken all of our teachers and so there's just none. So when the other districts open new schools, we're going to be in a world of hurt unless we actually It sounds like the money's there. We're trying to find money. Money's there, but it's just a matter of are we going to make priorities teachers, counselors, and those that are on the hard lines with the students. Again, I'll be there tomorrow morning early like I always do because I love my students.