2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 138
But I'm honest tonight. I'm not sure I can say I love my district. And that hurts me to say that. Thank you, [applause] Adrian. >> And then uh Gabriel, >> good evening. >> Go ahead. I'm sorry, ma'am. >> Sorry. Good evening, President Karen Sabres of Avida, JC Scott, president of CSA for Apple Valley Unified, who is proudly representing CSA at the state level, but watching live right now, board of trustees and superintendent Nelson. My name is Adrienne Forbes. I am the vice president of Avuda and second grade teacher at Rancho Birdie Elementary. I feel that it is time for me to stand up and speak for what is right and what I have been watching at our school board meetings. I've sat in the audience for the last four years and watched the school board approved budgets that they clearly have not been fully informed about.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 139
So much so that they feel that they have debured a new trustee because she is finally questioning the people that she had have been questioning the district who should have had the answers. Not sure if the other trustees feel guilty for not asking the important questions from the last few years, but maybe they feel culpable by being misled by the superintendents that work for them. Something smells fishy when trustees starts turn start turning on one another publicly. Unfortunately for our district, that is one of the many problems at hand. So, how can we expect our students to do the right thing when the trustees can't do it? Because the parents and the students are watching the behavior that the adults in charge are demonstrating. How we can trust our district and school board when they vote for compensation agreements that happen 11:30 p.m. at night when all the people that would have questioned them and held them accountable but had to leave because they have families and have to teach the next day.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 140
Our teachers in the district are exhausted with the administration directing the trustees to rubber stamp the budgets that are set in front of them. Our students and families deserve better. I would like to explain to you what my passion is, which required me to get into great debt to be a teacher. I am a highly qualified second grade teacher with a bachelor's degree in early child education and a master's degree in curriculum and education with a minor in steam and technology leadership. I explain my degree so you can understand what my education background is before I go into the jobs that I perform daily. I teach up to five different academic subjects a day to 22 8-year-olds. On Wednesdays, I teach up to 98-year-olds the basic principles of coding, which is something that the students will be used to for many different career paths in their future, which also includes up to an hour or more of grading a day.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 141
I am a problem solver, a social emotional counselor, owi fixer, nourisher, protector, disciplinarian, parent communicator, esteemed teacher after school, and on the side for school, I am our school's spelling be coordinator for the fourth year in a row, as well as wear many other hats. My weekends consist of grading in the evenings, during the week, and on my days off, which means I do not get weekends off. I go to work at 7 in the morning and every other day I leave at 5:00 p.m. I work 54 hours a week at my pay rate which equates to $8 more an hour than food service workers in the state of California. If I was teaching in Hisparian pay rate my pay rate I would be making $16 more an hour than a food service worker if I was paid hourly. Let's be real. I am underestimating my time calculating because it's quite more.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 142
You see, we aren't looking for the best competitive pay in the high desert. We just need a fair livable wage that you had no problem offering to the other associations to pay our teachers a fair livable wage. It would attract specialists in steam, special education, bilingual, and encourage long-term career commitment. Better compensation, enable schools to hire and keep higher caliber educators, which correlates with higher student achievement, lower absenteeism, and stronger classroom management. We are also asking for accountability for the situation our district is in. We as teachers do not want to be in the situation next year and the year after. As you well know, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing and expecting a different result. Please end this saga and come to the table with a reasonable offer that compensates your beloved teachers and remove the reasons for them to leave.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 143
Because we as a district spend far too much on induction support for brand new teachers that only benefits other districts when our brand new teachers leave because they realize they could be making 10,000 more a year 20 minutes away. That money can be better used elsewhere. Thank you for your time. >> [applause] >> Gabriel through >> Good evening. My name is Gabriel Murz. I'm coming to you as a concerned parent. Um, I don't know any of you or enough about the situation to speak completely intelligently on it. I don't mean to come off condescending or disrespectful in any way, so please don't take it as that, but it does uh upset me to hear some of the things that I've heard tonight and read what I've read in the articles. There's got to be a better way of doing business. I don't know what that is or what it entails.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 144
That's for you guys and the teachers to figure out, but we got to come to the table and figure something out. It's very concerning to hear these things when I got three of my children in your school district. And I expect them to have the best teachers, the best everything. And that should be your legacy and what you guys leave behind to these students. And if that means adjusting course and doing something different uh uh maybe even changing your culture uh to how you address these issues, maybe that's what's needed. I don't know. Uh I work as a correctional counselor. I've been doing corrections for 20 years. And I empathize with what the teachers are going through because we're going through the exact same thing. We've been asked to do more with less and dangerous hostile conditions for so long. It's become our culture now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 145
It's what's expected. Oh, that's just your job. No, dude. That's not cool. I mean, I'm good at what I do and we're successful at making a prison run uh uh the right way, but that's in spite of our management, not because of them. There's a difference. And they got that confused. They're okay with writing off our talents, our knowledge, and you know uh uh our ability to get our job done with with uh falling behind our wages. Also, like uh in my profession too, our wages have grown stagnant. Our benefits have grown stagnant. Uh I got a good slogan that I came up with at work a few months ago. Money talks and good officers walk. And that's what's been happening to us too. And you know, I'm tempted to leave too myself, but I'm kind of so close to retirement. I got to stick this out.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 146
And that's an unfair position for me to have to be in for all the time and sacrifice that I put in. You know, to have to go through that and then hear about our teachers going through that. Hey, I have my talents when it comes to corrections and law enforcement. You could put a tattoo murder in front of me and I'll confront them over something as petty as tucking in a shirt and stand on business. That's what I do as profession. But I will take a side door to these guys. What they do with the most precious thing to my life, man, they deserve more pay than I get. I'll give them more credit than I I'll take any day of the week. And we should be doing all we can to support them and make sure we have their back. And if that means sacrificing some uh pay at the top, uh uh some positions at the top to funnel it down to make sure they're at least competitive.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 147
If I heard them crying for, you know, the highest pay, I'd be like, "Come on, guys. Knock that off." But they're just asking for competitive wages. That shouldn't be too much to ask. We just passed a measure in the town of Alpa Valley earlier uh last year to add to our our taxes for more law enforcement and more firefighters. uh should we even asking for teachers pay because I wasn't aware that was an issue until recently. So I served in the United States Navy. I did two deployments on my ship. Our ship slogan was there's always a better way of doing business and I would submit that to you now. However we've been doing things I don't know what that is. I like to speak intelligently but it's got to be a better way of doing business. Thank you. [applause] >> Okay. Hey, that takes care of public comments.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 148
We can go back to board member comments. Uh, Anita Tucker. >> Thank you. >> I'm sorry. Nothing. Okay. Okay. Renee, >> um I just want to echo the appreciation um that Trusty Tucker shared. Um all of you showing up and being a part of this process and um being a voice is just so very important. So I want to encourage you all um to continue to show up and and speak to us because um we are listening. >> Maria, >> no comments. Amanda, >> I don't have >> I don't either. Uh, superintendent. Okay. Public hearing. Conduct public hearing. Receive comments on the annual 5-year statutory school fee report. Matthew Schulenberg. >> Oh, yeah. I'm sorry. I now open the public hearing to receive comments on the annual and fiveyear statutory school fee report. time open to >> Oh, thank you. >> I don't have any comments for the report, Mr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 149
Braley. Unless anybody has any questions, I think we need to keep it open for a minimum of of a minute to give the public the chance to comment. >> Okay, sounds good. [snorts] [clears throat] All right, I think that uh time is up for that. So, we have any comments or questions? Um we can close the um public hearing and time closed at 9:09. Moves us to item H, special meeting, none at this meeting. Discussion item session is recommended the board of trustees discuss and take action on the following items. Approve the agreement with CSBA for access to board self-evaluation survey BS and that will be for through a motion through a motion to approve item >> a move >> moved by second by >> Tucker >> Miss Tucker. Okay, we'll do a roll call vote. Um, Anita Tucker, >> I. >> Renee Longshaw, >> I.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 150
>> Maria Akbara, >> I. >> Amanda Buchanan, >> I vote I as well. >> Okay. Item two, approve the renewal of the Mountain Desert Career Pathway Joint Powers Agreement, MDCP JAPA. >> So moved. >> We have a motion through um Buchanan. And I had a second there by Tucker. Okay, roll call will be Anita Tucker. >> I, >> Renee Longshaw, >> I. >> Maria Aquara, >> I. >> Amanda Buchanan, >> I vote I as well. Item three, approve the certificate and classified personal actions as listed. Do I have a motion? >> So moved. >> Motion Buchanan and I'll second it. And rolling. And um Anita Tucker. >> Hi. Renee Longshore. >> Um I just wanted to point out that we have one additional FTE uh for the total of 60 new hires for the 2526 school year. Um and I >> you vote I Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 151
Maria Okara >> I. >> Amanda Buchanan >> I vote I as well. Item four, approve the recommendation request to leave as noted. I'll move the item. >> I'll second. >> Second. Um, Buchanan, >> Anita Tucker, >> I, >> Renee Longshaw, >> I, >> Maria Opara, >> I, >> Amanda Buchanan, >> I vote I as well. Item five, approve recommendation of the administrative hearing, chairperson effected immediately on exp 42526 and AR7202526. So, >> so moved. >> Second. >> We have a motion. U B U B U B U B U B U B U B U B U B U Buchanan >> Maria >> Second Opara. >> Anita [clears throat] Longore. >> I mean, I'm really getting tired here. Anita Tucker. >> I >> Renee Longore. >> I >> Maria Okara. >> I >> Amanda Buchanan. >> I vote I as well. Okay. Annual review case AR7202526.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 152
You already added. >> Oh, I did them. That's right. We did them together. Okay. Approve the adoption and implementation of the student information system SCIS from focus. We're going to have a presentation real quick from >> just briefly. Yes. Just because this is an item of such great consequence to our system, I wanted to just give some background before the board took action here. >> Thank you. Okay. Okay. >> And so, um, I'm thankful I don't even have to set up the presentation. someone else is doing that for me and we have such a great team here doing that. And I'll just mention that um this particular change is not coming to us at the time necessarily of our choosing because of some um items that are coming through and a change that's coming from our current student information system. However, thankfully the process has been of our choosing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 153
So I'm um going to introduce Mr. Buchanan, but he and his team and really a team of almost a couple of hundred uh teachers, uh clerical staff, um really anyone who's going to be interacting with the student information system were involved in this in some way. And so they really built a great process to go through and and make this um a process of our choosing. And um we're excited about this. We're not making a change to a system this big is a lot of work, but we're excited because we feel like this has got good um uh energy from those who made the decision, which was our staff. And so I'll I'll uh introduce Mr. Buchanan to kind of walk us through where where we are, where we're headed, and kind of give you some background on this decision that we're proposing or putting in front of you tonight.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 154
>> Good evening. Um, and as Mr. Slasher pointed out, I'm Jason Buchanan, director of IT for Apple Valley Unified School District, and I'm here to give you some more context as to this board item for approving um, asking you to approve the purchase of focus implementation system. Um, a couple of years ago, Aries informed us, our current SIS, who we've used for over 20 years, informed us that they were making some changes that would go into effects this next June or July 2026. Um, one of those changes is increase in cost about $50,000 per year. Also, we have to we'll lose some functionality that we currently rely on the ability to um sandbox to stage our own um patching. And so those con those changes con caused us to think whether or not Ari areas was continuing to be the best solution for Apple Valley Unified.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 155
So we decided to ask the system. We started a process to review um what we want out of an SIS and we invited um a couple years ago we invited over 137 staff to participate in a discussion about whether we should consider switching. And out of that discussion, there was an agreement that we should at least look to see what's in the market since it's changing. Let's see what's going on out in the world. We gathered the res recommendations from that committee about who should participate in further discussions. We had 89 staff participate in various focus groups to develop the criteria we used to build an RFP. And this last August, we published the RFP. Um and on October 3rd we received seven responses. The technology data team reviewed those responses and um scored them. Those score sheets are attached to the board item for your review.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 156
And we looked at the scores and we invited focus and edgypoint softwares to come and present a full-on demonstration of the scenarios we asked them to look at. We um sorry I'm at that point in my life where I have to take my glass off to read my screen, but now I can't see you. So [laughter] um the scoring included the scoring of that sheet is also in your board packet as the SIS evaluation section score sheet um of that. So when we invited all the each each participant was asked to consider how this would relate to Aries. Aries is our system and we don't want to just switch on a whim. So they were expect so we asked them to review it in consideration of how it compares to Aries and also score it and out of that we had 40 so we got those score sheets and out of that last two Fridays ago we had 45 staff members meet in a committee and discuss the review sheets and the scenario scores and provide their the cost analysis and provide their feedback and so that feedback as you can see through the charts there and this was included in the packet.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-08 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Nov 06, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 157
The first question is a really important one and that is even though we only had two vendors there, there's really a third vendor in the room. That's our current system. The new system was just going to cost more and lose functionality, but they were promising they would give no feature upgrades. So, we understood exactly what we were going to have if we stayed with Aries. But one thing we would have is no sort of implementation costs, right? There would be no like the pressure of changing and the the requirement for new learning for a system that's so important to everything we do. and of course reporting to the state. And so that was one consideration. And so the first question they had to wrestle with is should we go ahead and go forward with this kind of costly thing from the point of view of time and energy?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above