And I feel like there have been some norms in Greenfield that have kind of made that um a little bit fuzzy because it's almost as though we have felt required to attend their meetings and send our superintendent to report to them when as Secretary Geneive mentioned, you know, according to the law, the superintendent is supervised by the school committee and only the school committee. Um, so, uh, I think that's part of what we're trying to address here, um, is how do we have a good relationship, stay in good communication, take advantage of the generous offer of the city council platform to achieve our own goals as a school committee without um, uh, graying creating any kind of gray areas between um, as far as who really supervises is the school system. Um, so member Martini, >> just to clarify, this is about getting the leadership of the school committee and the leadership of city council in a room to talk about how to work better together as co-equal partners.
Um over representation of ethnically and linguistically diverse students in special education programs is the primary area of focus for most of our educational agencies. Um significant disproportionality. How do you how do you qualify as that? So um there is a set maximum risk ratio of a 3.0. Disproportionate means that a district exceeds the risk ratio in one or more indicator. to be significantly disproportionate. It means that we have exceeded that risk ratio for three consecutive years. Um when a district is in SIGDS, a CSA's plan must be written annually and 15% of our federal IDA funds uh must be set aside for the improvement of this work. So it's not new money. It's money that we already have but is reallocated. Um this is a snapshot of our last three years uh for our risk ratio of 3.0 or less. You can see that uh for the last three years 2122 22 23 and 2324 we exceeded the 3.0 mark uh in a great detail to dig a little deeper that is us going back to 2018 2019.
So that being said, I understand as well that that that the cops grants that we have um implemented prior have been very successful in not only um uh providing surveillance that was able to support um situations that may have been may not have been um um captured or or or been been observed to the degree that that the uh incidents were. And I don't I don't mean to say that that that's what happens all the time and that's why we're we're doing it. But I do want to say that the the overall effort um I think needs to be really heavily expressed. um that supporting these types of projects and and um we by by no supporting these types of projects and and regardless of where they come from um I think it's important for us to to acknowledge that our schools um are very different we do have some very special circumstances when it comes to not only location but also uh the fact that There are a lot of many there are many different factors as to why a student um may feel unsafe or feel or feel confident enough that they will do something so brash or so haphazardly that it will cause harm to others.
Um, I I I get it the ACTs and the SATs, but when you have students that are clearly doing a really great job, but then they h what's in it for me. Do you see what I'm saying? Like when you have to explain to a student when they're learning algebra or algebra 2 or trig and they're like, I'm never going to use this. And you're like, you're right. You're never going to use it, but you have to do it. Um, it kind of comes back to something like that. And my my concern is maybe pushing away some of those students because they're required to go take all these tests and you know attend all these career nights. Um so perhaps maybe just some small adjustments uh to make a big in impact and shifting some of the and requirements do this and this and this and this to or requirements perhaps um and using existing frameworks like national honor society uh and just ensuring that we're celebrating every student's unique path to success.
President Downey, members of the board, uh Dr. Lman, it is our pleasure to be here tonight to share I hope quickly. I know you had a huge agenda tonight. So there's there's we could have talked longer. I'd left some stuff out, but I'll try to make it quick. I am going to follow up on two things about that presentation that we just heard that um do come to mind. One is that with the opening of of a of a new school, it's always hard to know exactly who's going to want to go. And since it's a K8, which as you point out is the first one in the district, it's even a little bit harder because we know that there's going to be or I know there's going to be some number of seventh graders this year who just don't want to make that transition for eighth grade.
I support that as well. I just um where I do think I have a point of difference, however, is I support what it says in the city code that at city council meetings um it clearly states in the code um uh it's section 565-8 that at the city council meetings unless unless they change the code. It it um communications from the superintendent of schools and the school committee and then it um questions for from the council for the superintendent of schools and so but I agree with the whole rest of this. I think it's wonderful to have communications between the two bodies. So I will vote in favor of that. But I believe that the superintendent of schools should be invited to all of the meetings because that's our law. It's an ordinance that was voted on. >> Yeah. And I don't know whether that um was tested in terms of the whether a body like the city council can vote and require a school committee to attend.
Is that fair to say? >> Yes. Yes. And I think co-equal >> Oh, sorry. Go. I'm 100% all for it and I see absolutely no reason not to support that idea. >> Thank you for that. Yes. And I think co-equal is a good word because it kind of speaks to the separation of powers that are really built into the charter and and for a reason. Uh they really they both bec both both to uh comply with the state law and also um out of a understanding that the school the school's interest and budget are just a different animal than uh other city departments. Um so mayor >> I agree with member Martini. I support that as well. I just um where I do think I have a point of difference, however, is I support what it says in the city code that at city council meetings um it clearly states in the code um uh it's section 565-8 that at the city council meetings and unless they change the code.
So we have exceeded the 3.0 risk ratio for a number of years. Um, and then just to highlight in digging a little deeper, um, this is our Hispanic students being overly identified for specific learning disability. Um, we at some point decided that for students who needed this qualification, we would no longer identify them uh, for specific learning disability and we started identifying them for other health impairment. And as you can see, that didn't necessarily work because now we are um, above the risk ratio of 3.0 O for the last two years for Hispanics being overqualified for other health impairment. So our 2025 SIM plan for C uh Case um we are significantly disproportionate our Hispanic students are being overqualified for services within the eligibility of specific learning disability. >> Just can you go back to that last slide? Sure. I'm sorry to point this out, but uh like Miss Ortiz said, you see Hispanic uh over identification for other health impairment for two years in a row.
So whether this project um aids in that I I I I haven't seen anything that would tell me otherwise. meaning I I understand that there has been some very positive outcomes when it comes to what we've done so far with um the previous grants. So I just wanted to express that my my only my only um comment is that to support this is is definitely where I would say I would much very much want for us to be able to not only as a board look at those mechanisms in which maybe policy need to be very very stringent on how are we addressing some of these these things and what are the steps that we expect as opposed to turning this into some sort of pass through for JDC or for even adult detention centers whatnot so on and so forth because I don't want to penalize people I don't want people to feel like they went to school one day and then then the next day you know they were they were pointed at and something happened and you know there was no other means for them other than to turn it over to the authorities and so on and so forth and then they'll go their life down a path that that wasn't intended yet it became I'm not saying that that's happening but I do want to say that that is by far what I feel like you know where where we are.
>> I would like to address three of your questions. Um, we would be tracking this through student link or from school links. It is a studentled program. Um, it's something that I have taken on even with all of my additional duties because it is a labor of love for me and I want to see our students succeed. I want to see half of them stand up and be recognized at graduation wearing a white stole. Um, it is for all students. If a student has a question about if something can count, he can always come talk to me because the counselors have been given leeway over this program. And if we can find something that's comparable, I have no problem signing off on that. Um, what was the third one? >> Or yeah, there's a lot of ores in there. A lot of ores. Especially if you look at the gold level, it's not and and and the gold level is all ore.
But there's also going to be people that are in the other attendance areas who are going to be looking at this sixth grade option, you know, in a setting like this that are going to be attracted to it. And so the 440 whatever number is that we're we're banting about is likely to get is is probably wrong, number one, but number two, it's going to include I would think more sixth graders than we think and less eighth graders than we think. But there's going to be really no way to figure that out ahead of time unfortunately. I mean you probably do some early enrollment kind of stuff and get it and get and get a good handle on it which which will help but from this point of view you know it was a little bit difficult. Um, one of the other things I ordered actually two more.
I think that you they certainly have control over what's on their agenda, but for example, the city school committee can't pass a vote and put it in our operational rules that the city council must represent at city at school committee meetings. So, I I think that's kind of a a question. Um, member Martini, >> aren't these kind of two separate issues as to whether and how school committee uh responds to the regular invitation from city council to participate in their meetings and whether or not to get school committee and city council leadership together in a room to talk about how to uh engage as co-equal partners. Again, I I I feel like those are two separate two separate issues. >> I think that's correct. And I accept the correction. We should probably keep our comments more focused on the motion um at hand. Remember um mayor >> I and I was not trying to mix those two things up, but it it I think it was a I think they did get mixed up.
It it um communications from the superintendent of schools and the school committee and then it um questions for from the council for the superintendent of schools and so but I agree with the whole rest of this. I think it's wonderful to have communications between the two bodies. So I will vote in favor of that. But I believe that the superintendent of schools should be invited to all of the meetings because that's our law. It's an ordinance that was voted on. >> Yeah. And I don't know whether that um was tested in terms of the whether a body like the city council can vote and require a school committee to attend. I think that you they certainly have control over what's on their agenda, but for example, the city school committee can't pass a vote and put it in our operational rules that the city council must represent at city at school committee meetings.
If we also get tagged for this upcoming school year 2526 for three years in a row, we'll be having to write an additional plan just specifically to help support our Hispanic students and other health impairments. So, we would be writing two plans. >> And so, this isn't new to many districts in the neighborhood. they have multiple plans all being written and implemented in the same year. So we're hoping not to repeat in 2526 in order to not be disproportionate for other health impairments. So that's why we're having a lot of conversations with our principles and um school psychologists around this. Sorry to interrupt. >> No, that's okay. Thank you. I appreciate that. Um so again uh the 2025 plan what comes with that is we get 10 hours of technical assistance support provided by CDE. We gather and analyze updated data. We review our policies, practices and procedures.
So I want to make sure that we're continuing to not only discuss these types of situations and I had did have discussions with Mr. ideas and I did feel a lot better about where I was standing in that and I will fully support the board's decision. Um, but I just wanted to make sure to express that because that's just how I felt as a board member. So, I don't know if there's anything else from the board. Miss Stevens, um, I do understand your concern. Um I have similar thoughts and feelings toward this especially because um we we are heavily surveillanced here on the nation by border patrol and like dealing with that living in this area. Um and then also just in general we create this like I'm saying this path of this prison mentality which is not something that I want to support but I also do feel like I understand like there is also the need for safety uh especially with recent activities that happened.
You only pick two. >> Okay. I do believe that even our um self our sped students some of our self-contained higher learning sped students would be qualified for this >> even if they don't take the ASVAB ACT SAT >> because we have been given some leeway to work with that and we and as I mentioned the seniors this year we know it's going to be tight for them we didn't get to roll it out until October just simply because we were still working on drafts and um that came with the knowledge that we were going to do everything we could to help those that wanted it um but those that want have to speak up. >> I think that's fantastic. I would just encourage um sending that messaging out and making sure that the students understand that um and that the parents understand that that there's there's options.
One of them is that the attendance area in and of itself as it looks right now for the new K8, it looks a little odd and we did it on purpose because we did not want to move kids twice. And knowing that we're going to get approval in the next year or two or three at the most, you know, for another one of these schools, we, you know, we basically kind of let Saddleback get overloaded a little bit in the in the early years of these projections so that we don't move those folks down in the south twice. The other thing we did was be very careful about when and how we move um residents of the auction community and that was an important consideration kind of all the way through. The last thing I'll address is the Moonlight Ridge. You know that that issue up there and um we looked at other ways to try to get, you know, more more kids into the into the school and um it was a robbing Peter to pay Paul kind of a proposition and so with Butterfield being in the position it's in you know you know sort of the logical move at least for the time being is to come across and get those two grids five and six that that you were shown now five years from now seven years from now when that project really is humming and then there's another one south of it called Hajins Farms.
So, I was bringing up the element of confusion because if I'm if I didn't misunderstand this, I believe our superintendent was instructed not to come last month, whereas for 25 years, the superintendent's always been invited to come to the school committee meetings. And I think he's done a fabulous job with that and that he should continue. So, I'm I'm bringing it up because I am delighted to have this collaboration. I think it's a fabulous idea. I think that we don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater. >> And just to clarify, um, several months ago, I did instruct our superintendent to stop attending the city council meetings because I did not feel it was in the best interest of student outcomes or the school committee. Uh, I accepted a correction from people that I had acted somewhat unilaterally on that. And so last month when the executive subcommittee may met, the other motion that we brought to you was um that the full school committee assign a member to present an update on the superintendent search process to the city council at their October meeting and to respond to any related questions on behalf of the committee.
So, I I think that's kind of a a question. Um, member Martini, >> aren't these kind of two separate issues as to whether and how school committee uh responds to the regular invitation from city council to participate in their meetings and whether or not to get school committee and city council leadership together in a room to talk about how to uh engage as co-equal partners. Again, I I I feel like those are two separate two separate issues. >> I think that's correct. And I accept the correction. We should probably keep our our comments more focused on the motion um at hand. Remember um mayor >> I and I was not trying to mix those two things up, but it it I think it was a I think they did get mixed up. So, I was bringing up the element of confusion because if I'm if I didn't misunderstand this, I believe our superintendent was instructed not to come last month, whereas for 25 years, the superintendent's always been invited to come to the school committee meetings.
We have a root cause analysis and we identify our target population which Baressa calls our success scholars. We submit that plan to uh CDE for approval immediately following this meeting tomorrow morning. Probably not tonight. Um but it is due this Friday of November 14th. Um so in the process we I'm going to highlight two uh steps. Right now we are actually at step three which is the submission of our project. Um but to go back a little bit for better understanding at step two was our data and root cause analysis. This is in our new system edge of climber. All those little people are actually people sitting in our seats. So this is indicative of our actual population. These are our Hispanic students that were overqualified and were given the SLD qualifications. So if you see in 2023 we had 141 Hispanic students. Um in 2024 25 we had 151 and currently already this year we are at 116 students that are Hispanic with the SLD.