And that's a step function. You know, they they're kind of always full. So their their enrollment is fixed and then it bumps up and then it's fixed and then it bumps up. And then the other thing that we we we have some numbers on even is the impact of the enrollment uh empowerment empowerment scholarship counts and that's you know we're seeing that across the state and particularly at the lower grade levels. Um and that kind of comes out in this chart where we look at the distribution of enrollment um by grade level in these groups. We call them cohorts. um you have a very interesting distribution like this. Notice that the K2 group is you know typically now the smallest. If you went back and looked at this chart in the 2000s during the boom that was the biggest group and that group could grow again once we get you know the rate of development back up a little bit but for the time being it's fallen to be one of the smallest groups.
>> Uh okay. So, that's a discussion item kind of separate from the I I don't know separate from I guess the mayor's um motion didn't include the content for what the superintendent would be discussing. Um, so if you wish, you could ask the mayor if she'd accept that as a friendly amendment that that that presentation on the data be presented. >> If you wish, member Goodwin, >> um, mayor disorder, would you accept a friendly amendment? And I'm making that amendment based on maybe the superintendent may not be present. Maybe our assistant superintendent could give some attent. >> Um so um that's fine by me. >> Okay. So the A motion is amended to include the content of the superintendent's presentation would be the um report on um the accountability report uh presentation that was uh given to us tonight at the school committee meeting. Any other discussion?
I think member Ston attended last month. Member Ston did a marvelous job. If somebody else wants to take another turn, I'm happy to have that. or if member >> see if there's a second for your motion before we get into discussion. >> Um let's see. Is there a second? >> I'll second it. >> Uh second from member child's discussion. Uh mayor, back to you. Do you want to uh share your your thinking? >> Our superintendent did a fabulous job and was very wellreceived. Thank you. Um, any other discussion? I don't know whether the superintendent will be back or when does he return? Do you know? >> I'm not I don't know exactly. >> Okay. Uh, all right. Any other discussion? I would anticipate by next Wednesday, but I don't want to speak for him. >> Okay, member Goodwin, >> I think people would love to see that beautiful um slideshow about the MCCAST test or the results of accountability.
So, we do need to address that. It's very small, but those are the seven that they have identified as um board policies andor administrative regulations that do need to be updated. So, uh, the root causes that we took a look at for our 2025, uh, SIM plan, the first is that there is a lack of consistent implementation and accountability specific to assessment practices for English learners, English language learners when addressing initial assessments for special education. So, really what that speaks to is, is it a disability or is it a language acquisition issue? Uh our second root cause is there is a lack of consistent implementation and accountability for the multi-tered system of support including targeted academic interventions, behavioral interventions, and English language development. Our third root cause is there's a lack of capacity to have the hard conversations around implicit bias with staff, which is manifested in a lack of understanding of the dynamics of race, culture, and disabilities for students, family, and community leaders that creates barriers for true parent and caregiver partnerships and student success.
um and and to making sure that we going to do everything that we can possibly can. Uh but also we need to keep it uh keep it balanced. Um we do not want to um mil milit milit I cannot say militarize um our our schools. Um and I I will not be in support of that. Um I want to acknowledge that um we will do what we can and we will be more than happy to answer any ongoing questions to any family members because on cases like this we got we will have both sides and both of them is important to be acknowledged and and heard. Um and and when it comes to our our next steps um this is additional public funding that is free um that is coming our way and and yes they play they they will pay for the hardware. we still need to pay for the installation of of that equipment.
So, I wanted to make sure. So, professional learning wanted to report on the October 6 professional learning day that we had at the high school. Um, this first piece is related to the K12 um group, but our focus in this group was the 15-day challenge that you've heard about here and there um tonight and in the past. Um so based on that, the resources that we gave them to support them, this was out of a four. Um their rating of the resources, the session modeling, instructional delivery methods because we're always trying to model what we would hope they would translate into their classroom, and then their comfort in implementing into their learning environment. And these are um a little bit lower. We've been above the 3.5 normally, and we know that this is still new learning for them. So, we weren't surprised by this, but we we were excited about was the um qualitative feedback.
The oddest thing is that we're still having an issue with retention at sixth grade. And so I'm very hopeful that this new model of school will help address that because it's very odd to have the six eight cohort have a smaller per enrollment per than the K2 group and then it pops way back up again at high school. So you've done really well at the high school level and we know that across the district kids come back out of charter schools you know from 8th to nth grade. So that's, you know, keeping those numbers up and they're that line is probably more reflective of what's really going on in the in the school age population growth than than the other ones just because you have a really high service rate among amongst high schoolers. Uh we talk about the grids and this is just a map of where the students live today and this is just the number of of students in um that come from each one of our [snorts] planning grids.
Um Vice Chair Ston, >> sorry, I was just like trying to get our attention. >> Oh, thank you. is I'm sorry is the motion that the superintendent is to go and present the MCCAST data or is the motion that this a school committee member goes and presents the data or is it that both people go and present the data? >> Mayor, uh correct me if I'm wrong. I believe your motion was to both send the superintendent and a school committee member. I made a motion that the superintendent go and also I started to say and then we I I felt like I was that I was speaking too long. But I would welcome having another member go as well. I just didn't get that far. I would welcome another member going as well. >> Okay. Thank you. Okay. The motion as the um recording secretary has it.
>> Uh, okay. So, that's a discussion item kind of separate from the I I don't know, separate from I guess the mayor's um motion didn't include the content for what the superintendent would be discussing. Um so, if you wish, you could ask the mayor if she'd accept that as a friendly amendment that that that presentation on the data be presented. if you wish. Member Goodman. >> Um, Mayor Disorder, would you accept a friendly amendment? And I'm making that amendment based on maybe the superintendent may not be present. Maybe our assistant superintendent could give some attent. Um so um that's fine by me. >> Okay. So the U motion is amended to include the content of the superintendent's presentation would be the um report on um the accountability report uh presentation that was uh given to us tonight at the school committee meeting. Any other discussion?
And our last root cause is there's a failure to understand and respond to Hispanic and African-American students behaviors with appropriate alternatives to suspension. So how did we pick our target students which again we call our success scholars? First and foremost we want to identify that the CESACE work is about making changes for the few that affect many. And that's going to make a lot of sense when we go over this. So, two years ago when we uh created our SIM plan, we highlighted or focused on two elementary school sites and one middle school site. When that plan was reviewed, when it was adopted and approved by the CDE, and then once we gathered all the data, we wanted to see some progress, but we weren't seeing enough. And of course, our risk ratio was not going down. So, last school year, we broadened that scope.
Um and and as we continue to make these changes, we'll be more than happy to also provide any additional support. Um just like last time, um I'll be more than happy to you were part of of our meetings that we held in in different parts um the weekend and and and and provided um in in person and also virtual for any questions that they may have. Um the unfortunately yes we did have um u one incident um that is also giving us the opportunity what else can we do uh to be able to streamline to be able to say are we doing everything we can but also I want to invite the parents u it's uh the same way that we're going to try to do everything we can parents are we are they doing everything they can to ensure that the school the students come ready they come on time but they also didn't bring items that they're not supposed to that the nation is also in support of providing and reminding the community and reinforce um that we our schools is a safe haven for our students and for our staff and every effort and and we when we combine those effort um at the end we're going to have a much better community a much better school and a much better nation.
So, we gave them a checklist. It was a laminated checklist, and they were very much appreciative of that because it sort of summarized the steps. Um we have a book that we're using as our resource, but this was a double-sided laminated piece, and they really appreciated that. Um lots of great discussion around DO and the level of the standard. they gain gain more clarity on the 15-day challenge steps. And um one of my favorite pieces of that third bullet is interpreting the standard. They don't always interpret it in the same way. So having those discussions and really coming to consensus on what that standard means was really important for our teachers and they felt like it was very helpful to work with other campuses, especially that elementary level where they don't always get to collaborate. Um then our student services, they had different groups. We had goal book running for our um special education resource and self-contained teachers.
um now have a real heart of the district where there's more than 500 students per square mile in in the in in the core area of the district which um actually does help even things out in terms of enrollment. Um the last five years have brought us 2100 new school uh new students. So everywhere where you see red or pink on this map, there have been enrollment increases. Some of them very very large. Um, we're looking at though areas there, like I said, like in the Pima area, Santa Rosa area where these communities are built out, they're starting to age in place. And so that's what opens up the space for us to do, you know, some other things, you know, to help Butterfield out in the meantime. But, uh, most of the growth still up in the north, you know, northeast, I would call it quadrant of the district.
I'm not sure they heard you because uh we you weren't on mic. So why don't I lend you the mic to reread it? >> Hold on. Thank you. I have the motion as we move to ask the superintendent to attend the November school comm uh city council meeting and have an additional school committee member attend if they wish to. >> And there's a friendly amendment to have the content of that BVA accountability presentation that was given to us tonight. Member Martini, >> I wanted to offer another friendly amendment and see if this would work because it seems to me that the highlights from this evening's meeting are about the superintendent search process and about the district accountability data. So, it makes the most sense to me if they are available and willing to do this, for vice chair Ston to go and present information about the superintendent search process, and for the assistant superintendent for teaching and learning to present the accountability data uh that he did this evening to uh the city council.
Um Vice Chair Ston, >> sorry I was just like trying to get our attention. Oh, thank you. >> Is I'm sorry. Is the motion that the superintendent is to go and present the MCCAST data or is the motion that this a school committee member goes and presents the data or is it that both people go and present the data? >> Mayor, uh, correct me if I'm wrong. I believe your motion was to both send the superintendent and a school committee member. >> I made a motion that the superintendent go and also I started to say and then we I I felt like I was that I was speaking too long. But I would welcome having another member go as well. I just didn't get that far. I would welcome another member going as well. Okay, thank you. >> Okay, the motion as the um recording secretary has it.
We focused on every single school site in Beressa. So all 13 all 13 school sites, the 10 elementary and the three middle schools, they all had success scholars. They still do, but we were gathering data for all 13 school sites. And what we found is that we spread ourselves a bit too thin. It wasn't enough to make an effective change. So it was recommended by our uh technical adviserss from the state that we decide to focus down a little bit smaller. This year what we did is we are going to focus on three elementary school sites and one middle school site. The way we picked those sites is we took a look at who had the largest growth of our Hispanic population as well as who had the biggest ratio of specific learning or I shouldn't say specific learning sped students to gened students at their school sites.
Is there so this is and sorry this is a question that I feel like maybe and I want to make sure you mentioned that this is just hardware what is the cost for installation do we get to look at that do we get to see what that cost might be and what was it in the past grants because I know the last grants were the same thing weren't they just paying for certain equipment what have we actually expended in order to make this happen that's that's the first question second question um I would feel much better and I don't want this to turn into a nonapproval. And I I'm only saying that because I'm just just I want this to be fully supported. I'm I'm asking right now if we can table this item and I don't know if there's a timeline on this but if there is then then should have brought it sooner but if not then uh but if we can then I would ask to bring it back in next month but also to see what we've done so far with the cops grant what we've actually can be able to see as far as a report so far and everything that we've done what's been installed where it's at how it looks how it's operating schools operating.
We had FBA and BIP which was related to behavior programs for our counselor social workers. Um and then our psychologists and SLP teachers worked on some different things. So their sessions, their feedback for the same topics was a much higher um rating. They were more intentionally focused on their groups which they've been asking for for many years. So, we're glad to see that that's been beneficial for them. And then this is their qualitative feedback. [clears throat] The first one was our speech and language professionals were able to use a new resource Canva to make some materials for their students. And then that FBA bit process that our counselor social workers went through and then the goal book. And then the the bottom piece was our psychologist implementing what they learned in that FBA session. So overall, we felt like it was a successful day and had some positive feedback and we're taking that into our next steps.
Uh, the exception now is we're really watching the southwest corner. And when we start talking about that next K8, you know, we've kind of left an area down in that portion of the district that would be a logical next place perhaps. Um I talked about the, you know, the growth of charter schools. It does continue to increase, not very fast. Um it's gone up by a couple of hundred students over the last couple of years though because of that 250 I think because of that new school opening up. Um and that's going to continue to happen from time to time. It just is. Um it's not as big of an impact in the last two years though really as what we're looking at with the with the ESAs. And you realize when it went universal in 2223 and the number jumped from I can't quite read it to 300 and something.
no slate to our interim superintendent, but it just makes sense to me uh to do that this time. >> Maybe before we amend the motion, we should check with the assistant superintendent if he has availability. >> Yes, please. >> Unfortunately, I do. It's Wednesday, the 19th. >> It's a week. Yeah, a week from tonight. >> Unfortunately, I do not. Um, so the assistant superintendent is not available. Um, so we would be um seeing if the superintendent was was available um when he returns. Um, so let's see. I guess >> y please >> not to prolong this any longer. I am available for the city council meeting in December and would be happy to put that on my calendar if the committee so wished. >> Okay. Um great. So we we'll handle December in at a separate motion or a separate time. So, for now, [laughter] um, the current motion, I I guess the the question, Jenny, our mayor, is whether you would accept a friendly amendment to include, uh, Stacy Ston as a representative to update on the superintendent search process as well.