And if I can, I'm definitely upfront about it. Okay. It's the same. It's the same for me. >> No, I mean I agree. >> We're trying to do what we can to be at places and things come up or you know it just doesn't work out. But it doesn't mean that we don't fully support especially like I really wanted to be at the spooky night um at the intermediate I mean at the primary school and um I I just couldn't be there. So my but I was really looking forward and I was telling my daughter go you need to go because I can't go so >> and um she did and she took the little ones with her. I was glad that they went. I'm glad we did come up with those goals though, so that way we can kind of try to get to some of these activities and to be a part of it.
Um, so I calculate it as a GPA because I think it's helpful. Um, because when we look at a B and a B, sometimes it's not really the same. Um, I think what stands out here when we look at this data is that when we compare ourselves to the other public schools in Panol County, um, Col is rocking it. Um, and I think we should be very proud of that. We're not where we want to be yet. Um, these folks are amazing. I want to give them a ton of credit because they work their heart and soul out to try to improve things and grow for their student population. Um, our principles, our teacher leaders, our instructional coaches, the teaching and learning team. Uh, this is the stuff we live and breathe. Uh, we laugh together, we cry together, sometimes we get mad together. Um, but we keep pushing to do better for kids.
Um the district is still experiencing, you know, slower growth than, you know, we maybe maybe would have expected. Um but you know the school age population is still increasing and I see it really like I say keep saying more a function of alternative providers. Uh demographic characteristics are shifting. We saw that more older householders in particular but overall your you know your rate is still much higher than in most areas that we work with that are really established and are truly in that aging uh category. um saw single family, you know, sort of taking taking a little bit of a break compared to what we've seen sometimes in the past. But um every indication is that the market's going to come back and that there is plenty of projects out there in particular that people are spending money on right now, buying land, putting in infrastructure.
>> Okay. Uh member Martini and then the mayor. Uh I had similar thoughts. Um keeping in mind new members uh coming on. I think that um it's a great idea of course to post all information that members have seen or been asked to consider about items that are under the committee's preview. Um that should definitely be available to everyone. Uh and at the same time I wouldn't like anyone to interpret that as permission to just go ahead and do it. [laughter] I would like people to please not do that um by email. You know don't do not email the entire committee about anything substantive. You keep that to scheduling and other kind of housekeeping things. Um, and I think it would be a good discussion to have about onboarding as well as refreshing existing members um, in regards to open meeting law and about how to get their information and concerns um, heard on the agenda.
>> All right. Is there a second? >> Second from member Deniv. Uh discussion. Secretary Denive and then member Martini. >> I think this is a great idea and I definitely support it. But I wonder if I wonder if maybe a solution to this is to have a little bit of internal discussion or training about how to put items on the agenda. Because if people are feeling like they're having to get their ideas out by violating opening law, maybe it's just because they don't understand the procedure to put something on the agenda. It's just a thought as we'll be having, you know, new members and we want to make sure that everyone feels included and that their ideas can be uh heard and put on the agenda. It's important. We're all allowed to be on there. So, I would maybe also find a way to include a little bit of time on that so that we can be better versed in procedure.
And that's uh Tony for me. And as I've been getting adjusted to his modified schedule, I know I tease when I call him and I say, "Tony, I know it's not Tuesday, but I have a question." And you know, and he he always picks up the phone and just um you know, the years of it comes with years of experience in the field and it's really hard to um replace that level of knowledge. Um but certainly our schools and our facilities are better for the expertise that Tony has brought to the table. So, thank you for all that. >> Thank you. I just to say I really enjoyed working here. Like I think I told you when you first got here, the reason I'm here is because it's a great place to work. >> Yeah, >> it really is. >> Thank you. >> Um, okay.
And >> yeah. Okay. Mas President if you want to table it as well. Um that way you have a chance to review my recommendations and bring it back. Um that way you have the opportunity if there's this is uh thinking to generate more thinking and based on other ways that you might be able to support that you may want to add it. Um they're welcome as well. >> Uh motion to table. Is there a second? >> Nobody wants table. Do you want to approve it? Second by Miss Stevens. >> Number 11 this evening is the action item uh approving extra duty for Miss Rosa Buendia. And of course um due to conflict of interest I will not be voting for this item. Um I leave it to y'all. >> Motion to approve. Motion by Miss Anime Stevens. Okay. >> Second by Miss >> Kathleen Botath.
And so I think we're we're really starting to get there. Um, couple of of areas to note, you'll see Legacy QC and Legacy Santana and Ben Franklin. Um I mean I always give the full story. Um those were all B's last year. Um so they have improved for some of our surrounding um charter schools. So that's worthy of noting. We have historically been very competitive with Happy Valley which is you know right adjacent to us. Um and still I would say we're outperforming them. Um it was a rough year in Apache Junction. You can see that there. So again for for a traditional school district in Panol County I think we're doing really really well. Uh, I have that asterisk on there because if the appeal were successful for ranch, uh, that would be a 3.25 is what the math would work out to be.
So they're getting ready. It's not like they're not going to sit out forever. They're they're they're making those kind of investments. Future enrollment will continue to be impacted by choice. I think we all we all know that. But you're you know obviously positioned to grow um incredibly again. Maybe not tfold in 10 years, but I certainly hope not at this point. But uh uh it's it's a it's a it's a great community and you've done you put the pieces in place and I think it's starting to pay off for you. I'm going to be really anxious to see how the K8 uh you know impacts the whole picture.
We do have a process for that. It is spelled out in the member handbook. Um, and it's not hard to do and it's very democratic. uh folks just need to learn the ropes, you know. So, um I think it would behoove the committee to have a discussion about onboarding and also a refresher uh for folks. I would also just point out again that the last time this committee did have an open meeting law complaint. The committee uh proposed its own solution to the state for that which was to bring in a training so that people could ask their specific questions about OML that maybe are not answered by the requisite training um that's profered online by the state and we never did actually bring that training in. So, uh, just saying it again. >> Thank you, Member Martini. Mayor, >> um, so putting the email in the packet and not filing the open meeting law complaint would seem to me like not the best idea because you're announcing, okay, we did this, but we're not filing the complaint.
>> Okay. Uh member Martini and then the mayor. Uh I had similar thoughts. Um keeping in mind new members uh coming on. I think that um it's a great idea of course to post all information that members have seen or been asked to consider about items that are under the committee's preview. Um that should definitely be available to everyone. Uh and at the same time I wouldn't like anyone to interpret that as permission to just go ahead and do it. I would like people to please not do that um by email. You know don't do not email the entire committee about anything substantive. You keep that to scheduling and other kind of housekeeping things. Um, and I think it would be a good discussion to have about onboarding as well as refreshing existing members um, in regards to open meeting law and about how to get their information and concerns um, heard on the agenda.
Measure you. So, every so often we actually have to update the bond list and that's what we're here to do today. The good thing is um well, part of the reason we're doing this today is we have three things. is we've closed a lot of projects. We've closed schools. So, in part of that, we're actually cancelling projects. So, we're going to save money. And um so, again, that's kind of what we're going to show here. And again, if you have questions, just ask. And I'll kind of go briefly over what I did so you guys understand. Um again, you can see there's an approved budget was the budget that was approved in June of 24. The proposed budget is today. And then the next column is just the difference, either the savings or the ads. So again, overall we've with everything that we did, we saved about $12 million.
>> Motion carries. Thank you so much. Uh under letter G is our consent agenda. Without objection, a motion to approve. Is there a second? >> Second by Miss Kathleen >> B. >> Thank you so much. Uh we're probably going to jump into a little bit more. So, if you are done for the evening, thank you all so much for joining us. >> Thank you all. Get some food. >> Get some food. >> It's a Thanksgiving theme, so please get some food. >> I have an item for H that I would like to ask. Um, given the approval of the cops grant, I would like some information presented if possible. And again, I I fully want to I I will fully support the board's decision. I just want to make sure that we're also um looking at um not only what the benefits have been so far and what we purchased, what's been installed um but also just more or less um you know where it all stands, Mr.
So, um, you know, we're getting pretty competitive with with some of our neighboring districts. I'd like to see us above a 3.5, but we're getting there. Um, to give some historical context, this is what it's looked like over time. So, if you go back to 2018, our GPA would have been a 2.14. Um, 2021, you can see grayed out there, that's the lovely COVID year where there was nothing. Um, and then in the last four years, we've gotten to a 2.57, 2.71, 2.88, and then that we'll call it 3.13 to 3.25 depending on how that math ultimately works out. So, I'm proud of the work that our sites have done to really continue to grow year after year. Um, where we're headed next. So, we always do a comprehensive review of the data. Some of the stuff that I've already shared with you is are the elements that we look at targeting.
So we would take any questions. Um, I appreciate the uh the work and um we're a we're a very data driven board, so we like seeing numbers and you know uh graphs, you know, that kind of thing, right? So, um uh working with the with the boundaries and that kind of thing. There's a lot of the stuff is so messy, right? And it's so unpredictable um that uh you know there could be an event tomorrow. Let's hope not. And everything >> co you know I mean I mean prior to that there was nothing like that on on our radar. Yeah. >> Yeah. Exactly. >> You're right. That's the world that we work in. But I go back to, you know, I've been doing this a very long time, like 30 years now as applied economics. And before choice was what it was, we could be very much more accurate.
So, if there was a violation and you're putting it forward in the packet, in that case, we actually should have filed, I would think. So, I I find out I think I checked with the attorney before doing that. >> Yes, that is what the motion is is to direct the chair to uh consult with the attorney about uh whether and how to make this uh particular motion. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Yeah. Um I'll just say I noted uh two different things that I want to touch on when we're done with this motion. One is the open meeting law training and the other was how to get an item on the agenda. Uh so we will discuss those items. Um, is there any other discussion on the motion to direct me to speak with council about uh about this uh proposed motion? >> All right, Secretary Den, will you call the vote?
We do have a process for that. It is spelled out in the member handbook. Um, and it's not hard to do and it's very democratic. uh folks just need to learn the ropes, you know. So, um I think it would behoove the committee to have a discussion about onboarding and also a refresher uh for folks. I would also just point out again that the last time this committee did have an open meeting law complaint. The committee uh proposed its own solution to the state for that which was to bring in a training so that people could ask their specific questions about OML that maybe are not answered by the requisite training um that's profered online by the state and we never did actually bring that training in. So, uh, just saying it again. >> Thank you, Member Martini. Mayor, >> um, so putting the email in the packet and not filing the open meeting law complaint would seem to me like not the best idea because you're announcing, okay, we did this, but we're not filing the complaint.
Okay, which is great. Okay. Um and and there's a lot of reasons for it. About $5 million is because of the school closures. So we're going to move cancel those projects, move those, and be able to do other things. Um again, we had savings on projects. We did restroom projects where originally we were going to replace all the floors. And one of the ideas we had is just basically clean them, restrip um strip them, and then re-wax them and do that. And we saved about $1.7 million across the district. >> Another one was the fire alarm projects. We bid them a certain way at certain times and again we saved $1.6 million. Um PA projects, we had budgeted in the beginning, we weren't sure if we were going to go digital or analog. We ended up going digital. we saved at least another 700,000. Okay, so again, we did a lot of things to save money.
Diaz, if you know what I mean. If we can and it doesn't even have to be anything like too detailed. Um, I guess just a generaliz generalized like report. Uh, and >> and go ahead, Miss Stevens. >> I was going to say and also can that like information be sent out to the community so that they have that information available to them. um >> yeah, that's what I was going to um request for the future agenda items is what you requested that that that information come back in the report on what that first grant was spent on. How has it helped? Um, is there instances where um where is there documentation of um where it was really it really came in handy and and and how much better our schools are because of those cameras and because of everything. um if if there's any kind of um reporting of instances where um >> I think it's important to look at if we didn't have these types of >> Yeah.
Where are we doing things well? Where do we need to continue to grow? The PLC focus is a huge piece for us in helping our teachers with a higher level of intentionality in their instruction. Understanding the standards better is huge. Um, additional supports for subgroups. Um, I did not put that on the slide presentation tonight. Um, but we did have four schools that were under uh comprehensive support for our subgroup data, specifically our students with disability. Um, that started about four years ago that we were put in comprehensive support. Um, as of this year, um, two of those four are exiting. So, they've made enough growth to exit. Um, and when I say enough growth, I want to quantify that to say that we were sitting in the 8 to 10% range for our students with disabilities. Um, in terms of their passage rate comparatively, um, the sites that are exiting are now 25 to 35%.