2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 112
Um, I did check with the superintendent that this isn't urgent for us to do. So, it could uh we can add this to our December item for a discussion, adoption or rejection. So, we're now um reading the proposed policy or policies uh hearing a response from the superintendent report from any advisory committee assigned responsibility in the area. We don't have that and committee discussion and directions for any reddrafting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 113
So, any questions? >> I No. No. Okay. Good job. >> Okay. discussion um and information regarding the 202526 superintendent evaluation. >> Uh just a couple things that'll that'll happen at the next meeting in December. There a couple things I wanted you to be aware of. Uh Miss Wanganger will give you the form for on uh tomorrow on the 13th. uh you can take a look at it and if you go ahead and uh fill it out and return it by December 1st then she'll calculate what you guys write down and then the discussion will be based on on the way you you rated that that form. So nothing major but just wanted to give you especially the new board members who not sure of how the process is we'll just consolidate all the different ratings and and come up with in executive session whatever the the valuation piece is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 113
>> So, for tonight, you're just looking for questions or comments. happy to field them tonight um or in any way the committee sees fit. Um if people have questions over the next couple weeks, happy to take them either over the phone or meeting, whatever works best for you all. >> Great. >> But I would like to have a draft here for vote um at our December meeting. >> Member Goodwin, >> I think the draft looks great. The question is, do the teachers Have the teachers looked at it and agreed with it? >> I think the teachers have looked at it. It was presented at a faculty meeting at the high school specifically. I've met with the guidance counselors a number of times. They've had some questions as I have and we've been able to work through most of them. I think some of the questions right now lingering have to do with part of what we need to do in this is determine mastery.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 113
So I guess the item is just a discussion item to see if the committee has any discussion they wish to have about it and any uh directions for reddrafting. Any discussion? Not seeing any and not seeing any requests for reddrafting. So we'll just bring this back to uh the December meeting for the action item discussion, adoption or rejection. Uh thank you very much. >> And now we're on to the uh first read of draft competency determination. The first read of the next iteration of the competency determination. As you recall, you voted last spring um to come into compliance um after last November's vote to remove MCCAST as a graduation determination. Um there was little guidance from DESIE at that point. I shared in a meeting earlier this year that guidance came out over the summer in mid July. Um and we've drafted this competency determination.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 114
>> Um I have one too I have another question. Are we we're supposed to do the board evaluation too, right? >> Uh what we're looking at with the board of there's no statute like in the case of the superintendent evaluation, the statute says it has to be done by December. There's no statute about board evaluations whatsoever. It's it's not in statute. And so, uh with everything going on and the number of meetings you guys are having and all that and the change in in leadership, my thought process would be to talk to you guys, which we can do right now. I was going to do in December, but talk to you guys and see maybe that's something that you want to do with the new superintendent at the board retreat in June as some districts have been in do the actual board evaluation in June, not in December.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 114
So the state hasn't necessarily defined that. So different districts are defining it differently and I think that's one of the places that we're trying to get some clarity or shared understanding of it. Um and some suggestions that have come from the state and others are that you pass the final exam or you've completed a capstone project at the end of the course. So those are some things that are currently in there. Um, but it's evolving a bit and we've made some tweaks along the way based on feedback. >> Have a good one. >> I think it's going to be a living document. I remember when Vermont went to the portfolio system, it changed for four years before they finally decided. So, is there a way that the state would accept that this I mean, you're trying to teach while the train is running and determining which road you're going on is I I'm just it's a draft.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 114
Um, our attorney has reviewed this and has some questions about it as well. I'm getting feedback from high school counselors. I have some feedback from a member of the committee um and um other stakeholder groups because this will be the competency determination for the class of 2026. Now I also want to note that um on Friday I attended the superintendent superintendent roundt where Mary Burke from the mass association of school superintendent and Glenn Cooer from the mass mass association of school committees were both present and they said that the graduation standards they expect to go to the governor by December 31st but won't likely go in front of of the board of ed until April or May. So this will not be our last tango with competency determination. So we need to take a vote by December, our December meeting to get into compliance as of December 31st, but again I anticipate we will continue to revisit this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 115
And that way you guys can have a conversation about your how you perceive yourself to be with the new superintendent and then you can talk about that person and you guys as you move forward. And so my thought process would be move it out to uh June as part of the and and as a reminder I think the request from the board members was that we would collapse uh this is also for the uh leadership team. We would go ahead and collapse the retreat into the same day as the June board meeting. We would go ahead and and come in at 8:00 in the morning. I'm picking a time. It may modify a little bit but we would do the retreat throughout the day and then and it may be 11 o'clock or whatever. We have to figure out the agenda and then roll straight in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 115
It's definitely a draft. >> Agreed. >> You have to submit it. And I hate to sit in this seat and say part of what [snorts] we're doing in December is to come into compliance, but I do think that's a a part of it is we have the guidance from the state. The document that we have would bring us into compliance, but I also think it's part of a larger conversation, which is why I've tried to involve some other stakeholders and be open to feedback as we get it. I do agree that we're going to be revisiting this probably in the not not too distant future >> in the next decade. >> Any other discussion? Uh, Secretary Denive, >> I just wanted to ask um, Assistant Superintendent Sullivan if he has heard at all of the Massachusetts the MCIA, which is the um, state account, the new state accountability board, the consortium.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 115
>> So for tonight, you're just looking for questions or comments? >> Happy to field them tonight. um or in any way the committee sees fit. Um if people have questions over the next couple weeks, happy to take them either over the phone or meeting, whatever works best for you all. >> Great. >> But I would like to have a draft here for vote um at our December meeting. >> Member Goodwin, [snorts] >> I think the draft looks great. The question is, do the teachers have the teachers looked at it and agreed with it? >> I think the teachers have looked at it. It was presented at a faculty meeting at the high school specifically. I've met with the guidance counselors a number of times. They've had some questions as I have and we've been able to work through most of them. I think some of the questions right now lingering have to do with part of what we need to do in this is determine mastery.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 116
So the board retreat would end. We try to time up the board retreat to end at 5 4:35 and then you'd go into the June [clears throat] board meeting. That way we're not for the leadership team. You got a couple extra weeks where you don't have to worry about a meeting that you may have to come back for. So that's the intent as of right now. Um and you would just kill two birds with one stone and instead of coming back uh the next Monday or or whatever to to hold a retreat. So that's one we're working on and as a new person comes on board we'll we'll continue to have that conversation. >> Okay. So the board evaluation. >> Yep. >> So you're thinking your thought to do it on the retreat? >> Yes. >> That's fine. That's the end of the year. However, um as we move forward, it really is going to be it needs to be at the end of the year because you might have new board members in January when it comes next year >> and and we can put this in December if you want.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 116
>> I'm sorry, I missed part of the question that have I heard from them? Was that >> Have you heard of them? Have you ever worked with them before? Is it the consortium working on um performance for performance assessments? >> Performance assessments and competency determinations. >> I have heard of them. Yes. Um but haven't worked with them directly. >> Okay. I'm just curious because I knew that this this topic would come up so I wanted to try to take like we try to take the courses that work with what the district needs while we're here. And so I took one today. So, I'm going to send you that information because they're doing new competency determinations and it's a new free program from the state and I just hadn't heard if our district had had any uh chats with them in regards to this same issue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 116
So the state hasn't necessarily defined that. So different districts are defining it differently and I think that's one of the places that we're trying to get some clarity or shared understanding of it. Um and some suggestions that have come from the state and others are that you pass the final exam or you've completed a capstone project at the end of the course. So those are some things that are currently in there. Um, but it's evolving a bit and we've made some tweaks along the way based on feedback. >> Have a good one. >> I think it's going to be a living document. I remember when Vermont went to the portfolio system, it changed for four years before they finally decided. So, is there a way that the state would accept that this I mean, you're trying to teach while the train is running and determining which road you're going on is I I'm just it's a draft.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 117
We were just trying to be >> cognizant of what all the meetings you guys have and everything. >> I appreciate that. So, we just we probably need to think about that. I it's fine because we won't have a um >> any new board members come this next time, but then it would be like we'll have a six month then and it'll be another board, but it needs to be done at the end of December. But I get I get what you're saying and I can work on that. We can work on that. Okay. >> Y >> um and then last thing I have is discussion information regarding the capital bond election results. Just a couple things. We'll go into much greater detail. Um, but we did fail the bond. Uh, I have not seen the canvas results as we talked with leadership this morning. Um, going into the initial drop uh on the the 4th, we were down 419 420 votes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 117
>> Happy to look at any resources you might have received. >> Any other questions or comments? Okay. Thanks so much for bringing that to us. >> Of course. Thank you. >> Right. I would hear a motion to enter an executive into executive session pursuant to Mass General Law Chapter 30A subsection 21A3 to discuss strategy with respect to collective bargaining or litigation if an open meeting may have a detrimental effect on the bargaining or litigating position of the public body. and the chair so declares and seven to comply with or act under the authority of any general or special law or federal grant in aid requirements. >> So [clears throat] move >> uh the committee will return to open session. I have a motion from member Goodwin. Second >> Second from Vice Chair Ston.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 117
It's definitely a draft. >> Agreed. >> You have to submit it. And I hate to sit in this seat and say part of what we're doing in December is to come into compliance, but I do think that's a a part of it is we have the guidance from the state. >> The document that we have would bring us into compliance, but I also think it's part of a larger conversation, which is why I've tried to involve some other stakeholders and be open to feedback as we get it. I do agree that we're going to be revisiting this probably in the not not too distant future >> in the next decade. >> Any other discussion? Uh, Secretary Denive, >> I just wanted to ask um, Assistant Superintendent Sullivan if he has heard all of the Massachusetts the MCIA, which is the um, state account, the new state accountability board, the consortium.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 118
Uh, with the drop on Wednesday, we actually were down 500 votes. What I can tell you is the numbers that were presented, they may have changed a little bit, but not significantly. 70 racing basically 75% of all the voters for 50 plus. So whatever you do in the future, you have to un lessen until the growth of the community as such and the number of people's kids that are going to our school inc our schools increase that will still be what you have to overcome no matter what you do because you had like I said 75% of that vote um in there we thought we got in and and talked to some of those communities but you know again what you do and the conversations you have um make a difference uh does don't necessarily going to make a difference when you get into the voting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube School Committee November 12 2025 · passage 118
Any discussion? Secretary Den, will you call the vote? >> Yes, I'm a yes. Uh Vice Chair Sexton. Yes. >> Member. >> Yes. >> Member Martini. >> Yes. >> Mayor Disorder. Did she leave? >> She left. Okay. Member Goodwin. >> Yes. >> Does the chair wish to vote? >> Yes. And yes. >> Okay. It passes and we are adjourned at 8:49 >> and we will return to open session. So stay tuned. Wow. >> Great. Um, are we are we uh are we live GCTV? All right. Great. Welcome back. Um uh we had our executive session and we have now um uh on our agenda item 11, vote to accept the memorandum of agreement between the Greenfield School Committee and the Greenfield Education Association unit A teachers. Is there a motion to approve? A motion from member Goodwin. Is there a second? >> Second. Uh second from member Charles.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - November 12, 2025 · passage 118
>> I'm sorry, I missed part of the question that have I heard from them? Was that >> Have you heard of them? Have you ever worked with them before? Is it the consortium working on um performance for performance assessments? >> Performance assessments and competency determinations. >> I have heard of them. Yes. Um but haven't worked with them directly. >> Okay. I'm just curious because I knew that this this topic would come up. So I wanted to try to take like we try to take the courses that work with what the district needs while we're here. And so I took one today. So, I'm going to send you that information because they're doing new competency determinations and it's a new free program from the state and I just hadn't heard if our district had had any uh chats with them in regards to this same issue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-13 Pinal County, AZ YouTube / J.O. Combs Unified School District transcript source: youtube J.O. Combs Regular Board Meeting 11/12/2025 · passage 119
So, where do we go from here? And that's really more of the point uh of of that issue. What we've done is we've run some initial projections. And again, these are very very initial projections. But if you go ahead and say we know that schools um have to receive legally the lesser of 2% or inflation. Well, inflation is going to be greater than 2%. So, we would anticipating 2%. What that 2% is applied to is what's called the base support level. So the base support level, my numbers may be off a little one a little bit, but I think it's $5,113 and some odd cent. So if you apply 2% to that, next year's base support level should be $5,200 and some odd numbers. I I can't remember off the top of my head. So if you apply that in a perfect world, we actually come out 140,000 to the good.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above