2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 153
It wouldn't have to all be done at the same time, but it would be good to at least make a good faith effort on starting something. >> Obviously, we've missed the window for the fall. >> I think we need more than a good faith effort. I think we need a concrete effort um to start getting plants in this spring. >> Uh so through the commission and to Mr. Kai, maybe it starts with the wet mix seed in the wetland area and some of the 10 trees that are going within the wetland area. Um, >> yeah, even for that I already checked it's a substantial amount of money and I'm not sure whether I will be able to do that uh in one shot. Okay. I I wish I can do and also for this plan, I didn't really pay too much attention to this when when this uh guy come up with this plan and this uh this so-called this when when we cut when because the shraps I don't know where that come from because originally on that plant there there's really no shraps in there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 154
So we're going to so the ask is that we consider a framework that includes all the possibilities and then do we >> we don't attach any funding. I think that might be the >> but then but we have money attached to >> but we don't attach any funding. Maybe that's >> I know but there's a cost. >> So the estimated cost to all those things >> No, I get it. I'm trying to I'm trying to bridge but I'm not succeeding. >> Yeah, you're good. >> So the estimated cost to all those all those framework, >> but by voting on it, we're not saying the board is not saying go out and do this and spend this money. >> I understand that. >> So it's just it's a framework. It's no different like what uh Erica said. It's a strategic plan for our buildings. And then based once you you accepted that then you start thinking about okay of all these items how do we prioritize once we prioritize that how do we fund the projects that's a different conversation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 154
uh and uh the trees which he come up with all these trees I I don't think we cut all these trees because I actually did not cut because this two gentlemen two old guy live nearby and he he need they need wood for for heating so they come up to to cut this because >> well yeah >> maybe he can pay for these trees then because he got the wood I wish it can but I I don't know just because >> sir sir this is not a laughing matter. This is a violation of >> No, I'm not laughing. Okay. Because I I got I I feel very bad about this because I didn't know this is wetland. Okay. I wish I can do this uh because we are on limited income. Okay. I wish I have the money to do this so that I don't have to endure this this whole thing this nightmare.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 155
>> Okay. Well I guess coming from project management when we're planning we typically talk about how we're going to fund. So like for instance when we talk about the junior high school at 59.2 2 million those conversations such as deliverables what have you would all be encompassed in that 59.2 2 million ask. So I guess kind of maybe to her point, how do we kind of break that apart to understand what that looks like? Does that make sense? >> Right. So it does. So what it is is if everything were equal and all the suggestions that were made from the facility assessment, from the educational uh assessment, from uh thinking about the future, this is how how much everything is going to cost, right? But we know those are those are just framework right then you are proving the framework of the work that has been done with assessment with input with design everything and then then we'll look at based on how much that we can get to be able to make this happen and based on the importance of the different items that uh that put in the framework you identify what are the key that you want to manage.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 155
Okay. It's not a laughing matter. It It's not actually. So, so I I wish I I think I hope that as you said that maybe the the phased approach which I I can do something in this this this spring. Okay. Uh come up with some money because we are you know senior citizens in social security you know so we don't really have much money. Okay. So, so I I think that uh uh in this spring I I can maybe I can do we can do something. >> All right, >> Mr. Kai, why don't you stay in in contact with Becca >> and work something out and then she can bring it back to the conservation commission for approval. >> Okay. Yeah, sure. >> All right. >> And that will start next spring. >> Yeah. Becca, does he know where to buy these plants? I mean, don't go to western nurseries.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 156
Now, if you remember, they said 10 years. So, over 10 years. So, [clears throat] we'll look at what are the immediate things that we want to do within maybe a year to five years based on the the the criticalness, if you will, of those those items. And then we try to figure out how do we get funding for those things. >> Raphael, can I Oh, go ahead. >> But shouldn't we have an idea of what that is, right? In my head, I feel like we're kind of putting the cart before the horse. So, we're we're giving this framework, right? And we are understanding the scope and the different variables that come with it. But I think to >> Dr. Maria >> Mary Joe sorry on the I like uh perspective >> how do we incorporate that now so when we go to the planning portion of it on December 8th we know what we are >> approving or what the true framework is really going to be not just because when we I I'll say like this the strategic plan is very thorough rigorous right it gives you an idea of all the pillars and so forth so we understand and are able to associate what's next all the different phases, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 156
Yeah, it's going to be really expensive if you go to Western nursery. There are plenty of sources of plant material that are a lot cheaper than that. New England plants for the shrubs. They're 12 bucks a shrub. >> Well, she can she can assist him. She can assist him with that. >> I I didn't see $12 straps actually for this size, but uh if you could recommend it would be good. Yeah, >> I can try and locate some um different nurseries, see if there's any lists online and provide them. >> New England wetland plants will ship them to you bare root and they're like 12 bucks a shrub for a three-foot shrub. >> Okay. New Can you say it again? New England. What? >> New England wetland plants. They're out in Amherst. >> Okay. It's online. >> Yep. They have a They have a whole catalog online.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 157
>> But it doesn't include any costs. Like if you took the costs out of this, it would be the same thing. >> But I think as a parent and I see 59.2 million, my first question again, just a parent, where's this money coming from? Much to what you just mentioned, right? That's going to be our next topics. However, I believe just in theory, we should have an understanding of like the now, right? Like what does that look like now? So if we were to go through the junior high schools theoretically would it be 30 billion right based upon we did XYZ I think we maybe we should limit our scope before we move forward with act an actual plan if that makes sense >> it I guess so here's a theoretical like so the numbers and I and I would ask you all to speak if you could a little bit more about the numbers because these are real costs that whether we approve or not we may be facing these right so whether what this does is it actually gives us a coherent way to think about the range of costs that we're facing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 157
>> Okay. >> And that's where you're going to go to get the seed anyway. >> Hey. >> All right. We have direction now. Can we uh we have agreements? All right. Very good. All right. We'll move on now to the next item. Thank you, Mr. Kai, for joining tonight, by the way. >> Okay. Thank you. Goodbye. >> Enforcement order ratification 11. Diane Lane, Joe Notkin. Are you going to take this one, Becca? >> Uh, yes. To the commission. I will give an overview on this one. Um, so a bit of history going into this. Back in uh September, the previous owner of this property was looking to sell their house and had contacted our office several times to determine what could and couldn't be done on the property um because they were having some issues with selling the house due to the proximity of the wetlands um that were there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 158
to your point um Stu can you or I you know any of you could you speak to a little bit about when you use the word framework I think when we you think about instructional framework which are competencies that highlight I think there's a semantic issue here too which is this is really what are the priorities that emerge for us in our district about how to structure the next stage of what comes first second third and fourth right so and then how different is what you've done here with us compared to um 204 that just approved a $450 million uh lots of districts that you've been through and I'm not proposing for anybody listening that we're going to do a 450 referendum at all right so just no referendum in that context right in that way but I just want to name like I think it's important if that for the public to understand that we are talking about a framework really a prioritization of the And if I can just add on to that, yeah, wasn't there a report a couple reports ago that kind of broke down what was, you know, what was kind of like one to three years and then three to five years which started to put some of those kind of priorities in place.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 158
During that time, I had personally gone out and looked at the wetlands. While I did not do a full delineation, there were measurements taken of where the approximate edges were in different areas and and the proximity to the house. Um the no disturb zone basically came up right to the edge of the house in several locations. Um if you're looking at the house from the road, the left side is a stream and the rear of the house um there is another expansive wetlands um that is bordering that stream. Back in August, the property was sold to the current owner, Mr. Nutkin. And in October, um I think the sorry the when I said September before it was back in July. Um it was sold in August and then back in the end of September, beginning of October, the current owner, Mr. Natkin, had reached out um to see what could and couldn't be done on the property.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 159
>> And that's what's in here actually. Yeah. >> I think um be maybe before you respond, I think my the again the friction in my mind is when I vote on something >> Yes. as someone who's representing the public and we've seen a presentation where numbers are attached like what are what are we promising to the public in regard to uh in regard to our vote. So, if we're voting on a framework and one of my fellow board members made the comparison to the strategic plan, you're right, there's no numbers attached to that strategic plan, but we just saw something with some numbers attached to it. And but if if I if I think about it through that lens, that makes sense. But are we going through the strategic plan then and saying, "Yeah, we might not be able to do this, you know, three years down the road, we might say, we might not be able to do this because we don't have the the the funds to do so." And is that the same process that we're going to take take on here?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 159
Um at that time, I was unable to do the site visit. And so Sophia did do a site visit and informed Mr. Notkin that he would need a permit for just about anything he was doing out there. Um then on November 14th, uh Bill contacted us and let us know that um he had seen activity out there with some significant landscaping and some cut trees. Um I went out the same day and did confirm that um significant clearing had taken place. So, I will hopefully get these pictures to show up on the screen here. So, these were taken on November 14th. Um, the houses to the right here. The stream is just off of you. In this picture, you can see some mulch, some lom, some wood chips that have been put out here. From what I recollect from when I was out at this site, the wetlands came roughly to where my cursor is now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 160
Like we approve a framework that includes everything that's that we've seen tonight. And then I hear we're gonna are we prioritizing everything that's in the bucket or are we thinking about do we need to take stuff out of the bucket? That's I guess my question. >> I'm going to lean on our experts who've done this more than I have. I'm going to add to just the importance of making sure that the plan is a comprehensive long range plan because if we were to leave stuff out of the bucket that doesn't you do you a service in terms of how you plan it to. >> That's fine. I just want to know that we're voting on everything in the bucket. >> Yeah. I think >> the answer is yes. That's fine. >> Comprehensive need and vision for the facilities over the next 10 plus years. I think that's really what you're adopting as that playbook.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 160
And so everything basically to the left of that tree um would have been the wetlands. And this area up to the retaining wall is the no disturb zone. Um off to the right of the house, the lawn area there had been torn up as well. um that was within the 100 foot buffer zone. This is a better view of that area on the side and you can better see the stream channel um in that picture. And then on the deck looking back, you can see the patio. You can see some grading here. The rocks on the back here was the edge of the wetland. It drops off at that point. And you can see again this is in the back. Um this is looking off to that left side and then this is on the rear. And so this large boulder um was the exact point where I said the wetland was um maybe a little bit beyond it was very marginal.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 161
>> Okay. Typically what phase one of implementing a plan typically is much less than the total need just because you have it's often that you do it in phases too. So um what phase one might be in a in a sister district it's actually much less than their total need that they identified in their comprehensive plan. Okay >> and it might take five plus years or closer to the tenure mark to get to phase two. So it's often a phased kind of implementation where and that's really tied into the funding strategy and what you could do right up front. But it's important that it was comprehensive so so you could plan accordingly. >> Thank you. And um if it's a like let's say like I think again I love the um comparison to our strategic plan because we've talked about our strategic plan as a living document.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 161
Um and so this area that has been cleared and graded um is no disturb zone. This patio is in the 100 foot buffer zone because of the sequence of events where the um property owner had been previously informed that they needed permits um and they had gone ahead and done the work without the permits um instead of just doing a notice of violation and having them come to the commission. Um, a notice of violation was issued with fines in the amount of $400 for $100 for each violation of four violations. And an enforcement order was issued under the state act. Um, both the notice of violation and the enforcement order had the same requirements. Um, which normally I would leave some of these for the commission to determine, but given that the ground is freezing and we want to get the mulch out of the wetland sooner rather than later, um, I did put in the enforcement order, um, and the notice of violation that the mulch is to be removed from the resource area by hand rake immediately, that all disturbed areas should be stabilized with a straw layer and um, mulch or compost socks with a minimum of 8 in diameter should be installed along the perimeter of all of the disturbed areas and staked into the ground for stability.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 162
So like let's say we get through the first five years and we've been able to secure funding and do all these things and then we're at a different point in five years the economy is different population growth has changed. This can be uh a living document for lack of better terms. >> Exactly what it is that is helping. >> We're not we're not voting on on this the steps over the next 10 years. >> Yeah. I just want to make sure when we vote we're promising >> but we're promising to the public. We're we're adopting a framework that in our current moment um demonstrates what our facility needs are and we are also in that vote or in that adoption dedicating ourselves to viewing this as a living document. >> Yes. >> Okay. C >> can I ask you a quick question? Uh the numbers that you have in here >> from like the one to two and then you've got six to 10, those include like inflation and increasing [clears throat] costs over time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (November 17th, 2025) · passage 162
Mostly to have something in there when we get to the spring free thaw that since there will not be growth there um something is in there to help protect the wetlands. Um it was also required that they come to your next meeting on December 8th because this was issued on Friday. it was too short notice to require them to come to this meeting. Um, however, because there is an enforcement order involved, you guys are required to ratify at the earliest possible meeting you can, which is why it's on tonight um for that. The property owner did contact us uh today and um express that he thought that the restriction for needing permits was only for structures and that he was allowed to do anything else. um and that this is his first time owning property and he just did not understand. Um I explained to him the need to remove the mulch and told him to just remove everything to the left of that little retaining wall by the deck.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-11-18 Kendall County, IL YouTube / BOE Stream transcript source: youtube SD308 Board of Education Meeting (11/17/2025) · passage 163
Yes. Okay. >> Just to be honest though, no one knows what inflation is going to do. I think we use a baseline number. They use a baseline number >> and best available right now and there's a way to adjust that >> based on what inflation is going to do it. >> I anybody else? >> So maybe just one more kind of cap on that. There was a slide with seven ideas on it. We call them guiding design principles. Is that is do you agree with that vision for the district that at the end of the 10 years or however long it takes to do it that that would reflect the values >> and and be a a way to and I know those were very brief statements. >> We've written them in longer format >> as well. um they don't tell you everything because at the end of the day there are some physical conditions that have to be addressed otherwise you know you'll you won't be addressing the the immediate needs for maintenance and things like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above