He's a amazing instructor. So I just want to recognize that department is being uh doing outstanding right now. >> Please Mrs. Ferris, you know actually that's such a great idea um Mr. to avoid to have and I know it's probably a process for you to go through to ask them but it would be kind of nice and informative and give a new perspective to all of us if you had as you had suggested before each administrator coming to to talk about their work and whatever >> but also somebody tag team from each, you know, career area. >> Yeah. >> Like that would be a neat thing, I think. >> Yeah. >> So, yeah. So, we'll start doing that. >> We'll we'll start doing that actually. Um, I'll meet with the CT director and we'll put a plan in place so that you get an opportunity to meet each of the super uh supervisors and talk about their departments and maybe bring some of the teachers who might be interested in in uh >> uh giving uh a little uh outline of what happens in their program.
And like Bank of America or you know, I know the NFL when they had the Super Bowl in town, they picked up, you know, like a hundred projects statewide. And so there's different organizations that do that, but it's something our teachers have tapped into. So, um, I appreciate them trying to be resourceful and and good at that. So, that's that concludes my superintendent report. I tried to end on a positive note. >> Thanks, I >> Very well done. Thank you. Appreciate that.
And then the same as the previous one, the fast bridge we're taking in a couple well the last week of November, beginning of uh December. So, we'll have that at our February meeting and then I'm going to turn over to Dr. Dods Karen. >> Yeah, thank you. Um, similar to what you saw with interim measure um, 1.1, the graphs look very similar with 2.1, this is specific to our sixth through 8th grade black students. And you will see that as measured by interim benchmark one, our proficiency rate for our students is six points lower than their pretest. It is also lower than what we saw a year ago. The sixth through 8th grade student average passing cut scores um they did increase on our new cut scores, but currently we are not on track to meet our interim goal. You can also see that the end count for the first one we had 11 students and out of 73 and now we have seven students out of 80.
So, it's not per item like that. And so, we do have commodities for food. We also offer fresh fruit and vegetables, which is offer versus serve. So some students have unlimited amount of fruits and vegetables they can take and some students say I don't want any. So kind of balances all of that out. >> So Natalie, this is not um this is not all a cart, right? These are meals and so what's generally included in a in a full meal regardless like if they've got two or three choices of a full meal, what would what could those choices be? >> So at breakfast you have to have at least three components of a meal and at lunch it has to be four out of the five. So you would have grains, protein, fresh fruit and vegetables, fluid milk if you want, and then any of the side items which would be other vegetables which we break into colors.
I never told anybody how to vote. What I did, and what I will always do, is make sure that the public has accurate information. So, >> I'm sorry, Miss Van Hook. I you can address something that was spec I'm >> I'm going to uh ask legal at least the way I'm understanding this at the present moment I I disagree that that's what's happening. Um, President Wade, board members, at the conclusion of all the calls to the public, um, the board member has the option to respond briefly um to criticisms um to direct staff um to bring an a an agenda item in the future or to research a matter and possibly bring it back on an agenda. >> Thank you. Um, [sighs and gasps] what I will always do is make sure that the public has accurate information so that they can make an informed decision.
I have lived in this area. I moved out to the Queen, Queen Creek, Santan Valley area um a little over 27 years ago with my husband. So, this community is very important to me. I believe that um schools are the foundation and the heart of the community. And so, that's one of the reasons why I'm here tonight at JO Combmes. And um I want you to know there are several other superintendent openings across the East Valley and I have only applied for this district. This is really the community. I am part of Panell County and and I want this to be a great place for our students and our families. So um just something that I think is important for you to know about me. Um throughout my um career, I of course started as a classroom teacher and um after several years of teaching, I moved up to be an elementary school principal and I did that for nine years.
But while I'm still nervous about presenting my action research, I'm really excited about my topic and the potential findings that could benefit my students and strengthen my program. BPSU has had a tremendous impact on both my work and home life. The topics that we explore in BPSU go far beyond the classroom. Their true life skills that I now share with my students and my own children at home. The most meaningful part for me has been creating my leadership manifesto. While I've always viewed myself as a leader, I had recently felt a bit disconnected from my purpose as an educator. Developing my manifesto helped me reconnect with my core values, reignite my creativity, and restore a balance of fulfillment in my daily routine. So, thank you, BPSU. Appreciate it. [applause] Um, in a minute we're going to give time if our board wants to ask any [clears throat] questions, but I would be making a mistake if I didn't say uh Jenny Baron, >> uh, who is a speech pathologist.
Are the schools that different in size? Um 458 for Balmoral. Isn't there an overflow that if you get to a certain capacity? I just want to make sure. Are there's not too many kids in a classroom per teacher at one school compared to another, right? I mean, don't like I don't know how exact numbers per school, but that number seems awful different. >> Yeah. Okay. >> So, um class sizes will vary. Uh there class sizes will be cut off at a a certain number. For instance, at every kindergarten classroom when it gets to 25, those students will move to their sister school. Um and so that happens in cases. For instance, I know this year uh we had to close Creed Elementary's kindergarten classrooms and those students went to Mount Boral, but what that meant is that those students there were those teachers did not have 25 students yet.
>> Thank you. >> All set. >> Yes. As long as it gets down someplace. >> I'm sorry. >> How do we How do we get that? >> As long as it gets documented someplace and not forgotten about. >> What? >> Even Brenda's got it. >> You can call at any time and remind the superintendent. >> No, I love the idea. So, it's going to happen. >> Okay. >> It's related to that. No. When is the next general advisory meeting? >> Uh that's in January. Oh the uh we have a meeting of all the uh >> all the shops >> chairs that will come in that'll happen in January. >> Okay. >> At our January meeting. >> Thank you. >> Mrs. Fish your mic please. Uh budget calendar update Mr. Lavoy. So at this point uh we will be starting to meet with the uh supervisors of each department uh after Thanksgiving to review their particular budgets which if you you don't have any calendar but that's the next thing that we have to do based on the budget calendar.
Um, next item on the agenda is a call to the public. Anybody that would like to address the board, we invite you to do so right now. Keep your comments to about three minutes and and uh keep them in regards to u the school, not uh individuals in the school district. Open that now. Going going gone. Oh, come on up. We >> Yeah, there's a form at the back. There's a form at the back and and uh we need you to sign your name and everything. Give it to Mary Ford so we know who you are. So you can go into the public record for eternity. >> Oh, right now. >> No, before you leave tonight. Before you before you leave tonight. >> But you can tell us who you are and why you're here. >> Okay. All right. I'm Sada Chednoff. I'm a hydrogeeologist and I'm an executive director at a nonprofit, the American Groundwater Trust.
So we have more students. Yeah, >> this again is that seni graph for our sixth through 8th grade students. U nine students did increase in proficiency, 48 students stayed the same and 13 students decreased in proficiency. interim measure 2.3. This is for the percent of our eighth grade black students who score proficient on the DNA assessment. And you will see that our interim benchmark one, the passing rate for our eighth grade students was nine points lower than their pre-EST, one point lower than it was last school year. Again, the cut scores did increase, but as Marie and I shared on the previous um progress monitoring report, we did a deep dive again just to try to figure out kind of what was going on with these assessments. And specifically for um our eighth grade students, three of the eighth grade standards had been taught. Um two of the standards, our students had commensurate um achievement as their peers.
So you would have to on the week offer at least so much and then they would have to take so much. So when they pass the register with the person working, if it's not a complete meal, we send them back to go get more things. Okay? >> And the complete meal is what you get reimbursed through the government for. So, if if you saw on her chart, $469 was for the full reimbursement. So, even if we were to take the price that a paid student pays right now plus what we get from the government, it's still less than what we get as a government reimbursement for the free meal. >> So, I I know in the p I appreciate that explanation that cleared it up for me. [laughter] I know in the past, I think in the past, if I unless I'm not remembering this accurately, when we've raised prices, we've done different amounts at the different levels.
That is governance. Schoolboard members are elected by the public to govern. We answer to the voters, not to staff, not to contractors, not to special interests, and not to HA. The community spoke last year, and they spoke again this year. Whether we agree with the outcome or not, voters have the final authority in bonds and override elections. Some may choose to attack me personally for the outcome, but that won't deter me. Personal attacks do not change the facts, and facts don't care about your feelings, and they will not silence me from doing what I was elected to do. Provide oversight, ask hard questions, and ensure transparency. It is neither political nor personal. It is common sense and good governance. We must ensure that we are transparent and accountable. That is how public institutions earn trust, not by repeating talking points, but by confronting reality honestly.
And I think someone spoke about that um earlier. um just what an amazing job, right? To be the principal of an elementary school and get to see um those children every day and all the wonderful things that are happening in those classrooms. Um after that, I moved up to district level leadership and I have had the opportunity to uh be an executive director um over human resources, over K12 educational services. I've worked as an assistant superintendent and I am currently an associate superintendent um for a neighboring district. Um I've been with that district for 21 years. Um and so that's kind of my background and experience. And I want you to know that um over those 20 years I it's provided so many opportunities for growth and so many experiences um that I can bring to JO Combmes because the district that I've come to that I've come from excuse me um experienced a very similar tra trajectory um was a very small district more rural um we were declining in enrollment um there was a lot of school choice coming into the area and um we were losing enrollment um to other options that were within the community.
She started at the early childhood and I think she's worked in every school in the district except for Routolo and now she's at the high school. Uh, she was a part of cohort one and um, I would argue or contend she's one of the biggest BPSU champions um, in our entire district. um to this day she still emails us with ideas and thoughts and leadership things. She's incredible. She was supposed to be here tonight. She was not feeling well. Um and uh uh I just wanted to mention her because uh she would have you would have enjoyed her speaking because of her passion for BPSU.
And then when they reached 25, then we find another home for those um students to attend for that one year um while we had that transition going on. Same thing for other grade levels. And Dr. Dr. Melanchenko can speak to class sizes and numbers. Uh the state reports are what is average. Uh but then again there are classrooms that close. Again I would say Balmoral has 30 in their fifth grade class and there could be some variances across the district of what that looks like. >> Okay. So that's where I think for me and again remember when it comes to the the academic side, but I would think that would be more stressful for a teacher at 30 kids than it would be at 24. And I'm just not understanding. And again maybe I'm just understanding let's say that Talo only has 22 classrooms and Balmoral has 40 which could skew the numbers but they look I just want to make sure I mean we are moving the kids because the majority of people I think uh Mr.
So uh the process is going well so far and uh eventually we will uh give you an update on where we're at with the actual putting of the budget together. We'll have a uh after probably later into the year, more like February somewhere. I think it it identifies it in the budget, but we'll be able to give you more information, but at this time, that's where we're at in the process. >> Thank you. Would you like to touch on the admissions report? So admissions at this time um I think your report shows we have about 600 600 something applicants. >> 764 >> six >> 764 >> Oh 76 764 is showing in your report. Um but since this report we're up to a thousand So, which is a a lot higher than it's a lot higher at this time than we've been and we've been so uh we've had a lot of we continue to have a lot of interest.
So, just a comment. I got to do STEM takeover a couple of weeks ago, K through six for a whole week and I cannot say enough good things about our teachers. Um, I will also comment that I hope in the future we can continue with these smaller, you know, teacher to student ratio. It was fantastic when I got the fourth graders in there and I was only handling 20 versus 30 to 35 in the sixth and fifth grade. But I really appreciate y'all letting me come in. I also did seventh grade. Um, this year we're starting to plan the project wet water festival. We held it last year. This is a program for fourth graders. We have a number of entities that fully fund this to bring all of the fourth grade students from the White Mountain region to Mountain Meadows for a day of learning about all things um, hydrarology, watershed, water cycle, storm water.
However, um for the last standard, 16% fewer black students demonstrated mastery. >> I also I know you had clarified this on the previous one, but the R um underneath the percentage is basically the um correlation coefficient. And then when you see the N and the equal sign, that's the number of students. Just to clarify for everyone that uh what those numbers mean. And just to recall uh just to refresh ourselves as far as the correlation coefficient, >> we're looking for that number to be what >> 6 or greater is considered a valid. >> And for this particular uh assessment, we did dive in to the standard where we had less students demonstrating mastery. And we made a note so we would share with you just to kind of understand what are our students being asked to do again in those first few weeks of school.
It hasn't just been a blanket, you know, increase that's the same at all of our elementary, junior high, and high schools. Is that is that accurate or am I >> So I've been here since 2008 and since I've worked here it's always been the same amount. There hasn't been different amounts. When we did the first amount it was 10 cents. Then in 2019 uh it was voted on in the 2018 spring and it was uh enacted in 201920 school year. It was 25 cents because they had gone a long time without doing an increase. And so we thought it is easier for the families to do it more gradually than to all of a sudden oops we should have been watching our budget and doing a little bit here and there and then all of a sudden and and so previously we had to do the 25 cents because we were so behind on it.