Indiana law prohibits defamation which entails making statements that tend so to do harm to the reputation or of another as to lower him in estimation of the community or to deter a third person from associated or dealing with him. This is based on Newman versus the Jewish Community Center Association of Indianapolis um previous case law. Liability for defamation under Indiana law results in the following four elements are met. The speaker has made a communication with defamatory imputation. The speaker acted with malice. The speaker statement was shared via publication. And the defamed party has suffered damages. Again, noting the same uh Newman versus Jewish Community Center case law. Mr. Lance's accusations against Mr. Helming are destructive, defamatory under Indiana law. And further detail below Mr. Helming's demands that Mr. Lance and the board immediately retract these statements. Cease and desist from making any further defamatory statements about Mr.
>> Thank you, Mr. Wall. Anything else? >> John, I'd like to say thank you for everything that I've learned since I've been on here for the last year. Um, you're always open for conversation and you I what I've seen behind the scenes. You've done a great job. I appreciate it with you and Becky and the financial stuff. Um, and just a little bit of humor. I was a year old when you graduated high school. So, [laughter] >> well, thanks Aaron. >> Thank you, Mr. Carl. I'm going to stun everyone and tell them I don't have anything to add. I do have one thing more I'd like to say though because we need to take a moment uh to acknowledge someone at HCCS who truly works hard for our schools every day and has done so for some time. This person never asked for recognition yet is nearly irreplaceable in this district.
>> Is there any discussion? >> Go ahead. >> motion from Miss Ean and Mr. Quillis to reopen 10.1 through 10. >> Again that has been done. >> All right. So, so roll call to reopen >> the finance section. Correct. The entire section. >> 10.5 >> to 10.5. >> 10.1 to 10.5. So that's what this is. Mr. Diaz. >> I This is to open. >> This is to open. Yep. >> Just open the discussion to have another vote. >> Mr. Taylor, >> I. >> Mr. Rodto. >> No. >> That's no. Mrs. Assan, >> hi. >> Mr. Ramos, >> Mr. Quillis. >> Hi, >> Mr. Gaba. >> Hi, >> Mrs. Petiri. >> I >> Mr. Fino. I. So, I'm going to ask for a motion to approve 10.1 through 10.5. >> Second, >> Mr. Ramos and Mr. Quillis.
Helming and comply with all other demands set forth in this letter. Specifically, Mr. Hson hereby demands that Mr. Mr. Lance and the board comply with all the following. Mr. Lance and all other members of the board must immed immediately cease and desist from making any further verbal or written statements unlawfully defaming Mr. Heling within 15 days days of the date of this letter being received. Mr. lands must publicly retract the defamatory statements described above and apologize at the next public meeting of the board. Seeing within 15 days of the day of this letter, the board must censure Mr. Lance for Mr. Lance defamatory statements as described above. This letter is not intended to provide a full recitation of the facts and or a complete review of the applicable law. Nothing contained or in or emitted from this letter should be deemed to be a limitation, restriction, or waiver of any of Mr.
The accomplishments are too numerous to mention and most have been behind the scenes and have gone certainly not gone unnoticed. It is the board's pleasure to present Cindy Gray with a small gift in recognition of her celebrating 30 years of service working for Huntington County Community Schools. You really do make a difference every day, Mrs. Gray. Congratulations and thank you. [applause] So Cindy has been the administrative assistant for seven superintendants. Okay. She has been in that role for 21 years. Um which is an incredible journey. Uh from that um I will say to you my job would be impossible without her. um the wealth of knowledge um her encouragement um what she provides behind the scenes each and every day seamlessly is due to an enormous amount of work and hard work that goes on behind the scenes. So for you to have tolerated seven superintendent is pretty amazing uh along the way soon to be eight uh one day.
>> Is there any discussion? >> If I may, there's to the chair before everyone. >> Yes, I may, Dr. Tomco. >> And maybe Mr. Gler, if you can just read her and just clarify. I just want to put it out there. So, because I think everybody's probably confused. what's happening right here. So, so yes, this this payroll is C is a you certifying the payroll that individuals received it. It's peruncter. I know I use that word, Mr. Gel doesn't like it, but it's peruncter measure, meaning it's one of the only things that a board actually does uh approve post because usually the board meetings lie um after payroll >> after or before payrolls. So, like right now, we just finished a payroll. We wouldn't be able to pay people on November 15th. So, you're usually behind which means it's prefuncter. Um so again it's um if there is an issue or there's something you want to discuss that that might be something we can talk about um off off cycle or or uh because it's I don't know if it's a committee thing but again it really is just a measure of the board um to certify that the payroll was was completed and everybody got paid.
Helming's rights or remedies. Mr. Helming expressly reserves all of his legal and equitable rights and remedies, including the right to seek injective relief and recover monetary damages. I'd like to address some of the statements made. Madam President, >> go ahead. >> I felt this issue was serious enough to address um during this meeting given that the statements were made in uh during the last board meeting. So much so that I'm missing my son's senior year banquet to be here tonight instead sending my wife um to have pictures for me to review at a later time. Mr. Lance's statements are damaging to my professional reputation. For the past 14 years of my nearly 30-year career, I've been a certified digital forensics examiner for my agency, now serving as the supervisor of that unit. This role has required extensive ongoing training and many certifications in different forensic disciplines.
But I just want to say personally thank you. Um it's been a joy to work alongside you every day. You have helped me not step on a lot of landmines over the last few years. And so I just want to say personally I'm grateful for everything that you have done. Thank you. Uh if I could add one thing, if my mom and Kathy and Ted uh could stay around, we're going to take a picture. Yes, mom. You're g I'm in charge at least now. uh we're going to get a picture and then the rest of the group we're going to go out into the hallway and take some pictures of some things this evening as we get ready for the next round. So, thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Trout. >> Moving on to adjournment. Anyway, you like to make a motion to journ. >> So moved.
Um so at least for that one the other the other ones are a little different um 2 3 4 and five but I will say also the budget transfer these are gap gap accounting principles trying to transfer funds into different accounts it's not it's not money that's not there um since you are um dealing with different types of accounts here and accounting principles with regard to SDA funding meaning have a district funding where monies are allotted into one major pot of money and then have to be transferred out to the schools there's a lot of different movement that occurs. So that's part of these transfers. Um and uh and again, we're trying to fix some of those accounting principles uh that are going to be coming soon with some the audit report that you're going to hear about and also um the projection that we just received on Thursday, which we're also going to talk about.
In this role, I have testified in federal and state courts as a subject matter expert and countless criminal trials. His completely baseless and reckless statements jeopardized my credibility and the public's trust regarding my ethics in this capacity. Part of this training included network intrusion training at the National Computer Forensics Institute through the United States Secret Service. So fishing attacks are an area I have some experience with. Fish and email attacks generally require an action by the user operating an attachment opening an attachment or hyperlink. However, some fishing email attacks are now using AI powered worms to exploit the user's email assistant by replicating prompts to steal personal data and launch campaigns without requiring a user's action to advance the cyber attack. A recent example of this would be the Morris 2 worm one uh for one of these attacks. Mr. Lance indicated on November 21st, 2024, my email account, as Mr.
>> Thank you, Mr. Wall. Second. Thank you, Mrs. Miller. All those in favor signify by saying I. >> I. Those opposed. We are ajourned. cup has either first or second. So, he'll draw one name out of the first cup, one name out of the second cup, and match those up. And that'll be the sequence that we're we're going. Yeah. So Carrie will go first, Ken will go second. Um, the way this process works, just to to reiterate what's been presented to the public, when Mrs. time resigned. It started a 30-day process uh for filling this position under Indiana law by the statute. When a position opens up on a board such as this, the remaining board members uh fill that position. An application was sent out in a couple of weeks ago for persons living in Rock Creek, Salomony, Jefferson, Wayne, and Poke townships to apply for the position.
Um so so again, um I just wanted to clarify that regardless of your vote right now, I appreciate you revoting on that, especially 10.1 because it it actually, as Miss Material did say, did occur. Um and again in November you'll get we just paid two days ago. So [snorts] that's how it goes. Thank you for that clarification Dr. Tomco. Uh with that roll call please. Uh question I have. >> Yes. Uh Dr. Tomco as you mentioned it uh about a payment being held or you pay them three four months later. I have a question on page uh page four. There's a check number 020143. This is dated 4225. It's about 7 months old. Any clarification on that please? Why is it that old? Why wasn't September meeting October meeting? >> Did you say that check number? >> Check number 02 0143. There is two invoices for $18,000 and change.
Lance indicated my email account was the a victim of a fishing email attack. Mr. Lance received an email due due to his carbon copy on an email string during which uh I was coordinating health insurance benefits of my life um and between my employer and the school district. I've never had any direct con correspondence with anyone other than my wife and the director of business operations, Miss Gina Burr. uh both of whom also received this fishing email. Mr. Lance indicated he attempted to contact me about the issue but received an out office reply and received no further correspondence from me on this matter. The week prior to the incident, we had a death in our family and I was on briement leave the week of this attack. The attack occurred while my spouse and I were actually receiving friends and family paying the respects at the funeral home.
Um, those applying needed to be a resident of those townships. We had three uh applicants. Um we said Mrs. Miller, Mr. Thompson, and uh a third applicant that we released, Mr. Garwood, who who did withdraw his candidacy uh this afternoon. So, we will be interviewing the two candidates, asking them the same 10 or 11 questions. We're obviously streaming this so it can be broadcast to the community. After which uh we'll move into a uh still a public session, not an executive executive session. And uh instead of a motion, I move to elect A or B, we will just do a roll roll call and uh Mrs. Gray will say your name, alphabetical order, and you'll indicate which candidate you support, Mrs. Miller or Mr. Thompson, it will require four votes to elect. Um if we would end up after however long still a three to three tie um we could declare an impass and then it would be by statute it goes to the judge of the Huntington Circuit Court and he would he would make a decision in the manner he sees he sees fit.
Just >> Just give me one second. No problem. You don't mind? It's on page four. Okay. So, so those two checks that you talk about are are specifically for the windcreens outside. um on the high school campus, correct? Was it only for the high school campus? >> So, there were some um there was some back and forth bidding with regard to that back in the um in that time frame. Um so, there could be there could be numerous reasons why the check was delayed. Uh could be procurement reasons. It could be um delay in payment because of the transition that we had moving forward. Could have been something not signed correctly. I would have to do some research on that. I'm not really comfortable even though we we did we did talk about um you know the individuals that were involved here. We can talk about the public.
Upon return to work, I had over 700 messages regarding this attack. I contacted I was contacted by the school district's attorney, Mr. Shelley, regarding the incident. I provided him with all the information on this matter and the contact information for the city of Fort Wayne's IT provider for further information regarding the attack. Mr. Shelley stated that I need not to take any further action with m Mr. Lance's message as he was in investigating the matter. Upon also reviewing the October 28th board meeting, school board president Valerie Armstrong summarized that the results of an over $4,000 investigation paid by the school district found that the attorney general of Indiana, the state's high highest legal authority, had concluded no criminal actions in this matter. In summary, I find it horribly egregious that Mr. Lance, an elected member of the school board, would utilize his position to accuse a public servant of criminal activity, defaming their credibility through his u baseless theories supported by zero evidence.
So um first of all we need to have a roll call for this meeting. So Mrs. Gray, can you do that please? Oh. Uh, I need to call this meeting to order. Special session of the Huntington County Community Schools Board of Trustees, November 24th, 2025. Now we'll go to item two. Roll call. Mrs. Gray. >> Mr. Allen. >> Here. >> Mr. Mcclullen >> here. >> Mr. Melture >> here. >> Mr. Wall >> here. >> Mr. Carl >> here. >> Mrs. Miller >> here. I will turn this over to Mr. Wy. Okay. I already took charge there. Um okay. And we held the draw and uh to see who would go first and Mrs. Miller um matched up with the first position. So, and we've allocated about 20 minutes for this. Obviously, if it takes longer than that, that's fine. If it takes shorter than that, that's fine.
I'm not really comfortable right now cuz I don't have an answer um to the exact reason why it was delayed. I can find out for you. Um again those were delivered. Those are up. Um so and and you know that was something that we did uh we did talk about a few times but I can definitely get you that answer. Um, I just I just I would don't feel comfortable telling you exactly what I think happened right now cuz I'm not 100% sure and we have to be pretty careful as to that right now at this point. Mr. Gl, you concur with that? Okay. Thank you. So again, if that's something that the board um if the if the board isn't comfortable with that check, we can we can definitely, you know, that's something I would we we'd have to pay next month. we'd have to I I would wouldn't want to hold all of it up for that one check if that's the one check.
I would anticipate that his constitu constituents who elected him to this position would expect more professional behavior. My hope in addressing this issue tonight would be that if given the opportunity to speak further on the matter, Mr. Lance, issue a retraction of all previous statements regarding me or my wife's involvement and make a public apology to us for the damage that has caused to our reputation. >> Thank you, Madame President. I hate to kind of sell you what's been a very positive evening here. I've enjoyed watching all the positive improvements here around the school district and what you have to come. Um, my wife has really enjoyed coming into the Decal Central family and I wish you the best of luck on anything you have planned. >> Thank you for being here, Mr. Helpsing. >> Does anyone else have anything this evening? >> Okay, at this time um we will adjourn our meeting.
And the questions have been assembled by the by the board members. And obviously, if they have follow-up questions, you're encouraged to ask follow-up questions, too. Okay. With that, Mrs. Miller, please introduce yourself to the board. talk about your personal background, education experiences as it relates to your application for this job. >> Uh hello, my name is Carrie Beller. Um I am employed at Innovative Packaging. I have been there for 32 years. Um my employment um goes anywhere from the plant floor to the office to human resources to accounting to IT. Um, my education, sorry, it was supposed to be education education. Um, I graduated from Huntington North High School in 88. Um, I do have some college. I did go to Indiana Business College after that. Um, I fall into the range of people that would have enjoyed the learning center had it been available for me back then.