Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
We want this thing to be amazing, which is what our goal is to be able to get to. This is just one block of that castle that we are currently building. Um, I'm going to turn it over here to Miss Shy Decker in a second, but for iLearn, we're going to talk about the checkpoints. And part of the checkpoints, right, the state has put these in last year. And kind of the two focuses that they have is number one, it allows our our teachers to say what standards should we be teaching in this time frame, right? So, it helps our curriculum maps. Uh, but then number two, it also helps us identify the students who maybe are not on track to pass or even the SAT for that point. is we're going to talk about that data here today and what are we going to do with those students?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Public comment is limited to three minutes per speaker. Comments must be limited to the Wetlands Protection Protection Act, Ashlin Wetlands Protection bylaw, or Ashlin Storm Water Management bylaw. Questions and comments not related to the commission's juris jurisdiction will not be accepted. During the meeting, our host, Becca Solomon, the Ashlin Conservation Commission agent, will monitor the participants for raised hands and will be recording the names and addresses of commenters. Signing of documents will occur during the week after the conclusion of the meeting. We now open up our one and only scheduled hearing. This is an offcycle meeting. So we have notice of intent 61 Waverly street map 15 parcel 12 the Gutierz company D file number not issued and this hearing was continued uh from November 17th which was the first meeting where we had a high level discussion of the project and we also had a site visit on November 23rd which two commission members were present.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And remind me, Jay, was this younger or older before? Was it eight before? No, it's it was we never had a limit. Seven became like the new limit before you could like >> Sorry, I didn't mean to cut you off, Adriana, but there was a time when there was no limit. But then they put a limit in place and I think it was through seven years old with no caveats for there are circumstances where this can happen with se with kids who are um seven sorry it was there was nothing and then it was um K through four but then they wanted to add the language that if they were seven years or older under these extenduating circumstances you So, so three or four years ago, they put a statute in place that said um you can't do these suspensions for any kid kindergarten through fourth grade.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um how are we going to retach them the standards? Uh so that's kind of the point here. The idea of the checkpoints I'm going to turn it over to Miss Shyucker now. >> You can't see that, can you? >> Oh, not at all. >> Well, I do. >> I'm gonna move because there's no way. >> There you go. >> I'm still going to move. Okay, >> that's fine. >> I'm not sure. Can the board can you see that? >> Yes. >> Okay. So this slide is just simply to tell you a little bit about when for the checkpoints. Last year, Knox schools piloted what's called the checkpoints. The DOE, they asked if we wanted to do it, so we piloted it for our students in grades three through eight. This year, all schools are required to do these checkpoints. There are three checkpoints, if you can see, and I'm not going to read to you the windows, but here they are.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So to start this off um we can um have a a synopsis of the uh the site visit from the commission and topics that we discussed especially um focusing on the wetlands uh flagging. >> Just for the record, uh Greg, the commission is joined by Mike Carter. Yeah, we have at the table Mark Mike Carter from GCG civil engineering and land surveying to the commission uh for the overview requested uh at the last hearing on November 17th. The commission heard an overview of the proposed project and the uh and continued the hearing pending estimates for the peer review of storm water and drainage infrastructure as well as review under the wetlands protection act and regul and related regulations. A site visit was held on November 23rd with Bill and Carl both present. Um for the record, Bill is online tonight. Um uh they were both present along with myself and the applicant um and the applicant's team.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And then there were some situations that arose with kids and firearms or narcotics where those kids were older than seven and in K through four. And um those got a lot of publicity and then they went back and they adjusted the law again. And I I I think you're right, Katie. I think it was last year that the new law went into place, but it might have been two years ago. So I think what we're going to end up doing is leaving it how it stands and then since it's just copied and pasted from the statute, does that work for everybody? I'm totally fine with that. >> Um, and then, okay, so the next comment was me. Um, I'm pretty sure my only thing was just that we call it a hearing. And I think when I hear hearing or read hearing, I think like something very like even though it says informal, it just is a weird word to use where I think like would conduct an informal meeting would maybe fit better.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
These three checkpoints are formative assessment. It's just to give us, as Mr. Mick pointed out,formational data that our teachers can use to inform their instruction to help us build to the summitive test, which is the I learn the accountability test that our students take. Okay. So, our first checkpoint, the primary window ended on November 14th. That's the data we have tonight to present to you. Notice though over here there's a second opportunity window. So we have students who perhaps we have quite a few students you'll see that who didn't master the skills that were tested in checkpoint one those students when they are ready can have a second opportunity to take that same skill over and it's just any time between now and April 10th it's when the teachers feel the students are ready again more information all of this closes April 10th because the island window opens April 13th.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The west side of the wetland line was reviewed and two locations were identified to have sampling points. The catch basins and associated culvert and Waverly Street um that are being proposed for tying into for storm water were also looked at. Um the commission will discuss those observations from that site visit tonight. Um there was not a review of the east side of the wetlands which is the opposite of where the work is being done.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um especially because there'll be hearings later on for like long-term suspensions and so I so I don't know that was my only thing like is hearing kind of a misnomer there for what we actually do? >> Yeah. No, I made a similar comment on that same section just the phrasing of like the informal hearing and then the principal orally informs the student of the behavior. I don't know. I just wasn't sure if it's like if there's something about it being like a verbal or why the stipulation of like it is informed verbally in a hearing. I don't know. I was curious about that as well. >> Yeah. Well, and that's why especially because um orally inform the students alleged behavior is considered violation of the rules if not respond. >> Yeah. Especially because I think too we do like um we have the meeting with the parent and so like usually you do tell the kid first but then you end up having a parent meeting um and so even where it's like and the student's parent or legal guardian will be notified.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
That's the official testing window. Okay. So, if you move on, this will show you what we mean. So, in checkpoint number one, Mr. Mick said certain skills were tested. Here's just an example from fourth grade. Fourth grade in math. C4 point. That's grade four. NS is number sense skill number one or actually standard number one. That was perhaps one that and it was it was tested during this first window up to November 14th. So, we're just talking about so you can see how it's set up. The state has set up which skills will be tested in which window and teachers have all this information. They've added available to them. Um, we had it starting in the summer and then it just shows you the next window. Then we go to checkpoint two, checkpoint three and take that. So, let's get to the data. All right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Additionally, the estimate for storm water and drainage peer review was received from GCG which Mike Carter uh who was mentioned is here to answer any questions on that. That is also for discussion tonight um and for a vote to accept. A peerreview estimate for the wetlands review from Beiel and Thomas was received rather late this afternoon evening. Um the commission can consider voting on this though given it was a short time for you all to review. You could also consider tableabling that review to a later meeting um so that you can look over the estimate if you feel you need more time. Uh discussion from the public would be anticipated to be generally limited to those items unless the commission opens for additional um questions beyond that. Okay. I I'd just like to add to that that I believe and and correct me if I'm wrong uh that we agreed that this evening's meeting would be to review the scope of the peer review uh and that we would leave any substantive discussion uh until after that had been after the peer reviews had been done and and received which would probably be after the first of the year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, that's when we require like a meeting to get the paperwork done. So >> I Okay, so can we start? Let me start with this. Do we want to delineate a meeting versus a hearing or should I just make those synonymous in my mind and move on? >> So the reason why you need to have this language in formal hearing is because of just like administrative law. So those are like the key terms to show that you're giving somebody due process when it comes to like administrative law stuff. So I would leave it as an informal hearing. >> Okay. So then you're orally informing the student the alleged behavior the basis >> the orally thing is the only thing I can think of for that because it's not actually based in the statute is that they just don't want it in writing. I mean the less you have in writing the better legally speaking that I don't know the intention behind that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, this is elementary, right? I'm sorry. >> So, look at math for third grade. What happened in third grade was they were tested in number sense which was place value. Students in third grade had to read and write numbers up to 10,000. Find equivalent expressions up to numbers up to 10,000 and they had to round. And then they had what they call computation and algebraic thinking. That's a skill. And in third grade checkpoint window one they had to um add and subtract multi-digit numbers. do equations with missing digits etc. So our third graders 37% of all of our students tested in that window are proficient in those skills. The state average, remember they all test the same skills, 44% of Indiana students. In fourth grade, you continue it again was number sense. We pointed out that's they had to round numbers up to a million.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Is that correct? >> Uh yes. Although we would like to talk about timing of the we put you up at the mic. Thank you. >> Okay. >> I apologize for that. Israel Lopez for the applicant. Um I agree with uh what the vice chair outlined. Um I would just ask that maybe we can spend a few minutes talking about um timing for receipt of the peer reviews. >> Sure. >> Um but I'll let the agenda continue as it was planned and we can um circle back to that. Well, let's let's just clarify first of all because I uh misspoke a little bit on the on our sitewalk because I told you that there would be a peer review by GCG, but we hadn't decided who was going to do the wetland part at that time. We decided um a day or two later. And so that's that's why that's late getting here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> And Adriana can we note that James joined the meeting at 4:41 p.m. >> Okay. Hi James. Uh we just are looking at the student discipline. So if you go to the rolling agenda um if you just click on 5306A uh we're I think we're basically on page two. >> Yeah. >> Thank you. >> I don't know why I don't ever put page numbers on these. Um okay. So we got to keep the hearing and then so let me just clear that. Um, and then going back to what you're saying, you were saying, um, this is I feel like this is the like starting of like the investigation. I don't know if we want to Well, sorry. Actually, Katie, do you suggest that we keep with the exception of like discussing this orally, we keep the rest of this the same as well? Then >> it seems interesting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
They have to write what's called expanded form, find equivalent expressions, and then they had to multiply. They had to multiply four-digit by twodigit numbers. And and this is where what proves to be difficult for our students. They have to describe and explain the strategy used to solve those equations. It's not just a matter I can compute it. That's the algebraic thinking. Now I can explain how it was done. Fourth grade notice 53% of our students they are above the state average at 48%. That's important to note. Okay. For language arts checkpoint number one, almost all grade levels, it's almost every grade level reading comprehension except at third grade. there's something very important that goes with what I read and that's our reading foundations. They were tested in decoding this time and then in citing evidence and in fourth grade it was drawing inference again in language arts.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And uh we understand if you need more time to review that. Uh we've we've actually reviewed um both uh peerreview scopes that we received. The one that we just received um you know an hour or so before the hearing >> and the one that we received prior to that >> and I think we are generally comfortable with the peerreview scopes as they were presented. Uh we have a couple of questions just to clarify uh some of the scope items. Uh, but we were hoping that we could maybe talk through that, get some clarification on the scope this evening and and allow the commission to move forward with engaging both peer reviewers >> with that. >> Okay. Yeah, I think that sounds like a good plan. Should we open up to discussion for you >> talking about the scope? >> Yeah. Do you want to start with your question?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Well, the one interesting question I have is, you know, the principal will orally inform the student of the alleged behavior, but then it says the students will be the student will be given an opportunity to respond. Is that also orally or in writing? I don't >> Well, so that's why I'm saying that this feels like that part is actually more of the investigation part. Oh, let me start over. how we have like kind of classified it for ourselves is like we hear about something we let the kids know like hey we heard that you did this there's a violation um and here's like a statement form that you need to respond so that they give their side of the story or um like basically how they shouldn't get in trouble is what it ends up being. >> Yeah. Um, so I think that's what that part is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
They read something they have to cite their evidence. What did the author infer here? How do you know it? So you look at where we are 17% of our students in third grade are proficient with that versus 25 at the state. [laughter] And then in fourth grade 29 and 34%. Now third grade no please understand foundational reading skills they are huge in third grade right because that builds to I read. So our teachers our students will see these skills on every single checkpoint. And also I think we need to remember what our rate is on I read. We had a 100% of our general ed students pass this test last year. We're very good with this at third grade. So, I want you to to realize this. Um, and I will tell you these parallel what's the average prediction for the summitive test. In other words, um, now the DOE has just released what they call average prediction.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Sure. Um, and I'll and I'll just have Will Park, our civil engineer, um, come and just talk about that. >> Uh, good evening everyone. Um, Will Park, civil engineer at SMMA out of Cambridge. Um, hope everyone had a nice Thanksgiving. And thank you, uh, to the folks who joined us out in the site visit. Um, uh, I guess that was last weekend. Um, so, as Israel said, we are in receipt of the two, um, peerreview, uh, estimates and, uh, scopes of work. Um we, as Israel stated, we we understand the commission's um desire to have independent peer reviews from the peer reviews that have been um performed to date. Uh we did in reviewing the scope of the two um see a little bit of overlap um and just wanted to avoid duplication of effort. For example, there were several references to reviewing for consistency through the the NOI documents, consistency between the narrative and the drawings, consistency with checklists.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above