And then >> what we probably would have called the informal hearing is when we would like then be like, "Okay, now we're ready to tell you these things." And that's when we notify the parent. >> So, >> okay. >> So, I don't know if we need to like delineate that like the principal will conduct uh or the principal or the designate would conduct like an investigation including giving a student opportunity to respond. So, we like make it a little bit clearer that that's like the investigation part because what we don't do is we don't say, "Okay, you're going to get suspended three days for a fight. Here's the suspension paperwork." And then tell them like, "Oh, you can respond to me now." Well, the other thing that's weird about the way this is written is like, you know, it says that prior to a short-term suspension, the principal will conduct a informal hearing, but then we're like jumping the gun by saying that and then having all this after that, you know, because I assume all this takes place before the informal hearing.
What they think we will do at this point on I learn keep this in mind. These are skills that are expected to be mastered at the end of the school year, not the beginning. So, that's very important. And Michelle said, Michelle Tarno said it quite well when she set her summary today. Um, she said that we need to remember this is just like a toothpick in the cake check. That's what we're doing. What are our students doing? This is benchmark data. So, we know which students to target for which skills to continue. Okay.
Um, we just would prefer that that um be handled by one of the peer reviewers. Uh I get I think in our preference it would be the storm water peer reviewer who has a larger uh scope of work and that's typically falls within their within their scope and leave the kind of just resource area items to the wetland peer reviewer. Um, you know, uh, we did submit the D stormwater checklist with our submission. Um, although we didn't include the, um, Ashland stormwater checklist, we absolutely used it as a reference in our submittal. So, we are confident it is, um, the the submission is complete. Um so again just to reiterate we we see some a little bit of overlap in the overview of the completeness of the documents. Um and we also just want to state that in addition to the peer reviews that were performed through the ZBA, um we have also received uh very thorough uh comments from the conservation agent which we are reviewing and I just want to make clear we we intend to address those but just want to make clear we will incorporate those with the comments from the peer reviewers.
>> Yes. >> Okay. So, I feel like rearranging this wouldn't be bad. It would make more sense like y'all are saying. >> Okay. I think I think where it has Oh, I'm not sure what's happening there. Sorry. Um that go away. I'm on the wrong thing. Um where it says informal hearing right here. I think if we change that, we'll conduct an investigation. Um, and then like it'd be like during which the principal will orally inform the student and give them an opportunity to respond. And then following an investigation, if the principal determines a short-term suspension is appropriate, uh, an informal hearing will occur. >> Where the >> Well, they also have Oh, yeah. And then this is interesting down here. It's like Okay. Sorry. Sorry. Then >> yeah, I think that makes sense. Following the investigation, I'll hold a short informal hearing. >> Do you think that we need to delineate like the principal or principal designate or I guess it's up here, a building principal or other designated administrator?
Any questions on the elementary? All right. Middle school obviously four tested grades there. So as you look at it um math in fourth grade sorry excuse me fifth grade there was a lot um [clears throat] uh computation algebraic thinking and there was measurement there were the volume they had to tell and write prisms etc. Um, I'm sorry, rectangular prisons. And again, a lot of explanation at fifth grade in math. That's what testing is. And you can see they were 1% proficient above the state average. Okay? And in fifth grade language arts, if you look again, reading comprehension, inferences, explicit everything, just uh citations in their text, they were 6% ahead. Mr. noted something that was quite interesting. We recognized last year that's where some of our low scores were in fifth grade. Perhaps the transition from elementary to middle school. These same students did well in fourth grade, not as well in fifth grade.
and just want to make sure that no one's expecting like a supplemental in between submission. Um, we just want to want to address everything at once so it's not a moving target. Um, and again, this might be kind of the next agenda item that was introduced where the commission would uh discuss the the the site visit and the scopes of these, but we would appreciate to hear from the commission what specific comments or concerns you have with either the storm water design or the wetland delineation or impacts to the or lack thereof impacts to the resource areas. um we feel that you know this project is well designed and was pre-reviewed already. So if there are specific questions um we would just like to hear those you know sooner than later uh so we can uh take take those into account um as we make inevitable revisions to the drawings.
>> Yeah. Okay. >> I think if you just put principal then that's fine as long as you have that up there. Um, if the principal determines that a short-term suspension is appropriate, uh, a is this supposed to appropriate. An informal hearing will be I got too many commas kind of floating around in here. What do you think about that? If everyone wants to look at these from during which to the end of that second one. >> Say that again. >> I'm just Oh, are you still driving, Amy? Because then I probably >> No, I'm at my house now. >> Okay. >> So, you can see my face. >> Oh. Um, I was just saying I started like So, if you read the next two paragraphs, does that make more sense in terms of what we actually do? And should we add or take anything out?
So, if you remember, a huge change in the schedule was made. We now have one teacher over there for reading in fifth grade, one teacher for language arts, two separate classes, that's huge, and one teacher for maths. So interesting for that. You go to sixth grade and a lot of number sense being tested on this the skill a lot of its ratios and the rap proportional uh proportion proportional reasoning. So sixth grade math 25 of our students proficient that means they've got those skills mastered versus 31 at the state level. In ELA, our seventh graders are 10% behind the state average. Again, it was a lot of determining the theme. That's reading comprehension, analyzing what a text says, and citing evidence and proving it. You go to seventh grade in math. A lot of this are on positive and negative integers, properties of operations, number sense.
We just want to want to would appreciate to hear those soon so we can address them. Do do you want us to speak to that now or continue? >> Sure. Yeah. My last comment was just uh again before we adjourn would just uh like to um understand expectations for timing of the peer reviews and the effort to incorporate comments. That was all I had. Sir >> Becca, do you want to weigh in on on Mr. Park's comments? Uh, I will try to weigh in on all the ones I remembered because I did not manage to write them all down. Um, as far as the supplementary thing to the comments that I had provided, the expectation would be that you would provide that response in conjunction with any response to peer review as one large package. >> Perfect. >> Um, so yes, that is the case there.
Also, there's a lot of comma clauses happening, so somebody may want to double check that, too. >> I feel like that makes more sense to me and feels more like the steps that we are currently doing. >> Okay. >> And I see what you're saying about hearing. I feel like it should be an investigation. >> Yeah. So, we just changed it here, but I brought it down here so that you do see that there is an informal hearing. Do we need to move this um do we need to put this no appeal process up here? Like we notified you and you can appeal and then here are like some random things that may also happen. We're just thoughts. Say it one more time. I was rereading. >> It seems it's okay there at the bottom. Okay. >> Yeah. I think it's fine at the end.
you look at it 21 to 38%. So our seventh grade math teachers realize we have to do something right. We we don't have one/4 of our students right almost are mastering that particular or those particular skills. Again go to seventh grade ELA 27 versus 32. Again a lot of analyzing of text. It's all reading and analysis so far, giving our evidence. And then finally, you get to eighth grade. This was algebraic functions, a lot of solving of linear equations, coefficients, and 12% difference between what our students scored versus what state average is. And in language arts, right there, even. So, Mr. Mick will talk about where do we go from here, but as Mr. Condom pointed out, our teachers right now must be and they are they're reviewing which students need which skills, who needs additional support to master these skills. That's what it's all about.
Um the overlap I think the only line item is with the NOI reviews and Thomas has consistency between the plans narratives and wetlands border reports and GCG has um the the plans the narrative and the storm water report. Um I I think the intent of both of those is for GCGs looking at it just from the storm water side of the consistency and for Beiel and Thomas from the wetlands report side of things. Um we could probably ask for that to be clarified if needed. I can certainly Mike can probably speak better to the intention of theirs. >> Yeah, our scope is only the storm water, not the resource areas, not the delineated wetlands. um we will we won't be looking at that. >> From my perspective, uh Mr. Park, one of the things that we talked about in the field was the whole issue of the bedrock and and the potential blasting and that impact.
>> All right. And then next one is Evan. Um, I think we're all talking about this same like couple of sentences here about the written notice for the long-term suspension just um, >> yeah, >> I don't know that I don't know. It's not I think something that happens very often, but >> there used to be a official letter that we wrote and like through certified mail and sent it. >> Uhhuh. But that was guys. >> Okay. So, let's >> I'm going to see if I can >> We still do that. We still have to send a certified letter for the hearing and there's like a 10day limit. >> I can look in the shared drive for the APs and see if it's there. >> Is there a specified form or is that letter enough? Typically, if it's going to a formal hearing, it comes from uh Yenia.
And he pointed out something that Mr. Mick and I have already discussed. the teachers are going to have to review and maybe revise curriculum because my question was maybe we didn't use the information or we didn't have it in our hands soon enough to start in August, right? As far as what would be what skills needed to be mastered by checkpoint number one. So that's key information. We might have curriculum curriculums that need to change and move these skills earlier in the school year to match the data. Questions on the middle school? >> I have a question. So the the skills are just grade by grade. So it's not like it's the same skill that they're being tested on in fifth grade and then they're being tested again in sixth grade. >> Correct. >> Well well I mean it's it's a number sense. It's an area but it's a different skill in number sense.
And it's not real clear in these peer reviews that that is going to be reviewed except we kind of expect that to be reviewed. And if that is the case, um GCG and Bills and Thomas would be reviewing that from different perspectives. One would be the impact on the storm water and one would be the impact on the on the wetland itself or the potential impact on the wetland itself. So they would be they would be looking at the same issue from different perspective. >> Yeah. Un understood. Just reviewing for consistency just through different lenses. >> Uh and sorry I I mentioned the as an example I mentioned the consistency through the documents. Um another specific one was review of erosion controls in consistency with the Massachusetts erosion and sediment control guidelines. That's another one where we feel that, you know, a civil engineer stormwater peer reviewer is is has more of the expertise to review um than a wetland scientist.
So, it's typically handled at the district office. >> Okay. So, maybe that's why we don't know about it. >> Yeah. >> Uh Hilda, when you gave us a while back, you gave us like a link to the forms that um the trust has because they're not on the like actual district website. Do you still could you send that link again? Yeah, let me look for it and then I'll send it. >> And then what I'll do is I'll link it to the rolling agenda because I wonder if they already have a written notice of intent. So basically we just need we just leave this then, right? Because we'll use the one the district has. >> Yes. Okay. >> Or the process that we already follow as a district. >> Yeah. Okay. And then um I just deleted this and then I saw Amy added a comment.
Yes. >> The state has gone through and they've put an E by each one of those skills which means essential. That means you can count on those being on the island summited test. That's what all these are. Essential skills at each grade level because math, you know, it builds, right? What is the reading? And it does too. The reading I just I did a quick summary on the reading skills, right? Because when you're in third grade, you tell me you read something a student does and says, "Here's what the text says explicitly. They find the answer right there." But then you move up to infer. Now, what was the author inferring would happen? It's not right there. You got to think and put the context clues together. >> Okay. Okay. Does that help? [clears throat] Good question. Anyone else? >> Yeah, I guess mine is it's kind of concerning that well, first of all, like where your goal be because I I only think one of these even has a through the state is they're all the averages are under 50%.
I I think if I recall correctly, it came in late as we've stated. I think that was stated in both of them as well. Sorry, I'll stop interrupting. Okay. Does um any other commissioners uh like to weigh in? >> Well, I agree that that that we ought to try to coordinate things so that there's no overlap. That's not an unreasonable request. >> Thank you. >> Unless, for instance, it's from the same thing from two different perspectives to the commission. On that point, I think the intention with Beiel and Thomas one is again just looking at the impacts to the resource area. So they might be looking at it from the perspective of wildlife movement back and forth. Um as there are two potential vernal pools there and I believe on the uh May 2024 might have been 2023 uh site visit with Mass Housing for those of us that did go out into the wetlands.
Do instead of I it was back to the principal or principal design. Do we want to do administration? >> Yes, please. >> Maybe I should match it up here. I think that was throughout there was a lot of like it was principal principal principal rather than administration. >> Yeah. Oops. Apparently I don't want to spell it. >> Okay. And then I don't know do they have to be mailed or >> I think they were always done certified mail to show that we intended we could give them like so that way it was given to the recipient and that we had attempted and that it was signed for. >> It also says right here or hand delivered to the parent or legal guardian at the le last known address. I mean, it's kind of like serving somebody basically, >> more or less. And and we've even had people request to come to the district office to get them.
I think maybe one was back in third or fourth grade that the state average is >> 53%. No, we're 53 in the state. Yeah. >> Yeah. So, I mean, where would you set your goal? you're going to try to just hit the state or do you want half our kids or I mean that's to me that's concerning. I mean, >> well, sure it is. And this is probably the exact reason why the DOE has had these checkpoints, right? Because it's not just not students who are scoring, >> right, >> 30% proficient, 40% proficient, but you as a board looked at what our overall summitive data was >> and that's what we built our overall district goals and the percentages goals. overall putting all these skills together. These are just the building blocks to go to the summitive assessment >> and that would even answer your your question with growth, >> right?