Okay. So once you've identified what the issue is then we've got to go through each step in this process. So, we talk about the story, which is really just this narrative that helps everybody understand what the issue is. Um, and you want to do this before you start generating interest and options. And again, we'll we're going to talk about this more in in depth shortly. The next thing you take a look at are the interests. And these are whatever the underlying need is. This is the why behind the issue. Why is this a concern? um what is the priority and it and it helps to explain why this issue that you've brought up matters to each group or to the whole group here. Options are pretty much just what it sounds like. These are ways to address an issue that meets the identified interest. And again, we do these in order so that we can start to generate options that that meet those uh two things the the interest around the issue.
It's We're a small town. We have a small town government and there have been missed opportunities. We built 400 units on um Memorial Drive. We only allowed 10% affordable Why didn't we ask for 20 or 25%. >> Con I'm going to interrupt you real quick. I sat down with the developer before he started building and the first thing that came out of my mouth was that this board would not accept anything less than 25%. And he laughed at me. He said we'll never do that. We'll never do that. And that was before he put shovel to the ground. And that meeting took place up the old fab property. and we were outside having this discussion. He said he didn't want 25%. We said the town will take 25% and wants 25%. And he said that'll never happen. When you do when you do those types of projects, they have control.
Um, any discussion on the uh policy? >> So, I just don't >> We had a motion first. We had a the original motion was to approve the items. >> So, we have to entertain that first motion. >> No, we can [clears throat and cough] >> we can we can do this one first because it's pulling out >> because it's part of Yeah, that's >> so if it fails, then we can vote. We'll have you make the original motion and then I can rescend the first motion if you want to do it that way. >> I don't think we need to because if we because it would just be I mean [clears throat] the motion says approve the items listed on the consent agenda and if we can pull one out then it'll still cover the other two. >> So um can I speak on piece on this chair?
Then we've got to evaluate those options. Like I said, we're going to have some criteria. We're going to agree what that criteria is going to be. And you've got to look at it and say, "Okay, which one of these options is going to meet the collective needs of the group?" And you do that. We use a point scale that I'll talk about shortly. And then you come up with your solution. So we might have a laundry list of options, but once we evaluate them through our criteria, you may only have one option. You may have a couple of options. You may have options that you group together and we'll say, "Okay, this is the solution that we recommend. This is the solution we think we can get ratified. this is the solution we're going to take for approval to the governing board. So again many options but usually only a couple of solutions for that particular issue.
>> And he was given permission to build 400 units. >> All right. He was given permission because mass housing gave them >> was not a 40. >> There was a 40B, >> but he wanted to come in at the 40B originally when we had that first discussion and then he changed his mind about doing everything differently. >> So we So Connie, we don't have any townwide um we don't have like an inclusionary zoning policy where a bylaw where there has to be a certain percentage affordable. So without an inclusionary zoning bylaw, it's incredibly tough to negotiate um higher than okay, >> you know, like and and that's the same thing with the Chestnut Street apartments. It's it's literally um it conforms to the zoning. So if it conforms to the zoning, they they don't have to give more than than what's there. And that's that's >> They don't have to give anything.
>> Thank you. Um, so like I this maybe some of this is because I um am not on the policy committee and I think I have a stronger understanding that I actually do. But my understanding is that policies come to you guys in draft form. You work through them. Then you once you guys agree and you work with uh our admin and you work with our legal team on them. Then when you are ready, you bring them to us and we have usually 30 days. But in the case of these, we've had months, right? >> And we we've read them, we've given feedback, we've talked about them. I don't understand why we can't vote now on it. I mean, it's been months. I I don't get it. And plus, we're not voting on the regulations. We're voting on the policy. So, like, I mean, if the majority feels that way, then fine.
And then lastly, we'll talk about consensus. And um I'll go into depth, more depth about this, but I want you to think about consensus as really it's I can I support this decision or I can live with this decision. When I walk out of this room, I won't sabotage whatever the decision is. Okay? So, it's not voting. And we'll talk about that some more because voting, somebody wins, somebody loses, and that's not the point of interestbased negotiation. [clears throat] Excuse me. I'm going to spend some more time talking about um position and interest. Um because a lot of people get this is where things tend to get confused or people start to get positional. And so I just want to spend a little more time on this. And remember, you know, I put this this uh emoji or icon or whatever it is graphic about position because it's it's really I'm just saying this is this is what I want.
Yeah. >> They they can I mean if you look at some of the Fafford housing when that was built, there's not much affordable there. And unless the people that are working in town understand and push through at all the different levels, then you're not going to have it happen. And since I've been sitting here, this board has become much more educated. I know when I first came on the select board, I did not understand the difference between 10% and 25% and what you can count. So, it's it's an educational process that all of us have gone through. Um, you know, it's it's it's an ongoing process and it's an ongoing education. >> And the Cirrus apartments, I think people felt like we needed that housing there, right? We we specifically zoned that area of town for transit housing with the idea that people would live there and take the train.
I mean, we'll talk about it next month or next meeting or whatever, but like um I just feel like we have we've had a lot of positive movement with policies and I think that um I think it's worth passing. >> Well, and you know, and I respect your opinion on that, right? Um but I think, you know, it's a 50-page policy. We're replacing a two-page policy right now, and there's several areas of that policy that I'm still concerned with. Um, so therefore, instead of me voting against three of them, right, we have three policies. I'm asking for it to move so I can support the other two because if it fails, they all go back to committee. >> So, um, Rob, may I um, I hear what you're saying and I appreciate your strategy for that. Absolutely. What I think um so maybe uh you guys like help clarify >> the policy is only a few pages.
This is my idea. This is what I believe. This is what I want. I'm going to argue about it and and that's it. I don't care what you think. This is the way I think it should be. Okay. Anybody ever been with a significant other ever? [laughter] Yeah. Anyone ever have a significant other get positional? Yes. Maybe you're not with that person anymore as a result. I don't know. But I often ask myself if we were more focused on interest even in relationships because you can see interestbased negotiations happen in all realms of life whether it be like I said before a business international diplomacy whatever it is in this room that we're working together um we could probably solve a lot of problems if we actually said well tell me why you must insist upon X, Y, and Z. And then if they share what the re the why is behind their position, [clears throat] then you might actually say, "Oh, well, I you may not compromise." Because again, compromising means you're sort of giving in or giving up or you're acquiescing to doing a certain thing, but you might come up with some agreeable options that meet your interest.
Right? That was we we all thought that was a great thing for the town. The the unfortunate part is that we didn't we only got 10% affordable versus 25% affordable. >> It's interesting how developers can turn that around though when we ask for too much and say, "All right, I'll build what I want. I'll make it 40B. I I get confused. It's >> so It is confusing, right? I think I think that that >> a developer typically makes more money, stands to have more greater profit with >> following regular zoning, right? Because they don't have to have um you know lowinccome housing or or affordable housing. So, but if they want to just kind of zoom through and not have to deal with anything, they go the 40B route and it cuts into, you know, on some level profit. I don't know if it really does, but on some level it does.
The policy is not 50 >> 32 pages. >> Okay. Yeah. And we've had three months >> to go through this. >> So we have the motion to pull it out. Let's vote and see if [clears throat] it passes. So >> that's fine. Any other comments on it? Any other discussion? >> Well, I want to discuss it if we're if it's not going to pass. I guess that's the issue I have. Like I'd like to discuss it now. >> If it's if it's not going to pass, then we're not going to have be able to have a discussion. >> Well, the first motion is to pull it out. So, we just have to first see if it's like the first >> All right, fine. That That's fine. >> We just we I mean, we can keep discussing it this way. That's fine. But regardless, we have a motion to pull it out.
Because if you don't want to do whatever your significant other wants to do, you might find some mutually agreeable option. So again, the interest in in negotiations is really what is the underlying need, what is the desire, what's the concern, what's the motivation, why are we talking about this um as we negotiate.
And then, but they zoom through. So it's much it's >> but we were also it was also why 10 years ago we did our very first h uh afford our housing production plan because we started to get educated and when we put that first one in place and we had Cirrus go in we were in safe harbor for a while and then we did a second housing production plan again to try and safe harbor and stay in that safe harbor but then things happen beyond our control. We can't make someone build something if they're not ready. So, you know, it's part of the information that you shared back with us that, you know, now Pawn Street is coming online and a couple of these other things. Well, until they have their um their uh certificate of of occupancy, we can't count them yet. So, yeah, it'll be great when 501, but it's they haven't even put shovel to the ground yet for 501 Pond Street.
So, >> all right. >> If it passes, >> then it gets pulled out and we vote on the original motion. If it doesn't pass, then we vote on all three together. Okay. >> Copy. I understand. >> Okay. >> So, we can have the discussion now. That's fine. Whatever is >> Oh, the floor's open. Do you want to say something? >> You want to keep going? >> Yeah. I just um I mean there's two things that and just because we brought it to the full board doesn't like just as Stephanie has said in the past doesn't I could change my opinion or I wasn't >> Yeah, it's >> satisfied with the answers provided at policy. >> Um so there was two things that didn't sit well with me. The one was the walk out. Um, and the explanation we got from Mr. Blando was that he welcomes any student to come and speak with him and as long as they do it respectfully and whatnot.
Okay, any questions about position or interest? So, I'm going to have you do a little activity with it. Okay. All right. So, in your boxes, my hope is that there are some dry erase markers. They they're not the fancy expo kind. They're the cheap dollar store version cuz I'm retired. So, you're going to need a dry erase marker for this next activity. And if there's not enough, if you use a a Crayola or marker, that's fine, too. They tend to wipe off of here. So, get your dry erase marker ready. And what I'm going to do is I've got a list and it's in a uh screen protector. And I've got statements on the left hand side, several of them, and then a blank space over on the right. And your task is to identify if the statement is a position or if it's an interest.
And that's a developer who worked with us without it being a 40B who was willing to do the 25% which then allowed us to count all those units. Right? There are also people in town who push back when we say let's push for the 25% like we did for the 20 units we built on Pond Street. And there were people who said, "Well, we're getting you're only getting four units of those 16 even though 25% are affordable." We didn't create that law. We're just trying to work it to the best of our ability. So, yes, when these apartments go in that are 40b, they're going to be 25% affordable, but we're going to be able to account all those apartments toward our affordable housing number, right? >> So that once some of these are done, >> we can hopefully then get back in safe harbor and keep ourselves that way.
So, if that's the case, which I respect, right, he doesn't want to squash their freedom of speech or um then why not put that in there? Because in the policy it says um so that would go >> you would get you would get um actions leading to disciplinary action including removal from class suspension or expulsion a walk out or sit in within a classroom or school building on school grounds. You would get could get suspended for that or expelled from that if you do that. >> I thought that that was part of the regulation though. >> No, this is the policy. Okay. No, but may I speak to that real [clears throat] quick or sorry I don't want to interrupt you. >> That's fine. And I was going to talk about something else, but >> well, I was just going to say so the the the way that it reads and what we had talked about in in policy meeting is that those are that's how it's presented in the policy.
So I'll leave the definitions here, but remember position means I'm I'm taking this position. This is what I want no matter what your thoughts are about it. And interest is why it matters. So you're going to work on this individually and just write. You can just write P or I or write the whole word out, whatever works for you for position or interest. Now, here's my disclaimer. The answers are on the back, but you are not turning over the back. Okay? So, no cheating allowed. Uh, I'm going to give you a a few minutes to work on this on your own silently and then we will check answers and have a conversation. Okay? All right. Now, I'm watching So, it's okay if you don't get it right if you want to quiz yourself. a shoulder partner, somebody right next to you. So, in pairs, I want you to check your answers with each other and see how you did.
>> But it's a learning process and it's a lot of information. And you know, it's it's it's not an easy process. And I think you since you used the pawn street example um didn't you say um that Felmouth was appealing using that exact situation because they had >> we we let Mass Housing know all this information when we gave them our response for this first 40b back a year ago or whenever it was for 10 to 60 Main Street. We said to them, we have been working with a housing production plan. We have been working to get to our 10% affordability. We have these projects that didn't happen. We have UGC on Memorial Drive that we're waiting on. And Mass Housing still said, "We are approving this project." I know, but maybe an an expert that knows more than we do. Our lawyers, >> Lisa me who was sitting here and her firm, they train other law firms on how to do 40B processes.