2025-12-05 Passaic County, NJ YouTube / CPS TV transcript source: youtube December 4, 2025 - Clifton Board of Education Meeting · passage 60
Mahia. >> Yes. >> Mr. Ciano. >> Yes. >> Mr. Suarez. >> Yes. >> Vice President Santiago. >> Yes. >> President Paris. >> Yes. >> Motion carries. >> Okay. We have one more item under uh H agenda. Uh seeking a motion to approve item one under H agenda. >> Motion. Second. >> Commissioner Brunac. Seconded by Commissioner Mahia.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 60
So that sounds great but is it really better to do a different scenario versus a waiver? I'd like to be able to have the data to think about that completely. >> Yeah. >> Dr. Har. >> Yeah. Um I wonder if we can get back on page nine with the worst case scenario projections. >> This guy Yep. >> Yep. >> So that 10 in first grade at Barnum in red, is that an extra class? >> Yeah. So the way the building is designed is in essence there are five classrooms at each grade level. Um, if this scenario were to happen, right, there is flexibility in that building, if if it played out exactly like this in grade one. >> Um, I wouldn't have 10 students in a class, first of all. That's ridiculous, you know, when others are at 18. >> But, um, we would balance it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Passaic County, NJ YouTube / CPS TV transcript source: youtube December 4, 2025 - Clifton Board of Education Meeting · passage 61
>> Any discussion? Roll call, please. >> Miss Bassford? >> Yes. >> Mr. Brunia? >> Yes. >> Mr. Kenova? >> Yes. Mr. Media, >> yes. >> Mr. Ciano, >> yes. >> Miss Suarez, >> Vice President Santiago, >> yes. >> President Paris, >> here. >> Yes. Yes. >> Motion carries. >> And yes. >> Um, >> motion to adjourn. >> Motion by Commissioner Mahia, seconded by Commissioner Suarez. Everybody have a wonderful holiday. See you next year. >> On a motion. Good luck.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 61
I I left it hanging out there as kind of the remainder, if you will. Um, in that scenario, we have an available classroom that could be utilized at the prek level. So, in that year, this year, if it were to happen, I would take a kindergarten class, put it in that prek wing, which is literally right around the corner from where the kindergarten is now, um, and move a first grade class into that kindergarten space. And also I mean I actually think the numbers at fourth grade, fifth grade, six at 25 and 24 is those are big classes. And also notice that Norton has those 24s and 23s in the worst case scenario. Why why is Norton also high in the worst case scenario? >> Class size. Norton's not really impacted by redistricting at those other two buildings. >> So Norton's going to be that the classes are going to be that high >> potentially.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 62
And and you know I I know you're saying that that sounds out of the ordinary. It's not out of the ordinary today for for upper upper elementary in the treasure. >> In my mind, we're always trying to get class sizes down a little bit. >> I'm not going to argue with you. >> This is creeping up. Yeah, I'm not gonna argue with you. >> Beyond my comfort level. I'm just saying. >> Yep. And um the we would be adding five teaching positions here. Like this is actually four in this scenario. >> Yeah. So adding five is really when I ran a lot of different data over the last week utilizing various scenarios and things, you know. Um, in almost every scenario, it adds five teachers. >> Um, I just want to end by saying I appreciate all of this information, but um, as Sam said, you know, we we need to digest a little bit.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 63
I think December 11th is way too soon for us to um think about well first of all we won't have the information that we need if >> Yeah. I think it'd be too early to get good preliminary data. >> Um so I would I would really like to see um what what it looks like. I would like specifically I'd like to see how far from this worst case scenario we're likely to be. >> Sure. So, um, but I appreciate all your work. This, you know, it's obvious that this was looked at carefully from a lot of different >> Yeah, we we definitely spent an inordinate amount of time on it, but that's what's necessary right now. >> Any other Mr. Kau? >> Yeah. First, thank you for you and your staff coming back and looking and listening to the community and and finding other ways to sort of address their concerns.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 64
Uh, I'm a I'm a fan of this as presented. It's it solves for me the the long-term considerations with also the short-term considerations. The the third grader that has to get moved schools now has an option to stay there, you know, but we need to make decisions that also handle, you know, his or her children that might be in the district 20 years from now, 30 years from now. Um the two questions I would have for you on this, you mentioned in the worst case scenario that it gets tight in grades one and two if I remember correctly. Yeah. Does that continue to track >> year after year if those families continue to come back with the legacy waiver? >> It would be it would be tight potentially um if they continue to come back year after year. Um, and the reason it's tight is not necessarily like I could always throw three more teachers in there, but you you really change the configuration of the whole building when you do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 65
Um, I I think that I I don't know that I would advise of that. Um, but um, right now it's tight without really changing anything. Um so if they were to come back uh and we don't have significant moveins in those grades then it would be fine. >> Okay. And the Thank you. The other question I had is you you had a slide on there about budgetary concerns. Um we also mentioned the transportation wasn't you know that different across these scenarios. Um so you know B2 the difference between different families that submit for the waiver and are interested not or not in that waiver. You know it's not clear to me that any of these change across those scenarios. Am I understanding that correctly that that these are considerations regardless of the scenario the outcome that we get? >> Yeah. And again, you know, going back to the conversation with Heather that um you know, we are staffing based on ratios usually.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 66
Um and so and really what we're looking at is um the ratios don't change all that much. It's just the locations. And so there are external factors that influence our budget uh that are that are um little different this year that have nothing to do with this. >> Okay. Thank you. So I and I'll just close on on my couple other thoughts on the B2 there that you know the the data will certainly inform actions that you and your staff need to take around staffing the buildings but you know in my view if if the board is okay with the worst case scenario and the actions that would be needed you know the data and the results of the survey we would just be going back towards what you mentioned was the best balanced of the scenarios that have been presented, you know, where I think everyone was around 90 or less than 90 even in peak years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 67
So, you know, that's why I'm confident in, you know, putting my support behind a B2 because, you know, if if the worst case solves the short term for families that are concerned and also solves the long term and the best balanced capacity of the school, then, you know, I I certainly think this is a path worth pursuing. >> Yeah, I think that's what we were trying to get to. you know, how do we how do we meet both important needs, >> Mr. Dwight? >> Thank you. Um, second. Yes. So, thank you for having done this. I I appreciate it. I I have no doubt that this took quite a bit of time. One of the points that you made was about transportation and that would not be uh covered. I know that's what our standard >> Well, our current board policy Yeah. says that >> okay >> you know but you're the board you know >> oh absolutely I'm just saying based on what has been happening so the the one the thing I'm wondering about is assuming that was the case and there was no transportation provided have uh has there been any consideration of drop off or pickup does that become a disaster >> yeah I I think it it definitely becomes more difficult >> okay >> based on the number of people who take the waiver.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 68
>> Sure. >> And that's why again why I think that initial data is valuable. >> Okay. No. Yeah. No, that makes total sense to me. Um Okay. So, thank you for that. U >> any other thoughts, Mr. White? >> Yeah. Sorry, one second. Um >> yeah. Uh just following up on Ann's comment. So, uh you had mentioned Norton and the class sizes and Jeff's response to it. I So my son's in fourth grade there. There's four classes. There about 20 kids each right now. So if we don't add if we didn't add another teacher, but we do add Deaconwood or Highland, yeah, it's probably going to end up being about 24 kids per class. I could easily see that happening. Um I'm just curious for like a 30 or 60 second understanding on your view on the class sizes. So all of the first K through three are below 20 and then fourth and above jump up above 20.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 69
I'm just curious >> where you where your mind is at when you have it set like that. Uh you know what um I think that first of all the early primary grades uh we've historically because it is more developmentally appropriate taken a different approach than we have in the later primary grades. Um I think there is a benefit to having a um more students in that later primary uh where kids are engaging in more dialogue. There is there are more models. Um you know would I want to get beyond 25? No. No. Um is it manageable? Yes. But it's never been in our um really it's never really been what we've we've pursued. Um and again, we don't really get there here with the exception of um again the worst case scenario at Barnum with 100% and 0% opting out. Um, and so like I like I said, I've been in the district since 2005 and um we had a a parent large group committee um with parent, teachers, administrators and and we really redefined our our priorities called the personalized learning task force.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 70
It was probably what Marleene 2018 or so. Um, and one of those priorities was class size. Um, research doesn't indicate that it it makes the biggest difference, but it is definitely a priority for our staff and families and we really try and adhere to that. Um, and we try and be sensitive to it. I will tell you in recent years is the enrollment has increased. Um, and you know, we've had to navigate some challenging budgets. The elementary class size has crept a bit higher over the last and at a time when needs are um, you know, greater than they have been. Um, and so I think I am certainly conscious of that. this uh with the 126 teachers, it takes our class size down. You would think like, oh, you're adding five teachers, it must it must bring the average down a lot. Not across 200 kids.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 71
It doesn't. Um it brings it from what where it is currently a little above 19 to a little below 19 with five additional people because we're adding students as well. Our enrollment is growing. But so I think, you know, it's a long-winded way of saying, you know, we want to try and keep class size averages down. These are within the realm of what we've had. Um, you know, they look a little shaded higher at at Barnum under the worst case scenario, but I don't anticipate that coming to full fruition. >> Yeah, thank you. Thank you for that. And uh I mean as a parent in that situation, I prefer to see fewer kids in the classroom and more attention. But I also recognize there's budgetary constraints. And I also think back to I don't know if you recall her Ruth Pod. >> Oh yeah. >> She was she was a teacher uh for probably more than 40 years, maybe pushing 50 years and on the board of ed for another 10 20 years or something.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 72
And >> in her 90s I think on the board. >> Oh yeah. No, she was involved in the school system for a long time. But I remember her um voseiferously advocating for K through three Yeah. >> class sizes being small, saying that that's all the research >> shows. So, I mean, it's not something I particularly care for because it seems sort of counterintuitive, but >> anyway, uh I just wanted to add that I I I trust your judgment on this on the class sizes. >> So, thank you for that. >> Sure. >> Mr. Jackie, >> do we have a uh do the teachers contract limit the number of students in the class? >> We don't have that. >> No. >> Okay. How about the uh the size of the classroom? If we're putting 25 sixth graders in a classroom, are we pushing the capacity? What are we at?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 73
>> Yeah, I would say it's probably at capacity. You you guys have had um many of you the opportunity to tour our schools. Um, you know, some of the older schools are actually unique in the sense that when they were built, uh, 50 plus years ago, they didn't have class size limits for reimbursement. Like square footage, uh, wasn't really a factor. So, it's weird. We have some buildings that class sizes are a lot larger and others where the rooms are really pretty tight. Uh, I think it's been our experience as we um look at these new buildings with the um space allocations that they're they're well aortioned, but the uh I mean 25 would make it tighter. I you know, every student you add makes it a little bit cozier. Um and you know, 25 wouldn't be our target. >> Thank you. >> Any other questions?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 74
Miss >> com I guess. Um Mike, >> I just want to thank you too, Dr. Solen, for the incredible time and effort that went into this um report. Um I like Dr. Herrian, I need more time to study it and actually to drive around, I think, and really get a feel for um what this looks like. I'm looking over Merlene's shoulder at the at the map with the the actual street names. So, it is going to take a little time, but again, thank you for this. Sure. I mean, I I know how important this is to our families, how important it is to not just the families that are impacted with redistricting, but every family in our community is impacted by this. So, um, you know, we it's something we do need to put a lot of time into. We have >> Oh, sorry. >> New person want to ask questions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 75
Um, again, thank you to Marlene, Emily, um, Jeeoff, this is great. Um I'm just brought like curious when I look at all the scenarios like prior to B2 all the scenarios Highland is like curiously at lower utilization than like any of the other schools and I'm wondering why that was. I mean it's a bit corrected in B2 but it's still you know I'm just curious as to why that was. >> Mike I I think that's uh that's a mic question. >> Yeah, happy to address that one. So, um, one of the goals was to be able to lower the utilization overall. I believe in Highland, we're including in the capacity all the portable classrooms. Even though in the future, they may not be used as instructional rooms. They're still counted as full-size classrooms available. Um, those include the older legacy ones that would likely be used for storage or some other district need.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 76
Um, and the newer ones that have installed what the last two years, the last two years as well. So, um, part of the idea is to be able to bring that down to a more manageable section size, right? So, you're not really utilizing all of this large space, but you're really looking at having it operate more cohesively with more kind of planned sections and you're able to get back to having some of the spaces that the other schools can have. So, as you grow enrollment in a building, you start taking away little nice to haves in the building um because it's over capacity. Um it's the idea is to be able to return it to that but also have some flexibility knowing that it's centrally located. Um so should you get some growth, you have some future growth space there to be able to utilize that as well.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-05 Naugatuck Valley Planning Region, CT YouTube / CPS Video transcript source: youtube Board of Education 12-4-25 · passage 77
Um, and it was also kind of the function of the push and pull to a little bit in redistricting where we know we needed to fill out Norton a little bit more to get it up to the design capacity um, for that design enrollment as well as being able to push some students over into um, Barnum as well just because that was kind of the natural area for Highland for so many years is where that Barnum school is now. Um, so it's a kind of a numerous factors um, were at play as part of So if you took away the portables, that utilization would be higher >> because those are four classrooms that are calculated into the number. >> Yeah. If you were to do four * 20 um so that would be 80. You would basically that's 80 additional students that you could back out or 80 seats you could back out of the equation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above