>> Awesome. Thank you, Mr. Diaz. And again, members, thank you for um thank you for allowing me the opportunity. Um, with that, I'd like to motion to approve the resignations as presented by um for the Filipino teachers. Is there a second? >> Sly second. >> All right, I have a second. up. >> Motion carries. Thank you all so much. Number two is discussion and possible approval of the school facilities division 5 project grant awards. Mr. Diaz, are you presenting or was it Mr. Rolloff? >> President Bundier, members of the board, um we're proud to announce um five additional um um SFD projects. Um they constitute a transformer uh to move a transformer um for Babokuri Middle High School. Um and um some repairs at the Indian Primary Elementary School. Uh relocate reelect electric transformers for Indian Intermediate Elementary School. Uh replace windows in Indian Intermediate Elementary School and remove some electrical pan panels in Indian Intermediate Elementary School.
So, and golfers who will be joining us in January as well. So, lots and lots of uh athletic uh and uh other skills prowess that we want to celebrate. So, we'll be looking forward to that. >> Absolutely. Appreciate that. Um 9.1 public comment. Do we have >> Okay. >> On behalf of the board of education, I would like to thank the public for attending tonight's meeting. We value the feedback we receive from our members of the public and encourage everyone to take an active interest in their public school system. Individuals interested in speaking to the board this evening are asked to have completed a comment card and presented it to the secretary to the board. And any members of the public who have not yet turned in their public comment card uh to the secretary of the board are asked to do so at this time.
>> Okay. And then it so of those employees that are leaving or just the staff in general, I'm curious if we said, "Hey, if we offered you yoga classes, would you would this be more likely?" It kind of reminds me of the office pizza party like, >> "Yeah, >> thanks, but we'd rather see the money." So that's why I'm >> That's a great question. So then what is I'm just going to use the word because I've used this word a long time for that type of that type of activity. What's dangerous about that is is that you ask employees for things that you can't provide. And that honestly in in almost every scenario I've seen where you put money on a survey, money is the number one thing and then people expect a raise because why would you ask me about this if you can't give it to me?
Um we're still Mr. Kylie already mentioned we're still waiting for our acceptance into the MSBA. Um well, not acceptance. I'm sorry. We have acceptance. We're waiting to hear about our next steps. And I'm imagining that's going to happen shortly. I think in their timeline it said December, January. On the HR front, we're still ongoing hiring. Again, I'll just mention Mrs. Gentner because she'll be mad at me for doing it, but she just does such a tremendous job just keeping the wheels turning. When we do have folks that are ready to join our team, it's, you know, right away she's responsive and she gets folks in there and we get them into our schools where we need them right away. And so I'm really grateful and I have had folks across the district who are doing the hiring at the building level who are always uh praising uh Mrs.
I think >> it might be helpful to put that further down because there's a there's a part where there's an entire section devoted to this to per pupils. But so maybe that comparison could go there. >> Well, my only thought is I'd also want the the dart comparison in terms of you know, the enrollment and also the employees like we had with Karen during her presentation last year where she put, you know, what the administrative profile looks like at these comparablesized districts. So I guess I wanted it as more than just the one thing unless there's just a different page that is just looking at Dart and our neighbors, >> right? Dart is hard because you can >> Let me just skip down a little bit. So there's a financial overview for Greenfield. Just skip here. So there is the ben there's a benchmark data section that covers things like enrollment.
Seventh grade and math and language arts did very very well um within that. 8th grade performed above the state average. Um that's the first time in the last couple years that that has happened also. So, uh one thing that I've that I've done is sent to all staff members uh that gave the fall interim. I went through and we color coded it. If there if we're above 80% it was green. If it was um 70 to 79 it was yellow. If it was 60 to 69 it was orange. And then if it was below 50 59 it was red. Now obviously some of those skills on the fall interval we have not taught at this point. Um and that's just natural with that. So, and a quick reminder with the the results report you're doing, a 30,000 foot review of how things are. They are diving in in their buildings to individual students who are not doing quite as well.
Um the recommendation in order for BD to stay in out of compliance and continue to receive the additional funding from SFD, the BSD grant office is recommending the governing board to approve the five projects for grant awards.
When the secretary calls your name, I ask that you come to the microphone, state your name for the public record, and provide your feedback. Please note that comments are limited to five minutes per person. The board does not participate in discussion during public comment. Comments should address the board of education as a whole and not be directed to an individual board member, audience, or staff member. Followup on your questions or concerns may be addressed by administration through the contact information provided on the comment card. Thank you, >> Mike Litman. Welcome Hello blue. Blue. >> Yay. Thank you. >> First of all, happy holidays everybody. >> Happy holidays. >> Today is an important day. My name is Mike Litman. I'm from Lincoln Prairie, the 55 and older community on Eola and Route 30. Today's an important day both for the school district and the taxpayers. Today is a day that this school board puts into motion a plan to commit hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars with your long range facility.
So we we have like with the district health coach what she typically does is puts out a variety of things to say what would you be most interested in and then we work towards those. So we have things like hydration challenges, movement challenges, we have a book club over the summer, we have the yoga classes over the summer. You know those are things that we do study because we can and are able to offer those to the staff pretty much immediately. The danger in my mind to that is that studies show when you offer the staff something and then can't deliver on it, they're more frustrated than when you started. So if you say what if we were able to launch this big initiative and you can't see that through, that would be more detrimental to morale and to us as a district than I think we'd be prepared for.
Gentner and how responsive she is to making sure that they get the folks they need in their schools as soon as possible. So but we remain committed to finding the right right candidates. So, under our third priority, safe and supportive schools, um, vape detectors have been installed in all of the student bathrooms now here at Dartmouth High School. Uh, that's again part of an ongoing safety effort. We're identifying the high school team is working together to develop clear response protocols for what we do when we see inevitably we're we're going to see that there's going to be not an uptick in vape use, an uptick in recognizing the challenge that we have here at the high school, much like any high school. Uh so not unique to Dartmouth, but we are uh we are committed to an approach that balances the uh infor the health risks associated with BA vaping and still reinforcing that we aren't going to tolerate vaping in our schools because we're not it's just most you know years ago it was smoking, right?
Um and I think this might be it also covers things like class size per pupil spending things like that where dark comparison might be helpful. So maybe we'll do this >> like I do think we need to have our uh have an administrative comparison with Dart because that is an area that the community is always interested in. >> Okay. also an under teachers teacher mobility. You know, we used to have teachers who stayed here 30 years and now I I you know, the fact that we're up to 50% of them being new. I mean, the pandemic brought that about. >> So, is that something you would like to see in a staffing history? >> I would like to see Yes, >> it would be interesting to see if >> Okay, >> we can find another district that's experiencing the same. I'm sure we can. Do you want to word that, Member?
They're looking and evaluating individual students and that's very important for you all. They're having discussions with teaching teams, have discussions with all all staff. Building administrations leading those discussions and they're making sure that they're diving into the kids that have some challenges. to the question that I had why are we assessing kids on curriculum that we have not talked about >> that's just the way the state is set up >> we have no control so these inter test these are sum of tests are intended like the standards that you should be teaching you know what you're like be assessor so the states develop what they call interim test which covers all the standards but they want you to take that data and use it to form instruction because then you can take we We have a fall interim and then we have a winter interum and so you can kind of track the growth and like okay on this standard we we've made some gains or like or teachers were like yeah I I mean like last year when we gave for the first time my teachers like we we had fractions on that and we had like yeah we didn't know we got >> and and some of it doesn't even make sense why it's on the fall term as well >> but those numbers don't show up and it So it >> those are tools.
>> Any questions to item? If not, a motion to approve the school facilities division project grant awards. Is there a second? Second by Miss Kathleen >> Vance >> Mo. >> Thank you. Number three is discussion and possible approval of the school facilities board IFB 230824 edge construction change order one. Mr. Diaz. >> Uh President Modia and members of the board. Similarly, um we have a change of order to um um one of the companies so we can uh paint and expose drain pipes and sealing 88 pipe um pen um penetrations in the building um at also at the intermediate campus. This will be part of the weatherization of the Indian Oasis Intermediate School. So we we asking to approve the change order one in the amount of 34,570 to age construction for the weatherization of that school.
I spoke at a prior board meeting about the burden this will place on retired people who are on fixed incomes. There's an obvious benefit in this project for students and their families. but none whatsoever for seniors like us who are legally forbidden from sending kids to the schools. That applies to several senior communities in this district, not just Lincoln Prairie. Being on fixed incomes, we don't have the opportunity to increase our earnings to help pay for higher taxes as we would if we were still employed. Of course, it's not only seniors who should be concerned. What about the family of four that lives in your district, has kids in your classrooms, and is struggling with increasing food costs, rising electricity bills, skyrocketing insurance premiums, and an uncertain job market? How much of a tax increase can they afford? And will it be for things that the district needs for things that the district wants?
>> Is is that enough to make them stay though? I I mean like sure if if someone offered me more, I'd say absolutely yeah, I'd love to have that. But is that going to make them stay? >> It's a great question. It's something that we would work to find out. You know, I think right now, like I said, statistically when we look at our exit interview data, the biggest driver is salary. So, in my mind, >> unless we address at least part of that and make an effort for that, then we're not going to be able to find out. you know, we we can have conversations and I have certainly talked to employees that are leaving that say, "I love this about my building, but I love that about my building, but I love the commute. I love the community. I love the kids." Like all those things come up, but you're right, at the end of the day, everybody makes a economic decision based on their needs and wants.
and we didn't we didn't um tolerate that then and we're not going to tolerate vaping now mostly because it's not good for you and [laughter] those are the things that we're looking to do is to educate our students. Um, we also had our first training session regarding some of the newer safety protocols that we're putting into place. And I thank Kim Redlon, the entire crisis team for putting together some really high uh level uh professional development for really what is a team across the district. There are represented representatives from every school and in turn they go through some I would say extensive training. It's with Homeland Security. We also had members of Dartmouth PD there. Again, bringing the community together for this kind of professional learning so that we all have an understanding of what the expectations are, what protocols are, what safety measures the schools are taking, and that the Dartmouth profession, the Dartmouth Police Department is right there in working closely with us.
Good. Um I think back where you had staff would be um professional status which would mean that they've been working five years. So you could pull up how many professional status teachers we have um compared to not and I think that number explains our need for professional development funds. >> Okay. >> And I think should be funding that. >> Okay. So maybe professional status could be part of the graphic representations and staffing. I'm not sure. I mean, I'm not devoted to a whole staffing history section, but I I like the um suggestions that have been made about uh understanding our uh percentage of different types of staff and things like that. opinions. Maybe this should just be stuffing and not history. >> I don't know. I like the history as well. >> You like history also. Okay. >> We're facing staffing challenges that we've never had before.
It's just a good indicator. Are we on the right track for that? >> That helps our teachers a lot in my building like look at those results and kind of like okay like here's what we need to be doing. Here's where we need some work. So they are spending a lot of time in that data. >> That one is the 2024 where fifth grade was below but then on the 25 then sixth grade >> is up. No, that's those are all 242. That's all last year's data. So if you go to the >> So 25 that was >> that was that is this year's sixth graders currently, >> right? That's what I'm saying. >> Yes. And they're >> Go ahead. >> Yeah. >> So if you look at the fall interim data right now on our sixth graders, they're performing eight percentage points above the state average.
>> Any questions to the item? >> Motion to approve. >> Motion by Miss Sylvia Hendricks, second by Miss Vance. >> Motion carries. Number four is discussion and possible approval. the school facility sport IFB 230824 edge construction change order number two >> Mr. Uh, President Modia, um, also part of the renovations, um, this the last one, it will be for a change of order for a total of $242,496, uh, for the removal of existing existing windows, installation of new windows, uh, new, um, uh, HM stops, uh, repainting and work for the approved designed documentation. So we asking our governing board to move and approve the change order number two for the amount mentioned above to age uh construction for the weatherization of Indian Oasis Intermediate School under IFB23 um-08-24 and authorize the superintendent or designate to execute the necessary documents. >> Mr. Diaz, can you state what the amount is?
For your paid consultants, none of this matters. you actually we the taxpayers are paying them to tell you how to spend our taxpayer dollars. They benefit financially when you agree to spend our money. They certainly are making a lot of money to provide the recommendations. The larger the project, the more project phases are included, the more schools that are affected, the more money they make. We're talking about tens of millions of dollars just for their services. tens of millions of dollars. That's a heck of a lot of money. Think for a moment about their motivation. Whose interests are they serving? Whose interests are they not serving? If you vote tonight to move forward towards spending hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars, look at the current bond repayment schedule. Time your expenses to kick in when the current bond schedule lightens in future years, as shown at the last board meeting.