Um we talked about this at the beginning of the year. We had a training and uh that is a critical role. Um you know you don't always win when you vote. Uh but the agreement of a functional governing board is win or lose once you walk out the door you you got to support it. And I mean I've seen the same thing in committees that I've been on in various school districts is you know you speak your peace and if you lose then when you walk out the door you got to support the decision that was made by the by the whole group. So um that's just something that I think we should keep in mind. Uh for me that improvement on that would improve my score next year. >> Miss Schultz. [clears throat] >> Um yes, thank you President Wade. So I rated as a 175 and um as Mr.
But if it's your sense that u no Adrian you're crazy it it is actually gonna we're going to need to do more of this then I would say let's say that for a study session but I suspect that this work that we've done may make it a lot easier to just receive updates in uh monthly in in our in our meetings. Board member Benovites, last thoughts. I >> think for me, I would like to see um I don't I don't see a the need for a study session because we've done so much work here already, but maybe an update every other month and just kind of see if we have to pivot kind of what board member Ramos has stated. That's what I would like to see. Um, I I'm going to um agree with us having um an update every month. And if there's an update, great.
Glover said um number five was a zero or a negative zero for me. Supports board's decision once action is taken. um that is important and essential to a governing board. Uh there's things that I don't like sometimes. I mean, I've been on the board for 5 years now. And so my questions have already been answered a lot of times or I can figure it out on myself or I do ask questions ahead of time as Mr. Glover said because as Miss German said, I want the meetings to be efficient and run effectively. So we are the longest running board meeting I think in the state, maybe the country, I don't know. Um, but our meetings do need to be run more efficiently and effective and asking questions ahead of time. I often don't need to ask the same question over and over again because they're things we already understood.
And if there's not, then um there's not. But I would also like to add that around the times that our properties are going to be sold that we should have a study session, right? Giving um giving the cabinet the chance to say, "Hey board, you know what? for the next month or two like you guys need a study session. We have a lot of information. So I would leave it at the discrete of the cabinet. Um but would require for the board to to have an update every month. What do you guys think? >> Okay. Great. Okay. I think we rolled up our sleeves. We put on the bandanas and our little sweat, you know, wristbands. I I think we we tackled a very um important very important um agenda item that our the future of this district will will be speaking about for for a while other than the school closures.
So, having a Groundhog's Day conversation would just be a waste of time for me. There are things that we ask ahead of time or that I want to reiterate or make sure the public knows. And I think that I do I do that. But speaking over as an overall board since that's what we're talking about is um a 175 for this. [clears throat] Um I have probably in that same range of the 1.75 to a two. I just rounded up to a two cuz I didn't want to do the maths on that. Um I agree. I think the fact that we have um board members who speak out in varying public outings about things that are counter to what we as a board have passed. I recognize that that is a frustration um in that if you are on the side of voting or you have a policy that you don't necessarily agree with and yet that's the policy that we have in place.
And I I I want to thank my colleagues here today and Miss um Rodriguez Pena, our board member, who gracefully typed something up and gave her input as well because we are you know, up here on the DAS, it it's definitely democracy, but it's important that we also voice, right, what we feel and what we see in our schools and what one of the things that our board member G said, hey, I would love to hear from I would love to hear from teachers. So, I think that's a call to invite for our our our staff to come and speak to us. What do you think? We would love to know. come to our board meetings, let us know what your thoughts are. Today we had a group of people come in today, right? We had a a group of speakers. They came and spoke and so I I really appreciate that.
Um that is part of our job and that's part of the requirements of being on here. Um, [cough and clears throat] we as board members sit up here every board meeting and we work hard to hold staff and students accountable to our policies. Um, and I believe that that starts with us and I believe that we also should be equally beholden to our policies. And I feel that [clears throat] we have gone over in the three years that I've been on here our communication protocol which is item seven for me >> [snorts] >> um multiple times and yet we still uh do not adhere to it and I struggle to sit up here as a governing body saying that we have expectations of staff and students to follow and be accountable to our policies and yet we are not held accountable to our policies. Um, and there is great frustration in that.
Um and our we have a teacher here that's that always stays late with us. So, thank you for that. Thank you. Any more um comments, requests from the board? I see you guys packing up. So, um I am going to move this to to item the last item which oh 4.1 adjour. Oh, I'm so sorry. One more thing. Yes. Board member Benitas. >> I was just going to I wanted to request that the superintendent can you just kind of include it in our board packet the next? Yeah. What happened tonight? Which projects are moving forward? Thank you for >> Thank you for that. I really appreciate that. Now we moving forward 4.1. And can I please get a motion to move 4.1? >> A motion to move 4.1. >> We have first motion by board member Rodri Ramos. >> Second. [laughter] >> We have a second by board member Greer.
I also have a frustration with the expression [clears throat] that just because uh we aren't asking questions, it means that we don't do the labor or the work to be here. That's just disingenuine um and is a poor representation given that when we show up it is apparent that at least the board members know the issues that they are talking about. Um, I don't have many questions on a fair amount of things in that I worked in public schools. I have a master's degree in secondary education. And so, a lot of this information is all things that I'm greatly familiar with. And I do ask questions when we're here in the meetings. And I have asked questions when they arise or have specific issues for my person. I just don't have them all the time. And that doesn't mean that I am any less prepared to be here.
Any more discussion? >> No. With that being said, um would you guys like to vote by hand or vote by >> Okay. >> And we have board member Greer and I I we have four yes and one absent. And it is 9:27 and our school board meeting for today has been closed. Have a great night, guys. We'll see you next time.
I also wish to bring up communication protocols again because it is my interest and intent to uh hold ourselves accountable and the next thing that I'm going to discuss not only impacts my rating for this standard but honestly it's in a few standards in terms of how it is uh multiple things kind of overlap essentially is what it is and so I'm choosing this one um and my issue is that we have a situation in which we have staff [snorts] members who are human persons and we have a staff member that made a post on their personal social media page and on their personal social media page they discussed that their political ideology which in this case happens to be conservative but it's irrelevant to the overall argument and with that they also talked about the funding situation in the state of Arizona which honestly I think they did a pretty decent job of explaining kind of the inequities that exist and that are that are available.
But then they also went and made comments on behavior of a specific board member. To be clear, that board member is not mentioned. It's not named or any of those things. This staff member emailed me and the reason they emailed me is because they feel that a board member went beyond what communication protocols that we have in place. And I do think it matters. And so when you have a situation as a board member in which we are being criticized by the public, we are political figures. That criticism is going to come quite frequently. I get emails on the regular that tell me how ridiculous it is that I choose to have my hair in different colors. It is not my responsibility, nor is it my uh position as a board member to comment on every time I receive criticism. Now, in this specific case, this was a personal post on a social media in which every single one of our staff members, just as every single one of our board members, have rights and protections for us to exist and behave in the way that we are.
And then we had a response and board member Van Hook, it is you that I am expressing in which you used your HUSD email to email this staff member and their wife because their wife shared it as well who also happens to be a staff member and I'm specifically not using their names because their names are irrelevant to this. and you emailed them to respond to the criticism that they had about your person on their social media page and you included their administration. I struggle with this. Not only is that beyond our communication protocol, I find it to be an abuse of your position. I find it to be dangerous and as a board I find you put us in risk of liability. And I think it is unacceptable that if you have a situation in which you feel a staff member has done something that is against our staff policies, again, our first approach every single time should be to contact the superintendent.
And the idea that we would take our own personal HUSD issued email to send an email out to their work email and include their bosses feels it feels vaguely threatening. It feels again as an abuse of your position and what our roles are. So I think it's important and that maybe us collectively because all of us have talked about knowing what our roles are and what our responsibilities are that going into this next year we set up training for us as a board to reiterate why our communication protocols are the way that they are so we don't open ourselves up to problems. We also have many complaints in which we have had board members that have gone out in the public like LD14 for example to talk about our override. We also have had an individual at a public comment express that board member Van Hook you have given presentations to them at Trilogy.
Whether or not that is accurate from that person, I'm not really here to to to express one way or the other. My concern is that we have behaviors that are putting us at risk. And my question is what are we doing to make sure that we adhere to these protocols and and a large part of some of these and again it's other standards in in in different areas but for standard 4 insurance decisions are impersonal objective and professional. I struggle to see how that action and that use is within our standards. And so for me, I don't think that we are being effective as a board. And I don't think it is easy for us to sit here and expect accountability if we cannot hold ourselves accountable to our own policies. And the benefit for staff and students is there are policies in place and repercussions, but there is none of that for us.
And I I just think as a as a board, we should absolutely have training. So we are ensuring that we as individual board members are not creating a situation in which we are opening our district and ourselves up to liability for things that we should never have done in the first place. And because you called me by name, I will respond to that. Um, I am very well aware of my role and like I said, I do trainings constantly, but the messaging that was used was so inappropriate that I am also a community member [snorts] and I have every right to address it. And so I know what my role is and what our policies are and I don't do anything that would put the district at any risk. So saying that and assuming that you're absolutely incorrect because I'm also involved in the community.
Yes, I'm also APC and I am allowed to have conversations outside of my board member role. [clears throat] So, your accusations and your assumptions are absolutely incorrect. >> Ma'am, it's not an assumption. >> You're going to call me. We're here to discuss overall, but if we're going to get personal, I can get personal, too. So, would you like to go personal or do we want to reflect overall ratings? [snorts] I I I think both are available here when again, ma'am, if our expression is that I am a private citizen and using your HUSD email to email their HUSD email about a social media post, how is that you acting as a private citizen? That's That's not And I'm not saying that. >> Okay. But you went beyond that with your accusations. >> Okay. So then let's make it that's the only accusation I'm leveling here today because it's the one I have proof of.
>> Yeah. And and it was warranted. Where I'm struggling is that in this moment, your statement seems to not recognize the inappropriateness of that behavior to begin with. I'm not saying that you weren't upset. I'm not saying that you weren't hurt or frustrated or desiring to correct that issue. For example, when we talked about the dress code, I had somebody on a social media post express that I was a pedophile. That's alarming. I did nothing to that person because at the end of the day, it is a social media world in which that is not what I can control and how people feel. I'm not saying that you weren't frustrated or upset by that. You could have contacted that individual via their social media. And if you are not friends with them, then it makes it even more so a question of your choice in responding to something that was done separate of in a boardroom to use your board certified email that is provided to you from the district to respond to criticism.
And you can't see why that is not only outside of our communication protocols, deeply unprofessional and an abuse of your position, >> but also unprofessional on behalf of a teacher >> to use their first amendment right to say that they have an issue with the board member that they did not name >> to be unprofessional is what I said. They can absolutely use their first amendment right, but what they did was also unprofessional. And you want to talk about unprofessional. Let's let's discuss your behavior on the dis. >> Sure. >> With your facial expressions, your body body expressions that you can't seem to control. >> Yes. >> And and behave appropriately and professionally on that dis. And that has been a problem since day one. And we have people tell you that that's a problem. I I >> why can't you act professionally and be able to agree to disagree?
Instead, you if if I didn't say anything, there would be no conversation on this dis. But instead, you take the opportunity to lecture and pretend that, oh, I'm a teacher, so I'm going to lecture you. You don't agree with me, that's fine, but I'm not here to be lectured by you. If I'm if I have a concern, I have every right as a board member to have a concern because I've done my homework. You show up with no notes in front of you ever. >> That is correct. >> Yeah. And that should concern that should be concerning for everybody. [clears throat] >> So again, a choice of preference. >> Yeah. A choice. This isn't >> Yes, ma'am. I I would like to reiterate again. I have ADHD and I am autistic. I genuinely process very diff difficultly just straight audio information. So when somebody is just talking for extended lengths of time, it is difficult for my person.