2025-12-11 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting (December 10th, 2025) · passage 92
I'm going to support all of them if we go that approach. But I do think it's fair to say to the community, it's your community. um and it's your values and this is one opportunity that that the people who um participate in the process do get to say what's important to them um and sometimes we all as elected and appointed leaders have to hear that um and adapt to that. So right now I'm I'm you know certainly between options one and two personally um but I think there's some things that we really have to think about number two in terms of the choices we're giving our community members to to voice their opinion. Yeah. Could I could I ask just a clarifying question? What makes you think option three is complicated? Because it's literally you're now talking like one override question for 2.75 million. >> Well, I think if if if all you're putting before the community is is that >> Yeah, >> that's fine.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee December 10, 2025 · passage 92
I would just ask everybody to think for a minute if to find out all of the city information. Just yourselves to think do do you actually watch city councils to see what is happening you know citywide. My guess would be although you you may and um you may but many people do not and so it gives an opportunity because it's televised and widely watched for people to know what's happening. Um, additionally, as I said, it is in the code that so there's part of me that likes to follow the ordinances and code that we have. So, until that's changed, I but I don't doesn't matter to me which whether it's in person or via Zoom. We have hybrid meetings for all meetings now, which is a wonderful thing so that people can participate remotely, which works for so many people. So, >> I'd just like to clarify that this the city council does have the authority to create a code for themselves about what's on their agenda.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - December 10, 2025 · passage 92
But the city council cannot put into their code a requirement that this school committee or the superintendent attend their meeting any more than we could vote to require the city council president come to our meeting because there certainly are people who watch school committee meetings and don't watch city council meetings who might benefit from having an update on what happen is happening at city council. So, I just don't I think I feel like right there you can kind of see the um the confusing um power dynamics I guess at play or the the conf confusion of our co-equal roles as different uh branches of the Greenfield City uh government with our own kind of authority and um responsibilities. Um so I just feel like it has there has been something about it that has been confusing. I feel like the optics create a a scenario where it looks like the city council plays some role of oversight in the day-to-day operations of the Greenfield public schools.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Madera County, CA YouTube / BLSD LIVE transcript source: youtube BASS LAKE JOINT UNION ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEETI… · passage 92
Um, so we've done that to kind of make things a little bit more like time efficient. >> Yeah. >> Um, and then the next slide is suspension rate percentages. [clears throat] It's pretty obvious why we're in differentiated assistance for that, right? I think enforcement of our district suspension is why ours are higher. So I mean I mean you're making >> I mean some people would be like that's good like you're holding kids accountable which some cases it's very appropriate for the suspension to be the holding the kid accountable right. Um however there is a lot of research and we are doing a lot of work on is that suspension actually changing the behavior right and if it's not some kids it's like they get suspended once and they're like not doing that again and other kids not so much right and so the other kids not so much might be for a whole multitude of reasons why and that's where the professionals look at that and they go okay maybe we need to do something different.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube December 10, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 92
uh Google knows so it keeps sending me those u all those bad news that comes along with it. And uh and the the worry that I have currently as of today is uh the an article that I that I uh read about uh some of our some of the not some many of the H-1B uh visa holders they've traveled back to their home country because they have to do that to um get their visas revalidated. uh they have had appointments. So many of them took advantage of the holidays and took their families including children. Um they have they had appointments to get those visas revalidated. Um but those all those appointments got cancelled and they've all been rescheduled to next year in May um because the government wants to uh review their social media uh you know pages and so on. uh you that's not in our jurisdiction but the reason I'm saying is uh those students are not coming back uh there there's no way for them to come back so that's going to you know first of all first and foremost going to put pressure on them because they're going to lose those uh learning opportunities and affect our bottom line because it affects our ADA uh it's a completely lose-lose situation I don't know why um there's no not much advocacy I don't see any any of our local state federal representatives speak out more about this um this thing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting (December 10th, 2025) · passage 93
It's the fact that if you're moving something to the excluded data, I'm assuming there's a vote that would have to be like any other exclusion. you just do it >> there because it was part part of the the >> and [clears throat] then I'll retract that concern. Yeah, I mean I'm still concerned about the fact that I think we have the long-term impact of reducing our operational budget and that that concerns me. >> I do realize that's a 20 to 45 concern. Yeah, >> you know, I think if there's going to be an even if we don't need a vote, but there's going to be an explanation about it, >> then that's kind of confuses the matter a little bit. It really does. I mean, I >> I think you try to keep things as simple as possible. You talk about inflation and and that's something everybody understands what's gone on with inflation, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee December 10, 2025 · passage 93
And what they have put on their agenda is a standing item where the school committee may, if we choose, go and take advantage of that platform. But the city council cannot put into their code a requirement that this school committee or the superintendent attend their meeting any more than we could vote to require the city council president come to our meeting because there certainly are people who watch school committee meetings and don't watch city council meetings who might benefit from having an update on what happen is happening at city council. So, I just don't I think I feel like right there you can kind of see the um the confusing um power dynamics I guess at play or the the conf confusion of our co-equal roles as different uh branches of the Greenfield City uh government with our own kind of authority and um responsibilities.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - December 10, 2025 · passage 93
And I just think that's confusing since that's really our role as a school committee when when they have the opportunity to just ask whatever question in whatever tone they wish on any topic they wish. Um, I think that that creates a a picture of authority that uh is actually not um in the charter or or in any code. Any other discussion? member Goodwin, >> I love that rebel side of you and but I guess the part of me is sitting here and I've been listening to the desire to work better with the city council and people from both the city council and the school committee to work together. So I'm just maybe that's the first topic of those people working together to address the the whole issue um and coming up with an understanding that that's not going to happen. I mean, maybe that is the the mission of those first meetings because I'm with you and so I'm listening to you and I'm going go Glenn and then I'm hearing people want to work like as together as one big committee and I'm going okay so which is it like so are we two separate committees because that's I mean who we are or are we trying to form one that works together and I think that's so and I sitting here Glenn want to say to you I remember the first time you gave a speech and got on school committee with Adrien Nunees and I negotiated with you for um with unions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Madera County, CA YouTube / BLSD LIVE transcript source: youtube BASS LAKE JOINT UNION ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEETI… · passage 93
Maybe we need to do um some [clears throat] sort of different like restorative practices, right? Um and and teach kids social braces and appropriateness and do some um you know, like if if I wronged Tara, like we had a conflict, like get get those get them in and do some sort of like conflict resolution between us and so maybe like that doesn't happen again. Um so we're looking into a lot of those practices and um that has been happening a lot more this year than in years past and it's my understanding principles if they want to speak to it they can. It seems to be going really well and working in more cases than not. So I don't know how you guys feel about that but >> it's been a mixed bag. It's still learning. No doubt. I've had it be seeming successful and otherwise.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube December 10, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 93
I don't know why there's hesitancy to defend um uh you know people on work visas here. I you know it's one one avenue of coming to the United States. United States is supposed to be welcoming to immigrants. Uh you know we always hear that but that's one avenue for some reason no one wants to come out and defend saying that you know this is a opportunity. only thing we hear is uh that program is is fraudulent. There's a lot of fraud and abuse happening and and I don't know what kind of fraud is happening there. No one is no one has made a you know clear statement about what is what fraud do they see in that system. Uh but the point of it is the the the reason it's important to to our district is because you know we are in the heart of Silicon Valley where there's a lot of uh work visa holders that come through here and you know they have they have their children coming here and attending our school and it's going to put pressure on uh on us with all those changes and I you know I just hope um you know common sense prevails so it doesn't look like from whatever we seeing uh but uh but you know it's it's a challenge So I just wanted to highlight those things and I don't want to I didn't mean to add bad news to already bad news that we heard but these are the challenges we we are uh we are seeing but with all that said you know I wish the community very happy holiday season and merry Christmas and happy holidays to uh everybody and to all of you also.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting (December 10th, 2025) · passage 94
and and why 2 and a half%, you know, was never intended to be enough to run a a community year after year after year without overrides. So, um I I do think you need to keep it simple, even if you don't need to have a vote. And and I'm not sure that it buys you enough to to to complicate things. >> Um you know, it's either 33 or $39, I think, um on that >> in the first year. >> Yeah. So, so that that's just my feeling in terms of um you know whether we do a menu or we do it, you know, we are a community and there are people in our community and they're at all different places. Um and we can certainly make an argument for how expensive it is for a family to live in this community if they have kids in school and they're paying for the bus and they're paying the the fees for the um sports and they have more trash than I have in my house.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee December 10, 2025 · passage 94
Um so I just feel like it has there has been something about it that has been confusing. I feel like the optics create a a scenario where it looks like the city council plays some role of oversight in the day-to-day operations of the Greenfield public schools. And I just think that's confusing since that's really our role as a school committee when when they have the opportunity to just ask whatever question in whatever tone they wish on any topic they wish. Um, I think that that creates a a picture of authority that uh is actually not um in the charter or or in any code. Any other discussion? member Goodwin, >> I love that rebel side of you and but I guess the part of me is sitting here and I've been listening to the desire to work better with the city council and people from both the city council and the school committee to work together.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - December 10, 2025 · passage 94
We went through the pandemic together. you gave me Netflix recommendations which were excellent and I've always enjoyed your humor and so I appreciate everything you have brought to this table and I want you to know that um even though you know we've had differences but I have watched you. I've watched the the madness of school committee that you went through um and all of the drama that you went through. I was there um and watched all of that play out and so I hope in the future that that drama is not and there's probably a Netflix just for that. Um but so this is like a okay so I've got Rebel Glenn which totally yes go Glenn and then I've got people saying they want like so I'm sort of like which do I listen to? I mean, and I bet you have a video game for this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Madera County, CA YouTube / BLSD LIVE transcript source: youtube BASS LAKE JOINT UNION ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEETI… · passage 94
>> I got to come up with a plan for summer tomorrow. Actually, >> that's a consideration that I have. >> Yeah. I mean, you think about it, it makes sense, right? Because not every child's going to respond the same way to a strategy just like in the classroom. So, it's going to be dependent. Some kids love to be suspended because they get to stay home. And so, you know, for some kids, they're not looking to to be restored. Yeah. So, they're looking to cause trouble. So, I I you know, I think it's good that we're looking into this, right? Because all you also sometimes we're rewarding kids by sending them home. That's what they want. So, I think it's on a case- by case basis. And, you know, kudos to you guys for having to do so many different things with so many different kids because it's not easy.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube December 10, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 94
>> Thank you so much. Any other comments? Um, I would like to just say thank you to my board members. I really enjoyed last week. Not only did I learn like four days worth of content um, and drank it like crazy. I just a sponge. Um, but I got to know you all better and that made me more excited to be here. Um, I'll also say that it feels like every district in the state is going through what we went through last year. looking at consolidations, figuring out how to do it and it and how some and them talking about how they have gone through it. And it actually really validated um the processes that you all actually chose um to to use for our district and I'm really proud of that. It was really hard and I was in one small piece, you know, the recommendation and the the committee part, but I know there was so much work that went before that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Triboard Meeting (December 10th, 2025) · passage 95
So um and then you know we have people who are on fixed incomes and who um aren't getting any raise every single year or getting very a minimal one. Um you know we we're this country was built on you know taking care of each other. Um so I I do think that that is the more responsible way and and certainly in keeping with with my values. Um, you know, so I just think we we would need to to do it as a one I one vote for the entire amount. Um, >> even even knowing kind of the odds. >> Yeah. You know, sometimes, you know, Mike, you've seen me now. Sometimes I do things because I think it's the right thing to do um no matter what. So, you know, that's just what what I I think. Um, >> okay. that sometimes you got to do it because it's right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee December 10, 2025 · passage 95
So I'm just maybe that's the first topic of those people working together to address the the whole issue um and coming up with an understanding that that's not going to happen. I mean, maybe that is the the mission of those first meetings because I'm with you and so I'm listening to you and I'm going go Glenn and then I'm hearing people want to work like as together as one big committee and I'm going okay so which is it like so are we two separate committees because that's I mean who we are or are Are we trying to form one that works together? And I think that's so and I sitting here Glenn want to say to you, I remember the first time you gave a speech and got on school committee with Adrien Nunees and I negotiated with you for um with unions. We went through the pandemic together.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Franklin County, MA YouTube / Greenfield Community Television (GCTV) transcript source: youtube Greenfield School Committee Meeting - December 10, 2025 · passage 95
So, I I guess collaboration or rebellion, which would you recommend? This is your last chance to like give a strong recommendation. >> I'm really not proposing rebellion at all. I think what I'm what I'm saying is in a good working relationship, both parties recognize each other's kind of autonomy and authority and and re respect. And I feel like there has been just through tradition a little bit of a confusing element of it. And I I will have to say that my initial um foray into this was reactive and it came after a time of intense struggle and difficulty and being raked over the calls myself, but in particular I feel like watching our business manager and our superintendent get rad over the calls at those meetings one week after being raked over the calls by us. You know, it's our job to rake them over the calls about stuff like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Madera County, CA YouTube / BLSD LIVE transcript source: youtube BASS LAKE JOINT UNION ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT BOARD MEETI… · passage 95
It's a lot of, you know, a lot of work and a lot of time. So, yeah, thanks for that. >> I think it's also worth noting like I know when I've gotten some students new to my campus and they've been suspended, the parents are like at the other school, they were never suspended. I would just come and pick them up. And I'm like, well, that's a suspension. And so there is a lot of that too. I mean it's similar to what Diane said like we're being honest and when we send them home I mean even if the parent like we is fine with coming and picking them up because they're disregulated and we can just say oh release the parent you know like parent wanted to come get them but that's a suspension and so we're marking that accordingly and being honest and >> I don't think that's happening everywhere.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-11 Santa Clara County, CA YouTube / Berryessa Union School District transcript source: youtube December 10, 2025 Regular Board Meeting · passage 95
And um and in hearing these districts kind of struggle and and think through it and you're like, "Oh, you're like years away." Like this is going to take a while. Like you just realize how much time and effort and thought and and discussion go into these decisions. So, um I'm grateful. I'm excited to be here. I'm looking forward to the new year. Um, and yeah, the the doomsday demographers report, it's disheartening, but I guess one thought I had was that it's probably shifted a lot in our district. People don't come here to have a family. They come here after they have families and they they're picking their district. It's I mean I grew up in this district but I did leave and then I came back when it was time for my children to go to school. So I was looking at those birth rates they're very important to look at but I also think there's just different scenarios happening in our district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above