CACA will no longer tolerate this. Where is the accountability from the district school board? And does this superintendent plan to hold her administration accountable? And let me be clear, if this district continues to ignore retaliation, harassment, and discriminatory behavior, I'm going to begin referring my members to the California Civil Rights Department. At their right, and in the financial state we're in, I really don't think this district can afford any more litigation. I will also begin logging and filing unfair labor practices if necessary. The district has been given far too many chances, and we will take every legal avenue available to protect our members, which is CSEA's right. It's also heartbreaking that no one on this board has addressed the fact that some of our own employees, people who serve our students every single day, are having to donate plasma just to get by. This should outrage every single person in leadership instead met with silence.
>> It has all the same like the like the last instead of saying Mr. grant says the applicant, but it's the same square footage. The 60 at 60% AMI is all the same. The 15 at 20 25% workforce is all the same. So, we just kind of moved around some wording to make it seem a little smoother and got rid of the EOlc and got rid of the NOA was released last week. >> Yeah, this one feels like more meeting minutes like Mr. Grant stated complete. So I think that's a cleanup that has happened there. >> I understand. So then the actual point about it changing to or to for it to emphasize the fact that it's going to be the electric cost is is high and going to be switched to that's why they're seeking the hybrid one that comes in six. >> Yeah.
that document is supposed to be audited by me and basically be reported back and just to kind of give you an overview. Okay, so I always mention that an audit report is a technical document. If you're not an accountant specializing in school districts is extremely hard to understand. However, there is one page that all board members should refer to. I'm going to refer you to page 102 of the audit report. Oh, we all have copies. Wonderful. Okay. The header is called summary of auditor's results, page 102. >> Oh, sorry. >> We don't have it in the book. >> Oh, okay. I'll go there. >> Okay. Oh, okay. So, uh, take a second. One second. Is it 102? >> Yes, page 102. >> Thank you. >> Header of the page is called summary of auditor's results. This goes up to 21. Oh, bun. Oh yeah, six.
And that silent also sends a message louder than any speech ever could. It tells me that the well-being of our employees is not priority. It tells me that the people who keep this district running are invisible. And it tells me that as it stands today, I can no longer say with confidence that my employer cares about the basic dignity and survival of its workforce. Because of this, I no longer have confidence in my district leadership. No employee in Apple Valley Unifi should have to sacrifice their health to afford groceries. No employee should have to choose between paying their bills and feeding their children. And no employee should ever feel that they are struggling and being ignored by the very leaders entrusted with their well-being. I am asking and I am expecting that this school board and district investigate and will pour out on these issues I have raised tonight at the next board meeting.
So, so five and I I combined five and six into one. So that's kind of like okay here number four said number four says what we wrote in the actual decision >> right but it's it hasn't changed right that's exactly what >> right because that is what was written in the decision >> cool >> and then five and six >> five and six >> you combined into >> right so because the cost of electric and gas aren't equitable thus they are asking to to make for us to make this change. >> Okay. >> Right. So that's why that's why I got rid of I combined those two. >> It's basically all those five points are just a trying to a summary of what was presented to us relative to the gas. >> And this is more decision and not meeting minutes. So it makes sense for some of those lines to have disappeared.
>> Oh, okay. Got it. Okay. >> This is only our second meeting with computers. So instead of having the the tree sitting here, >> the tree. >> Let's see. >> I've been using it. They're just slow. You said 121. >> 102. Page 102. >> I was I was close. It's the schedule of findings and questions cost. >> Uh right after that the header is called summary of auditor's results. >> Summary. Got it. >> Yeah. >> Okay. Sounds like we're all there. Wait, he said 102 or 110 down there. Okay, that makes a big difference. It does. >> All right. Is everyone good? Are my colleagues good? Crazy. >> Yep. >> Here. >> Okay. >> Looks like technology isn't exactly working for us. >> This is only second time you say. Thank you so much Fina. >> All right. Wonderful. Now we have now we have copies of it.
Despite these challenges we face, I stand here tonight with determination, with belief, and with hope. Because I know the power of our community. You've seen it tonight. I know that the strength of our educators, classified and certificate alike. And I know when we stand together, we are unstoppable. So, I urge this board, choose transparency over silence, action over complacency, and dignity over convenience. Our students deserve it. Our employees deserve it and our community deserves it. Together we can rebuild trust, but you got to want it. We can restore stability and we can create a district where every worker is valued and every voice is heard. The work begins with all of us and that time is now and is way past due. Let it also be known as elected officials, you have the duty to your students, your constituents, and all of us employees. We can and we will hold you accountable.
>> Yes. I mean literally it is the meeting minutes in here. Yeah. which is why I wanted to clarify it actually into a decision and not >> meeting minutes that >> you know. >> Okay. And then nothing has changed after the 56 change. >> Right. The the other the other four points were written by Jasmine, approved by Lisa. I mean, Lisa probably read through the other stuff as well, but she's what she's um concerned about is the amending of the decision, which is these four points, which is what we're actually signing off on. >> And what does that what does us approving or not approving this do to them getting their approval? >> We've already approved it. It's already voted. Our votes are already me, you, and Deepa, we approved it. We voted yes. >> So, changing of this wording doesn't really affect anybody in any way.
>> So, so again the audit report is a technical document and I I think the best way to gauge how the audit went is to refer to this page and go through each of the sections. Now, as you look through this page, you're going to see three headers. First is the financial statement. Second is federal awards. Third is state compliance. Those are the three main focus areas that we touch upon as part of the audit. Financial statement being the biggest. Now, before I get into the results of the audit, I'd like to kind of preface this with a little bit of a technical term that I'm going to be using. So, all auditors don't provide what we would call an absolute assurance, meaning that we're 100% sure. We we do what's called a reasonable assurance, and it's in the form of a professional opinion. Now, we do this by a varying degree.
The same needs to happen from the very top. We did not create this mess. Why should we have to be responsible for repairing the damage? Dignity, community, authenticity, and service. Or is that just a logo and nothing more? In solidarity, Justin Carile Scott, CSCA chapter president, Apple Valley 828. >> [cheering] [applause] >> Karen before I begin um I would make like to make a request. So according to the Brown Act 54957.5 notwithstanding section 255 or any other provisions of law agendas or public meetings and any other writings when distributed to all or the majority of all of the members of the legislative body of the local agency by any person in connection with a matter subject to discussion or consideration at a public meeting of the body are disclosable public records under the California Public Records Act and shall be made available upon request without delay.
Except for the >> It's I just wanted instead of instead of >> I understand what you want. I'm just trying to make sure that the project moves forward and that doesn't cause any pause. There's no pause. >> No, they're probably This is the official Yeah. The official signature >> besides us having to print another two pieces of paper and assign it. There's no >> And I understand again I'm I'm talking about the logistical piece of it. There's no like >> they're not waiting for it. >> Nobody's holding this back. Okay, cool. No, >> got it. They knew they do need this signed to apply for their funding. So the verbal approval isn't enough. So they do need this signed tonight. >> Okay. >> We we have to sign it. >> But so if you make the changes, we can print it and sign it right now.
The highest level of assurance being an unmodified opinion followed by a qualified. Lastly, an adverse or disclaimer of an opinion. Okay? So, think of it as the IRS. IRS will not tell you anything if you did if you did everything correctly. I will guarantee you they'll contact you if you did something wrong. We operate in that same manner. We only unfortunately report the bad. That's why no one likes us. Okay? So again, please keep in mind that the highest level of assurance is an unmodified opinion. So I'm going to go through each of the sections and just summarize the results of the audit. As far as the financial statements are concerned, as of June 30, 2025, our opinion with respect to the overall financial statement of the district was unmodified, highest level of assurance that we could provide. During the course of our assessment and audit of the financial statements, we did not identify any type of deficiencies that we have to report to the board.
However, this section does not include any writings exempt from public disclosure section 6253.5, 6254, 6254.7 or 62 5422. Basically, we are asking that any um materials handed to the majority of the board be made public to us. It says that they're supposed to be made um public immediately so that we can have copies and follow along as the board follows along. Thank you. Okay. Good evening, Superintendent Nelson School Board, Cabinet, President Scott, and everyone in the audience. My name is Karen Sabers, and I am the proud president of the Apple Valley Unified Teachers Association. Last week, Abuda had the privilege of taking part in the town's Christmas tree lighting event. We handed out gloves of all sizes, toys, candy canes, and beanies. We love giving back to our community. We love connecting with the families. This event reminds us of why we do the work we do.
>> Yes. It's already done. Already printed. >> That's what I >> having not been here through any of this. Just is this clear to everyone that that allow of change to natural gas is pending all of these affordability cuts. if that gets reverted to something different that this goes away. >> So for me reading it, I don't I don't necessarily see that, but I haven't been involved in >> that's more in the original decision. So this is a modification that they're requesting. So this will really only reflect what was requested in the modification, but the original decision does have language that reflects that type of agreement. >> Thank you. >> Yeah. Well, and I mean it's um the deeper um the gas should be I mean I think I understand what you're asking like >> I understand the trade-off inherently in what we're doing. I just wasn't sure if it was clear here having not been involved in other conversations.
Now, what we're talking about in terms of deficiency is if there's any flaws or problems when it comes to the reporting of the financial statements or the gathering of the information of the financial statements, we are required to report that to the board. So, fortunately, we have nothing to report in that arena. Um, federal awards. So, if you're a non-federal entity receiving currently 750,000 or more in a given year, you're subject to what's called a single audit. This is the piece that actually delayed us from issuing our reports early because of the closure. We frankly did not know what the direction was from the feds until right before Thanksgiving. That's when we found out. But in any event, that's the trigger. And during the uh 2425 fiscal year, we were required to audit your one-time dollars. You've heard of the term ESSER, right? The the remnants of it.
Tonight, I would like to address a few concerns and one that has deeply affected our staff. First, I'm going to start this out by it's not personal. Don't know Dr. Pal, but this board voted to contract with Dr. Pal and have him train the PAR educators. We paid him $3,997 per 90minute session, $441 per minute to train six to eight pareducators. when Selpa can deliver this training for free. So, I wanted to bring that to your attention. Most of us saw the message that was sent out the Friday before Thanksgiving, a message that went out to families, not staff. It did not wish the staff a happy Thanksgiving or tell them the district is thankful for them. Then again, today, another message. Meanwhile, when we are out informational picketing, students roll down their windows and wave with excitement when they see their teachers. Parents roll down their windows and ask how they can support us.
If you're saying there's another thing that already made that very clear that this trade is based on these cuts and if these cuts you don't get the funding and you don't make these cuts it's electric. >> Yeah. No, that that is I mean >> so the point three on that deliberation kind of hints to that if until somebody else is not reading it that way. Um that tells you that it goes back to electric which is the >> three just says it goes back to passive house which passive house does allow an exclusion for hot water and cooking. So that doesn't say >> wait where where is the passive house note I >> on >> no the next deliberation following deliberation the board voted in favor of >> right >> that section >> if it becomes if it becomes um right if it becomes cheaper they have to go back but also if they don't get the funding and make these deep affordability cuts in theory it would go back that's the part that I didn't think was clear which could be have been made clear in an original decision that I don't I'm not privy to.
And that we were also required to audit your Title One Part A funds, which are federal funds dedicated for underprivileged students. Okay. Based on the audit procedures performed over both of these programs, our opinion was unmodified with respect to the district's compliance with both of these programs. We also did not identify any type of control or checks and balance deficiencies that the board has to be aware of. Okay. So again, it was a clean opinion. Moving on to state compliance. And I always mention this is kind of a unique area because it evolves every year. It changes bit by bit every year. And unfortunately, we just have to accommodate it. But I know you don't have this, but if you're ever curious, the list full listing of all the programs that were required to audit are going to be on page 99 and 100. Okay.
So, when the district says we are making people uncomfortable, we ask what exactly is uncomfortable? I asked the educators to tell me what makes them uncomfortable. And here's what they said. It is uncomfortable to work in an environment where staff feel fear retaliation on a daily basis or for speaking publicly. It is uncomfortable to teach in classrooms with severe behaviors that go unsupported by administration. It is uncomfortable to watch factf finding get delayed by the district. It is uncomfortable seeing the district add positions away from the classroom while taking away instructional coaches and reading specialists. It is uncomfortable seeing decisions that are done reflect genuine or not reflect genuine care for students. We are uncomfortable when our salary schedule and the fact that we still do with our salary schedule and the fact that we still do not have a contract. We are uncomfortable with the misinformation that continues to be shared by district administration.
So that's the only thing I would >> What did did Lisa comment on that? Because that was my question as well. >> She didn't make any specific comments. I said would this you know hold up with the legality of it and she read it and said yes this should but I can if you want to add that change that language in some way. Um but I would sign it tonight regardless and have Lisa review it afterward um so as not to If the applicant doesn't get this funding because they don't have this decision that's >> right >> um doesn't look great for the town. Um I think it's just that um it's it's instead of following following deliberation there's another line that sometimes we use um about um like in light of the above conditions and after deliberation. So that so that it kind of says that um >> I don't see how that change I I can change it.