2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 113
Based on the audit procedures that we performed all the programs that are on page 99 through 100, our opinion was unmodified with respect to the district's compliance with all the applicable programs. We also did not identify any type of deficiencies and checks and balances in ensuring compliance with each of these programs. So overall, it was a clean audit. Um, normally if I have any issues that I have to report to you, I'll certainly mention it here, but it's also always going to be in the report in the following pages. So, if you again, you don't have the report, but it's okay. If you flip if you scroll through the report, the following pages will indicate none reported because there are no findings that I have to report to the board. Okay. So, in other words, it was a clean audit.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 113
It is uncomfortable to show unwavering dedication to a district that does not acknowledge its educators are struggling with rising cost and need a fair, competitive salary. I'm uncomfortable, these are their words, too. I'm uncomfortable with a board's refusal to address the conditions that are hurting morale and stability. Parents and staff are uncomfortable with the district sending the message that it is teachers versus the district. That message is harmful, divisive, and embarrassing. It is uncomfortable knowing that other districts in our area pay their teachers and counselors significantly more than ABUSD, including teachers and counselors who have given decades of their lives to this community. It is uncomfortable having to fight for fair wages when the district should have taken care of their staff long ago. It is uncomfortable working for a district that does not appreciate the certificated cat staff. Educators are uncomfortable with being portrayed as a problem simply for exercising their right to pick it and speak up.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 114
I just don't see how that changes the intent of the decision in any way. >> Well then then let's think of something else. Right. >> So but but my question was exactly what Angel was. >> So I'm not I don't Okay. When they took over from Tras this is what they what the condition was. Didn't we kind of approve it right there? There is no question of them changing anything. >> The affordability requirements were established in the original decision. This modification >> had no bearing on the affordability component whatsoever. They were only asking to change from hot water to gas and we're saying yes only under the condition >> that it remains the more affordable option. This >> this modification didn't touch the affordability component of this application that that still stands in the original. So who voted on here can undo >> the requirements that they have to do for affordability.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 114
Any questions for me? >> Fantastic. >> No. Any questions? >> Good news. >> Not out of time. It's great news. Thank you so much for your presentation. >> Okay. >> And we love your enthusiasm. >> Yes. >> Thank you. >> And we're proud to have been your first uh audit. And then just clarify that um people might get the wrong idea. You say you work for us, but this is uh what you have to do and you have to report uh if you have findings. >> Yeah. When I say I report way, when I say I work for you, I solely report to you. >> Our our sole platform is to be independent and that's what you want out of audit. Correct. Right. So you don't want to make sure you know quote unquote sleeping with the client, right? >> Correct. >> So yeah, we're definitely independent.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 114
They are uncomfortable with the increasing loss of special education pair educators and with inclusion classrooms lacking PAR educators. They are uncomfortable with the district's lack of transparency and accountability. They are uncomfortable with the financial situation created by leadership's decisions and even more uncomfortable watching the board vote unanimously to increase longevity bonuses for administration while keeping our district's certificated staff among the lowest paid in the high desert. They are uncomfortable with money spent on professional development that teachers find little value in year after year. They are uncomfortable with leadership creating this crisis and then shifting the blame on to teachers. We are uncomfortable with Superintendent Nelson stating in a board meeting that she inherited this when in actuality she helped create this situation. It's time for you to take ownership. One educator said, "I am uncomfortable telling my son I can't help him with his tuition this semester because my paycheck is too low." Others shared they are uncomfortable witnessing favoritism when staff try to report student behaviors.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 115
>> But wait wait wait wait wait. So the original the original document was 25% affordable at 80% AMI. Pretty sure that's what it was. They asked for another modification which is right here. um they asked for a modification that would allow um deeper discounts. So instead of 25% at 80% AMI, they're putting in that um no less than they wanted to be able to allow themselves to do deeper discounts and our original didn't. It said 25% at 80% AMI, >> but the modification did >> the mod right. So now they can, >> right? >> But the but the question is they they don't have to though. They can if they want to and if they get the funding. So the question is if they don't get the funding and they do 20% at 80 AMI, does it have to go back to all electric, no gas, because you're not doing deep discounts?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 115
>> Thank you so much. >> You're an external auditor. You're not Yes. You're not an an employee of the district. Yes. I want to make sure people understand that. >> Yes. We're we're external independent auditors. Thank you. >> Thank you so much. >> Thank you. Okay. >> All right. Moving on to 16.3 first interim budget report. Uh deferring to Dr. Nen. >> Oh, I skipped one. Yes. Yes. So, um Andrew on the 16.1. That's the um financial audit. Then we also have the bond audit report for uh fiscal year 2425. >> Thank you. as well 16.2. >> So that has to be a two separate um any type of bond is a separate audit. So they conduct a separate we have a separate contract with them and they do the audit completely separately as well. >> Got it. Thank you for the clarification. >> Thank you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 115
It is uncomfortable when I have to go to the food bank to get food to put on the table for my kids. And many said they are uncomfortable that the district cannot seem to figure out how to give certificated staff a proper raise and that certificated staff must must pick it simply to fight for what is right. Honestly, I could go on because I've received tons of emails with this, but I'll stop there. These are not isolated opinions. These are not exaggerated feelings. These are the daily lived experiences of Apple Valley teachers and counselors. The people who show up for our students every single day, regardless of the conditions created around them. We don't want to feel this way. We want to feel valued. We want to feel supported. We want to feel respected. We want to feel like partners in education, not obstacles. We are hopeful that the district will choose to listen.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 116
>> But the modification overrites your original. It's like an amendment to the original. Yeah, like saying original. >> What do you think was overwritten? >> The tax. >> No, no. Yeah, it was, but it's only up to like >> So, you think the base affordability is not enough to give them the exception? You're saying we will not give you this exception if you don't give us this additional discount is what you want to get. >> I I thought that's what we were agreeing to when we >> No, I I interpreted it as they were asking for the ability to swap because the prices are too high. by the way, here's what we're also doing. We're also aiming to do deeper discounts. We're that so that was like a by like here's this extra thing because they can get better financing or something like they they said what they were going after, not that it was we're we're giving you this to get this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 116
>> Okay. So we have two separate audits. One's measure H which is phasing out or has phased out and one's measure K. I'll go through these audits rather quickly. So when you look at a bond audit report, it's a two-part audit. First half is the financial statement aspect of it and second half is what everybody's interested in is the performance aspect of it. I'm not going to get into much of the financial aspect. It's normally tied to the district's overall audit, but we scale it down to audit specifically for these funds and the pockets that that these funds are held in. Right? So for both of these funds, our opinion was unmodified with respect to both measure K and measure H bonds as of June 30, 2025. Okay, again the highest level of assurance. >> What what interests everybody is how much do we test and what do we discover.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 116
We are hopeful that you will choose to prioritize classrooms and the educators who make them work. And we are hopeful that the board will choose collaboration over conflict and move toward a fair, competitive salary that allows us to attract and retain highquality teachers. our students deserve. Thank you. In solidarity, CAN I [applause] OKAY, I want to address what happened before close session. While I was preparing to enter close session for negotiations, a teacher in the audience yelled out and called me a coward. That was not part of the public comment. It was not on the agenda and it was not within any formal process. It was a personal attack shouted from the crowd during a time when we are supposed to be conducting district business. I did respond because I'm still a human being. I asked, "You really going to say that to me as I'm walking in to negotiations?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 117
That wasn't my interpretation. >> And I didn't think that was what you meant by when you were changing this. We were only documenting that this project is bringing all these additional deeper discounts. Hence, we're justifying this. That's what I understood that as. >> Yeah. Like I I >> That's what we're trying to do. Maybe that's what you maybe you add some language here. What? So, let's say they didn't have the deeper discounts and they just showed up and said, "We're going to do, hey, can we do gas on just the hot water because it's cheaper right now than the electric is. Would you approve it?" I still would have approved it. I'm just telling you this is what I would have done, right? To me, them doing this extra affordable housing was just icing on the top because I understand why they're doing it. They're not doing it just to be nice people, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 117
>> Okay, so when you refer to the second half of the page, this is what we would call a performance audit under government auditing standards. Okay, this is basically we're set out to um answer a variety of questions in this case. Did the district spend the bond proceeds in accordance to what the voters have approved or voted for. Right? That's ultimately the the main question that I'm answering along with a little caveats here and there, but that's the main answer that I'm trying to answer. So, I'll give you some information as far as how the district did overall for measure H, which is the bond funds that have been fully exhausted as of June 30, 2025. Um, we tested 677,000 and some change out of the 684,279 spent, which represents so we basically tested 99% of the total expenditures. It's not a big number to be honest.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 117
You could call me a coward. [clears throat] >> I said that I would remember that in close. >> Right. And I said that because it's completely inappropriate for anyone to undermine negotiation. >> You know what? We let you guys talk and slam us. Can you let me talk, please? >> No. Excuse me. >> What? >> I'd like to call point of order. >> What? What's the order? >> I believe we're not supposed to respond to public comment. >> Well, I'm going to You can call. And I said that because it's completely inappropriate for anyone to undermine a negotiation by attacking one of the people responsible for it. That kind of behavior poisons the process before it even sit down at the table. What concerns me even more is what came next. After close session, the union representative JC Scott chastised me for my response, yet said nothing about their own members yelling out insults.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 118
they're getting better financing or something out of it, so that's why they're putting it forward. To me, that wouldn't have changed the decision. Are you saying it would have changed your decision? >> No, not necessarily because I know how expensive things are right now. It's not for heat. It's just for the water. >> Right. So, >> that was just my interpretation of what I thought happened. So, that's why I was asking for clarity. >> Yeah. So if I think if you feel the same way as I do on that and I don't know how you feel then if that is the way then I think we should just move forward with it as with your modifications. >> Okay. >> Um if it is something that you think was a this for that then that's a different discussion. But I I didn't interpret it that way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 118
in the scale of a district, but we covered just about everything. Okay? Based on the testing that we performed, the district spent bond proceeds in accordance to what the voters have approved for measure H. Okay, this is the old bonds and then the new bonds, measure K, just to give you more information in terms of how much we covered and what our result was uh for the 2425 fiscal year. Um, our sample included 30 I'm going to just going to round this $36.7 million which represents 91.1% of the total spent of $40.2 million. Pretty good coverage. Okay. Now, what's the result? Based on the testing that we performed, we believe that district had spent the proceeds in accordance to what the voters have approved for. So, I really have nothing to report to you from a from a performance and compliance standpoint. Okay. Good. No news is generally good news from the auditors.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 118
That selective accountability says a lot. It tells me that the union, you know, there we go. Just proves my point more. It tells me that union leadership is more comfortable criticizing the board than addressing the behavior within their own group. At the same time, the union has been posting incomplete, misleading, and inflammatory statements on social media throughout these negotiations. They criticize me for reacting in a room. But they have no issue attacking the board online day after day, often without context, without facts, and without any acknowledgement of the legal and confidential parameters we are required as board members to follow. If the union truly wants productive negotiations, then standards must be held in the same for everyone. Respect cannot only apply when it benefits one side. Professionalism cannot be demanded from the board while union shouts insults from the audience and publishes one-sided narratives on the internet.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (December 11th, 2025) · passage 119
I thought they were just telling us hey by the way we're making it even better >> and this is what we're going after. >> Yeah. I I think that's fair. I think that's fair. I think, you know, >> right? >> Yeah. >> I mean, maybe they kind of muddled it up because they said the two things all together and the date thing all at the same time. Um because it was kind of a lot >> considering it wasn't here for the original. You know what I mean? That >> Yeah. And then this kind of goes dates back to some of these old applications and amendments already as I mean this has to be some level of trust factor. It's >> Yeah. And it is a it is a passive house, you know, so it's it's a high >> which is definitely better than Yeah. >> All right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 119
Any questions on that? >> Questions? >> Okay. >> All right. Well, thank you so much for both audits on Measure H and Measure K. We appreciate you being here tonight. >> Thank you. It's my pleasure. >> Thank you. >> All right. Now, 16.3 2025 through 2026 first interim budget report and deferring to Dr. Nen. Well, before I get started, I do want to thank staff um especially Karen and Joe for the clean audit and also all the um accounting staff and the budget team as well. So, everybody worked very very hard to get that um clean audit. It's it's a lot of work. So, um starting um very early, you know, before we even close and through, you know, July, July is really heavy and by August. So, uh, you know, um, Joe and Karen, thank you so much. I know it's a lot of work.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 119
I'm committed to negotiating in good faith. In fact, I get calls all the time from Karen Sabers, JC Scott saying that, you know, we want to negotiate. We want this. I am committed to doing what is best for our students in this district and our staff. But negotiations do not move forward when one side chooses theatrics over truth. They do not process when people try to provoke, intimidate, or shame elected officials instead of working collaboratively at the table. Tonight is a reminder that leadership requires discipline, integrity, and consistency. If the union wants accountability from me, then they must first demonstrate it within their own organization. And if we are going to model this behavior, we expect from our students and adults in this room need to act professionals. I will continue to show up prepared, respectful, and focus on solutions. I ask the union leadership to do the same.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above