2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 148
They shouldn't have said that. All right. I I can I'll say that. If no one else will, I'll say I don't support that. Um certainly though, the response was unnecessary, too. You know, and if you want to, you know, uh come on this side and be a civilian, by all means, speak up, man. defend yourself. I'll have your back. You know, that's no big deal. Say what you want to say. But when you sit in those chairs, behind those name plates, it, you know, it's a higher calling and it's also a higher standard. We have to hold ourselves to that. Even as a parent, I have to control myself and not say things that I want to say, you know, otherwise I'll be asked to leave and or forced to leave and that's just a decorum that we're in. And I think all of us need to be reminded of that and understand that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 149
Like hey, you're going to graduate. Can we get back all those things? Or hey, you're leaving eighth grade, right? So we try to do that to the extent possible but we also don't want to put any undue burdens on our um families. So there's a lot of sensitivity to uh you know not penalizing um students uh you know they face a wide variety of circumstances um that sometimes lead to that and so you know ultimately we just try to make sure they have what they need to succeed um academically. Uh and again that's Dr. Sudu does that work. Diana Fujimoto with the working with the curriculum specialists on the curriculum adoptions and and all of that. So, it's a real team effort um there in terms of what that uh looks like. >> Superintendent Masuda. >> Yeah. I think you bring up a very interesting issue because um statewide um even though this I mean in my opinion it's very outdated to have textbooks right and considering that we are teachers are creating standards aligned performance task assessments combined with the access to the electronic materials you know we are spending probably 8 to10 million a year on textbooks and I would venture uh superintendent uh freed that if you were to um start looking at how many teachers use our textbooks and it's not just in our districts but this is a growing problem and a trend right >> I would say that it's very the numbers are pretty low depending on the subject area >> but um I mean I I just I think it's very antiquated when we are when you know because you have a textbook adoption every six years and um you know they're obsolete the day they come out given the world that we're in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 149
Um, you know, uh, if you're looking for someone to be a mediator, I'll volunteer. I'll do it for free. You know, I'm off on Fridays. Sign me up. you know, you know, I can't promise to do the best job, but you know, it'll be free nonetheless. You get what you pay for. But, you know, uh, to the teachers in the room, uh, and to the ones that were here earlier, I see you. I had no idea what you guys are going through, what you guys carry on your shoulders, the smiles you give when I drop off my kids, the smiles and handshakes you give when I pick them up, how happy they come home to me every day excited what they learned. I had no idea. I have really respect you guys. I appreciate you guys as a parent from this community and I really hope you hold your heads high.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 150
And um I think this is uh the district potentially can save a lot of money. And I think that what we need to push for is uh maybe some sort of u innovation zone around textbooks. I we we're there are a number of districts that are beginning to question this. >> Dr. Free. Yes. So I love what he's saying because I want to say we're already moving in that direction. Um so so to I want to give Sema Dr. Dudu and and Jen Va a lot of credit and of course Joe is also part of this work especially when he was on the ed services side of the house. um with the 1:1 devices now you know and just as a point of clarification the Williams act really applies to the and I hate using the word core because I believe all classes are core but the traditional core classes English math history science but with the onetoone devices now what we've done is we've gotten class sets so instead of every kid having to lug books back and forth we just buy the class set which is much way more cost-effective approach and to Mr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 150
Uh uh keep doing what you're doing. Thank you so much. Um to another point, uh all these kids that were here earlier, it was amazing to see the things they're accomplishing in this school district. Uh the stuff that they did that was so cool. Uh the the kids from Apple Valley and Granite, the way they were speaking. My gosh, we we have such great kids here. And but what I took away from it was who put them onto that? Who gave them that opportunity? You know, it's the people behind me putting in that work, those long hours. They deserve more consideration and more more uh uh uh compassion. Uh uh uh as I saw those kids espouse all their accomplishments, I couldn't help but think of the teachers, those long hours, some of them what they're talking about with their personal lives. It is incredible.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 151
Mr. Rasuda's point with the performance task assessments, we do see less and less teachers using text for their assignments. Um, we do have some classes like a math class that is a little more dependent on math books typically, but we're seeing less and less, but this has been a cost-saving measure where we have the class sets now. We do have an overage of textbooks that we have to purchase because as you heard, we will have students who choose or to have a hard text, whether they're a student with disability, a plural, or just a student who wants a physical textbook. So we do get overage but we are saving the number of books that we have to purchase because we've moved more to the class set model. So that has been a cost-saving practice and I agree. I think the textbooks generally speaking is an outdated approach but we're still mandated to have books via uh the Williams.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 151
I feel so bad for them. I had no idea we were doing this. Uh um Miss uh Long Shore, I really respect what you said earlier. Uh uh I was elected six years as a vice president for my own local union and I had to go against my own president and vice president and it got ugly and I had me feeling like damn you know I the bad guy did I mess up but then I realized no I'm the one that didn't change. I stood as I did before exactly who I said I'd be. I didn't let people change me and I was tempted you know it was out there for me to uh take advantage of things. Um so please uh I if you know what you're doing is is right keep doing the right thing and you have my respect you have my support.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 152
>> Thank you. >> And yes I'm next. >> Yes. Thank you Joe um for that explanation. I while we are sensitive to students who um you know through no fault of their own or family circumstances we still have a tremendous loss of materials and we ha we are obligated to provide um I remember when uh you couldn't get your diploma if you didn't return your textbooks or devices and let's not talk about devices because that's a whole another story but um you We do our best and we are sensitive to our to our families. But um I think a messaging uh you know out to families that that that it does cost uh funding. Um thank you for this presentation. Thank you for waiting until the end to ask your question. The reason being um if uh people want to come back and review this because as a district we really need to uh provide this information for people.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 152
there's anything I can do to help you and any of you guys, man. Uh uh um Miss Nelson, I know you've been around for a very long time. I don't you don't remember it, but I went and got I had to get my applying for a job with the sheriff's department and I had to get my certified transcripts and you helped me out with that and got me on the right path. And you know, this a small interaction years ago. Uh uh uh so um but you know, you've been around since then. So I mean you guys have the answers. We have to find a solution. Uh um it looks like there's some good ideas, but has to start with communication. These guys have great ideas. uh of the people from the ground up that are doing the job physically probably should have the most consideration what's going to work for them.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 153
I wish every seat was filled up in this um boardroom because when we have these presentations, the facts are here. The numbers are black and white and red. Um you know, people aren't here until there's hard uh decisions that we have to make to cut or take things away. Um and I wish that uh folks would really uh take the time. Um, and if you're online, you're listening, uh, or you're in the room, please, uh, have people look at these numbers because what we were talking about in the last couple of years, if you look, you know, on the pages, we project four years out and we have been doing that um, for years and years and years. We knew when things were going to be tough for us a couple of years ago and people act as if wow that's we're surprised and we didn't know.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 153
I've had that experience. I've told my supervisors, "This won't work. Just get it done." So, I did it and then it didn't work. Why isn't working? Because I told you it wouldn't. You know, why don't you listen? And then, you know, it became my fault that there I couldn't make their idea a reality when, you know, with this. So, please uh you know, I'm very proud to be from Apple Valley. Uh I grew up here. I've represented this town everywhere I've went. I don't hold back. you know, I've gotten into so many arguments, you know, whatever. But I'll say this, when you come to Apple Valley, our town motto is a better way of life. And and I think that's amazing. It kind of tells me I'm where I need to be because I've always wanted just a better way of life, man. Uh to improve myself and my family.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 154
I'm not pointing fingers. I'm just stating the facts and we all um have to uh be accountable for knowing the facts. And I feel if you are working in a school district, it really is incumbent for you or as a parent really come and to understand these um these things. Not just, you know, the things that you support, but really understand that we're we're we're dealing with um millions of dollars. We're dealing with a lot of things that we have to provide. We're dealing with a lot of things that are out of our control. um that we're we're having to um and not that we wouldn't as a district, but we're having to answer. Uh we have to be sensitive to student needs and we have to feed children. That's just a thing that we have to do. Um and the budget may be cut for that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 154
And that's what we need to espouse. And just not not only for ourselves, but for our community. And it's not a it's not a selfish way of life. It's not an evil way of life. It's not a corrupt way of life. It's not an arrogant way of life. It's a better way of life. And we all need to try to fix that and get to that point. and service our community with authenticity and dignity right in this room. We're sitting in the middle of it, yet we seem to kind of oversee it, ignore it. Please don't let pride or ego get in the way of progress and doing what's right for everybody in this room. Thank you. [applause] Uh Mary Quillin. Um, I just wanna Sorry if that's a little too loud. I just wanted to first um say thank you to Bianca for sharing your story.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 155
And so it it just feel um I'm giving a plea out to folks to really really understand um when we do these reports. Um Nancy and the team, you do a fabulous job and um we should really honor that work. It's here. Let's educate ourselves and then we can all find the solutions that we need to when hard times come and decisions come that we have to cut. So that's I'm getting off of my um bully pulpit right there. Um I just wanted to ask a couple of questions, Nancy, and thank you so much for this comprehensive report. It's beyond what we had been doing uh in all of the years that I've been um serving on the board uh the projections and the extra projections and I mean these are very comprehensive reports. So thank you so much um in actual I wanted to go to the last page.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 155
Um, I'm a special educator and to hear you um stand and advocate for your children is amazing. Yep. Okay. and um continue to continue to know your rights as a special as a parent of a special educa um educated student, a deaf student um in terms of IDA and your offer of faith. So, just want to throw that in for you. Um, I'll be honest with you. Uh, this is the first time I've ever spoken before you. And um, I am a little shaky because I have felt the intensity of tonight. And, um, so I'm just going to I'm going to read what I wrote because this was before everything happened, but I just want to share with you from my perspective. So, good evening to our board of trustees, district leadership, to the teachers, school staff, and community members present here tonight. Thank you to our guests here who are for giving up your evening to be present engaged in the important work of our district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 156
You had a couple of lines for the transportation for busing. Why the two different figures on that? Um >> page 19. Yes, >> there's two. Um Karen, are those two sets correct? >> Sorry. Can you come to the mic? >> Can you come to Thank you. >> for those watching just so they can hear. >> Oh, that's right. Okay. >> Is it for one for CG ones for Yeah. Okay. I can remember >> that was an error. The first reserve for bus list leasing 786,000 that is the commitment. The second line that is a reserve for um carrier for supplemental and concentration funds. Okay. >> So yeah that was an error. Okay supplemental and concentration funds. All right >> concentration. >> Thank you. Okay. >> Thank you. um on the additional 3% reserve that that we we wanted to um we wanted to add. I mean um a lot of folks want to come after that reserve and we say we have an extra amount of reserve.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 156
Again, I am Mary Quillin. I'm a special educator co-teer at Mariana Academy. And like I said, I've gone back and forth if I was to speak and I decided to take a stand with my fellow colleagues tonight. I've been to many board meetings and this is the first one. Almost felt like a well, I wasn't going to say never mind. I'll stop. Stay the strip to the script, Mary. A quote from one of my favorite TV series, The West Wing, is decisions are made by those who show up. Everyone's presence here tonight and on days past is a reflection of that desire to be part of the process of getting things done for the students, family, and staff of Apple Valley Unified. This is only my second year at Apple Valley, my second year in California. My husband and I moved here as almost empty nesters when he found his dream job in Hisperia.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 157
I mean all you have to do is go back and look at the next year's out as to why we made that decision. Can you just talk about how important that is to have a healthy reserve? >> Right. So um the having a 3% reserve you we would not be able to make cash flow. We would not be able to pay the salary. So you look at um average I mean we're about 10 months right for most of the employees right from um and so when you do it 10 months so you need to have about you know even 10% to make cash flow for each month. And um we are still getting deferrals. Remember we forgot the whole deferral still. So there's still some deferrals. Um but we are we have enough cash flow so we do not have to worry about the deferral that we're getting and so the concern will be in the out years if they continue to have deferrals then we would need to um even track you know the cash I mean we already have a 18 months projection but if there's additional things that came um I don't I mean I think some of you were around in 2008 2009 that was u I was a brand new CBO that year and we literally had to look at the cash flow daily we had to see how much was in the bank how much is coming and which bill do you have to decide which one you're going to pay first and so um having u a 3% reserve even the 6% reserve the board has mandate it will not be enough to make cash flow so we will not be barely be to be able to make payroll and so I think having a healthy fund balance will definitely help us because if we do have to go out to borrow and the cost of borrowing right now is is very high and so we would have to you would have to pay the cost of borrowing as well >> superintendent Masuda >> yeah um trust and Marie Tjo, I think you bring up a really good point about um paying attention to numbers, especially declining enrollment um because we could very well be in the position we were um with the riffs a few years back.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 San Bernardino County, CA YouTube / AVUSD Official Channel transcript source: youtube Dec 11, 2025 - Regular Meeting of the Board of Trustees · passage 157
He grew up here in the high desert and wanted to return. So, if any of you remember Scarcella's Pizza from way back when that was my husband's family's business, so it was like coming home for him. Um, for me, it was brand new. I taught I was a licensed teacher up in North Dakota uh for several years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-12 Orange County, CA YouTube / AUHSD Communications transcript source: youtube 12/11 AUHSD Board Meeting: Open Session (6:00 PM) · passage 158
And it's really important and Germaine, I'm glad you're still here because uh th this is really the the the board and the district really needs to get out in front with our associations with folks like yourself in terms of these numbers. Uh cabinet had a discussion about where is the bottom in terms of declining enrollment and it's we don't see the bottom. We're going to drop below 20,000 in the next 5 years. We're at 25,000 now. And if the uh projected retirees do not sort of if those numbers don't work out, we're the district's going to be in a little trouble again. And this is why it should if you know 3 to four years down the line. Hopefully hopefully things you know the retirees match the declining enrollment and we're going to be okay with the state budget and all that. But if the numbers don't and it and it's kind of scary when you think that we're going to fall 19,000 students right in six years.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above