Digits in terms of any key decision making within the district. I appreciate both of those gentlemen and their leadership skills and their knowledge and I feel very comfortable making that recommendation. I would also request on number 11 um I know you've had access to those, but we are truly blessed. Um, I've been here back four years and I'm amazed at the amount of generosity in this community that is given towards our uh, kids, our programs, our teachers, and our corporation. There's numerous different opportunities on there that will benefit our kids. And I greatly appreciate all the donations uh, for your approval tonight. >> Thank you, Mr. Rimberry. I'll entertain a motion reference to consent agenda. Make a motion to approve the consent agenda as presented. >> Thank you, Mr. Wall. Is there a second? >> Second. >> Thank you, Mr. Meltchure.
We talked about some of the cons. These are some things that we found in some of the research and having conversations and getting a hold of places that maybe did some different things. It can cause decreased participation over time. So, if a kid is is is a freshman year, as I talk about is that we see the higher standard there. when kids are held to the higher standards, if they don't meet the higher standard, kids and they're not able to play, they'll shy away from playing in their sophomore, junior, senior year. That was what some of the data um did display and some of the some of those elements out there. Okay. Um you have the possibility of declining student enrollment or elements of students looking for other areas. We we are a very competitive market for students. Nobody was implying in the room when we saw this.
>> What is the contract up in 26th? I was just >> the contract. Uh, >> it's in 25. >> Yeah, it's up. >> Oh, so it's already >> it's expired. Obviously, we would work with them. uh they would work with us on any kind of issues that we would have to have without the contract. But now the contract is back signed um and or hopefully the contract will be approved and then we will be under contract again. >> Could I get a motion to approve? >> So move second. >> Any other questions? >> Michelle, quick question. So when you say the peer average was 2.5% and the Gil charge Stevenson at that rate. Yep. >> When the project's value is under 3 million, which means they don't charge anything. >> So, when it's 3 million or less, then we're we're competitive with the industry. When it's more, which is where we usually land, we actually get charged a lesser rate, which doesn't necessarily happen with our peers.
>> So the bottom level, so is is if you were a Heritage, you went to heritage 2, then you went AP Spanish >> is Spanish 5 like if you want to take four years of language school, that's like your only other option. Is that what that means? >> Yeah. And Spanish 5 is so different than the other um levels of span. By then the um it is an immersive class. Um it is very much literature, culture, history based. It's not focused on academic language as it is as much as it is on really using the language to learn um different aspects of culture. So they fit very well into that course, too. Other questions? Did you want to add anything? >> No, you did great. >> Thank you. >> All right. Thank you. >> Thank you. Excellent. >> Thank you. So the next course is uh not a brand new course to north or south but it is a course that has been being revised uh along the way and one where we want to complete that revision and also uh do a title change a name change for the course.
So, we don't just walk in, I'm speaking for myself, I don't just walk in and say, "Yep, that sounds good. Sign off." I agree. like I it didn't make sense, but for us as a school corporation, once it was explained to me and once the assessment was done or appraisal, I should say, it did make sense. So, I mean, um, I just wanted to address that myself. I'm sure you you guys might have some thoughts as well. >> Well, I I'll just chime in about the class size. Having been a second grade teacher, class size is extremely important. And and I recall the exact presentation you were talking about because for me, class size is always like, hey, how can we get those a little bit smaller? How can we get those closer to, you know, how they were before we've experienced this, you know, kind of insane growth of the last 15 years.
I mean I got to see teachers really welcoming the students and the students were coming around hugging these teachers when coming to school in the morning. Uh I learned some things like the huddles I thought was really cool. PLC's. We sit through a PLC. I thought that was very informative and very productive of what I seen. Um, but I just, you know, everybody's there was a kid that was kind of acting up and I think it was the vice principal. She's walking with us. You keep walking and just responded immediately, you know, to that student. So, just everybody's doing just fantastic work. And you know, we see it, you know, and I thought really thought I know we don't do this and I've been told 100 times, but you know, there's going to be a teacher, there's going to be all these dunes and rolls and stuff and I go in and man, it's just dynamic, you know, and it's just going and moving and stuff.
Any questions or comments before we vote? >> Appreciate >> you first. Uh, mine's mine's quick. I just appreciate Mr. Mberry getting that section plan in place so everyone knows what's going on and how that process will go down. So, I appreciate that. >> Yeah. Thank you. >> I'm curious by nature. the uh Bana Kefir who rescended her resignation. Is there a reason why? What? >> Uh yes. It's my understanding um she was uh you're talking about our salmon. Uh she was one of our adjunct teachers. Uh there's a lot of schooling that goes with that and that um process was um reflected on by her. I know Mr. Peters and uh Elizabeth Kit [snorts] uh Kitchenen has talked to her extently and she is excited to start those classes as required as the adjunct and is glad to be back. So thank you for the question too.
Nobody in that committee said, "Hey, we want to keep the we want a lower standard so that kids don't leave." Nobody said that. That was never the element. It was always we need to find a way to keep expectations higher in our programs. We also talked about conflicting message to our students of a dequalifying for graduation, but then it's not allowed for athletics. So, we said that does that does bring a different message to what we're saying. Why would it not be the same that we we think that to graduate from our high schools, it would also be a higher element? It could forfeit the possibility with lower numbers of participation. They recognize we already have certain sports when if numbers aren't high enough that there has, you know, we have those conversations of if we have to forfeit a game. Well, if you don't have those numbers, you just don't play.
We get a good friends and family. [laughter] they group the projects together for if we're doing summer projects individually they may not cost as much but generally altogether they will and we'll get the rate >> 100%. So it's it's a rate for the overall projects of a summer which might bleed into two summers like the EBA the the east building edition was a project in it of itself which put us over that that 10 million threshold for the much cheaper rate. That's correct. Yeah. Is Gilang supporting other districts? >> They do. >> And then are they charging different rate [clears throat] for different district? They charge us lower than other Oh, >> okay. Don't tell. [laughter] >> Um are you happy with the service that they've been providing? >> I am. And that's a great question, uh, Amy, because, um, as you know, Gil Bane has undergone, um, some leadership changes, um, from their executive vice president, Doug Lim, to, uh, Jeff Masters, who was not only here for 30 plus years, but his children also went through here.
It is a fine arts course and our fine arts department chairs could not be here today. So I just wanted to talk through it uh a little bit with you. Um the course uh has been used in recent years for our percussionists. It's run the last couple of years at South and this year at North. We believe that this revision as well as the title change will really be truth and packaging. It will really explain to our students and our families when they are selecting courses what is actually uh being taught and what students are learning and practicing and rehearsing in the course itself. And so it's really not a complete new course, more of a revision and a title change. And the options there you see under where it says year long with the pass fail option so forth. That's in the existing course as well.
And um you know, the whole graph shows where this is how many kids and this is what it does. You know, if you do a teacher here, pull a teacher there. There's some cohorts where it's like we have a random age group that there's way more kids in that and they need a fifth teacher and then they don't another year and kids come in later, kids don't register who we thought would register. And so it's a little bit um it gets a little bit trickier than it seems. But um from a a schoolboard perspective and with regards to budget cuts, I I can echo uh Mr. war's thoughts on, you know, increased class sizes beyond what we have would definitely be an absolute last resort. Um, and and with regards to the folks who had kind of mentioned that they've been paying a lot of attention, they're very interested.
And I thought this is fantastic. So anyway, thank you for that. I look forward to more of them. And yes, merry Christmas to everybody. Just to piggyback on what uh Trusty Kefir said, it it it was really um heartwarming and encouraging just to see um the care and love that the staff had for the students and students for for the staff, but also just the welcoming environment and I mean we know they're schools, you know, and and but just to see that there was so much um pride in the students artwork and attendance even, you know, where they were getting special recognition on their lockers. And what really hit me um was at one of the schools was the number of children who grabbed that free breakfast. And I wish those that hold the purse strings in the state would would um would know what it feels like to to go without breakfast and to have that available to our students and how incredibly important that is.
Good question. >> Any further questions or comments before we vote hearing? None. Let's vote on the consent agenda. Motion passes 6. Moving on to H1 facilities update award of H&HS window replacement project bid. Mr. Brimberry >> Mr. Allen and board for your consideration tonight. Mr. Thornsbury is actually at another district. He doesn't just work for Huntington. So it it we have proof now that Terry goes to other districts and he is at their board meeting tonight. Mr. Hurdle would normally present this and he is under the weather like many people are. Uh so we're hoping Rich gets better. I will read you Terry's uh recommendation on this process. Uh, as Terry Thornsbury from Vidian Architectural Design previously presented, the HNS uh, HNHS window replacement project includes the replacement of the windows along the front of the building at Huntington North at the doors 10 and 34 in the cafeteria and in the athletic hallway going back to the arena.
And we're part of the AIA. That's part of our our element that we agree to um is to provide those teams. So that's you know and we pay dues to that and everything else to be a part of the AIA. And then finally that last bullet correlation between participation in athletics and student success and and really that goes back to that original point of will it cause students to less participate as they as they move forward. Does it bring a negative impact towards or a negative connotation towards athletics? two things that also came came to in uh that came out in looking at the research. Um, one was would you have great inflation? But we saw that and one is that we didn't see any we didn't see that students maintained that there was no evidence that students maintained the high marks once the season was over.
Um, and now we have, what was, what's nice is that the project executive, which is, uh, essentially the title that, um, uh, Jeff was under, is now, um, Jeremy Rowling. I knew I was going to blank on his name. Uh Jeremy actually started here as a project lead has worked his way up through the company and has been assigned our account to keep that continuity and that historical knowledge that is really when you look at all of the various additions that we've had on our campus is really important when we open up the wall and we know what to expect when we open up the wall. So, >> so sound like sounds like it's been a 20 plus or 30 plus years. >> Oh, way over 30 years. >> Way over 30 years. >> Jeff was here for 30 years plus. >> And the term of this one?
So it hasn't changed there. But over the years we've started to focus more on our percussions. This is the actual description which is significantly different uh that is in our academic planning guide. It does say pending board approval because as I said these courses uh will be up for a vote tonight. Um but we are now describing the course in a way that students really understand what is being taught in the course and can make an educated decision on whether or not they wish to enroll.
Um, I highly recommend checking out our ambassador program for the next group that comes through, I think it's really beneficial. I know, um, before I was on the board and when I was teaching and you kind of I kind of paid attention to board meetings and sometimes it would be like, wait, what's happening there? and and it's easy to kind of feel like, oh, I think they pulled a fast one and there's a land swap thing. I think the more you kind of understand the whole process and the pieces that go into it and everything is multi-layered in ways that don't necessarily not every detail is is pertinent in the moment. But I think as you guys kind of go through, I hope that you trust that your board is asking questions um on your behalf to make sure that we are spending your taxpayer dollars in the best way possible.
And it also makes those those children feel um seen and understood that somebody knows I'm hungry and they care enough to provide this for me. Um so uh I love that I would um love the opportunity to go again and if it's cold I'm going to ride with Trusty Keeper because he has seat warmers under. So that was part two. I would like to say I'm sorry that I didn't make it with the broken back. I am limited to the steps that I can make, but it broke my heart that I couldn't be. I'll be at the next one if I have to roll. >> I'll be there. And I just want to say to all of you, >> you know, it's a blessing to serve on the board with each and every one of you. All of you administrators, all that you do all the time, so often we don't say thank you.
The project includes the complete replacement of the existing curtain wall window frames. The new windows will be 1- in insulated glass [clears throat] with a 3mm safety film for added security. All new doors and associated hardware will be reinstated or reinstalled back to their original locations. For this project, we received five bids. The lowest bid at the time being from Allen County Builders, who's done a lot of work for us in Huntington and has done very well at $922,000. After the bidding process, it was discovered that Allen County Builders made a mistake and did not include the cost of the roofing portion of the project from the approved roofing contract for this project. With that being said, Allen County Builders withdrew their bid and apologized for their oversight. The second lowest bid was from CME Construction in the amount of 958,000. This includes $150,000 project contingency.
That once seasons were over that grades uh when students weren't participating, grades were declining. And I meant that as in a kid who's in fall sport that's not playing after the season's over, what happens there? So there was a lot of elements and I'm just I'm telling you these are just elements we looked at in research. But those were the big pieces. What we wanted to finish with though was what are we currently doing to make sure that our kids are being held accountable. Mandatory tutoring sessions. We do additional grade checks. Our coaches talked about all the different things and what the teachers were saying in the room. Parents said, "Yes, we we know that my kids being held accountable. frequent coach teacher counselor conversations, meaning that there's elements where counselors are involved in and helping to track grades. Um, we have we have schools that set up later practice times so that there's time to make sure that kids are going and getting the extra tutoring they need.