So what happens now every time there's some kind of disciplinary action that has to happen, she has to bump it up to uh either uh either one of our other deans in order to uh uh follow through with any um discipline action or recommendations for uh any additional uh requirements that uh she sees fit for issue may be having with the student. Um and sometimes it having uh operational conflict. So you have a a section there that uh sometimes it creates confusion among staff and her role in her role of what her uh authority is and what it isn't. Uh she does an really terrific job with the uh freshman. She only oversees the freshman. Uh and this would give her uh the requirement uh management uh significant increase uh in working with the challenges that uh she does with students in terms of making uh recommendations and giving consequences to to students that are needed and working with parents getting parents in and not having to always uh take that responsibility and turn it over to other deans who are already have a large load.
Um, just based on what I've seen. Um, so, uh, I just I know that this will probably sail through, but, um, it's just regrettable that, um, you know, the what I've seen in the records to date. Um, and, uh, I just wanted to bring the commission's attention to that. >> Thank you, Mr. Garber. Is there anyone else in chambers who'd like to speak on this matter? Manager Leonard, do we have any remote participants? >> No hands raised. >> Oh, I spoke too soon. >> Not too soon.
>> The 24th doesn't work for Jay, but the 23rd does. >> Okay. I can make I can make the 20 I can move things around and make the 23rd work if that works for others. >> Uh I can make the 23rd basketball game that day, but I could >> I can see if Martha can go to the basketball game >> on the 23rd. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> The there's a basketball game for Gateway, too. I could ask to see if somebody could cover it as well, though. It is the last game of the season though. I don't know. We should probably be there. I feel bad missing it. >> Think about that. There's been some support provided that if you guys wanted to hire a site like coordinator for your school. There's um procedures for doing that at your school all the way down to how you fund it and even the interview questions.
>> Any questions? >> All right. I will entertain a motion that the board of education approved the HVAC equipment and controls purchase as presented. >> Motion by Raquel. >> Second by Katie. Sydney, please lead us in roll call [clears throat] vote. >> Arandu, >> yes. >> Meadows, >> yes. >> Gerals, >> yes. >> Sliger, >> yes. Gonzalez Thomas. >> Yes. >> Gilbert. >> Yes. >> Motion passes. Thank you very much. Item 8.4. Tom, please lead us on this item, the social media litigation. >> Yeah. So, board, I I tried to do the best I could in giving you a little bit of lead time through my weekly updates about this matter. Um this was a more recent development but one of my reflections and I know you're going to talk about the annual joint conference in a little bit. Um but in the reflection on our conversation around personal electronic devices and just concerns that some of you had shared you were hearing throughout your connections in community about uh students both in school and away from school with their with their devices and and social media.
So we have this would be our third dean for almost 2,000 students which is a substantial amount of students for deans to operate. So um that's why I'm asking to upgrade the position to uh um a full dean uh responsibility. >> Any further questions? I'm sorry. >> The expected salary or >> the salary would she would fall in the salary schedule of where her experience lies regarding administration as an administrator. So, uh somewhere I would say at the uh I'm not sure because we haven't done an interview or we haven't posted it yet. I'm assuming it's probably going to fall somewhere in the very beginning of the salary schedule, the lower end of the salary schedule. Henry, >> are we are we discussing this? Are you taking a a mo making a motion? So the we can discuss this or do you does it matter?
>> Alex Lope, you can unmute and address the planning commission for up to three minutes. >> Hi, this is Alex Low, 2532 Pittsville Boulevard. just uh I just want to say that the fact that uh that this will become a non-conforming structure shows a major issue with our uh side setback rules. Thank you. >> Thank you, Mr. Low. >> No other hands raised again. >> With that, I will close the public hearing and read the motion. The Ann Arbor City Planning Commission hereby waves the area plan requirement as provided in section 5.29.7.8, excuse me, A and 5.29.7.B B of the Unified Development Code because no new construction is proposed and recommends that the mayor and city council approve the zoning of 715 and 717 East Hiron Street to R4C multifamily District. Moved by Commissioner Lee, seconded by Commissioner Mills. We are in discussion. Who would like to kick us off?
Just throwing it out there for y'all. I know if I had teachers that were even interested in coaching, I would also hire one to supervise the games, but [laughter] right now the teachers are also tired and burnt out. [laughter] >> So, are we going to go for the 23rd or the 25th is also an option if people are available? Um, I can cancel what I have on the um 25th if Wednesday works better. I can just switch it on one of the game days that they're at. >> I can do the 25th. >> That could work. Is there no teacher? Is there no PD that day? >> Let me look at my coaching goals. But um I'm pretty sure there is that day. >> Oh, it's the um >> it might be. >> What day are we talking about? That's a report card prep day.
Um this opportunity came up uh landed kind of in my lap. I was talking with superintendent colleagues and we were addressing uh I was addressing like what what are others doing and some were sharing things that they had and all of a sudden one of my colleagues said hey Tom have you heard about the class action lawsuit that's been filed and it's a nationwide one but hundreds of school districts in the state of Illinois have joined it and so I asked them [clears throat] to share more information with me. Um so they sent that to me and and I provided those documents to you so you could take a look. Um, I do know some of the superintendents in the districts that are uh joining this uh class action lawsuit and spoke with them and um so I felt really comfortable. Um I did have our attorneys review this as well.
>> Discussing now. You can make a motion. It's up to you. [clears throat] >> Okay. Um unfortunately um the individual in this position is doing a great job. However, I see no need for number one, another administrator, and I've never changed my I've never waved from that statement since I've gotten on this board. There is absolutely no need for another administrator. And second, there's no need for three now deans in that office when you have an assistant principal also there. So that's a little topheavy for me. And as all Chiefs, no Indians. Um I don't believe that, you know, the freshmen take up an enormous amount of time. I think that they're well supported by the the the [clears throat] guidance staff more than they are the safe department. And as far as issuing consequences and things like that, that definitely falls under the jurisdiction of that individual without the title and without uh a huge bump in in pay.
Looks like it's Mills or Lee. Okay, it'll be Commissioner Mills. >> Thanks. Um, I want to start at the end, which is about the non-conforming. That was the last comment that stuck in my mind and and I also appreciate the comparison table as always. I love the tables. Um, I'm curious. Um, it was noted that the side setback is is one of is in your report that makes it non-conforming, but my read of the table is that it doesn't have enough gross lot area either. What is that problematic? Is that uh what is the implication of that? uh you are correct that it's another nonconformity, but since there's the structure already existing that they're not going to expand, then we just look at the lot area to look at uh the number of units that'll be allowed within it. >> Okay. >> If this were a blank site and something new were being built, we would treat it differently.
So that would work actually. >> Okay. >> So the 25th. >> Um and then Jay, are you aware of if we have to present to community council? >> I think it wouldn't be a bad idea. What what I've learned is if you try to go through the changes with community council, you get to see the whites of a lot of people's eyes and their pupils go away. >> But it wouldn't be a bad idea to maybe have a 10 to 15 minute presentation on, hey, you may have heard of this committee before. Here's the work we're doing. Um, we're still potentially recruiting more members, so if you're interested, you know, reach out. And these are the policies that we've worked on. And this is the link and how you would find the information. Please, you know, take the time to take a look at it and provide us with commentary or feedback.
The template uh language and the agreement that is presented to you tonight is uh there is very congruent to what these lawsuits look like. Um there's no financial liability on the district. Um fees would be collected out of any kind of settlement or judgment issued uh from the case. So, the reason why I share this with you is because uh if you looked at the document, if you had a chance, uh you will see I think a lot of this addresses what some of the board's concerns and conversations have been um over the last couple of months. And I wanted to give you an opportunity, an option to take some action if this is something of your interest. Um there's no need to make a motion on it. If you guys discuss it and as a board feel that there isn't interest in it, nobody simply can make just you don't have to make a motion on it.
Again, it's you know, you know, I'm I'm conflicted only because of the person, but definitely not because of the title. It is not necessary. Um, you have an assistant principal in that office and the amount of students. I mean, I'm hearing every day, every time I come in here how great the kids are. No issues. We're doing this, we're doing that, and all of a sudden, we need another dean. You know, that's kind of, you know, polar opposites there. So, while I appreciate the effort, I am definitely not in favor of this. Thank you. >> Mr. Vice, >> um just in line with what Miss Ferry, so I'm um I don't know. I'm kind of confused. Well, first confused and second, um I have an issue with this too. Um because we one got a commitment that we were not going to add more administrators and the second is we are talking about giving this position to a particular individual to cover the duties of the administrative dean.
>> You couldn't build anything on it if it were a blank site, right? Or you a single family home. >> Single family home. There you go. >> Single family home. That's right. Okay. >> Um All right. Super. I just wanted to make sure I was reading the table right. Um, I think overall this makes sense. Um, changing the use and I I do remember passing or recommending uh the change to the UDC to allow for units or for particular parcels within a PUD to to um pull out effectively of the PUD uh to amend the PUD that way. Um, I appreciate the research, Mr. Gerber, that you brought to this, too. I don't know h how to deal with that information. I'm not going to lie. Um, and I guess I would put it on ask staff is it how like I I don't know that we we do such a thing.
Um, that's probably the extent of it because there's just not community counsel just isn't long enough to [snorts] try to walk everybody through the proposed changes. >> Yeah. No, totally agree. Okay. And would that be for the April one? Cuz that's when we usually >> Yeah, typically we bring it to the April meeting >> cuz then cuz I was just thinking then I feel like we need what we had to do last time is we had to have like several meetings in the month like back to back almost like um so maybe like either like when we get back from spring break we would want to do like >> two Tuesday meetings like the 17th and the 24th or something like that. Um, >> do we want to schedule them maybe on the February 25th meeting? >> I was thinking that like and this was very difficult like um so I'm worried that if we don't schedule March out now, we won't be able to get everybody together.
and then we move on to the next item. Um if there is uh interest in it then board members you would go ahead and are there any questions or do you want to have go ahead and have a conversation please feel probably at this time is the right time any questions or general thoughts >> you reviewed it with the lawyers right and everything is is fine I guess I don't see any negatives >> and I like the positive of making kind of stance on it too. >> All right, I will entertain a motion to approve joining the social media litigation lawsuit. >> So moved by Rob. >> Second by Aaron >> Sydney, please lead us in a roll call vote. [clears throat] >> Arandu, >> yes. >> Siger, >> yes. >> Meadows, >> yes. Kilberg. >> Yes. >> Gonzalez Thomas. >> Yes. >> Thank you very much.
Um and the third is we just voted on the maps of contract. So my first question would be um is there a third administrative dean position that is weaved into the maps of or the new maps of contract? Because to my my knowledge there was only the assistant principal and the two administrative deans or one one administrative dean. Um and then the second is my understanding of the limitations behind the job description of the freshman team leader is around discipline. Is that correct? >> Yeah, it's around discipline. Okay. So I mean in my mind I see it as a simple job description fix um and something to be renegotiated with that individual or that position. Um, but I'm not an administrator and I haven't been administrator, so I don't understand that piece. But, um, in my mind, reading the administrative dean's position versus the the freshman academy team leaders, um, I I see it as a job description that needs to be amended.
>> Yeah. Uh so my initial reaction is zoning is set out in the UDC about how we should be considering that and that should be considered by any applicant. Um we talk about this a lot actually in the context of you know types of businesses or the rent charge we um I think we have to be very careful to be thinking about the land use decisions that we are making and those land use decisions shouldn't be appropriate perhaps based on one owner versus it based on another owner. Um we do incentivize some things through sustainability or affordability and there might be change in ownerships but generally my off my initial reaction is I those are the applicant is actually not that significant of a factor for a reasonzoning decision. It is what the plan calls for and the context context of where that is. Um we could certainly um pose the same question as it advances from this body to city council um in the event that our legal council would have any other thoughts on it.
But I am a worrier. So if I can if you want me to chill, I can. Everybody March. [snorts] Okay, sorry. Say that again, Hilda. All right. I think it might have been Evan talking >> that we can look at March. >> Okay. So, then we have break is the 9th through the 13th, right? >> Yes. >> So, what does everybody's uh seven like the week of the 16th look like? Um, I can do >> only concern with scheduling these now is that we don't j like for James and I, we don't know the spring sports schedule. >> I think that >> just put them on there now and then >> I I think bring them up to the team too. >> Yeah. >> Like do like you know like these are not games that the two of us can do. Um because they haven't made it, right?
Motion passes. All right. Item 8.5, adopt or amend board policy. Second reading. Brad, can you are you leading us on this or is it >> Tom? >> So, this um this policy is we've talked about this on numerous occasions. This is not only state law, but something that we want to get a jump on in enacting. So, um, it was a rarity to have all of the board members at a policy committee, but it was really good and we had good discussion about the stance that the district would be taking by adopting this early and moving forward with this. So, this puts us in compliance with that law, but also makes a statement about where Betavia stands.