2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 101
Um obviously when COVID hit um that uh office core was vacated and was not used by anybody for several years. Um DTE realized that they were not going to repopulate that for office uses. And so, uh, the the the condo units were, uh, put on the market and purchased by, um, 414 South Main, which has a variety of, uh, development experience, but was interested in putting in multifamily uses in that space. Um the PUD terms for the high-rise did allow for multifamily, but uh you know back in 1999 when this was finalized, we didn't realize or foresee the the very dramatic drop in demand for office uses or the increase in demand for residential uses or the variety of residential uses that we see now uh in town. Um, so that is the reason that we're seeking to amend the text to accommodate the the uses that are allowed in D1.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 101
So, um, so I went to that and I know Kristen will probably talk about session she went to as well. So, this one caught me a little bit off guard because it was facilitated by uh, an individual that was part of a company that sells a superintendent evaluation software. And I thought I had like walked into a commercial, you know, for this software. and they were really like and they had people on the panel that used the software and they were, you know, singing the praises and stuff like that. So, I was tempted to walk out um because I didn't I didn't feel like that's what I wanted to hear really, but it actually turned into not a not a bad session, you know, and it it talked about and it's not necessarily these are like revolutionary concepts or anything, but you know, talking about goal setting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 102
Just for funsies, um, Ms. Palashius was talking about the restart of the PUD. We were the second one in the queue of starting this process and it was actually three years ago almost to the day that I was here making the same pre-etition presentation discussion to the planning commission. Um subsequent to that we did submit an application but then it was stopped by the department while it worked through that issue of who had to approve an application. In our case, the 48 town houses to the south had been sold. The several I don't know if there four or six units upstairs. So, there were essentially 50 uh I'm sorry, yeah, 56 owners within the PUB. Clearly, we would not have been able to get approval from all of those people to proceed. Eventually, as you are aware, um the city council tweaked that language to make clear you don't need everyone's approval within the PUD.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 102
One of the things I did uh pick up on is um um you know and I and I found this out you know as we're doing Tom's evaluation starting that process is I was trying to you know recollect things that uh happened over the course of the year and they made a point of we should be documenting um significant actions and accomplishments throughout the whole year. So that to me was like a good suggestion and something I hadn't been following and now you know somewhat struggling with to try and um think of things um as I as as we do the evaluation. Um and uh the other thing is uh you know uh goal setting um and being able to uh there's there's probably a ton of goals that we can throw at a superintendent. Um but uh we really need to be um prioritized and we need to really focus in on [snorts] what's what's going to be in the best interest of our students and uh and making sure that those goals then we're supporting that throughout the course of the year um and helping the superintendent to achieve goals.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 103
And so now we're starting back the process. And they said, well, notwithstanding that you've already got an application in because three years have passed. Start at the beginning. So here we are starting at the beginning. We'll have our uh citizen participation meeting this Thursday and we'll see how that goes. Um, so that's basically it. We're requesting uh an expansion of the uses in the high-rise portion only to allow for simplicity sake all the D1 uses that are permitted um to the north. Um, [snorts] uh, Steve is here if he thinks I missed anything and then we're happy to answer questions. Thanks. >> Great. Good evening. Um, yeah, I think Scott did a a great job. Uh, I I just want to just reiterate, um, the the purpose of this resoning to the D1 is is just simply to align the the zoning with everybody else on Main Street, more or less.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 103
by the way, and that's that's another big thing is is we want these goals, but we want to be able to um help the superintendent exceed them. So, um so as we set these goals, we we want success, you know, uh we don't want to set a goal to say, hey, you failed this particular thing. Um in a way, then we failed really if we if we're in that that kind of situation. we should have we should be setting goals to help um the superintendent exceed them. Um, and then the last thing I got out of that is, uh, this is, you know, we got Tom currently, but you know, Tom will not, hopefully he's here for a long time, but he won't be here forever. And, um, this is a good basis as you're thinking about skills and what you want out of a superintendent.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 104
Uh, that that's essentially it. Uh, the structure already exists. We're not creating any new physical impacts or features, no additional traffic, no infrastructure demands, no nothing. All it all it's doing is removing the outdated PUD restrictions that were tied to a one-time development approval and that's it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 104
As you're looking for your next superintendent, you can draw back upon these evaluations and help you to u pick the best candidate to for the for the position. So that was the superintendent evaluation. Um Raquel and I were both in the recruiting diversity hiring uh retention one uh talk. Um so a couple things I got out of that is uh in interesting stuff. It was it was interesting to hear the perspective of the panel. Um they came from diverse backgrounds you know. Um but uh one thing name bias you remember they were talking about name bias and it that that one resonated with me is you know we have a lot of biases and preconceived notions just by you know looking at a resume and seeing a name and we can already have made up our minds about that candidate. So they were making us aware that, you know, you got to, you know, understand that that's a real thing to have those biases and obviously try to avoid them.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 105
So happy to answer any questions from anyone if if you have any. >> Great. We'll have the staff presentation and if we have questions, we'll call you back. >> Thank you. >> Yeah, you're welcome. Planner Melen Cochran, do you have a presentation for us? >> I do. And I will just um share screen really quick um so we can see um just the zoning. So this is uh a zoning map that the applicant shared. So you can see this is the high-rise, the tower portion um that is outlined here in this PUD district and we are on the cornerish of Main Street and William Street. Um okay. Uh just a few uh general reminders about the PUD process. So this is a pre-etition conference which is a required step uh to apply for and receive approval for a new planned unit development or to amend existing PUD supplemental regulations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 105
Um, another suggestion that was brought up, which I thought was pretty good, and Stephen, I'm not sure how often we do this or um, but they said, uh, sometimes having school board members at the recruiting fairs, >> um, is a good idea and that helps. You know, kind of shows candidates that, you know, serious about the position. You know, you have the school board there trying to pitch and sell you on coming to their school. So, um, maybe we're doing that. Maybe we have done that in the past, but that was another item that came up. >> I can let people know. >> More than welcome to join. >> I'll just build off of the one um which uh yeah was really interesting. Um and I think now with the generation of social media like uh candidates will automatically go to our website to see what what do we have.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 106
Uh which is why we're here tonight. Um and then tonight the planning commission may offer comments regarding the appropriateness of the proposed land uses, the proposals conformance with the adopted master plan and policies and the beneficial effects to be achieved. And that's from uh section 5.29.11 of the UDC. And I'll just add a couple more things. So like the applicant said, this is really just about uh amending the PUD supplemental regulations to allow for all permitted D1 uses just in the high-rise portion. No changes to the low-rise portion and no proposed changes to the site plan. Um the original PUD zoning um and site plan were approved in October 1999 and since then there have been three changes to the supplemental amen supplemental regulations. Um these were in 2000 2003 and 2007 and both of those in 2003 and 2007 were for adding permitted uses to the supplemental regulations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 106
So if you know someone is minority group, they're going to go and they're going to look to see what's on our website. Do we have diversity on our website? Because then that will tell them we are a diverse school district. Um, local school district was on the diverse picture. >> Oh, that's right. Yeah. East >> Easter was on they had one school district that was not as diverse and then they had Easter on there. Go top. Um, and then it was just um because and I think that kind of ties into like that belonging whereas like representation matters, you know, and if a student sees taught by someone that they reflects mirrors them, you know, they're going to have that belonging. Um, so yeah, it was it was a really I feel it was a really good discussion. Um and like there was one she was a former superintendent retired and one that's a current superintendent of a local school.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 107
Um, as you can see here, to the parcels to the north are zoned D1, downtown core, and to the east, west, and south, they are zoned D2, downtown interface. Um, the applicant mentioned that this was first proposed um a few years ago and did not move forward uh because of the requirements at the time for all owners to approve any modifications to a PUD. So, that has now changed. Um, and this petition, like I said, would constitute the third revision to the supplemental regulations that would um increase or change the permitted uses in the high-rise building. Again, those two other ones were also just for permitted uses in the high-rise building. Um, the increased flexibility in the proposed language would allow for all permitted uses, including uh short-term rentals. And this was also noted in the staff memo that was presented at the preud conference that was held um a few years ago.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 107
>> Yeah. The one was the state superintendent. >> Yeah. >> Uh so I went to dollars and decisions 101. Uh was >> Tony waits with baited breath. Sounds excellent. [laughter] Sounds really good. That sounds exciting. >> Tony perked up all of a sudden. >> Uh, and you know, it it was interesting. They provided explanation of the board's role in shaping school finance and um focused on debt management and budgeting, return on investment. Uh it was interesting because we were at tables and we were given examples of kind of um imaginary school districts that have you know there was one that reminded me of our school district because there was a school district with faired failed referendums. They had to had buildings that needed to be updated. Um and so then as a team we had to decide how we were going to allocate funds and how you know are we going to look at health health life safety bonds.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 108
Um overall I have included um in the staff report the original findings for benefits in that were included with the original PUD. Um and staff does not believe that the proposed changes would negatively impact the original findings that established this district. Uh the site would still be developed with a mixture of retail, residential and office uses in the downtown and uh the development is surrounded by D1 and D2 zoning. So the downtown permitted uses would be appropriate. Um I'd also just like to note that uh these supplemental regulations were originally written about 25 years ago and the way that we write supplemental regulations now is different. Um and we try to make them a little bit simpler and have more flexibility. And so as part of this, staff is likely to support additional changes that would simplify the language and interpretation. Um mainly reviewing and removing outofdate language, things like vehicle parking, um references to chapters that um are now no longer correct, things like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 108
It's very interesting. Um so yeah I definitely worth my time. It was great. And then the other one I did was the superintendent evaluation. Uh some which was also excellent. Um some there were a couple things that I took away that I thought I would bring up here. One was that they recommend it was through IASB. They recommend um that before we do our evaluations that the superintendent does a self evaluation. Um probably too late to do that now, but it might be something we want to discuss for next year. Um The superintendent does it and gives it to us to review. >> Yes. >> Which I think would be helpful to hear from Tom what he feels his successes or challenges. >> Yeah. You mentioned that to me and I don't know why I didn't think of it because that's what my own company does, >> right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 109
Um, and I'll also note that the city attorney's office is also considering proposing changes um to section L affordable housing and they are working with ownership of the low-rise um the town houses to propose updated language that would clarify that the affordable units um can be rented rather than just owned. So, this is the first step in the POD process. even though it's just changing the supplemental regulations, the process remains the same. Um, and that's all I have for right now. Thanks. >> Thank you, Planner Meline Cochran. Appreciate your presentation. There is no public comment or public hearing. So, um, and there is no vote. So, we will start our discussion uh from here. Which, uh, planning commissioner would like to kick it off? Okay. Commissioner Mills, then Commissioner Dish, >> maybe this is a theme. I'm going to start off where you just left off, which is about the affordable housing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 109
Our staff writes our own self evaluation like you know so and it's just a it's a way to provide context and it also helps us remember those things we may not have remembered. So yeah. Uh, so that's one thing we could discuss in the future. And then they also suggested having a less formal like midyear check-in to see how things are going. Um, and then I think that was those were the main takeaways that I saw. I felt like we are we're on a pretty good path, especially talking to other people. I mean, there were there were school districts that they're like just starting to do superintendent evaluations. >> This is our year two, so [laughter] >> side of it, too. >> We are on a good path and maybe, you know, there were some some steps we could take to improve things, but we're we're on the right track.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 110
I think this makes tons of sense. And I mean, the question in my mind was at what point can we just take PUDS and say we're just going to reszone it? Because um you don't have to necessarily answer that, but that's one of the things that I was just thinking of. The question that I really had was about the affordable housing component of this and I didn't read from the original supplemental regs whether it needed to be in the low or the high-rise and I just wanted to make it is in the low. Okay. Cuz I just want to make sure that that's not lost somewhere along the line. So, as as long as and and that you talked about it and I noted that in the staff report, but just wanted to make sure that that the changes because it's possible it's possible that it's not housing that comes here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 110
All right, I guess it's my turn. Uh, I also went to two sessions. The first one I went to was called Leading Schools in a Highly Polarized World. It was led by Dr. Ronald Thomas from Towns and University. And it was basically his discussion focused on learning how to depoliticize school improvement and empower stakeholders to work together. And I guess his thesis was sort of three-pronged. It was you need to develop a vision and goals for student learning shared by the majority of stakeholders in the community. Then use evidence to document the current reality of performance areas for strength and growth and then identify systems with the most potential to make a significant impact. He also spent spent a significant amount of time talking about how you can have the best people in the world but if you have poor systems they will fail. So you have to have strong systems in place to for success.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above