And so putting um now the and and really I think the larger kind of question is yeah I think it's like if this wanted to be a hotel like is that wrong? I mean and I'm looking that I'm thinking of that from the standpoint of okay we have talked about the changing conditions of hey like we need we need to improve affordability. This is a you know downtown zones generally tend to command higher rates. We'd love to see an affordable component of it. I'm just thinking from again practical utilization of the building footprint. We have to kind of ask ourselves is this um like by saying hey we don't want STRs in the rear of the space or something along those lines. And I'm I'm just trying to I suppose articulate some of the actual dimensional challenges that office buildings face when it comes to uh converting use to full resi.
Um, so I hope that over this break everyone can take the space to empty their schedules a little bit, slow it down, just pause and just be with loved ones or be alone with the book, whatever it is that you want to do, just take space just to kind of, I don't know, recall the year. Um, and I appreciate you guys all going over the triple I conference. I wasn't able to go. I can't line up child care and my all of our family live out of state, so I wasn't able to go. I may be following up with some of you, but I really appreciate you guys taking the time to go over that um and to share what you your the points that you um took from it as well as like what we do when we go over committees. It's just really helpful um when you guys are sharing about schools and everything like that.
Um and then also asking kind of a larger um question as to um the the role of tourism within economies versus sheerely from a I'm just thinking from like revar adrs those are um terms that you would use average daily rates revenue per available room as you look at tourism and also visitation and and the kinds of revenue that folks tend to spend especially when they're visiting downtown zone. So the question being like is this I think more and and so I think that by looking at it from a PUD amendment standpoint we may be pigeonhold to say like hey um we'd actually like to see affordable um you know be be a part of this kind of discussion. There's a lot more I think discretion when it comes to amendment of PUDS. Um whereas I think the question of like consistency um we heard about resiliency um you kind of have to ask yourself like the downtown core does this fit the overall kind of like pathway of land use patterns that we have talked about and uh so yeah but I just also ma mostly I wanted to talk about the challenges of creating full utilization when there is office buildings that have like a huge depth to it and So that is just one of the challenges again geometrically um uh folks will face.
I used to love being able to go and just personally with my change of my schedule, I can't. And so I just love that you guys do actually take the opportunity to really spell out what you're what you're seeing um what you're experiencing. So thank you. Please keep doing that. Um, the only other thing I want to bring and Katie kind of actually hit on it with her triple eye shares. I just want to just want to remind that I did want to uh make sure whether it's January, February, uh, to bring that discussion to the table for the student voices, >> uh, student um, board members. >> Okay, >> that's it. That's all I have. >> Uh, I don't want to be too repetitive. By the time it gets to me, I'm like, "Yeah, what they said." [laughter] Um, I really appreciated the opportunity to view the CKLA curriculum.
Um so um all that to say uh I I think you'll find that with this body affordability is at really kind of at the core of what we are looking for and to really promote. Um, obviously STRs detract from that and I think there's a right I mean literally it's like it could be a family that lives there for a year or it could be a transient, right? Um, but I think the question that you may want to re uh ask is what is the appropriate land use function of this particular parcel as it transitions? Um, uh, well, no pun intended. I know we we're going to talk about transitions um a little later on, but uh so just wanted to articulate some of the challenges geometrically with activating deep um corridors and office buildings and natural light. Thanks. >> Thank you, Commissioner Lee. Commissioner Nordon, >> Could I um ask the petitioner?
That was really cool to watch. Um, that was a great day. I walked to Louise White one way and then I went home and had some lunch and then I walked to JB the other way. Um, and I just spent a whole day in classrooms and that was really, really nice. Um, thanks for the building presentations these last few weeks and I just wish everybody a safe winter break. Um, and I hope we all find uh moments of rest, joy, and belonging. >> Thank you. Um, only thing I will I won't reiterate everything that was said much better than I would have ever said it. So, thank you for putting it in the way that you did. Um, I will state, you know, that while I do want to say an appreciation for everybody to get their rest and break, that I'd like for us all to remember there are people that don't get time off during this time of year that have to not only work for a living to keep feeding their families and everything else, but have to slay the dragon at our building so that they are ready to be back in session at the beginning of the year.
I'm trying to figure out what were the special benefits of the PUB that justified what were the public benefits that justified having it be a PUB pud way back when? How would you characterize the core benefits that it provided? >> Right. It was um there were a variety of them, but part of it was the difficulty of constructing the site under an existing zoning. So the PUD I would say that city council was uh aware of the difficulty of putting that whole package together. Uh but the benefits were you know downtown uh diversity um contribution to the you know the benefit the um activity of downtown pedestrian activity on Main Street. There was the affordability um issue. who you guys talked about the eight units that was a huge factor back in 1999. It was very difficult to figure out how to do. I I'm only saying that because I was the one that got it approved.
So, this is for a lot of staff, this is a little bit of a reset moment while they work to prepare for the next year. So, not only mentally, but also for many of our, as I called, 12 month workers that may or may not get all the time off that some others may get. So, um, appreciate all the time and effort put into this year. Um, and I appreciate you guys as well. Keep up the good work and I know you will and thank you. And with that, um, we are going to be moving to close session. So, um, the band will go to the board will go into close session. We will not ban. That's a good one. band. [laughter] >> Yeah, we will not end rehearsal. >> We will not have any action. >> Pile it back, dude. >> We will not have any action items after the close session.
And so the affordability part was a major part of the PUD approval process >> and the and the mixed use >> that was part of it. It was all I mean it's right in the the report that you guys there's a summary of the benefits that the city >> So what because you just said that changing this supplemental regulation wouldn't diminish the public benefits that justified allowing the PD in the first place. >> I don't believe it would. I mean I believe that the the same benefits are still there. I mean, in fact, as Commissioner Lee mentioned, um, you know, there was a concern then and even now about people spending money downtown, um, and in trying to improve the vitality of the downtown retail and entertainment value. Um so the conversion to multif family which has already happened arguably has you know produced more of those benefits.
You're welcome to stay here if you like, but if um you do decide to leave, we want to thank you for coming out this evening. The time is and I will entertain a motion to move to close session as allowed under open meetings act for the purpose of exception 5CS120C1. Motion by move >> by Raquel. >> Second by Katie. >> Cindy, please lead us in a roll call vote. >> Yes. >> Meadows? >> Yes. >> Kilberg? >> Yes. >> Thomas? >> Yes. Right. >> The band. The band. He's going to session.
I mean there was back then there was a discussion about okay how do the DTE workers go out at lunchtime and spend their money because at the end of the day they all leave. Well, now you've got a better uh I would argue um population in that building that are spending I suspect more money on a daily basis in the downtown core. >> So I think I don't have a strong sense of I'm not heading towards some kind of an agenda but um I do think it is correct that but for the PUD this property would almost certainly be D1 or D2. It's kind of right at the edge of between a D1 or D2. So reworking this in a way that makes it consistent with D1 would be make it entirely consistent with what would have been there. But for the PUD, PUDs are different from byite zoning because you have the whole idea is you're a developer is proposing something unique and different than what would be allowed under a clunky zoning code provision, but it's allowable because it's providing some public benefit that you wouldn't get otherwise.
I think that's appropriate. I get really nervous when we we when the city starts seeing that as a way to leverage things out of a developer kind of in a coercive way. Um which [snorts] would make me nervous about saying well we'll we'll let you amend your PUD supplemental regulations if we get something out of it. I think that's kind of heading down that road. So I that's why I'm asking would making this change diminish the benefits that were in place in the first place when the PED was allowed and if not then there's still benefits to the PUD being there just in some reconfigured state. I'm kind of thinking off the cuff a little bit here but I also want to be clear to the petitioner and I read some of the comments. I looked through the materials for this and the comments from some of the folks who showed up I think at your public participation meeting who were pretty skeptical that you really have some kind of ulterior motive going on here and it's not just because you're trying to make it consistent with the larger neighborhood and and I'm I'm just telling you what I read um what I'm hearing is what you want to have is the option to be able to do something different within the future in a timely way without having to come back and request a resoning.
So, you're kind of thinking ahead and trying to get there. Is that correct? >> I'm sorry. Hold on for a second. Uh, Commissioner Lee, I mean, Nordon, are you >> specifically asking the petition? Is >> that what you're trying to do here? Yeah, [clears throat] >> it it it's long-term viability. I want to make it very crystal clear to to uh the the board here, the commissioner here, that we have long-term rentals in the apartments right now. They're in the 90 plus% rented. So, we don't have any plans whatsoever uh now or in the immediate future to do any change. We have no reason to make any change to um what what's being described here today. Um, so but it's more about long-term viability, long-term flexibility, long-term sustainability uh of this property and and and we were very very sensitive to that. >> Yeah. So, I guess in the spirit of giving feedback on this preliminary conference where you're supposed to be getting feedback >> and and seeing the people's concern that you're trying to be sneaky here and you're not really telling us what you want to do.
>> We have long-term leases. How could you know there, you know, we don't have any other motives here. We have a management company that's there. We have long-term leases and we're taking leases. We're we're signing leases for 2026 and beyond and 2027. As a matter of fact, >> put a point on my comment. I think saying that you're doing this just to make it consistent with the rest of the D1 doesn't rings a little bit hollow. To say that you're doing this because you want to have the op option to do things in the future like everybody else in a D1 district does that. Okay. At least to my mind that makes more sense. >> Well, that that's that's sort of That's just feedback for you. And then I think as I'm just >> noodling through this, the reason the way to think about it is this is a change to a supplemental regulations on a PUD.
That's not a reasonzoning. It's more akin to a text amendment. Um, and you would approve it if it is makes sense given the conditions in the in the neighborhood and the things that have changed. and for a PD it would make sense especially if it doesn't un diminish the special public benefits that justify doing the PUD in the first place. So those are the things I'm thinking through now we also are going to have I mean this will open the door to allowing anything that could be in a D1 district which is a lot there's a lot of stuff that could happen but that's not any different than it what's could go on across the street or next door. So, I'm just kind of putting this on the table as we think it through. Thank you, Council Member Dish. >> Yeah, and that's why I read uh the list of benefits that I I don't think I think this was meaning to be current, a current list.
Um encourage a dense land use that will foster an active street life, encourage diversity of housing opportunities, and strengthen downtown's role as an urban neighborhood. Those were listed in their memo. And in my view, the conversion to residential in no way harms those. I think it advances them. But if in future, let's say more than 20% of this building were converted to SDR, I'd have a problem with that because I don't think that's consistent with those benefits. But I understand that I may be a minority view on the board. But I I do want to state that because it is I agree with Commissioner Lee that STRs are not um STRs one buildings that are largely STR. We are hearing feedback from residents that I take seriously um that the buildings can be empty a lot of the time. It does not contribute to a feeling of neighborhood.
It contributes to something else. I don't know what it is exactly. And but for me, it is a matter of proportion. It's not a moral, you know, none of this, none of that. And so I would want to because to me, those things that they list in their memo are not diminished by the conversion to residential, but would be if in the future something over x%. And I'm thinking 20 just to be random uh were converted uh to STR. So, and I understand that there, you know, that that may not be a shared view, but I I think that I am reasoning exactly as you want me to reason and I'm coming to the conclusion not that I'm trying to leverage something, but that I do have an opportunity in the way that this decision is playing out because we're being asked for to make a change.
I have an opportunity to to ask to to make an amendment. >> Yeah. We're not voting on anything today, right? We're just >> We are not. We are not. This is just a discussion. >> Are you done? Council member. >> All right. Uh, Commissioner Weatherbe and then Commissioner Lee. >> So, I'm I'm not sure if this will help or hurt or but I remember when this was built and I remember the uproar when it was built. Um, and it was going to ruin everything, but it was it did replace the downtown hole in the ground that actually had a song, the downtown hole in the ground because it was just a giant hole in the ground for a really long time. And this finally came through and the affordability and there was a lot of issues about the affordability and if that was good or bad.
And as I recall, the walkway through was considered a public benefit. Um, which is why I always walk through there because I figure it's mine and I can walk through it if I want because it's public. Um, but you know, this was just uh this was an office building. It was full when there were power outages and all the DTE trucks came in and all the DTE people came in. And um I I think I look at it as you know what's our worstc case scenario is that it's short-term rentals or a hotel or and this seems like a pretty appropriate place for those things. I don't know that we can I I personally am not swayed by whatever the petitioner says because that's not it could be a different petitioner in two months. it could be. Um, and so I, you know, I really have to go by kind of whatever we're re whatever the is, whether we reszone it to D1 or whether it's a amendment to the PUD or however we decide to do it.
Um, you know, we can't take a petitioner's assurances because that's just not really unless it's written down is not a thing. Um, no offense, but [laughter] um, but to me, I I don't the sort of what if this were a hotel, which or a shortterm rental building. I've stayed in one in Chicago that's just a old building. They took an old building and it's all short-term rentals. And um, you know, those things exist now. They might not exist in the future. There might be a lot of them in the future. We don't really know, but uh it definitely I I think this is a reasonable use of sort of it's it's really right downtown. And one of the problems is that it's not quite we haven't given it downtown ability to exist. And why that's always kind of a little it's a little weird and it's a little because it's across the street and there's a gas station that inhibits sort of the downtown feel and then like we made all the mountains and the windows have to be there.