2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 146
So then people can't see in and they can't so the retail isn't great. So, I think things have changed and this is a building and a development that helped change those things, but now it's kind of behind the times of those changes. And so, I'm I think this is a reasonable whatever however we get there. I don't have particular feelings about whether it's I mean I think this is shows why PUDs can be kind of annoying because [laughter] like we they don't change with the times and then you're stuck looking at something that's 25 years old and we're just having to kind of say I don't know I guess it's okay if but you know 25 years ago it could have been a hotel and it would have been a functioning hotel all these time years and we wouldn't have cared because it would have been a hotel right downtown and So, I I think um again, I'm not sure if that's I'm not sure I'm contributing to this, but I'm just saying like I I just I think it's a reasonable it's reasonable.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 147
Whatever any of these uses, any D1 uses, I think would be reasonable here. And however we get there, I I don't think it's an unreasonable thing to ask. >> Commissioner Lee. >> Cool. I I'll make it quick just um for when you underwrite a hotel just by way of STRs or whatnot you generally try to assume um 60 to 70% occupancy you hope to get 70 sometimes you'll range from 50 to 70 there's seasonality as well so I think your concerns about its impacts to sense of community uh you know within the actual you know the transient nature of things is is well placed um so I think that there's a real um concern to be had um the I I think the overarching question for me especially with the context of this is is there a deprivation of the public good that was envisioned at the PUD level.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 148
Um and I'm just going to repeat kind of what you had indicated which was best interest of the surrounding properties in the city of Ann Arbor. The downtown area is preserved and enhanced by providing highdensity mixeduse development on the site. High quality of architecture and site design which I don't think we lose. strong pedestrian orientation. I think we still have that. Enclosed and below grade parking. Okay. Um and a variety of residential units on the lots described above and with a beneficial effect on and will not adversely affect the surrounding properties or the city in terms of public health health, safety or or welfare. And so I I [snorts] really think um our and I suppose maybe if the question is posed is are does STRS have a detrimental impact on the health, safety, general welfare? Um I I think reasonable pe people could probably disagree on the um community activation of like an apartment building versus one with a certain ratio.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 149
But to me, I think it's more important that we focus on is there a a detraction or a deprivation of the public goods sought and agreed to at the PUD. Um, and I'm not con I'm not particularly convinced that there is by, uh, you know, changing this to D1. So, um, so to that effect, um, again, those are just, uh, I I I suppose I don't necessarily see a huge issue with this. So, thanks. Any other commissioners? Commissioner Nordon, >> thank you for your I'm trying not to beat a dead horse, but >> please don't beat any horses. >> Try not to beat any horses dead. Um I think it's usually the case when someone requests a resoning, they have a particular use in mind. I want this resoning so I can build a hotel. This is a little different because there's something there and it's working and you're requesting effectively kind of a resoning and everybody's trying to figure out what are you doing?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 150
What's the secret behind the door thing you're really trying to get at? That's what I got out of the stuff I read. So, I'm just trying to respond to that. Uh, and and my council to you was just to kind of think about that as you think through and go forward your proposal about what you're trying to do. It makes sense to me that you're just looking ahead and want to have the freedom and flexibility to do what everybody else in the downtown can do. I think that's okay. I'm just suggesting that might be the statement. [clears throat] >> Have you asked a question? >> Um, no. That was just friendly. That was just friendly. >> I can clarify something for you though. >> But he hasn't asked a question. >> Um I could ask you could you clarify it quickly. Just really quickly the >> what what you're asking there was there was a case for uh uh there was there was a company that approached us four years ago when we first bought this thing to do short-term rentals.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 151
That's why that subject came up then. Right now, we're doing just fine as multifamily. We're doing great actually. Uh and we're very pleased with what it is, but we want to keep the options open should something arise. Uh as developers, we just want to make sure that we have all options available to us for the long-term viability of this project. That's it. Nothing else. There's no there's no agenda. Um like I said, we have leases into 26 and 27 right now. So, um, we'd be foolish to stop what we're doing right now at this point. >> Okay. >> All right. Thank you. Any other feedback from commissioners? >> Planner Marie. Uh, Melen Cochran, do you have any feedback or clarification for us or the petitioner at this time? >> Uh, no. Just that if you got all of your recommendations and you feel good, then that's all we need.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 152
>> Great. So, it sounds like if I were to do a quick summary, I'm not going to um take up uh former chair Lee's uh summarizing abilities uh which were so great uh to say you may want to uh come back just as a a clean D1. Um it seems like that might make a lot of this uh easier and um we look forward to uh your petition should it arrive. >> Appreciate you. Thank you. >> Yeah, have a great evening. Thanks for joining us. All right. Thank you. That brings us to 11B, other business. And I believe we are going to be joined by uh principal planner Michelle Bennett. >> I know it it changes a lot. [laughter] I hear it change like at city council and other places. So, I'm trying to keep up with the times. And as you get um settled and ready to give your presentation, Mr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 153
Monroe, can you come up? I wanted to I'm going to use the the privilege of the chair to understand something that you said that I did not quite get. So when you were talking and thank you for coming up for Yeah. [laughter] When you were talking about the 250 ft buffer from our natural features inventory, let's assume no one knows what you're speaking of, even though it's in the record and it is accessible. Just give me a sentence or two of what you have in mind as you are making this uh recommendation to us. >> Yeah. So, um what I have in mind is what I told Brett on Saturday is kind of my gateway drug to the whole comprehensive plan, right? And it is this boy that's an entrance place. Uh [laughter] yeah, it it's a place that's been near and dear to my heart and I can honestly say for my entire life, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 154
I grew up by Argo. Uh even when I didn't live in Ann Arbor, when I came back to Ann Arbor, that is the place where I went, right? And uh if you all are familiar Longore Drive, right? It's this lovely dirt road that kind of curves away from the city park, right? And historically there has been steep slope right and woodland which are in the natural features inventory which are pictured right there in a picture that is actually outdated and probably should be updated to reflect the devastation of the woodlands and that steep slope right um and so what what I have in mind is that my understanding is that development occurred without a site review that's my understanding and so If we're saying that we're going to protect our natural features and yet there's this loophole that allows our natural features to be destructed without site review and the UDC says the way that we protect our natural features are through site review.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 155
I think that's a hole. And so the 250 ft I also want to add as you've watched it like I've watched this construction they have not just impacted that side of the road they've also impacted the other side of the road which is also in our natural features inventory and so you know that's where I got the 250 ft buffer granted that road is not as wide as 250 ft but I do think it it's a reasonable place to start the conversation. >> Okay I think I I understand better now. Thank you so much. I'm going to direct my question to staff. I you're good uh for from my point so you can have a seat now. Thank you. So uh Mr. Leonard um this development in particular was on private land and on private land that doesn't require a site plan review. >> Well, private land is not the distinction.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 156
>> Great. This is this is why I was starting this this way because I knew you would jump right in and give me the distinction that I needed. So uh the uni unified development code sets thresholds of what scale a project requires what level of review and Mr. Monro is absolutely correct projects of that scale don't require a site plan review. Um they can be they're still reviewed to make sure they meet setbacks and the like. But a distinction that I think he is raising is that when we process a building permit for either a new home, a new quadplex, multiple single family homes, what have you that fall under that category, we do not require tree mitigation. We don't require the the all of the natural resources. Those requirements and review are done for site plan review, right? And so what uh what happens is as in the past we have set that threshold um partially to frankly control the cost and impact of different scales of development.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 157
And so >> because the site plan is more than just the natural features remediation cuz now you have to invite almost all of the city's departments. So you've got to bring in engineering, sanitation, traffic. So the cost to a development would be significant and assuming that was a u a mono uh structure um that could be cost prohibitive for them to build on a parcel of land where they by right could. But >> I think Mr. Monroe's point that he made this weekend and now is that the city has the ability to set what that threshold is though. So, >> yep. All right. I I that was helpful. Uh and I appreciate the indulgence of the table. Not that you could stop me, but uh I was using the privilege of the chair to get uh that clarity. Uh planner Bennett. >> Yes. >> Are you ready for your staff presentation?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 158
>> I'm ready. >> Excellent. Well, I will turn it over to you now. >> Great. Um in your packet under the this item, you should have four attachments. I'm going to propose how I think we should go through them for this evening with any modifications that you all want to offer. But I would suggest that we start with the document that has the edits that we discussed from last meeting. I want to show you all the notes that we took. There were a few instances in which you asked staff to come up with the wording for some things. So, I'm going to draw your attention to those examples first. But anything that's on here is open um for us to talk about. But this these are edits that you submitted for the November 18th meeting. We discussed and took notes and here are here they are for you to correct the record if you think that we u missed anything.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 159
So I'd like to start there and then secondly you have the comments that are being submitted through the engage page on the project page. You have all 500 and something of those. So after we go through our edits, I would open that up for you if you want to bring any of those up for discussion that we can I can take notes on here and add to our running list of edits for next time. And then um as a part of that, I also included an updated future land use map. Not updated in that we changed anything, but updated in that there were requests to have a higher quality map. So those are in there. That's in there. and we can open that up and see if that's um to your all's liking. And then lastly uh was the memo that um Chairman White had brought up where I walk through the process of um future land use map to zoning map to text amendments to resoning kind of laying out that process of how things um will go and how they currently go and how they will go.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 160
Um, so if you all are okay with that, then we'll start with the staff edits. >> All right. Uh, do we have any feedback from the table? >> Um, uh, Council Member Dish, sorry. >> Thank you. Yeah. Um, in general, these all looked great to me. I checked over, but I was conf I was confused by the first one. >> That's a new one. So, I was going to draw your attention to some I was asking a slightly different question, which is Do we have any feedback on the proposal from uh planner Bennett? Okay, great. You you have made your comment, planner Benner. Go ahead. >> That's a great segue. That's where [clears throat] I was going to start. So, if you can see under discussion, um so that would be page two. Page two in the document you have, but it is referring to page 57 in our third draft of the comp plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 161
So, um Brett, if you could share your screen, um I want to direct you to the map. This is a staff edit um that came to us recently. Um, and to be clear, this map already had a few questions from you all and changes that you all wanted to be made, particularly regarding the major walking barriers that is indicated by the orange lines on some of our um corridors. So that was the original kind of ask from staff or I'm sorry from planning commission but staff had came back to us and thought that um because they are going to be starting the new pros plan coming up that they feel like it would be best for them to sort of categorize and reimagine you know what counts as a community park what counts as a neighborhood park. Um this map on page 57 lays out that community parks you know they have their own definition here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 162
they're 5 acres or greater. Um, and so they had asked like, could you remove that for now and replace that second bullet point um, with the text that you see here? So there's on top of that, there's another option. We could completely remove the map if you all are okay with that. Um, that would give us more room for formatting. or if you feel strongly that there should be some reference to parks there, you know, are other maps of just our park system for example that we could add. >> Sure. Uh, council member Dish. >> Okay. So, I I don't necessarily I'm not I don't feel a pressing need for a parks map. I'm fine with removing this map. I like the language that says replace the second bullet point with the following. And so if that's going to go in, that would be great because I hearing this a lot about the lack of parks.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 163
So I like this language. >> Any other commissioners? >> Great. Oh, Commissioner Norton, I didn't mean to say I was just reacting to the fact that I was moving on and you interrupted. Please don't hear anything else. >> Um, that's fine. I'm thinking though that we make it clear. I'm trying to remember up at front at the start of this comprehensive plan, we say this plan is replacing yada yada yada, but it will work in conjunction with was the pros park plan one of those that it will work in conjunction with. So, we're not like getting rid of this. We're just saying that's the place to go to get the more detailed information. >> Correct. >> Okay, great. Thank you. Can would I think it would be better if commissioners have concerns about anything that's in here instead of us going one by one? I don't feel like >> I was planning to go one by one.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 164
I had like three or four that I was going to show you where we actually wrote something new. >> Okay. But >> which which direction do we want to go? Are there table comments or do you want to go with the four new ones? >> Okay. All right. Go. Well, so do I have clarification that this is a supported change from >> Yes. It doesn't look like there's any opposition uh to the staff. >> Remove the map and replace the language. >> Yes. Okay. >> Just if for everything in the spirit of clarity um when you I don't even know I don't even know how to say this. I think what I want to say is there has been a lot of controversy around the parks >> and removing the map I think will feed into a narrative that there is something untoward happening here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 165
So out of an abundance of [snorts] communication and clarity, we should note that this change was requested by the parks commission. And um once that process is finished, a new map will be created and a future version will include that just so it doesn't feel like it's being it's underhanded uh in a sense. Go ahead, uh Commissioner. I I I'm right in line with you, but maybe a little friendly amendment. I would kind of add both both of the text, right, to remind folks do the replacement that's proposed, but also add the rationale to remind folks that the pros park plan is one of the plans that's done parallel with this plan and it's currently being updated and revised and that's the place to go for that information so that we don't >> so it's clear we're not >> I like that. That's a that's a good one and it's just an overabundance of communication.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above