2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 186
>> Oh, okay. [laughter] >> I I trust that everyone has read it. Um I did and I thank you for it. Um but any discussion >> you I will you include um petitioner initiated resonings. >> Mhm. >> You don't talk about council initiated resonings did or did I miss it? Um I think I talk about that in the sense that the future land use map is essentially like a city backed either you know by council like I think I was trying to show that the future land use is sort of the precedent for that um and that's how we will be planning to reszone the city but that additionally petitioners have that right as well >> and I the the reason that I asked for this was there is um ambiguity about how resoning happens. I think a lot of people in the feedback that I'd received only know about it through the city initiated process but were unaware that at any time anyone can come and make a um resoning petition.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 187
And that was just what we were trying to highlight so that it doesn't because part of the feedback that we were looking at in particular was um around the fact that we're making um a plan that will create a set of code that will initiate resoning. But it ignored the fact that individual petitioners could come and do it. And there is a process for that. It is already spelled out in the UDC. And what was helpful for me when I met with uh planner DO is she she gave me a a helpful insight to this. She says once the plan is approved, even before the UDC gets changed and new zones are created, petitioners will come and ask for a reasonzoning because they're seeing uh to use a uh a biblical term uh which is really just a Greek term, the telos. They see where this is all going and so they want to they want to be there right on time.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 188
>> Yeah. So, >> which is all fine. I And maybe this is a bit formalistic, but um >> anytime you label it, [clears throat] it's >> a [laughter] bit formalistic. I would I'm just going to suggest you've got process for reszoning and you've got a subheading for petitioner initiated. It would be useful to have city council initiated as a second subheading and it maybe only needs to be a couple sentences that you know one of the reasons you update a plan and then you look at the zoning is to see are there places we need to update the zoning code to now reflect the plan. That's kind of what this whole plan update is about. And then in addition to that, it's always the case that petitioners are coming before us and asking for resonings. So this this memo will become its own freestanding document.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 189
And I think it would just kind of it'll take on a life of its own. It would be helpful to have that extra subheading and have a little bit of an explanation. Is that making sense? >> Yeah, I have no objection to that. >> Any other feedback? >> Yeah. Go ahead. >> Just to say thank you for the language around transition. That will be very helpful the way you describe it >> in this memo. >> Yeah. I I hope that helps. I I I'm I'm trying to explain trying to assuage any fears that like um that there isn't that there isn't a process when we are in between that time when we have adopted the plan but haven't it rewritten the UDC. What kind of happens in that limbo? That's what this memo is meant to address to show people that like we still continue this process and that it's been on it's been on the books and will continue to be.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 190
And then my I think I put it in my comments to you um planner Bennett, but I think we would benefit in the new year maybe between the period of the plan being approved by this body and it being approved by the next body that if we could have a presentation on just like planning 101 could just go back and just sort of help people understand how the UDC gets activated. The idea that there are um plans that get reviewed by staff but don't have site plan, therefore they don't come to this table. It just some of the bigger issues that I don't think a lot of people grasp, but there are assumptions about and if we could just have a a little section on that. It could be a staff presentation with a discussion and we can figure out the format. But I would actually invite the public if we could figure out a way to do it in a in a uh organized way to ask their planning questions like you know we just set aside some time and it's like fences like this neighbor's on a corner so the fence over here looks like this and their fence over there looks like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 191
Oh, well, it depends on where the position of the house is relative to the, you know, the other pieces. And I just feel like any demystifying that we can do, um, from my point of view just establishes more public trust >> in the process. And if we can engage the public in an orderly fashion where they feel heard and we can respond with information, I feel like that helps engender trust. So, I would just propose that manager l >> 100% agree with that. And just uh put another plug in. We don't have any more at the end of this year, but next year we will be um rescheduling a couple of our what we call A2DU. Um just to put a plug in for that. That's where we send our um planning team out to different um places in the city for basically an open office hours.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 192
And that's a great opportunity for people to also come and want to understand the nuances of a fence or how to do this or that. So, um that's I totally agree. I think that's a great opportunity for this board, but there it's not the last opportunity. >> Yeah. And I I think the reason why I'm proposing it here is the the number one uh criticism that we receive is there we're not in a dialogue because the nature of public comment is it's your time and then it's our time. But if we schedule a timelimited dialogue and we can u administer it orderly, I think that can help sort of take a little bit of that away so that someone can say, "Hey, I think this thing got reszoned illegally." And we can say, "Okay, let's pull it all up and we can show you in UDC exactly how it got resoned." [laughter] Um, and how this all works or lots, you know, we're looking at a lot that was already a double size, but we thought it was a lot combination.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 193
And so therefore, we're doing something underhanded and it's like, nope, this this is the law. So, we actually have to follow the law. And that could be an hour um on a on an agenda where we just have a initial presentation and then we have a a bit of a form if there's a way for us to facilitate it that fits all the legal statutes. I would love any feedback or discussion or objection to that if you have it. Okay. Fantastic. All right. So, I think we're done. Oh, no. We have 523 comments to review. [laughter] So, how would you uh propose to do this? I have I I just have a couple things out of the public comments that I wanted to raise from my review. Um, did you have an orderly way you wanted to receive these planner Bennett or are you just open for us to uh share with you?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 194
>> I'm open for you all to share. >> Excellent. The chair can't go first. So, who would like to go uh to kick us off? Oh, Commissioner Adams. >> Got a quick one. >> So, um John Hilton wrote in [laughter] >> um suggesting that our discussion of the history of We have a discussion that's lengthy regarding the placement of the plan in history that refers to how the city became segregated and how that segregation was uh enforced informally and formally which he argues to be inaccurate fundamentally. Um, I reviewed his arguments and I don't know that I agree, but at the same time, I didn't write that section and I'm not a historian and some of it is cited to and some of it is not. >> And I realize this is a homework assignment more than it is like feedback, but it is something that I think we really got to mail.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 195
Um, it's a pretty serious discussion within the overall document and he's alleging that it's just false. >> Yeah. Um, so we just need to go back and who I don't know if it was consultant drafted or staff drafted, but um, if if the response back is we use passive voice in that section to slide over some complexity and nuance, I think I'm reasonably comfortable with that. If we think he's right that it's making inaccurate claims, I think we got to make some guesses. >> Okay. Yeah. >> Uh, Commissioner D. >> Yeah. uh I flagged the same thing and I read it carefully and I have uh taught some of this history and so what I took away from I took I did not fully agree with him. I do not agree with the statement that segregation was not based on city law. I think minimum large minimum lot sizes was quite clearly something in city law that created racial segregation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 196
So, I I just think that, you know, and I'm sure that if he and I had a conversation, we might come to see that similarly. But he did mention that we do not mention Ann Arbor passing the first open housing law in the nation in the timeline. And we might want to put that in because that did happen. um uh it it was relatively close in the time of adopting those minimums. So, it's a very complicated history, but I think his comments boil down to you left this one thing off and you blamed the city for segregation and that's not fair. And I'm I'm being a little bit crude, but if I'm boiling it down and so yes, I think it would be great, as Commissioner Adams suggests for staff to look that over, see if they feel good about the whole thing, but I would just recommend sticking in where we uh the city passed the first the nation's first open housing law before the federal law required it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 197
Great. And I would add um I was on a I served on a panel with Dr. Matthew Countryman uh from the department of history here at the University of Michigan who also knows uh the local history. They've mapped all of the houses that were owned uh by black families in the Kerry town including the churches, the business, the social uh setting. So he might be a resource to um doublech checkck uh that uh information. And I also would articulate that it is not entirely the case that the city did not use its enormous um rules and laws to enforce the segregation because the city received I sent you this um uh document. the city received block grants from the government to do selective code enforcement. And that was a um a tool that they used uh to um displace African-American uh families who could not qualify for uh insurance.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 198
Uh while the city of Ann Arbor did not have uh a um red line map, they did have uh the fire insurance map was a tool that was used to um deny mortgages to African-Americans because they could not get fire insurance and therefore they could not get a mortgage. So it was another uh tool that was there. So there are a lot of um both overt and probably not so overt tools that city government and the community use to um segregate. Um so Dr. countryman has I think um probably from from my vantage point given that panel I think the best pulse on it and he would articulate that Ann Arbor was ahead of its time uh as a progressive community uh because it actually permitted an African-American community to to live here and then we now have to understand how that community was displaced and so that was a that was a collection of tools both formal tools and informal tools uh for that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 199
So, I'm happy to make a connection. Um, >> thank you. I appreciate that you look into this. >> I'll do it tomorrow morning. Anything else off the off the top from anyone? Go ahead. Uh, Commissioner Dish, >> I have a very short list. Um, uh, we received many comments that are asking us to resolve the residential or transition category. And um I think that the memo that you have written is a great response to the anxiety around that. Um so I just wanted I what I'm trying to do right now is just address that we're not not listening to these comments but that this is our response is that um you know that is going to be hard work [laughter] and it's going to be done. when we sit to think about that. Um, we keep on hearing about shading of solar and I can't remember if we ever got any language about that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 200
>> I thought we did and a present. Oh, no. I'm thinking of neighborhood week. Uh, there was a planner who did a whole presentation on shading. Um, a former planner. I can send you the link. it was quite exhaustive about specifically Ann Arbor and how the building heights affect um others. So there's a couple things that I remember. Uh one I thought in response to that partially in response to that was the capping heights and als in residential and also making transitions height context sensitive so that there wouldn't be that issue or we'd help mitigate that issue. Um Missy Dr. Stoultz from OSI um asked some researchers to look into it at U of M. They had some preliminary findings that it wasn't um that severe and so I think upon hearing that we didn't um put a ton more in the plan on that topic.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 201
>> Yes. And so I'm glad that you uh reminded me that we can cite th the two things that you're talking about that we did do in the plan. Um, [sighs and gasps] yeah. I don't know if we should put I mean because people are feeling like there's a contra that like the city's working at odds with itself with its own policies. And if there were something we could cite to say, you know, it's not all day long unless you're, you know, in some kind of canyon in Manhattan, which is not really what we're going to create. Um, but I don't I don't really Yeah, sorry. >> Maybe we could follow up with OSI if they've it seems like we sort of heard the conclusion of that, but we don't really have the detail of it. Maybe there's some way we can take that to a referenceable finding in some way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 202
>> I confess I think that this came through either right before my summer vacation or right after and so it got buried. Um, but I think it was that uh Dr. McGra had finished a study that she's an architect that included some figures showing throughout it's it's not so much they don't necessarily show throughout the course of a day but at the at throughout the course of the year like when there would be shading and when there would not be shading. Um, and so I will figure out I think I don't know where that is public, but I I saw something that was finalized. [laughter] Um, so I'll put that on my back. I'll dig it out. >> Yeah, it was looking at like winter solstice, summer solstice, and then I think it was like 9:00 a.m. noon, 3:00 p.m., 6:00 p.m. And it was three stories.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 203
I think it didn't go higher than than four or five stories. um right next to a single family. >> So there there were a few different scenarios. So we can dig that out and see where >> we can refer to that in the plan >> and that might be something to that Toddman might be interested in putting online that then you could refer to. So that's what I will actually follow with because then you could reference it. It would be freely accessible actually. So just for what it's worth, part of the conversation was I think it's a really cool analysis that other communities might have interest in and one of the things that my center does is to try to share these kind of things and the feedback was it is very specifically tailored to our latitude and so we should not necess like >> there there are limitations to generalizability and so this was very much for Ann Arbor it was based on a 5ft setback distance which is what we have in R one B I don't know which one one of the um one of our specific zoning districts and so there were some questions about whether it would be super useful to generalize it so I didn't put it out through the center for empowering communities but I I will follow up with Jen and see if she's interested in being able to put them on top to reference >> that would be fantastic and then it's easy to just have a couple sentences and a reference to it and to maybe state explicitly that um by capping heights in residential and making transit trans transition contextsensitive, we are aligning [snorts] this plan with the solariz program that is an initiative of you know I might have put that too strong but uh you know um I'm asking only because I'm trying to be uh responsive.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 204
We were asked to provide guidelines on conflicts between historic districts and underlying zoning. But I think that there there wouldn't be a guideline. I mean, the point is that the historic district I don't want to say trumps because I really don't ever want to say that word, but um but that that's the guidance, right? I mean or Yeah. >> Yeah. There is underlying zoning now. >> Yes. So, >> right. And you can only do what the historic district allows, right? And what the district commission approves and there are certain things that cannot be approved. And I think we've said that many times. So I think this request I I don't know the exact one you're referring to but I have met with the old west side and I think there is some fear around any mismatch between underlying zoning and what we're proposing and there is some overlap in the old west side where we are saying that it can be transition and so I think there's some question about like what's the precedent behind that if um if zone if the underlying zoning now says that it can be a certain height What position does that put like the HDC in when they have final say, but they also have, you know, the underlying zoning and their own guidelines.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 205
Like there just isn't a ton of precedent, I think, for that. And that worries some people in that area that live in that area. I I don't know if I call president but an example is recently [clears throat] there was a large scale development just north of the Michigan theater. The literally the historic district boundary is basically along the back of the buildings that front liberty. It doesn't include the properties along Washington. If you look closely in in that development there's actually two buildings as part of that development. There's a smaller building that is accessed basically only off of the alley. Um, and then there's the larger building. I would say that that is an example where that building in the historic district despite similar zoning for both of them happened at a different outcome because of the convergence of both zoning and historic district regulations, >> which is always the case unless the the um historic district zoning is or uh um designation is removed.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above