2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 206
And so the the land use imagines what that land would be if there wasn't a historic district there. And that was how we drew it on the map. And um it is now restricted by the historic district designation which would require a uh vote of council and [snorts] then a vote of the neighbors or the folks inside that zone and the Michigan legislature. So I'm I'm not sure how else to just you know sort of offer comfort uh to the group given that there are three layers of if you will protection. [clears throat] Um there uh since Commissioner Abrams is not here to say Abrams is not here to say this um I do want to note that there that I do still find in the comments reference to proposals that are not in the plan such as proposals to reduce or remove lot sizes, setbacks, and other regulations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 207
So >> yeah. >> So what's the edit? >> No edit. >> Okay. It's not [laughter] an edit. I'm just making note because this is one thing that Commissioner Abrams did one time. It's just saying can't address this because it isn't a thing. Um, and uh, >> well, I mean, under 1.1, it says reduce or remove minimum lot sizes, adjust setbacks, and other regulations to allow more flexibility. Does it say minimum lot sizes in 1.1? >> Remove minimum lot sizes. I'm looking at the implementation matrix under 1.1. >> Yep, that's Yeah, and it was quoted differently in the person's comment. So, I believe that they are not understanding the intent of this because >> But you're not proposing a change right now. >> Okay. No, because that's part of zoning. And it's not as if it is not as if the proposal is that everything will be allowed to take to go from lot line to lot line.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 208
There's no >> there is no proposal for adjust right there's no nothing like that. So um and then uh I think we I mean I have raised this before what Mr. Monroe is raising which is that because our natural features protections are right now triggered by site plan review and this plan envisions more things being by right and bigger things being by right. there is I wouldn't say a hole but there may be there there may be a shift um and I would not I would not reference the particular thing that went on on Longshore because that's a different thing that was a lot split and whatever so um we can consider having building permits trigger those um but we need uh trigger natural features protections, but we also need to consider the limits on what we can say that people can and cannot do on property that they own, which is where we are now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 209
And so I do not suggest a change to the club. I think this is just something that we will wrestle with when we move forward. And that has been my understanding all along. It's not that we are unaware that we are making a change, right? Or or so I put this out. Is there anything that we should say that anyone feels we should say? >> Good. Commissioner, >> one of the reactions I had reading the public comments was the um there's a lot of folks who are commenting as if this plan resolves um all of the land. I'm I'm chuckling cuz it's it's sort of a startling like task to think about, but um imagining that we're addressing every issue at this table. The length of the document would signal that and I think that I didn't quite appreciate that in January that by making a document so big and so all-encompassing, we have in fact signal to people that we're doing everything here and that nothing can be done after the fact.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 210
I think that if there's a desire to do something on that level, I think separate and independent factf finding needs to happen and it needs to be done carefully because I've already been in front of the ZBA like three times and just to do renovations on my house. That's a highly regulated house that I have. Um, and I would hate to have to like I just cut down two trees to put a solar array in. I would have hated to have come a fourth time in front of some panel to get permission to add solar panels or cut down a tree. So, I just it's not to say we don't want to do that or that the balance we're striking is right. It just feels late in the hour and outside of our scope. Uh, Commissioner Norton, [clears throat] >> that's so I'll point out I've had people complain to me and we've heard lots of comments that this plan isn't nearly detailed enough [laughter] and how much more detail we need to move and then we and then we get but this plan is so long I can't wait through it all.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 211
There's just too much here. So, we're definitely trying to and and need to strike a balance. That said, I'm troubled that um if we have standards to protect natural features, they should be standards that exist to protect natural features that shouldn't change based on whether or not you had a site plan review tripped or not. They're they're standards that should apply. Either they apply or they don't. It shouldn't be it's artificial to have it only apply because we've defined something to require site plan review. So, but I don't think that we can resolve that problem in this plan right now because that's not the level of detail we're getting at. So, I'm looking on page 152 at the at the goals that are speaking to natural features and I I'm wondering and maybe I'm kind of looking at staff and maybe you can come up with the right verbiage, but it sounds like in the process of doing the things that we said we should be doing, which is to update regulations and processes to reflect current ecological understandings, part of what we should be doing is revisiting the code to make sure that important natural features aren't slipping through the cracks.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 212
um because of artificial requirements or something. So that in the process of updating the code, we need to be mindful that we don't want to create loopholes that actually defeat the purpose of having natural features protection. Can we just add that sentiment somewhere in that text so that we don't so it doesn't slip through the cracks? >> Is that goal 10? >> It's goal 101. >> Can you suggest So you want it to say >> I can I can noodle on I keep use the word noodle. Um I can think about this when I can send you s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s suggested if that's okay with folks. >> I think generally it's okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 213
I just want to highlight that this is the current code currently. So the the plan doesn't change it. This is how it currently is. >> The way it's currently working. It sounds like something's wrong with the way it's currently >> which is from from one point of view the plan is not making this change. This is something that already exists and I started to look at the map around uh 250 ft from that inventory. I think that would it would prevent a lot of development. It would actually change almost everything. So in order to look at a buffer from Mr. Monroe's suggestion, we'd have to see it in a gsi map like we see TC-1 to see what it would actually prohibit. And if every tree is um fitting inside that criterion, which it currently is not because it's by site plan review, then almost nothing can be built because of the fact that we have 1.5 million trees.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 214
So it's trying like I I hear and wanted to clarify what I was hearing and I think it is potentially worth us revisiting the UDC but that is coming. So once the plan is approved, if it's approved, the next phase is the UDC amendments and that is the appropriate place to say how are we handling natural features and what is inside review and what is outside review. And I think we should do that in light of um we also need to do that in light of uh potential downstream burdens that we would put on land owners that we have not considered. I mean, we have petitioners that come who are frustrated with our waste management because they have very strict rules for that. Um, as I talk to planners, I hear very clearly whatever the fire marshall wants, the fire marshall gets. Like that's a rule, but it's not written in the UDC.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 215
So, those things are they have implications um on the development environment. And I think it is also um slightly at odds with um the economic development memo uh that the city administrator um sent and has been uh instructing some of the work that we've been doing to try to simplify development in the city. So we have a lot of things that are at odds um with each other. Not to say, you know, I I have five landmark trees in my backyard, so none of those trees would be able to be cut down and no additions can be added um you know, for the same purposes that um Commissioner Adams uh just noted. So, I just want to make sure that we recognize that what we're actually discussing is in the current UDC. I can appreciate that we may want to strengthen what we say in the comp plan and if that's what your uh proposed language is, I have full support of that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 216
>> Totally understand what's going >> but I don't want to get ahead of the UDC uh [clears throat] uh process because that's where it'll be managed. >> If the language we have in the plan is signaling strongly enough that we should revisit >> natural features protection to make sure things don't get slip out because they're in loopholes or whatever. But see, that that's the part I I'm I'm probably not uh it's been a day. We've had uh two ill kids at home and I've been at home with them. So, navigating all of that. I'm not currently sick, but I'm wearing a mask even if I was. >> I'm not. Let me step back and say, >> yeah, >> um >> I don't know. I'm haven't studied the UDC to know if what's going on there is could be characterized as a loophole or if that was a policy choice that was made or something.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 217
>> Sure. And so that that's the part that I'm >> told that we would only apply standards because we've defined some some things to go through site plan review and others not. >> Right. So you're you're you're at a I guess what I'm trying to say is the the scope of what we are talking about. I feel like the thing that you are questioning which is valid and should be debated and discussed is out of scope because the this current plan is not proposing to change that. So, so we're not saying >> is signaling that we should be revisiting the whole UDC to advance our new goals >> and when we get there that's where we could directly address the plan is signaling strongly enough that we recognize that that's something that we need to and maybe it's already there. I mean I someone could convince me the >> I'm not trying to convince you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 218
just trying to make sure that it was the slipping through part I think was it like I I would be in a different position if the plan said um you know all these things are now going to no longer um have this review and I think that's the piece that uh Mr. Monroe is trying to get at is that if more things are going to be by right, does the by right automatically mean no site plan review? And so how does that then fit inside that criterion? And I think that's maybe the thing we need to process, but let's hear from uh commission uh commissioner Adams and then we'll hear from staff. I haven't turned to my left. I just wanted to say I mean I I think the plan as a value expresses plenty of support for the preservation of natural features. I think that the specific claim that there's something about our current udc that's arbitrary I don't agree with.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 219
So to the extent that there's a desire to make a proposal, we need to do it some other time. I don't like I think the plan is adequate on the on the on the policy. It's not making a specific recommendation for changes and I'm not in a position to support that. I don't I don't agree that site plan review as a trigger is arbitrary. It I actually think it reflects a rough policy choice that certain types of larger projects need that type of review and merit that type of review whereas my solar array does not. >> All right. Um, manager Leonard and planner Bennett. So uh I don't get to vote on this plan but I think goal 10 the highle goal there I think gets to this point. It's to balance development with protection and integration of critical natural features. So I I I do think that the plan explicitly identifies the goal of finding that balance.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 220
Now, I fully agree that the nine members of this commission, the members of my staff, let alone the members of this community might have differing opinions on what success looks like in that regard. And honestly, that's probably why it is framed as it is. It is not saying, you know, and I think Commissioner Dish, to your point, part of the part of the start of this was I think there was a desire to at least not lose ground. And I think it's fair like when we're talking about opening development, are we going to lose ground because of different byright developments or whatever that goal [clears throat] tasks you and the city and staff of finding that balance and I think the ordinance development is the time to do that. We heard some examples here in about you know trees in my backyard or whatever. Those are great examples that there's a lot of ways to do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 221
Right now we don't prohibit the removal of lame trees. there's just a consequence and we could change what that consequence is. >> A quite expensive one because the housing commission had to come before this body and apologize and pay a fine that was almost $100,000 for that landmark tree. >> The other the other piece of it is is that we rely on we rely at times on a not insignificant cost of a site plan. So we know exactly what features are on that site. And so um so there's a lot of considerations to go here and I do think that the ordinance is the right time to do that and I think that this conversation is evidence that this commission is mindful of what that balance is. But from my perspective I think the the plan calls on you and the city to find that balance >> other commissioners.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 222
Oh, sorry. >> Yeah, I just want to reiterate. I think that is why balance is is selected, right? And it's not more strongly worded because we are being asked as staff, not just in this department, but across city staff to help try to sol solve the climate crisis, the housing crisis, right? Um, and we have pages, we talked about this a lot earlier about these trade-offs, right? Not every single site can be the most affordable, the most dense, have the most trees, be the most suitable for solar, right? At some point, we're going to have to decide what that decision-m framework is. And so, I think that language is trying to say like we have a lot of things we have to balance. We do respect our natural features and we will get to that later. So I think you are both correct, Chairman White and Commissioner Norton, that we don't have to solve all the loopholes right now.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 223
That's for the UDC. But it is time now to say like, do you think this is hitting the point that you want to set us up for a UDC rewrite later? >> So I think that's what I'm trying to get at. I totally get that we're not going to solve the problem here. We're going to solve it when we revisit the EDC. Is the language the way the goal is sten stated sufficient to signal that we expect to do that when we get to that stage and make sure that we're taking steps to protect and if everybody in the commission is satisfied that it's strong enough then I'm fine with that. >> Want to make sure we've thought about it and make sure we're comfortable with that. >> Yeah. What say you all? [snorts] [clears throat] >> Commissioner Mills. >> Yeah. Sorry, you you saw me.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 224
You're thinking. So, I am looking on page 152 because I and I flipped back to the to where we talk about goal 10. Overall, I do think that this is the place. I actually think that the language on 152 has some here's my observations. The very first part um the very first non-bolded section under 10.1 says um blah blah blah maintain 2025 regulations. So that suggests to me that we shouldn't slip the m the maintain the regulations like I think is the nod to let's not make it worse. But I also and in my mind I toyed around with like do we change that maintain to um evaluate because I think that that gets into if there are pro things that are broken right now but I I actually think that that could potentially make it worse. So like I I like the idea of maintain.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 225
There was some language earlier on in the earlier chapter where gold 10 was actually introduced that said something about like site review and and that made me think like oh we're only talking about site plan review but in the very first bullet point here it [snorts] talks about um incentivizing quality rather than quantity in open space and space requirements within the zoning code. So it's not just within site plan review which again I think that that can be interpreted a little bit more broadly. Now this is only in the context of open space but but this is it's open space to protect critical natural features. So I think I think that actually if somebody wanted to think about this in the future when we take up this bullet point that's the place to do it like I think that that gives us the flexibility in language.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above