2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 226
Um, and that that language that I was talking about that made me feel like it was only about site plan review um is linked to the second bullet point here because in the earlier text it talks about earlier consideration insight review but it doesn't it's not repeated here and I think that this is this is our implementation matrix. So this is what we're going to look at and this is not only insight plan review. The second bullet it's it of um result in earlier considerations. that doesn't say doesn't say specifically site plan review. It just says within development sites. So that is my rambling way of saying I think it's covered. And also for people that care about this topic when we get to this when we get actually to implementation that I think that um those are the places where we'll be able to come back in and say um hey we might have some loopholes now and the language doesn't say that we're like we're it's entirely about balancing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 227
It's not um uh opening more gates necessarily. So, yeah, that's what I was thinking. I'm comfortable with it, too. >> All right. It doesn't look like there's support to make any change. >> I'm okay with I I wanted to have this conversation just to make sure we're on the same page about what we're doing and so thank you. >> Yeah, absolutely. U Commissioner Weatherbe >> just to now the only thing in that with your second bullet point it is in the four to six year range and I don't know if if that seems fine or if which one in particular the develop and incentives. >> Yep. >> Yeah. the the the time frames are are tough because the thing is we're going to be writing the UD rewriting the UDC at once and so that whole process could take several years. I think this might just mean the ones that say one to three is where we would start.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 228
Um, but that's all up to you if you all want to make that >> Yeah. I'm not saying that's unreasonable, but it sort of signals maybe not [snorts] as important or >> as like a ongoing or one to three, you know, >> would you like to propose something? >> No. >> Okay. [laughter] Commissioner Dish, uh, you had the floor, uh, with your list. Have you finished your list? Okay. Other commissioners. Oh, the chair. Oh, thank you. Uh, let's see. Uh, Mr. Garber wants us to change a whole bunch of uh words uh because of resiliency. And I wonder um so through those seven comments, are there any things we can extract out of those that would be helpful? Um here that would strengthen our commitment to the com to the climate um and our understanding of that. and the challenge that we find ourselves in.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 229
So I think a lot of the feedback was just the the term isn't as meaningful and useful um in the way that is used and it's used a lot in the in the text. >> So the recommendation is to strike that word. Well, I'm I well a I'm asking the table um thoughts about how we can through our words strengthen our already present commitment to uh the climate. So we have the millage we're taking affirmative action all of the time uh to that and is that is that effort equally uh reflected in the plan and I think Mr. Garber's comment as I understood it was the use of the term resilience is is not as useful. Go ahead uh Commissioner. >> Um I I think I understand what Mr. Garber is concerned about. I'm I'm thinking like an academic. The academics debate all the time over the use of terms and they can always find out reasons for why this is a bad term and it doesn't d and you can kind of go in circles.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 230
So, I'm a little less troubled that we're using the term resilience maybe too much. The thing that I struggle with is is I understand as we've had conversations in the past, some of the things that we're being asked to require through the plan, we can't actually require because of state law. >> Correct. >> And so, what I'm trying to figure out is does the plan make clear enough what we have agency to be able to address versus what we just can't do because it's state law. are bound and our only recourse is to go lobby the legislature. >> So, and I didn't have a chance to study Mr. Garber's comments. >> Well, and and we do now I think under this current administration, the city now has an a lobbyist uh at the state level because I know I wrote a letter when I was secretary to the federal government uh to lobby for uh some initiative that we were looking at here.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 231
And so I wonder if staff could take a look at our current lobbying efforts and see if any of those efforts to affect positive change towards the climate could be reflected in either our implementation guide or in the code itself. So just supportive language. So when we talk about X that's followed by a climate millage that was passed by the city. It's followed by lobbying at the state level. It's followed by um ongoing initiatives to address the climate and the the crisis that we find ourselves in. Something along those lines. >> Okay. So, the recommendation is for staff to look at our lobbyist efforts in this regard. But is that >> just to see but just to see if there's any way we can strengthen what we're saying um inside the plan >> as an action? >> No, I guess a reflection of the efforts and work that we have already undertaken and are undertaking.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 232
So does and I'm and forgive me the you know I've read it and I've read it again but I haven't committed it to memory. Uh so like do we even talk about the climate millage that we've put in place. So that could be something that would be added, you know. So like a for example, all I'm looking for is like maybe a a parenthetical somewhere where we say for example our recently passed climate mill, our lobbying efforts at the state level and our ongoing efforts to um meet the current climate crisis. that would be the kind of >> so OSI has reviewed this every single draft and they have added in many instances um those kind of sentences of things I was unaware of. So there are several um kind of four examples or four instances of where we connect and where they're already where they're already doing things.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 233
Um >> would that be adequate? >> I think so. I mean I can talk to you offline too. Um well if I can I don't know if I can never know how that all works but it's just towards this end. I don't think there's any objection from the table. >> So I don't have an actual edit at the moment. [clears throat] >> We you do not >> I think I did just check under millillage and there are many millages that we mentioned but we do not mention the climate millillage. >> There is an edit. >> Is it in the timeline? It should at least be in the timeline but >> I don't know >> if it's missing then we can add it. There's an edit. >> [laughter] >> Okay. >> Yeah, there there's an edit, right? >> Yeah. And this is what I made, Mr.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 234
Leonard. So, the sustainability, climate, natural resources policy agenda. So, if we just reference that, I think that that at least says that it's we're not paying lip service to it. We're actually um taking affirmative action uh in the regulatory environment we find ourselves in. If we had a more permissible regulatory environment, we'd be able to do more. >> It is in the timeline. Okay. >> Okay. I when I search under a millillage I didn't >> I think uh the other millages are referenced in boxes and it says a little bit more about what they're doing and so maybe I mean it'd be very easy OSI is constantly generating factoids about things that they're that that have you know increase in solar and all that kind of thing and using village funds to do it and that might be great. Um, do they mention the Bryant decarbonization?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 235
>> Yeah, I was going to mention that one, too. >> Yeah, let me look under Bryant >> in this plan. >> Yeah, >> we had an image of it and it was removed along with the cartoons, I believe. >> Oh, it just got scooped up in the in the cartoons. >> Is it? [laughter] I thought we had removed it. >> No, no, not the image, but the but the project is O. I hate laptops. 88. Page 88. It does. It's It isn't There isn't detail. Um. Yep. And also it Yeah. So 88 actually we mentioned the shading thing and it just could be augmented a little bit with the language about transition stepping down. There's a place like right in there to fix that. Um yeah. No, this is good. But and the you know maybe a little bit more specificity on what the millillage the climate millillage has done would be helpful but I don't I don't really want to make this a homework assignment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 236
It's very late in the game very late in the game >> to me. It was just a parenthetical so not not a big um a big >> but that's supported as an edit for us to discuss more about the climate mill what it does and also BR community decarbonization efforts. I I think given the magnitude of that project and at this point now we do have the Department of Energy $10 million grant that's really coming through. >> Okay. >> It it warrants a little bit because it's like it's a national it'll be a first. >> Well then we don't need to plan for it since it's already done. >> Maybe we plan for more humidity. >> We've been out there drilling those geothermal holes as we speak. So there were four major uh areas that I saw in December. Uh it was around the transition which I think the memo addresses.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 237
The historic district which I think we've already addressed. There are ongoing conversations around affordability. I I think uh Commissioner Adams uh addressed some of that tonight in his uh comments uh which I appreciate it. Um and then the infrastructure uh concerns which you brought up uh planner Bennett at our work session uh last week that there is um still a large uh comprehensive plan that is happening around infrastructure. And so the plan already references it. And so I just wanted to note that as I look through these comments, those were the four repeating um uh comments that came up. And then with regard to the affordability questions, I just anywhere that we can in the afford affordability where the plan speaks about affordability that we would point people to the housing appendix. Um because I don't think I'm I'm beginning to believe that people haven't looked at the housing appendix because a lot of the questions that I hear about it are addressed in the housing appendix.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 238
But I don't want to um make a disparaging remark about whether or not someone has read something. But it is there. It is in the plan. We have a whole appendix for it. Um, and so I just want to um, state that on the record again. And if you feel like there are places inside the plan where staff could just refer to it, see the housing appendix, I think that that would be helpful uh, for folks who might be scanning um, and not looking at the whole document. And given on engage they're in two separate links, >> I think a lot of people don't realize they're actually forming a single document. other commissioners. Oh, >> can I go back? >> Oh, yeah. Sorry. >> In terms of the word resilience, are we suggesting an edit there? >> I I did not propose one. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 239
>> Commissioner Lee, >> I I thought Mr. Garber's point was well taken um in the sense that, you know, I advocate for clarity and simplicity wherever there can be. I I do want to avoid jargon at any point we can. That said, I do also think there's actual value to the concept of resilience. So I I guess this is actually one in which um the ability to adapt, overcome and come back stronger is the kind of concept when we talk about social resilience or um physical resilience, things of that nature. So, um I don't have a proposed change, but I do want to acknowledge that um I agree with his sentiments about simplifying or making it more plain. Um that said that I actually do um think there's still value in the concept of resilience. So, I don't have a proposed change, but just want to acknowledge that I've given it thought and um still don't have a change to propose there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 240
So, thanks. >> Thank you. Any other commissioners? Commissioner Mills, >> as we were having the conversation about the changes, first of all, I really appreciate you put putting in specific changes. Like there's a lot to dive through and a lot of the comments were really long. Um, and having being able to search for page like what the specific changes are was really really helpful. So, thank you. Um, many of these I feel like I I really hate to punt, but I sort of want to know if OSI supports them. I mean, I think that a number of the changes are really strong. Um, and some of them make me think like I don't know. I I I know enough to know that it could also go sideways for some of these things. And so I'm curious um about what that would be. And so if I were to do anything, I before making these specific edits, I I would love OSI to weigh in on them, which I don't think is part like I wasn't I don't know that that was the plan.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 241
So, um, so that's for and I kind of use that same lens for any of the others comments, which honestly there weren't tons of comments that were specific page edits. Um, and so that um, that's the filter that I would have here. I don't know if that works in our proc like our timing wise. Um, and I confess that like I I can also go through them all 32 31 31 separate edits um to to see if there's specific ones where I think I just had I did not do my homework to come to this meeting having gone through all of them. I confess. So are you you're referring to you're not referring to this discuss the climate millage and the car in the Bryant community decarbonization. You're talking about there are more edits in the packet that you're looking at that you would like OSI to review.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 242
>> Yeah. So within the 520 what is it 523 >> 56 >> 523 lines there are number that are from Mr. garb broken like 31 comments broken down specific edits broken down into multiple and it it's super easy to follow. I just confess there were 523 lines in the spreadsheet and I didn't do at all. Um so I I think that there are some elements and I kind of want somebody else to weigh in and I'm not prepared for that right now. So maybe that means that I missed my opportunity and I'm sorry that I failed. Um, but that I would suggest that that would be something very e like specific rather than going through all 523. Like there's there's some that are extremely specific edits and like does this from a staff perspective make sense? I would love to know that and I think OSI is well positioned to weigh in on some of the specific changes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 243
Um, again I on the conversation about resilience like I completely agree with Commissioner Lee like there's pros and cons of using something that is like that and um and I'm looking at the one right now about emergency response and shelter. Like actually that's what a lot of folks are thinking. I mean that's how I think about resilience hubs but I don't know the implications of changing the name of a resilience hub to emergency emergency response and shelter. like um I think it takes out some of that jargon which I think could be helpful but I don't know if that loses something then and I I legitimately would need to phone a friend like ask >> so >> can I respond? >> Yep. >> Um that term in particular [snorts] is from OSI and so why we're using that word to align with their terminology. There's probably other references to resilience where maybe we could consider changing that one, but that one I feel strongly like we're trying to show support to their to their effort.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 244
Um, I'm happy to show OSI these comments. I I can't guarantee given the holidays coming up that they will review all of them and have responses by the January 6th meeting, but I will ask them to do so. >> Commissioner Lee, thank you. um kind of going back to the thematic elements like the four that she had kind of uh said let's I wanted to talk about the infrastructure um comment as it was a fairly recurring theme um I'm going to specifically speak to um Mrs. Derphy's comment um just regarding and I just for purpose of clarification I'm thinking through this like okay so let's talk infrastructure what are we talking about okay storm water the ability for sites to retain water actually a lot of the sites currently don't comply so when you develop it they'll be required to have a certain level of retention that'll actually be a good requirement what else okay tap fees for wastewater treatment So that that is a question I have.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 245
Generally, you're required to pay a tap fee. So when you tap into clean water, whether you size a 4 in, 2 in, 6 in, 8 in, um you're going to uh pay a tap fee associated with the level of fire suppression, um how much water you plan to consume, etc. So let's take for example there is a neighborhood that is well and I just want to because generally as a developer you you come there you start talking okay this is my tap fees etc. Um what happens at the point where that that incremental developer comes and it's like oh shoot um hey city so I would like to build a triplex it's by right and you are telling me that um uh we don't have any more clean water capacity um or >> uh wastewater capacity right um generally it's been on an incremental fee like a water tap fee basis.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above