2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 246
Um lead me through because I think that's one of the questions that was specifically um just what happens at that point whether it's substation electric capacity or and it's that one like it's at capacity and that next developer comes and says hey I'd like to do this and you're like actually we don't have that. itself. >> Yeah. >> What happens at that incremental moment? >> So, that's a big question and a [clears throat] lot a lot of different things could happen. But one of the ways that we mapped this out is we mapped out where we thought there was potential. So for example in a lot of residential areas when in talking our to our infrastructure spe specialists converting a significant percentage of homes from single family to triplex the infrastructure in those areas is really is appropriate to handle that >> and so when we make the regulatory changes that start doing that we will look at that as part of that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 247
On the flip side, um if we have identified maybe some area as hub and based on the assessment that's happening out of an infrastructure perspective, we find out that we need to make some infrastructure investment prior to being able to realize a high level of development. At that point, we're going to have to be thoughtful in like a petition by petition property owner application for that or certainly any city initiated reszoning to to do that and that is sort of the first level of protection. The second level of protection is regardless of any site that of particularly of a large scale that is site planned. That's part of the analysis is to make sure that we do have the capacity. And sometimes as part of that we find that there might need to be infrastructure upgrades as part of that. And so that is frankly a concern.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 248
Sometimes we hear from petitioners that not only do they have to pay the tap fee but they might have to be responsible for infrastructure too in order to provide that. There might be times where the balance of what that infrastructure would be necessary in order to accommodate that might be out of the realm of their proform or whatever. And so >> does that help answer the question? It's there's a lot of different ways that it could happen. Um, but in short, we're going to be mindful of the regulatory framework that we do, where we enable it, to make sure we can accommodate it, and particularly those areas that are frankly going to have more potential and thus a bigger impact. We're going to be we're going to have to look very closely at those public services infrastructure studies that Michelle referenced that are going on right now to make sure we're we're phasing that work appropriately.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 249
>> Yeah. Gotcha. No, that that's helpful. I'll talk a little bit about my experience when we had to build a clean room. Um it's just a room that has a very very no dust whatsoever, right? It's for um analyzing semiconductors. Um DT said actually you we need to upgrade the substation. Um we don't have enough electricity to actually serve that. Um, we ended up, uh, you know, through negotiation with the tenant at the time, um, from the developer side, we ended up paying about $500,000, uh, negotiating a new easement. Um, it's a part of the project cost. And I think one of the things that um, folks are concerned about is that will this result in higher taxes or will the city be on the hook for paying for infrastructure upgrades? And and [snorts] I I want to and that's why I'm thinking through like I do want to make sure that folks understand because I saw that was a kind of repeated occurrence of concern about infrastructure capacity and it's done really kind of at a project by project level again and when we talk infrastructure I want to be like I guess concrete because it's it's it can be vague.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 250
So I'm talking utilities, electricity, natural gas, um and then that utilities and then let's talk storm water, waste water. Um uh there is also again treatment as well as supply of water and these things get looked at at a project by project basis and if there's insufficiency there is like the developer basically gets uh and what we have talked about is like well is it fair for somebody to use up like from 95 to 99% and that next developer to you know have to say oh shoot now I have to pay a much larger one if I have to upgrade the substation and that that's where that thoughtful whole kind of like capacity planning makes sense. But I think one of the things because I for example Mrs. Dury's concern um I think has uh just about zoning and permitting getting ahead of infrastructure on a project by project basis if there isn't capacity.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 251
Staff says that to the petitioner. It's not like and then the petitioner has to kind of deal with it from a oh shoot I have to budget for this now and um and then they may come back and say okay it doesn't work um they may look to say I'm providing housing at a 20% at 80% AMI so um could I take a look at a tax increment financing to help me with the infrastructure upgrades there may be different ways to tackle it but I don't think there's a point in which the changing of zoning results in this um total kind of like catastrophic loading of infrastructure because it's done at a project by project. Each developer has to go through that process. So I I just wanted to talk about that incremental process of like when somebody submits um city staff reviews it and so and like and the actual changes that are profered here is about adding to page 130.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 252
It's possible that the vision for a particular area neighborhood development may need to be delayed until the local infrastructure is upgraded. That's an entirely fair I think assessment. Um the question is whether that acknowledgement is um I suppose like u does it add a level of um comfort relative to what's its actual utility? Um because to me I'm like yeah it is absolutely possible. I think that's actually a a very fair statement. Um, but again, I I defer to trying to simplify language as much as possible and try to take out things that don't necessarily carry meanings uh or carry um substantive impact. That's that's really what I meant to say. So, um just wanted to uh clarify. I think a lot of folks that had concerns about infrastructure at a project by project level, there's a very thorough analysis that occurs. And generally if you are at the capacity um it's like sorry it's yeah you're gonna have to pay to upgrade it essentially is and then we have a discussion about does this make sense etc.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 253
So, um, just wanted to give that, um, bit of a backdrop as to a lot of the comments that I've read. And so, um, I'm not sure that I am specifically asking or proposing for the additions of, um, the commentary regarding local infrastructure alignment causing potential pauses because again, it it's that that's just kind of a a fact of how uh, some of these developments might go. But I just wanted to acknowledge the concerns around infrastructure. We hear you. And um city there there's very talented engineers and city staff that are reviewing every project to understand capacity um from uh waste treatment, trash removal, electricity, water, um storm water retention, etc. So um just wanted to give that feedback. Thanks, Commissioner Adams. This is quick. Unfortunately, it's another one that I can't quite do on my own and I can't propose something specific, but I will but I will flag it's not a general comment.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 254
Um, there are along Packard Street, this was a public comment we got flagged it. >> There are five or six what I'm going to call residential slivers. They look almost as wide as a road. Um, that starts from where a Packard interfaces with what appears to be stadium. There's a little strip there and then there's a few more strips that you'll see as you visually track down Packard Street. They're literally like in some cases as wide as a road. The problem with it is that it's going to trigger tapering for all of the transition. If you've got like a little tiny strip of residential there, you're going to like maybe it butts up against other other transition or something else on the other side of it. If there's a strip of residential and we taper off a residential proximity, then it's going to automatically whack all that stuff down to three stories when it probably doesn't need to be and I can't actually tell if those slivers were intentional or not.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 255
Meaning like >> future land use map. >> Yeah, there might actually be good reasons for those slivers to be there and that's what I can't scrutinize. So if there's scrivener errors like meaning it's a product of the staff getting more fine or the map getting more fine grained then I'm fine leaving them in. if they're intentional, but if they're errors, I just want them taken out and cleaned up. Does that make sense? >> Yeah. My guess is so um between the second and third draft, we moved the map from like the Adobe Suite products to GIS. Yeah. >> And so there have been a few things that have come up like that where I think it's just like that transition to a new software. I don't recall us ever discussing that. I don't have that in the records anywhere that that would be um done deliberately.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 256
Do you recall anything differently regarding that? No. So I I think that's just like I can ask them to maybe fill it in, but I don't think that was done on purpose. >> Yeah. I don't want to disrupt any specific policy changes in the map, but if that's just a product of moving from one image to another or any other kind of error, then I just want to get it cleaned up. I'm relying here on the fact that the plan's specific about how these are meant to be general guidelines and I'm not that concerned about the policy ramifications of it. But if we can avoid that error, again going back to my original comment about cleaning up errors at this stage, that's something I want to fix. Other commissioners. All right. Seeing no other commissioners, planner Bennett, did you get what you needed tonight? >> Yes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 257
Thank you. >> Excellent. I think I can go on to agenda item number 12. Public comment. This is a second opportunity for individuals to speak up to three minutes on any issue. We'll first hear from those of you who are present with us in the chambers, then remote participants. To speak remotely, press star 9 if on phone or use the raise hand feature in Zoom. For phone access, dial 877853-5247 and enter meeting ID 97766341226. City staff will identify callers by the last three digits of their phone number or by name if on Zoom. You will hear an announcement when it's your turn to speak. Please ensure that you're in a quiet area and mute any background noise. For all participants, whether in chambers or on Zoom, please uh give us your name and address at the beginning of your comments. Is there anyone present in chambers who would like to address us at this time?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 258
Hi, I'm Susan Kaufman. I live at 630th Street. Commissioner Weiss, you asked what more could be done to reassure those of us who live in or near I'm actually outside historic districts um about their ability to essentially continue operating under the guidelines of the historic district commission, which I appreciate. But what would make us feel better is to have the underlying zoning comport with the way the historic districts actually look on the ground, which could be done by making the land use category, the underlying land use category residential. It would encompass everything that currently exists in historic districts, including multi-unit buildings, apartment buildings, including commercial establishments. Nothing would be excluded that I think have been the goals for those neighborhoods. It's hard for us to understand why the transition zoning must remain there when it can't be enacted given the historic district guidelines and why we can't make the actual land use be reflected in the underlying land use category.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 259
So that's what we've been struggling with. It's hard to understand why we're remaining committed to a category that cannot be enacted to which we cannot build which is true of uh transition. So thank you for your consideration. I appreciate your efforts but it's still a frustration for us. So thank you. >> Thank you. I was going to call on you, but I I figured you were going to come. >> Thank you. Appreciate that. Um, Greg Monroe, uh, W five. Um, okay. So, let [snorts] me be honest. I I understand the the rationalization of, you know, maybe this is a UDC punt thing, the issue I brought up with the natural features protection. I I truly understand that. Um, but I will point out the comp plan does make a pretty strong value statement, right, that these things matter. Um, it also acknowledges that residents are concerned with that balancing act you all just described.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 260
And and again, uh, Commissioner Mills, if you're pointing to a specific bullet point with like a four to six year time horizon, I think we can update it with more robust language. Um, and again, I'll I'll go back to the the balancing act. So, it seems like this is an asymmetric trade-off for us, right? In the UDC, uh here's a quote like collateral damage during and after construction on scenically important sites must be scrupulously avoided. It will take 150 years to replace any intended losses. That's right in the UDC. That is our city value statement of sort of what is at stake, right? Uh you've seen in the news this week, Seattle and Palestine are in the news for uh flooding and undergoing a lot of disruption, right, to their lives out out of flooding and natural um disasters. So you know, forested land observes two to four times more storm water than developed land.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 261
Mature tree canopies intercept 30% uh of rainfall before it hits the ground. Um clearing and grading slopes cuts water absorption by as much as 90%. And again, the development I'm speaking of occurred within 200 feet often river. So this loss accelerates erosion, delivers more sediment and polluted runoff into our primary source of drinking water. Uh and and just simply beyond a public health concern, this loss just feels to me like an erosion of public goods that are disappearing at an alarming rate in this country. And so um again, I I also I'm not going after your trees in your backyard. That's not what I'm asking for, right? Let's not conflate the long-term property owners with active development activity, right? So, I understand that maybe the UDC perhaps intends for bigger scale projects, right? For these protections to be triggered, but I again taking all of this into context and again, if you frame these as 150year losses, I don't think that's a good trade-off for 10 condos that cost $1.5 million each.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 262
I really don't. I don't think it moves the needle on anything and we are losing in the long run, right? So, um, you know, and again, just to hearken back to like an earlier comment, you know, I I understand that that there may not be another city somewhere else that we can point to and say, "Oh my gosh, like look what happened once they reszone, but I think a lot of us are saying we're seeing stuff in our backyard, right?" And so we're seeing luxury condos being built in our backyard and we're seeing the erosion and loss of natural features which again we all seem to agree even with our documentation. We're making a value statement that these things matter and we're just sort of giving them away and it doesn't seem like anyone seems to care and I think that's a problem. And the last thing I'll say is that I think it's also a problem.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 263
It's not that we're relying on the private market to build housing. Like I understand that argument. It's that we're relying on private market to achieve outcomes that are in contradiction to profit motives. So that's all. Thank you. Thank you, Moro. >> Gabrielle Boer, 1721 Newport. Um just to follow up on a few things that I had mentioned earlier. Um, someone had said something along the lines of like, you know, everyone comes up here and says, you know, you're not listening to me, so therefore you're not listening to anybody. Um, you know, most people in Ann Arbor don't even know this is happening. And they know that something is happening cuz there's pause the plan and neighbors for more neighbors signs out, but they don't actually know what's going on in their own town with their own government. And that was said multiple times in the comments.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 264
Um, so I feel less concerned that my specific voice isn't like the poster of all this and more that like the residents of this community don't even know what's going on. And you know, the the way that the comments have been addressed tonight really does elucidate for me what this process looks like, which is not very comprehensive, not very responsive to the community of the 400 people who were randomly sampled to give input about this. um the response of this team does not feel very robust to what people are coming in and talking about. So, uh this plan doesn't appear to have the robust support that you guys seem to report. Um and just to address a couple other comments. You know, development today, um looks pretty different from what development, you know, 40 or 50 years ago looks like in terms of concentration of capital and, you know, um uh just in terms of like who's buying and selling houses that, you know, profit is is really coming from holding homes, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2025-12-17 Washtenaw County, MI YouTube / CTN Ann Arbor transcript source: youtube Ann Arbor Planning Commission Meeting 12/16/25 · passage 265
Um um centering builders versus the residents and things like that. I think that that's a huge problem. Um, and you know, to liken um, you know, Ann Arbor to a city like Houston, um, feels like really odd given that Houston is like millions of people and there's like all this sprawl. So, um, yeah, you know, it would just be nice for there to be like a real, uh, relationship between the government and the people who at minimum would like to have a better understanding of what exactly went into this plan, who was consulted about it, and what problems is it designed to address? Is it designed to address problems of people who want to move into this city or is there really any thought around what people who actually live here want and need? Um cuz those things just aren't really lining up for me.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above