2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 77
There we go. We talked about this last time. The governing board does meet to discuss the interestbased negotiation process and to give principles that they would like the team to have in mind as they're going through the IBN process. Uh the board met in executive session on Tuesday and then in a public session directly following it and they determined that they weren't going to make any changes. So the principles that we worked under last year are the principles for this year. Uh you can see which ones those are up here. So alignment with SOFG goals, uh sustainable salary for all staff, sustainable health care benefits, exploring revenue generation options, and adhering to budgetary recommendations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 78
So, any questions about those principles? Yes. >> I I know you can't discuss the the private conversation part of it, uh, but I'm curious in terms of how the process of how that conversation took place. Um, uh, [snorts] is it is it that they kick it around and decide themselves? Do you present new information to them? I guess I I was just curious. Um what I can say because I you're absolutely right. Uh in an executive session, just for those of you who are familiar with the law around this, um it is not allowable for anyone who is part of that executive session to discuss the nature of the conversation or the information that was shared. That's protected by statute. In fact, I could be fined. Um so I I'm going to try to avoid that. Um but what I could tell you is that the executive session is helpful for the governing board to be able to talk freely uh in that space and get information that they've requested presented to them about whatever that topic is.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 79
So there were presentations there was information shared by M Shapiro Dom and myself they had an opportunity to have that discussion and then when they close the executive session they open the public section session then that's when they can ex discuss it openly uh so that it's part of the um discussion that's on record for that governing board meeting and then they a vote to adopt or not. >> Yes. What was that for? >> That means that we are going to adhere to the budgetary recommendations that are brought forth from the budget side and that's been in place for the last several years. This is nothing new. This is the same standard that we've had for a long time. >> What exactly does that mean? There's a budget that will be presented to this team >> and you need to work within that budget. >> Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 80
Okay. I was just wondering whether something discussed, you know. Yeah. Okay. I get it. >> Dom's going to go through some of that information today and then there'll be more budget information coming from Vanessa in a future meeting, I think. Right. And then part of that also is that there are certain aspects of the budget that you can't discuss until the governing board has that presented to them. So there's a whole bunch of other things that go with that. You'll have a beginning of a start of an overview today though. All right. Um so when we think about our class sizes uh that's often an area of conversation that we have in this team and there was a request to have this data from last year or from this current year sorry uh last year's data is also in this spreadsheet. It's a little further down on some of the tabs.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 81
Currently this represents 40th day for this school year. Our 100th day is January 15th, which will then determine budgeting and planning for the next school year. So, as most of you know, budgets are set by the 100th day in districts for the most part. So, we'll I will update that on the 16th or 17th whenever we get all the numbers. the way this data is gathered. Make this a little bigger here. I go into synergy. I run reports for rosters for every teacher that has a home room. So, this is just classroom teachers. I write down the number of students that are in each class. I do not include self-contained regional programs. We don't forget about them. and they're here at the bottom. Whoops. That group is at the bottom of the page. We just take them out of the general education setting because that's where your M funding is most impacted.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 82
There are different revenues and different ways to support the self-contained classes. So, we want to make sure that we're capturing in the ratios or in this class size view um how many actual students are registered and enrolled in each class. Um, what I did this time is we kind of took a look because if you take a look at the class sizes, generally speaking, if they're below the allocated ratio, which is 27.5 to1 in that particular class, that will be a green cell. If they're not, then it would be anywhere from light yellow to deep red. the whoops the percentages and the count of where that those non-aligned C classes are listed. It's also on that page as well. So you can see that districtwide we have one class that has 35 students. If you wanted to know which classroom that is, you would be able to scroll and find out that it's at Gateway in seventh grade and that's one of their homes.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 83
Remember, this is the 40th day. So, it may have changed slightly and may maybe not. You know, we get students that leave and come back. Um, so we'll make sure that we have the information for the other day at the next meeting. Yes, >> I saw that we have two classes. One is listed as one student, one is listed as four students. What's up with that? >> I missed the first part of your question. >> Oh, like there's two classes on the spreadsheet like at TCA in the sixth grade. One says that they the class has one student and one says the class has four students. >> Yeah. So, if you look the color of the border would indicate that they're part of a different group, right? So that one student combines with that 19 and combines with that 10. So there are actually 20 students in that home room.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 84
>> I understand it's a combo. Okay. >> Yeah. Yeah. It just looks TCA looks a little different or >> and it is a little different model, right? TCA has a little different spread. So if you look at other sites that have combo classes like LCK and Monav Vista, um they're more traditionally aligned, right? So you have a K1 at LCK, you have a one two at Monav Vista, you have a 45 at Monav Vista. So that that kind of is probably what we're used to seeing. Uh just TCA is different. Any other questions about this look? We also did um calculate an uh effective class size rate based on our enrollment based on the FTEES that we have and we're actually more at 23 to1 right now. If we take all the classrooms uh and all the students and all the FTEEs that we have represented, we're at 23 to1.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 85
Yes, Dorothy, >> I just had a quick um kind of I guess it's process question. Um so when you see trends, I don't know who you is. um when the district sees trends with particular schools maybe being higher in a grade band or something is that I know right now that's fully left up to the site team to make those decisions right we have the 27 27.5 to1 but then each school can decide on their own how they're going to distribute that that um people power is there if you start seeing things that that make you go make you take pause. Is there um coaching that happens or is there any kind of guidance that is provided by the district especially if you like see a pattern like that over years or is it really just you're autonomy you're the principal? >> Yes, there's coaching that happens.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 86
There are conversations that happen because what one of the things that we're really intentionally uh focused on is the equity of it also. Right. So we do have some sites that have some hotter spots than others. And so those conversations with the principles are centered around what their needs are on their campus and the rationale too. Um you know there might be some sites and I'm not going to call out any specifically but there's a cohort of students who've been split or divided or had challenges with staffing over the course of several years. And so there might be an intentional we're going to keep this group smaller because they have more need for support and accept that that's going to squeeze out, you know, like one of those stress balls. It's going to make a more hot spot on this grade level because of this decision.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 87
Um, so those conversations happen especially at the beginning of the year when we're going through the 100 or the 10th day 10day drop period. uh and then we have those conversations one-on-one with those principles. Um there also some programmatic reasons why we may shift numbers. Um you know we had we have a challenge with uh LCK you can see it on the board. They had one kindergarten teacher and we needed to work out a way to make sure that we didn't have 45 kindergarteners in a class. So um so those conversations are ongoing. But that does that answer your question? Yeah. >> All right. Um, moving on to the next. So, we provided this overview. Uhhuh. Do >> you know we can get last year's document for that? >> For which one? right now. >> It's right underneath it. >> It's right there. >> That's the last year's one.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 88
>> Yeah. >> But mean with all the dollar amounts. >> It's there. >> Oh, this is Well, so the one on the bottom is last year, the one on top is this year. >> Yeah. My [snorts] intention is to keep doing that. Just adding to this particular tab every year so you can start to see patterns over time. I did add, let me let me give you the overview and then I can give you a couple more thoughts about that, Ariel. Um, what you're looking at with this view is you're looking at the impact or the use of contract employees as as um replacements for vacancies that exist because we don't have a district hired employee in those positions. Uh we really tried to separate them out so that you could see the impact in different departments or needs. Yes, Ariel. >> Um I have a question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 89
>> Could you use the microphone, please? >> Yeah. Um yeah, I'm noticing that the agency salary employees are growing at a higher pace than the district employees. Like last year, for example, general ed teacher like the average agency was like 87. Um but last year it was 72. Last year the average district was 50,000. This year is 54. So contractors their salaries are growing faster than ours. So it will actually benefit all of us to walk away and just become contracted employees. >> They know the rate they're making, >> right? That so that number includes the administrative cost and the c the costs that we have to pay to the agency. So it's not necessarily what out of pocket that teacher is getting paid or that psychologist or that >> oh agency the last box is like 3,000 up there at the top it jumped to 12,000.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 90
>> So let me just do a quick a quick process check just because I think you were going to go through sorry >> never mind my question for later. Keep going. >> That would be good. Let's just put Ariel's name on there and we'll come back and then I thought I saw another hand come up, James, uh after her. So, let's let let him go through some of the data and then um we may have time to ask some questions that we may not have all the answers to today, but maybe need some further development or explanation. Okay, >> James, the process question. >> It's a process. It's not It's not really a question. It's a comment. >> Okay. But I can not do it if you don't think it's >> a comment about the data or a comment about what we're doing >> data in this step in the process as I see it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 91
But it it can wait till >> let let's let him go through and then we'll come back to that. Make sure you write down what you have and then let's make sure that we're um reconnected to the speaker uh at this time. So thank you. >> Thank you Alexis. Uh I one of the things that I add to this look this year was uh on the last two or three columns J through M was to sort of do a comparison about what that impact is budget-wise. Right? So, I think this really helps with sort of the bottom line view that right now we're paying an additional $964,969 because we are using agency hires for those positions. What that represents is in the last column if we're using our 27.5 to1 ratio that essentially is 13 FTEES. Um part of that conversation would be what is the benefit of having those contractors?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 92
What is the need for that um role to be filled? Is it compliance? Is it, you know, an additional FTE that we could cut because we don't need that position any longer. So there are some other conversations that can happen with this set of data. Um, and as you look through individual groups, keep in mind that we do have some challenges. And I'm going to specifically point to school psychologists. We have currently we have two district hired school psychologists, which is why that row has such a high number of dollars that are uh that are allotted to it. um nurses, registered nurses, same thing. And you can see where our registered nurses salaries are very different than what our contract agency payments are.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 93
So, um any questions about how to orient yourself to this look and keep in mind that the purple table below is last year's data. And then next year, for those of you who are with us next year, I'll just add to it so that we can continue to have those comparisons year-over-year. >> Thank you for this. I just want to say column I where where it says the difference between agency versus CSD, that means if we just had district employees, we would essentially save that money. Okay. Thank you, >> Ariel. Was there anything else that you wanted to >> So just so I'm understanding correctly. So >> Sure. >> When it says the agency average is what we're paying the agency. >> Yes. And that's not necessarily one specific agency. That's the average. So remember we have >> people higher. >> I'm sorry. >> There could be some agencies that are higher.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 94
>> Yes. >> And some that are maybe a little bit lower. >> Yep. Absolutely. Because we often hear like there's no money to pay employees more, but it seems like we're willing to pay more for non-employees. >> Well, I think we're put in a situation where we have to pay a non-employee. Otherwise, we don't have seven school psychologists, which makes it impossible for us to be compliant with sped law. Right. >> That's true. If we don't have a classroom teacher to meet kids in the classroom, then we have a class of 60 kids. So, you have absolutely we would so much prefer to use that $964,000 toward our employees, but in the absence of that, we have to have those positions filled, right? >> So, is there because I know you guys are working on behind the scenes and whatnot. Is there any talk behind the scenes on what we can do to get those people to come in as employees?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 95
Maybe increasing salaries or doing something or advertising so that the extra 900,000 we're putting towards non employees we should put towards our own employees. >> I'm going to hold on that. Um the the short answer is yes. And that's also something that meat confer can talk about. Um, so that's that's the short answer. We do have intentions to hire, but we don't have people applying. So if you don't have someone applying for a position, you're kind of in a in a catch 22, right? >> I agree. Do we How many student teachers do we currently have in the district? >> I would have to look. I don't have that on top of my head. Yeah, if you could add it to the parking lot or put it on the task, then we can get you that information. >> There are post-it notes in your box.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 96
So, if you have something that or put it in notes as Joel said and then I just want to make sure we're coming back. Ariel, are you finished with your questions? >> Thank you, Ariel. James. >> Um, so, uh, just for, uh, for people new to the process, uh, this is the best equivalent I can think of for this is like we're if you've been in staff meetings or part of staff meetings, this is kind of like where you're looking at data analysis in the I notice, I wonder uh, type of stage of looking at the information that Dr. Lauren is presenting. Um, and the reason I want to point that out is because uh, it's very easy to get caught up into the little nuances and the little details about stuff and uh, and it circles back to that idea of identifying what the problem is, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above