2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 97
We talked about this yesterday in a meeting uh where you're trying to figure out you know what what information is missing from the data or what information do we need in order to make uh in order to correctly identify the problems so we can move to that next step of solutions. Um and the best example is that I can think of is that uh the class sizes that we had in the previous slide. I was I was looking and I I hesitate to bring this up because it's like you're being punished for doing really well. Uh but uh tooting our own little horn here at Gateway, we have some of the highest uh uh class sizes in the middle school of anybody in the district, we also have some of the highest scores in the district for math that we went over as well, too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 98
So, the two are not necessarily connected, but I don't want to go and say, "Oh, well, you know, it's just it doesn't matter what the class size means because people can rock it out no matter what." There are there are other pieces of information that are missing that are equally important. Um, and have the mindset of, you know, I notice I wonder about the data and how you process it and try not to get like fixated on the little details of things and say, well, okay, this means this and this means that because there's a lot of other pieces that go along with it. And thanks James and I I appreciate the reminder that if there are pieces of data that aren't indicated on this look, then let us know and we'll bring it back to the group. It's another reason why I think the change in the policy where we're now required to get the data to you at least 3 days prior to the meeting uh is helpful.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 99
Right? So I know that for some of you, you may not have had time. I know Monday was a rough day for a lot of us just getting back into our schedule and routine. Um, but having that opportunity to get some eyes on the information beforehand that might also help in creating some space for you to to ask further questions during this process. Um, Katie was next and then we'll can you add Dorothy to the stack? Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you Katie. Dorothy. >> Um, just looking deeper at this, I I want to make sure that nobody leaves this room thinking that these are actual salaries, right? They're district average salaries. So, you know, they are impacted by who's in those roles right now. It doesn't necessarily mean you could hire new people and they would make that much money. And it's calculating the cost to the district, not the amount that the people earn.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 100
That's both for the agency hires as well as for the district employees. That's why there's all those columns plus this plus this. That's not dollars that people are making. That's cost to the district. >> Right. Right. And and one of the things that that's a a good reminder is that columns D, E, and F, and G are costs to the district for an employee that are not included in the agency costs. Right? So while the sped resource teachers average salary is 56,000, you add the 21% benefits, the other benefits package that's paid and then the market demand. And then that last column H gives you more of a average for Kraton school district employees including the extras not the base salary because base salary is column D and I know that we focus on base because that's what gets people excited and interested in coming to the district and people excited and interested in staying in the district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 101
Right? So that'll be all, you know, Dom's got some more information about that side of it, but this is the view that we're looking at for agency hires versus district hires >> Ariel. >> Oh, we're looking at a contracting website and I know we get paid bi-weekly and then they were saying like the weekly salary was anywhere from 2,200 to 2,800. But we were just looking at the some of the contractor websites just for SPAT teachers. >> Okay. >> Oh, you were your hand up. >> Yes. >> When? >> No name is not up there. >> Yes, it is. It's right below Katie's. And just real quick, Rox, for processing, we should put even though Dorothy like started speaking, so you were like, I'm not going to write it. Just so we can keep track of how many times people are talking. Yeah. >> Not that Dorothy is going to be up there multiple times.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 102
>> I'm not trying to say that. >> All right. We'll go to Yolanda and then we'll we'll >> I was the one that was supposed to be under Katie, not Ariel. So, I think that's what got messed up. >> Katie and then I thought, so my apologies. [laughter] >> All right. You're [clears throat] >> microphone, please. Rule [clears throat] four is fed self-contained referring to um paras or >> no this is this is all certified. That's a great clarification because we do have a substantial number of classified employees that are contracted that um if you would like we can do a deeper dive to that as well. We'd be happy to do that. So you could put on if >> you could add that in the action item that'd be great. But you it seemed like you had more to say. >> Just to clarify if it was teachers because I know we do have paras that are also >> Yeah.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 103
And really that's only been in the past two years that we've had a significant increase in pair professionals that are hired through agencies. So that I think that's a great addition to this data set. Thank you Yolanda. Mr. Diaz. Um uh this is just a question about that because I know other districts struggle with this as well too and I if this is data that can be accessed somehow is it possible to figure out >> and I'm I'm just going to throw it out there and see if it's something that could be turned into a question or an idea. Um, how is it that other districts are able to manage such a huge hit to their budget knowing full well that agencies charge a such higher amounts than in-house hires? Because I I and correct me if I'm wrong, but I know like Scottsdale, they've fully embraced uh agency hires and my understanding is they have a bunch of them as well too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 104
I don't know if that's true or not, but I've just heard >> it evolved. Um, actually Scottsdale has just flipped it. So that they had very few agency hires than uh >> district hires. No, that was the case. Um that was the case absolutely in Scottsdale, but they were very intentional in making steps and making changes to their salary schedules and all the other things that go into that um to change that process and that problem. the districts they were doing all this. They're laying off all these teachers. They were laying off a lot of their contracted teachers and everything like that. A lot of the districts flipped it. >> Well, that would be the the riff process anyway, right? I mean, we would obviously if they if we were going to reduce our force, we would start with that group with the caveat that again, if we have a psychologists that we have to have, then we might not be able to do that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 105
But a classroom teacher that we could riff as a contractor as opposed to a district employee. Absolutely. We would do that. >> They got rid of the contract. Oh, I'm sorry. Because it was cost them so much money. A lot of districts Phoenix L did something similar. Madison, Bolts. Um, >> so is that the question then? What is it that is it possible to to research, you know, what are these other districts doing to affect that change? >> Yes. And I think we're getting into options. >> You're getting into options. So, let's just stay on looking at the data and just uh to your point saying I notice this or we'd like to request information about classified uh contracts versus in district. Um so that we just stay in this arena. I I get it. It's real easy to jump into, but just try to keep your feet right here in the overview.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 106
>> Understood. >> No problem. So in the spirit of moving forward because we also have Dom uh needs to present information on budget. I want to turn your attention to the separation by classification spreadsheet. Um this is longitudinal. So this covers from 2016 to last year. For those of you who are not used to working with um the data in this way, when we talk about 2025, we're talking about the year 202425. Um so we don't have turnover rate information for 26 because we haven't completed the 2526 school year. So the way that this is um this is spelled out is that I've got all in the first group of numbers and then as you scroll across it's disagregated into certified non-admin administrative classified and certified and then classified only. So you'll see patterns of separations below that for those same groups. So for all employees, certified, administrative, and classified.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 107
And then if you're more visual and uh respond more to the column, look, it's the same information. So um typically when you look at charts, you usually start with the most current year at the end of the chart. I kind of flipped it because I feel like it's easier for us to have conversations if we're looking at last year most current data as the closest to the XY axis. So that's what we're looking at. Make that just a little larger so you can see.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 108
So any questions about the orienting to this particular spreadsheet? So the the way that this information comes to me um is that we use our visions program right which you all access through employee access um by employee group by um position and um by separation right so terminations are part of this uh resignations job abandonment non-renewals Um and retirements. This is also different information than what you would get in the intent to return forms. I want to make sure that I clarify that because those are coming out pretty soon where we'll ask employees to give us their intention as to whether or not they're returning. So, you know, we we try to engage principles and assistant principles in that process and departments just to make sure that we're getting as accurate account of number of people are going to commit to next year. It's non-binding because it's just a survey, but we have a little bit more information after that process.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 109
Ariel, >> um how accurate? So when comparing the two was the people that the number of people on the survey about their intention and then the amount of people that actually resigned was it similar? >> Uh it is similar. I don't have that on the top of mind. So I can certainly look at that and bring that back to you. >> So the survey is pretty accurate about parable for the following year >> mo more or less. Yeah. Yeah. And remember the the one of the things I think that benefits us as a smaller district is that um last year we really tried to be intentional in having our meet and confer stuff advertised before contracts were due for teachers. So I think that helped um and we have so much instability in districts around us uh as far as closing schools, reducing force. Um, I know our our fiscal team has been working with the fiscal stewardship committee to try not to have that be Kraton's trajectory this year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 110
So, um, or in the future, but, uh, that all I think helps. But I can certainly look at that information because we also have people that don't return their contracts that end up being rehired. So, that's the other part of it, too. All right, I think that concludes the information that I was to present. So, if you do have any specific questions or requests for data as we're going through the process, if it would help to have this information, it may not be available immediately. It might have to be for an next another meeting. Um but parking lot list in the agenda uh just let me know. Okay. Yes. >> Okay. Thank you. >> All right. Are we ready to >> maybe did I see your hand or no? Just a strand. Okay. Okay. >> All right. We're ready to turn over to Dom. I'm really only going over the wind 25 certified regular and STEM position data.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 111
>> All right. Hey, hi everybody. Thank you for your time. I'm uh I'm glad to be back here this year. Uh stepping in for Vanessa. She's in Hawaii. So, um, feeling a little jealous, but, uh, it's good to be with you guys again. Um, I want to start by saying the, uh, we don't have the meet and confer budget number today, uh, but we'll be presenting that at the next, uh, meet and confirm meeting. We need the, uh, 100th day data from AD to get a more concrete idea of what our outlook is for next year. So, uh, we'll be presenting that at the next meeting. Um, I have put in the, uh, 1% document. I know Vanessa's mentioned that a few times at these meetings. That is on the meet and confer updates, uh, sheet and there's a link to it. I don't want to get too far too into the details on that sheet.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 112
>> Yeah, she >> Well, it's Yeah, they already access. >> Yeah. Um so yeah just a couple of points uh couple of things to point out with this sheet. Um basically this is a calculation of what 1% of costs are. >> That's okay. >> It's I don't know why it's not showing up but it's available for you to link to. >> Okay. Yeah. So, if you guys can pull that up on your on your laptops. Um, so those are 1% of costs based on salaries and benefits for various employee groups. Um, we split it out by M costs, grant costs, and food service costs. Uh, we did it a little differently this year. I don't think Vanessa included food service uh in the calculations last year, but um we've included those. So Vanessa wanted to touch on this document a little more when she's back at the next meeting so she could sort of explain some of the adjustments she made in the fiscal year 2425 calculations.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 113
Um but it's there for your for your use so you can get an idea of what 1% of costs are. Um and uh we may use this document to come, you know, assist us in coming up with a budget for meet and confer. Um but it does give you a good breakdown of uh certified, classified, um you know, principles, directors, all all of those various employee groups and what the cost increase would be potentially. >> Where is that? for that. >> Can you explain what the less what increased percentage means? The very less column. >> Yeah. So, if you see the um Hang on, let me pull it up real quick. >> Sorry. >> No, it's okay. So, if you look at the 1% increase column, Yeah. and the the total there is about 386 212. So the increase percentage column explains which group which percentage of that increase amount belongs to each group.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 114
Right? So of the 386,000 49% of the increase would be for certified staff. >> Exactly. 36% would be for the classified staff and so on. So you can you can just see the effect of the total change that each group has. >> Yeah. just use your computer. It's okay. >> Yeah. Get me on the certified regular. I apologize. My air parrot uh wasn't cooperating. >> Yes. Thank you. >> It might be zoomed in too much for you. if you want to get to tabs. There we go. >> Well, you they have it on their laptops, but yeah. >> Okay. Um before I address the um certified and STEM position data, I just want to mention that there was a bus driver data request. We're not able to provide those numbers yet because the compression committee is going to address uh classified staff in their January meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 115
So after that meeting with the compression committee, we'll bring back uh bus driver data for you guys. So all right. So go ahead. >> Yeah. So facilities would be included in the classified discussions as well. Yeah. Yeah. >> All right. Um, so the one document I wanted to go over today is basically the updates that you guys um allowed to happen last year or directed us to uh begin working on. It's the uh certified salary schedules. Um so we want to thank you guys for allowing us to dig into that work. Um I also want to do give a big shout out to Linda uh Linda Mock and payroll. She put a lot of work into this. Also, the HR team and uh Vanessa didn't want me to get give her any credit, but she deserves some credit as well. There was a lot of work um put into this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 116
So, um basically um Joel could probably speak more eloquently to this topic than I can. But we had two different salary schedules for certified staff. One was a a placement schedule, one was a tiered schedule. So, we've now condensed those into um one consistent placement schedule. Um so, I just want to help you guys. Uh I want to assist you guys in analyzing this document when you read it over. I know you open it up and there's a ton of numbers and rows and columns and um so uh if you if you're on the Does everybody have the document open or can you see it? Okay. So the first tab is the teacher regular pay schedule. Um you can see that the units are separated by letters. Um to fit everybody on this schedule uh after conducting the one-time uh compression adjustment that we did last year, we extended that A through Z and then even went through to AA and AB.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above