2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 117
Um A is the row where uh a new a brand new teacher would would land with no experience, right? Um if a new teacher comes into the district uh and they they already have 20 years of experience, we only credit them for 10 years of experience. So J would be the row that a new teacher with um over 10 years of experience would land. Is that correct? >> Okay. I'm sorry. I went off. Okay. they'll give them a little bit more credit for the work they've done. Uh, and then you can see that the varying degrees of education also affects where you where you would land on the salary schedule. Um, there's some highlighted rows in there. Um, C indicates when you hit that three-year threshold for longevity, E 5 years, J 10 years, O 15 and so on. And then as you scroll down, you can see scroll down on that same tab, you can see the change from going from unit to unit, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 118
Um, so going from A to B, it's an $835 jump. Go ahead. >> Go ahead. >> All right. Um, and then as you go down, you can see the the change as you move from unit to unit. If you sum B through Z, you get 8,236. And if you scroll back to the top, you can see um, row A with a bachelor's degree is $50,000. Row Z 58236. So that's that 8,236 change if you went from A to Z. And then down below that it's the educational tier. So u it shows the uh change in your salary if you went from a bachelor's to a bachelor's uh with 18 credit hours 36 a master's and so on and so forth. And then next tab is teacher regular number of positions. So you can see here the number of positions for each area on that salary schedule.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 119
So if you just take the first uh column B row row A, there's 18 teachers or 18 positions, I'm sorry, um in that that portion of the salary schedule. The next tab is the FTEES. So the numbers won't be exactly the same, but the placements will be the same. Um, a good way to look at this is if you look at uh row A at the bottom, you'll see in col in uh column D, the number of positions is one, but the number of FTEEs is 0475. So that means there's one position in there, but it's a less than a halftime uh position. So that's what the FTEES sort of signify there. And although this is one schedule now there's actually two it's one consistent uh format but there's actually two schedules one for uh STEM teachers as well. So the STEM teacher tabs follow the same patterns as the uh the regular uh schedule.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 120
>> So go ahead. >> Okay. Yeah, Dorothy, I can answer your question. >> Sorry. >> No. Okay, let's scratch off key. >> Yeah. [laughter] [snorts] >> So, um I've had some conversations with Vanessa last year trying to make more sense out of our salary schedule. And one of the things that she kept trying to help me understand was that each letter doesn't necessarily represent a year of employment. So that leads me to be confused about why row C, row E, row I, J, row Omatically assumes that those are the rows that would add the threeear, the five, the 10 year, the 15 year. Because if the letters don't actually represent years, because they may or may not, then that doesn't make sense to me. >> Yeah. Joel, can you speak on that at all? Or >> do you understand my question or >> I do understand your question.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 121
Yeah. And and the and the other confusing thing about it, right, is that as teachers gain years of experience, they aren't just automatically moved down that salary schedule. >> Correct. That's what Vanessa [clears throat] taught me. But then this seems to counter that. >> Yeah, they are. >> Can I ask is this a is this the placement? >> This is a placement schedule. Correct. >> Yeah. >> Versus >> So >> the existing salary schedule. >> So >> this is only for new folks coming in. >> No, it can only be for new otherwise it would only go to the 10th year. >> Say that. >> So it is combined both. >> Yeah. I hear what you're saying, right? Because Yeah. You don't automatically get a raise. I don't automatically go from J to K. So why would I automatically get longevity stipened at those specific rows?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 122
Right? >> That's my question. >> Teachers are still, you know, >> right, >> interested in whether whether or not you guys recommend a raise and whether or not the board approves it because they don't get that years of experience automate. Last year was a special case because we wanted to address compression and we did what we call a one-time compression adjustment where we actually did honor um years of experience and we moved people along that schedule according to their their years of experience. And um just to just to throw this out there, that's what we call the the horizontal uh compression adjustment because it's more of a peer-to-peer adjustment, right? vertical adjustment would be a manager um versus versus one of their employees, right? Um but yeah, I understand why that would be a little bit confusing. Uh I guess >> I think it just misleads that automatically everybody who's at a J is getting that 10-year stipen and that may may or may not be true.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 123
>> So some people, >> especially if it's a new person who just came in, right? Yeah. They have 20 years of experience. We put them on J, >> right? >> Is a K, I'm sorry. Yeah, >> we put them on K, but they're not receiving. >> And as we're making decisions about where to put what I'm going to assume is a limited amount of money, >> we don't want to have misunderstandings about what people are making at different years of experience. >> Yeah. Dorothy from talking with Vanessa last year and I don't want to speak for her but she was saying a major reason of like doing the salary schedule like this including existing current employees right and even though it is a placement schedule and you can only be placed up to K as like a new employee um is so that you know in the future like even on a yearly basis we can make a decision let's move everyone we have money let's move everyone up a year instead of giving a raise to the salary schedule right um as a way of like continuing to honor user service I think the longevity thing I I don't know, just looking at spreadsheets, I think it's just listed for ease of it's a way to represent that a 10-year employee in in the district has another method of earning money other than, you know, because on the salary schedule, it's usually just at the bottom, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 124
>> Yeah, it's a different thing. So, yeah, I think that's the part. It's not it's acknowledging that it exists, but it's not automatically at those rows. And I think that's what just distorts the reality a little bit. But yes, she's explained that to me, too. I understand that part. >> Yeah, I hear you. I think that's just uh maybe the way that was presented was a little confusing, but >> this is not published for >> Yeah. Yeah. This is just for you guys. And um let's see here. >> Okay. Uh Dom, real quick. I just want to make sure if you've covered everything in here and then we'll go to Kelly who has a question. >> I'm good. I actually was just wondering about the highlights, which is exactly what Dorothy was asking about. Um, so I just want to make sure that I understand too.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 125
So the yellow means years of longevity applies to years in Kraton, whereas the placement might be years outside of the district. >> That's correct. Yeah. So you have to work at Kraton for a certain number of years to receive longevity. But but yeah, if you come in with years of experience from another district, you will be placed higher on the schedule. You won't be on row A um you know, as a a brand new teacher, right? um you'll you'll get honored for that work that you've done in the past um but only to a certain amount >> or a certain level >> right and then I think there's a tab that has longevity on there right yeah with the amounts um which shows the benefit of staying within the district >> and then those longevity amounts are yeah they're also um your FTE is factored in there too >> okay thank yeah >> so you can cross me out and Daniel I don't know if you had another question oh okay >> yeah he any >> um >> yeah, I don't know if this is the right place to ask this.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 126
I was just looking up um like things that are going on in the legislature and if they're going to increase like give give an increase to public schools just to increase teacher pay specifically or earmark those dollars. And I don't know does that ever live like does that only do those decisions only live with meet and confer? So for example I'm reading here governor hobbs is really pushing to extend one 123 that is specifically earmarked to increase teacher salary. Would that conversation live with like the executive team and they say, "Okay, this just passed and now we're going to increase teacher pay." Or is that something you would bring to us and then that's part of our decision making? >> I hear what you're saying. You're saying the governor is giving us money specifically to increase salaries. So would we just automatically do that? >> Right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 127
>> Uh I don't believe so. I think we would still work through the meet and confer process and also uh get governing board. >> So if I can give some context remember when 20 by 20 came up that went back to meet and confer and we convened meet and confer to talk about how to reach those goals. Okay. And that also was part of the conversation when we had the increase in minimum wage >> and we decided that time I know Dorothy and James and there are several people in this room that were part of that conversation as well. How do we get to that $15 per hour? And as a district meet and confer, we made the decision we're just going to jump to 15 and not do the incremental increases. So that yes, that absolutely would come to meet and confer. >> So then my follow-up question to that is when when does all that information come out?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 128
Um cuz like this it looks like it's almost gridlocked, you know, right now. So is there we have a deadline that you guys get that budget and then we get that information right and you don't have that yet. >> When you say that information which which information >> I'm just looking at all these >> right >> key funding increases for school or you know school year 26 it says base level pay is going to be increased teacher pay is going to be increased flexible funding school facilities low income support. >> So that's all Governor Hobb's wish list. Okay. >> Right. So she'll take she'll take that to consideration with the legislation and the legislature might come up with a completely different plan. So this is what Governor Hobbes is proposing as budgetary uh language and potential laws that are going to be passed enacted in this legislative process.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 129
Um but that takes the whole spring. >> Right. Right. And then at that point July 31st, we would have to figure out what we're doing, right? So it's >> Yeah. That's >> so we'll make decisions based on the information that we have at this time. >> Yep. Yep. What we have and that's why the 100 day is so important. That's why what's happening with federal dollars is important. So all of those things come into play. Um but we can't really plan for things that aren't actually legislated yet. >> Yeah. Yep. Absolutely. Yep. >> It has to go to the So, it has to go to the ballot. So, they have to have hold when when's the next election, people will vote on that prompt and if the people vote for it, then it pass. But also, the Republicans will only send it to the ballot if they can expand vouchers.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 130
>> Yeah. So once once something's set in stone, I think what that could affect if there were more if there was more money for some reason, you know, if we had a one-time supplemental or something like that, that what that could affect is potentially the budget that you guys are able to work with for purpose, right? Because those dollars typically you you have to use them for their purpose, right? Um so if it was for teacher increases, then that's what it would be used for. Um >> but yeah, So >> I know there's I know there's a perception that we make a lot of those decisions on our own, but we really don't, right? We we rely on um meet and confer. We take direction from the governing board and and then just implement that stuff. So >> Okay, I want to come back. Katie, do you have any other questions?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 131
Okay, so we're next to >> Ariel, I have to say that prop that you're discussing is a ballot initiative that they want to send to the ballot. And if they send it to the ballot and it passed as a proposition, if it says the money has to go for teacher raises, meeting confer cannot change it. >> That's all I'll say. >> Okay. >> Different different processes. You know, there's that and there's the budgetary process. >> And even if they, you know, the legislature say yes, let's send it to the ballot, that doesn't mean anything until the election. You have the next election. A1, let's say A1, for example, the bill passes 56 to 44%. Then you have to wait a whole another year to actually get the fund. So, it's not it's going to be anytime soon. >> Okay. >> Thank uh >> um we already kind of moved past this, but I thought this this 10year giving up to 10 years, even if you're a 20 year veteran, is that was that something that was decided at like a previous meet and confer?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 132
And then um is that pretty standard because that seems like that would be quite a hurdle to get experienced >> if other districts are offering >> I don't know is that is that a pretty standard >> I yeah like you're saying that could be a recruitment tool to increase that >> right I'm just wondering did that was that decided at like a previous meeting for >> yeah my history here is uh sort of brief so I don't remember um ours four years Oh, okay. >> Okay. Okay. >> 10. >> Okay. >> There are some districts that >> Okay. All right. Thank you. >> 20 years of experience to a new school district all of a sudden. Makes you wonder what type of teacher are they after 20 years you have to go to a new district. >> Dominic, do you have um >> more slides or more?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 133
>> No, that was uh that was all I wanted to address. Um, if there's any other questions that you guys >> If there are any other questions, if you could raise your hand and we'll try to address them one at a time. Going once. >> Any data that you want, please put it on the parking lot. We we'll be glad to get it. >> All right. >> Thank you. Let's give Joel and Dominic round of applause for presenting all of that. And I have no idea how to get my laptop back up. Russell, >> okay. >> Russell is a magician and I'm very grateful that he is here. >> All right. Um with just a little bit more stuff before we uh break for lunch in about 30 uh unless we go a little bit earlier. We'll see. So we had a discussion after our last meeting uh about representation at the IBN table.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 134
So I just have a brief little bit about this on here and then if somebody uh if if it came to you last night or Kelly if it came to you last night let me know. Um, I think I think and we I touched on it a little bit this morning when we first started is, you know, really talking about what your role here is at the uh as a representative uh on the IBN team. Um, so I just sort of put it as in quote, you're here because others have authorized you or appointed you in some way to uh bring their interest to the table. uh their live experience that's going to come through in our stories uh versus advocacy. And again, it we will do it because that's our human nature to do so uh for our respective groups, but we want to try to remember that we're here not to be positional um or not to get what we already decided as a group that we wanted because that is very positional.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 135
we're here to work through some options through the IBN process. So, if you're looking for a win for your team, uh that is that is an approach I want you to try to put behind you is that we're looking for a win for all um as much as as we can. And in that respect, it's, you know, we're not fighting against each other. we're working together with each other to try to represent interest as best we can and to come up with some options to meet those um interests. So that's just a little tidbit about that and then I want to go over just I the IBN process again. I just have some key questions for each part. I'm also going to give you this um sheet that I'm hopeful is going to help us stay on the particular part of the thank you process when we are starting to address an issue.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 136
So, I'm going to give you about five minutes to just review this on your own as an individual and look through each part. My hope is that some of these questions and examples will help you understand even though we went over this last month, just to refresh your mind. So, I'm going to give you a few minutes to do that on your own, please. No talking, just looking it over and reconnecting. All right, I'm noticing lots of folks back on their technology, which tells me folks are finished. And so I just want to reconnect um back to this process of interestbased negotiation. These are the steps and the order that we go through in order to um unpack issues and come up with some possible solutions to uh those particular issues. Does this look like it might be helpful for you to use as we go through these things?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above