So, I'm going to give you just about four minutes. I'll do a check in at four minutes to see how you're doing and see what you found. So, take notes on whatever works for you on the couple of issue areas. All right, next step we're going to move into small groups and I want you to orient yourselves. Um, I've got a paper in the back, a chart paper over here for classified. That's administrator in the back. Certified over here. And what you're going to do, and I would encourage you to take your chairs with you and have something uh take a marker or two because you're going to fill in these charts, is when you get back there, I want you to each share what you identified as an individual for your issues that you think we need to tackle. We're just looking at priority ones right now.
Then I want you to agree on two to three issues that you think we should address as a team. So you have to come to agreement on two or three of them. And what you'll see is each chart has uh a column one that says what is the issue area. I'm not looking for an issue statement. Just give me an area. Put working conditions. And then you might put uh scheduling or something of that nature there. The middle one says why it rose to the top. So you're not going to say because I said so. You're going to give me some data as to why you decided to put that one there. And then the last column is who it affects. So, is it classified employees, all employees, students, [snorts] all of the above? Name exactly who it is. Okay? So, remember, all you're doing is staying at the issue level.
I don't want to hear any conversations about how to fix it. If somebody jumps into that, just remind them. Remember, we're just we're going to set aside options right now. We're just identifying what the issue is, why it rose to the top because 87% of people identified it or whatever your your reason is, and who it affects. Is everybody clear?
Any questions? Okay. So, again, classified folks, I want you to take your chairs. are going to come sit around this uh chart. administrator. the camera to be back on >> and microphones. >> Oh, I did not. But thank you. Uh I Joel think Adam got a lot to track here and I'm glad you're here to keep me on a couple things before we get to the priority uh issues that we just talked about and we're going to talk about how we're going to address this that I forgot to address when you came back from lunch. So a couple things I just want to make note that um I know that we talked about previously like if there was a caucus small group, right? That's when we turn the cameras and the mics off. Um, but I may also ask for that to happen if you know things feel a little curly as someone used to say uh you know if it feels a little ruffled or whatever it may be just to give space to have a conversation or whatever uh may be necessary.
So, just wanted to let you all know that and I will it'll obviously be announced if that happens. The other thing I wanted to bring attention to is that Joel uh during his lunchtime worked on some of the parking lot, not all. Uh so, some of those things are in there, but we're going to address them, come back to them at our next meeting and make sure that we give um an update on some of those issues or items, I should say. Okay. Anything else you want to share on that? Yeah, I just captured them. >> Oh, you just wrote them down in the document. Thank you. He didn't answer, per se. >> Yeah, that's what I said. I wanted him to have something to eat. >> Some of them he may, but I don't want to get in this habit of like, okay, let's get the answers right away.
So, we want to be thoughtful about when we're getting that information. All right, so here's what I have. Um, we're not we have some direction based on the small group whole group work that we just did. And if my illeible handwriting serves me well, that the priority issue that we've identified to start with is workload with 12, scheduling at 10, and then staffing is at five. That doesn't mean that there are not other things that will be addressed, but these are the ones we've identified that we're going to start with. So, I want to get consensus on this being the priority issue, this workload, and we're going to have to dig in to really understand what workload what what it means when we say workload. So, do we have consensus in the room to begin our work around the issue of workload? I'm looking for thumbs.
All right. Very good. Thank you. Okay. So, now what we're going to do is we're gonna try our process and see how we do. Are you guys ready? Okay. So, I want to You're going to want probably to have your framing worksheet available. And I want to start with this idea about workload. And we're going to start by identifying the issue with a statement about the issue. Okay. So we've got workload, but we need to frame it as a problem, not a solution. Okay. So if you start to come up with an option or a solution, just say, you know what, I just noticed I'm going into an option. Let me back up, retreat from that. Okay. So we're going to try to say I'm like if you look at your example, there are concerns about workload that are impacting so and so or such group in ways that affect it might be an outcome or an interest.
So some I don't know if you identified exactly uh why it is but it say if workload is the issue is it an impact on retention? Is it an impact on what? And so that's what we want to try to name. Okay. Real general, not no options. Is that thunder or >> Yeah. >> Okay. Um and I'm going to ask to see if anyone wants to try to take a take a Dorothy. Let's put um Roxanna, can you put Dorothy? and then Katie and let's see. We're not judging. We're just listening. See how it settles with us and then we'll take it from there. >> Dorothy, you ready? We need a microphone. Thank you. >> There are concerns about workload that affect teachers and their job satisfaction, which in turn affects retention. Man, do you think you could say that twice? >> Probably. >> There are concerns about workload >> about workload that affect teachers and their job satisfaction which in turn affects retention.
>> Katie. >> All right. Mine's similar and I stole a little bit of yours to add to mine. Uh there are concerns about the discrepancy between prep time and the amount of work that is asked of teachers that is impacting their work life balance in a way that impacts job satisfaction and student outcomes. >> Can you say that one more time? >> Well, I think I said impact too many times. >> That's okay. We're not we're not going to >> Okay, words. >> We're not right. There are concerns about the discrepancy between prep time and the amount of work that is asked of teachers which impacts their work life balance as well as job satisfaction and student outcomes. Sorry, I'm just taking notes. I hope you keep yours there as well. Okay. Caroline, >> I feel after talking to neighbor that we could uh just not say teachers, but maybe staff.
Uh we've got school bus drivers that are starting work at 6:00 a.m. and ending at 6:00 p.m. They're still doing runs. >> Okay. >> So, I think we could use maybe teachers and other staff. uh when you when you were doing your work in your smaller groups, did you see evidence of that in your survey results? I'm not saying that you can't still identify it, but did that show up somewhere? And somebody if you want to take a look or Eve's going to look >> I'm not saying no. I just want to hear a little more. James microphone. Thank you. Yes, there is evidence. >> Okay. >> I was surprised to hear that it was just teachers. >> Okay. What is your evidence? >> So, the uh I don't have the specific numbers. I can find them though. Um uh that their uh workload was specifically related to um uh uh uh that distribution of you know what you're being asked to do and the time that you're asked to do it with.
I think that relates to classified. I think that relates to administrative side. I think that relates to all employee groups. >> Okay. Is there anyone else in the Yes. Ally, >> you want to take a you want to try a statement or >> just to add to this? Um based [clears throat] on some of the responses in the survey, I think um some of the classified staff, specifically custodial staff, was mentioning being understaffed, but I do think that also can is kind of about this workload. They have too much to do at the schools and they're not able to get it done. So, some of the campuses are ending up not being like fully cleaned is what the comment some of the comments were saying. And that when we get to the story part, that's I'm going to need you to to remember that part because that's that that is part of the story.
Okay. So, let's go back to the identifying our issue. We've had two takes on it. I think we're okay. Kelly, I see you. Um I think we're okay making the change to staff or all employees. Um, but I'll I'll do a temperature check on that in a second. Kelly, >> um, I just felt like Dorothy's was pretty general and could easily be replaced to Garland's point with staff, but I felt like Katie's was very specific to teachers in terms of prep time. So, I don't know if we want to include two different >> okay >> issue statements because one is specific to a group of employees that specifically have prep time which classified staff do I understand but I think if I'm understanding you correctly it was different right and and the other one was a little more general >> no I appreciate that >> and then Ali's was even more specific to a different group that obviously has a different workload but not because >> I think let's we might want to unpack workload a little bit because I I think to your point when you're talking about that prep and I don't know if that shows up as another if if that falls under scheduling or planning or workload, right?
Like if if there are not enough uh custodial staff, I might have to clean two buildings instead of just one sort of thing, right? That's seems to be like a work load. But let's let's keep unpacking this. Eve, what do you got? Um, I pulled up the survey and there was one classified person that was dissatisfied specifically about time to complete duties, but there were four, nope, six uh that were um neither satisfied or dissatisfied because of staffing and workload. >> Okay. 10% of that particular group that responded. Okay, thank you for the clarification. All right, so let me go back to uh one of the first one. There are concerns about workload that affect staff. Is everybody okay with that change? >> And job satisfaction, which is Thank you. I can't even read my own handwriting. Okay. Is everybody okay with that issue statement as written?
>> Thumbs. Thumbs down somewhere. >> Would you like me to repeat it? >> Can Dorothy, would you repeat it since you It's >> I didn't write it down. Oh, there are I'm going to make sure I chicken scratch. There are concerns about workload that affect staff which is impacting job satisfaction and and affecting retention. Job satisfaction and retention. Okay. All right. I will capture that. >> I'll put it on the note sheet. >> Perfect. >> Concerns about work. which is impacting job satisfaction and retention. >> Okay. >> Now, I'm going to ask for uh somebody to help me take notes because um a I have terrible handwriting that sometimes I can't read my own. Most time I can. Um, but we're going to try to move to the story part of this issue. Okay. So, if somebody is willing and wants to come up here to take notes on the particular uh columns for me, that would be much appreciated.
>> I'm willing to write, but do you have any markers that are different than these markers? >> Are they not >> like the flip chart markers? >> Are they Are you telling me you don't like my markers? >> I like your markers. Ah, they're not working. >> I've got towards >> Gotcha. Listen, >> I know. I know. I know they're cheap markers. I kept my Mr. Sketch markers at home. All right. So, before we get started, the story, if you recall, and I think that's where you're going to. Yeah, I'll tell you in just a second. The story is the part of where we talk about what's happening, who's affected, why it matters, and what constraints might be in play. So, we're going to try to walk through this one question at a time, some of which we've already covered, but we're going to capture it up here and then capture it as a a a sentence or two.
So what is happening now? What are we seeing? And not shoulds, just descriptive. And you've sort of alluded to some of this uh already, Dorothy. >> Oh, sorry. It escaped. Uh from my experience, one of two things is happening for myself personally as well as other people that I see. Either people are working very long hours or work and presumably essential work is going undone or not done in a timely manner. Try try yeah just capture. It doesn't have to be full-blown sentences right now. We can make it Is this a current problem? Did it just start this school year? Did it start last year? When >> do we have any evidence? >> Are you asking everybody? >> I'm asking the group. Is there anything spelled out in the survey about it or no? Caroline, >> I was going to be smart and just say the district started in 1884.
It's been a problem since then. [laughter] But I don't have survey proof. >> Okay. >> This is Was this an issue last year >> that you talked about? Okay. >> Has it gotten just since COVID? Is it related to staffing shortages that have increased over the last couple years? Okay. Um, we talked about a little bit about who, but let's be specific about who it is impacting. Who's feeling this the the most most directly? Most directly. Is that a appropriate grammar? Where are my ELA teachers? >> It sounds like te teaching staff for sure. And sped, transportation, facilities. >> Okay, hang on to capture teachers. anyone else that we're not thinking about that is impacting that maybe it showed up in a comment. James. >> So I guess questioning process but not questioning process. Um I I feel like I feel like this is systemwide.
So and what worries me about like prioritizing like the first thing that came to my mind was what what group of employees has the most immediate uh uh contact with students. So I I would definitely first say teachers. Uh but uh I would also say that it's a systemwide thing and it it sets up this priority saying you know well this group of it's like whose ice is colder, right? This this group of employees is affected by it more than others. I I I have trouble with that. >> Well, you said it though like who who is impacted the directly, right? and it either showed up in the survey or not. And Eve gave us a couple of numbers on the teacher side or certified side. We didn't talk about the specific numbers, but was it more predominant? Eve, >> let me let me pull that up.
>> Okay. And to add to that part of the data, the largest employee group is teachers. So it would make sense to me that they would be the ones who would be the the the largest uh participants in the survey. So I feel like that needs to be a part of the conversation too. >> Yeah. And maybe if we think about it in terms of percentages, right? So even if more certified responded to the survey of those responses, what percent spoke about workload? Right? because you could have a lesser response from a different group, >> but it could still show up as their primary concern if that makes sense. >> Okay. >> I mean I mean from the survey, but our students are really being impacted most when work goes undone or people are burned out and teachers are turning over. it's impacting students and that's showing not necessarily in the survey data but in our in all of our data.
>> Tell me more. >> Well, I mean we have very we have a a you know high rate of turnover and we have fairly low test scores, you know, speaking comparatively to other districts. >> So, is the issue turnover or is the issue workload? Are your are your folks leaving because of workload? >> I'm sure that workload like the workload doesn't match the comp matches the compensation. You can go to the same district, you know, a different district, do the same amount of work, but get more money for doing it. >> So that's a different issue though, right? If you're talking about compensation, so if you were going to stay in that workload thing, right? I want to >> really come back to >> is workload affecting retention because the workload and the compensation isn't matching >> and I so I'm just I'm what I want to do is sort of push this towards some facts too, right?