2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 177
I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just saying it could be that workload is impacting retention. Well, I mean, I guess my evidence is that I've worked in a different district where teachers get two preps per day and those teachers do not turn over. Like they're there for life. And so, I guess I'm I'm comparatively speaking. And then obviously it's like all over. It's it's like the huge war cry right now is like >> this profession is built on unpaid labor. >> But what do you mean when you say facts? Do you want us to collect data? >> Well, I want to know, do you have some data that would support this? So, Eve Eve is >> I have some data that would support this. So uh we talked about six um classified were neither satisfied or dissatisfied but they were unhappy with the workload and one was dissatisfied um which I think we found to be about 10% but of cert certified 49% are either dissatisfied or neither satisfied or dissatisfied.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 178
So like neutral specifically about workload and it's also it coincides with compensation but we're talking about workload right now. So that's the data from the survey. >> So 49% of teachers specifically put that they were dissatisfied. Don't tell me about the neutral ones yet but just 49% though did indicate dissatisfaction. >> I included both. >> Tell me just about the dissatisfied. 10. >> So 10 10 people. Is there a percentage associated with that? >> 10 out of 39. >> So it's 15%. Okay. Dissatisfied. >> Where are my math? But the question that says, "How satisfied are you with the district's overall working conditions?" >> No. >> Is there a specific question about workload? >> It's working conditions, which says staffing, resources, tools, facilities, safety, communication, scheduling, etc. is 15 that's dissatisfied. >> Okay. Ally, we're getting 25% on which Pete >> 10 out of 39 is closer than 25.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 179
>> Gotcha. Okay. But again, to your point, Kelly, what you're saying is it showed up under working conditions. Were there were there 25 comments about workload alone or it was just that overall area? >> Are you talking about the comments or the bar the pigraph? >> I'm trying to narrow it down to workload. So, we got working conditions and within working conditions, there are lots of different things. You guys identified workload. How did you get to workload being >> that prior priority? >> Daniel's doing right now. >> I'm just I just listen. I'm not debating. I just want to unpack it a little more. >> There's not a lot of comments about workload. >> Okay. >> Are are we only using the survey as the evidence or can we use our background knowledge? >> But workloads including work conditions. So if you choose your top priority people said working conditions does working conditions include workload or we're looking to see did they specifically say workload.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 180
So I don't know if workload is one of the options or are we focusing on working conditions. >> So work is working conditions. Well, let me back up because within working conditions, there are multiple things that can happen within a working condition, right? Your schedule, your workload, safety, all of those areas. >> Yeah. So when you all were in your groups and identified workload and this could be on me as the area focus on my assumption and if uh was that you saw some data that said this is something we should really take a look at because it showed up whether it showed up in the comment or and I don't have the survey in front of me or as a specific thing within um so I'm not saying we don't address it. I'm just I just I'm trying to unpack it a little more.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 181
And I and to Katie's question, >> the prioritization >> asked specifically about workload, which is like it asked people to to rank their top three prioritization and that was >> 48% >> of all employees, okay, >> indicated that workload was their top priority or what meet and converse should the IBN team should focus on should explore. So, let me get back to Katie's question about are we only using the survey or can we bring our background into it. There's going to be a little bit of both naturally, right? Like some of the things that you talk about that you saw on the survey probably led you down a different path. You're sharing information about uh another uh organization. I think what you want to be careful about is right is that that that background in particular about the other place is not specific toraton. I'm not saying that you can't and won't have other issues but if you look at your survey and what your people responded to, they identified 48% identified workload as a priority area within working conditions to to address.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 182
Does that make sense? >> What you don't want to do is carry the water. And I thought I heard it in a uh a small group conversation about one person that you've heard on your campus who has a specific complaint. And by carry the water, I mean you're not going to just bring that here if it's just one. If it's multiple as it showed up on the survey, that's a whole different ballgame. Does that make sense? Do you want to spend time going through this process like we're doing right now for a p one person who has a concern or for 48% is where I'm trying to get you. >> I think what Katie's getting and I don't want to speak for you Katie so let me know if this is off base but I think all of us probably can think of an employee or several who have said like I'm overwhelmed overworked like I have too much to do.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 183
I do not have enough prep time. So I think that's what you mean by like anecdotal you know knowledge of questions that have happened with staff who feel sure overwhelmed and >> and like I could even go to data you know our learning walk data shows that teachers are not as prepared as we want them to be well of course they're not because they don't have enough time to do it same thing we can look at our AASA data our CFA data so I have like data components in my head but I think your questions are like can you pinpoint that is the exact reason and yes I can because yes I >> [laughter] >> And also my concern with using just the survey is how many people responded to the survey? >> 74 out of our whole district. That's not representative of the whole district.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 184
>> But statistically it is. >> It's still statistically statistically it is. >> What about the exit survey? That's what I was going to ask about was the exit. >> Let me come back to a couple things you said. So you have data. You are correct. And I am not a statistician. I said this last time. I'm never going to claim to be. But if you start, you've got causation, correlation. I'm not going to go into all that. The the doctors in the room can do that. Um, >> so you have to be really careful because if you can say 1,00 you are highly confident and you can prove statistically that as a result of not having enough planning time, students are not proficient in math. And if you just fix that thing, everybody would be proficient, the majority. You have to be very careful because I'm going to bet there's could be could be I don't know I've not seen your data there could be an issue around maybe you have teachers that are not uh content savvy when it comes to math at certain things right if I'm a brand new >> time to get content >> but they might have had professional learning you're right this is we could have provided them professional learning.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 185
So, I'm not trying to negate the issue. I just want to be careful about those sorts of things. And I think the other thing we have to be mindful of is you've got the survey. We yes, we wish that more people had responded, but this is the data that you have. That doesn't mean that you're not going to talk about in this story. You're already talking about some of the impacts like what you've heard. If you looked at exit survey data, uh, which is why I asked a question about workload, do you have evidence to say people are leaving Kraton because of the workload or is there something else that is being shared around that specifically? So, I'm not saying no. I'm just want to put that out for food for thought. Did was there another question over here? >> Ally and then Eve. Oh, sorry.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 186
Ally Dor. Oh, you're on it. Thank you, >> Ally. >> I am not very good at using like a spreadsheet, but I'm wondering if maybe you can look at the data of new teachers or like teachers that are within the first five years of teaching within the district and seeing their satisfaction scores and maybe using that sort of data to determine whether um that could be a potential reason why they're we don't have as great of as we want. >> Okay. So, um, Ally, then Dorothy, >> I was just going to go back to the exit survey data and do we is are is there a question around workload that we could directly look at that kind of information that you just talked about in terms of a certain percentage of teachers are citing that as a reason that they are leaving. >> Okay. >> But I don't know that we did exit survey.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 187
We did more of the stay surveys. >> We still do that. >> Okay. Okay. All right. >> Or you have both. So you might >> Or we have both. And maybe we can find something in both. I don't know. >> And again, I'm not I don't want to get too much in the weeds about it. I just want to be careful that we're not um just saying this because we know it to be true, right? You have some data pieces. That data may better inform some uh things as we move forward. Um but and we're gonna have to come back to the story in just a second. >> Can I just respond to Dorothy? So we uh it's a voluntary survey. So last year we had 40 respondents to the exit survey. Workload is a specific criteria that they can select. Um I can throw this into the um chat, but the specific question about why are you leaving?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 188
out of 40 responses, 15% noted workload. So, six six people out of 40. >> Yep. >> All right. >> Hey, I'm a miracle worker sometimes. >> Yes. All right, Daniel. >> Um I just went on the spreadsheet and like set up the filters to show me the numbers, but of the classified respondents, um 56% had workload as one of their top three issues. And then of the certified respondents, 87% had workload as one of their top three issues. So that is why when my group did listed workload, we said it primarily affected certified, it wasn't that the classified wasn't affected. It's that on the survey data, 87% of certified almost basically almost every single respondent had workload as one of their top three working conditions issues. It >> did um administrators, you have any data on that group or no? >> Yeah, I can check.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 189
>> Okay. All right. Thank you. and thanks for the data. Um, Eve, >> um, I have a little different data, but the of the, um, the comments area where it said rank your top three priorities, um, 31% of classified staff said workload and, uh, 62% of teachers said workload. >> Okay. All right. So, we're we're tackling the right thing. Okay. Again, I'm not I'm not I'm not trying to argue. I just want to make sure we understand fully like be mindful about what you're putting out here because again, you've you've got anecdotal evidence all day, every day, but we can't solve every single one of those issues. We we gave a survey. We identified some of the top areas of concern which led to this work and is now taking us down the story. Um, okay. >> Do you want the admin? >> Are there any other Oh, sure.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 190
>> It was It was 100% for admin. So, of all the respondents for admin, they all listed workload as a top three issue. >> How many do you know how many? >> 10 out of 10. >> 10 out of Thank you. Okay. So, it is fair to say that all staff >> Okay. All right. Now, we're going to go to the next part. What are potential impacts in this story about workload? What are the impacts if nothing changes? So, just I don't want you to focus on the urgency. I just want you to focus on potential consequences. If it stays as is, what might this mean over time? Don't pro no fixes, no auctions. Um I was going to say when people are overworked they cut corners right like when you are given 10 hours of work to do in an eight hour day two hours of work doesn't get done right and in some cases it means like in classified a building doesn't get cleaned something doesn't get fixed right certified it's like maybe some papers don't get graded maybe you know something doesn't happen that needs to happen things like that >> okay so the impacts are uh Wait, how can we put that in a shortcuts or less quality or incomplete?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 191
>> Yeah, lower quality or less work completed. Yeah, because I mean I thinking as a teacher it's like the impact really goes on the students, right? If I have, you know, 30 papers to grade, some of those kids aren't going to get those papers, right, if I don't have the time given to grade it. Okay. >> Other potential impacts, Brian. Um to build on what Daniel said, um if you're given, you know, some some employees will then take that extra missing two hours or three or four hours and take it home where um then it then affects, you know, home life, mental health, um >> work life, >> work work life balance, those type of things. any other potential impacts. Uh, Kelly >> um Joel reported what was the number again that folks that said it >> 15 >> that you just said% >> 15% >> that's all groups is that correct or okay >> all all employ >> so high staff turnover >> yeah retention >> yeah I I linked the results of Seems so the highest one was 37% [clears throat] salary 37 change.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 192
>> Okay. Other potential impacts >> Justinians. >> Thank you. others. Dorothy, >> well, I think Katie made a good um connection to student outcomes. If if work isn't getting done, ultimately that's going to start affecting student outcomes. If, for example, lesson plans or lesson planning isn't happening in a way that leads to effective instruction, that's going to affect student outcomes. If kids aren't getting timely feedback on the work that they're doing, that's going to lead to potential impact on student outcomes. So, >> okay. Other outcomes impacts, >> Kelly? >> Maybe like low morale overall. >> Yeah, morale. >> You just put morale. >> M O R A L E. Okay. All right. Any other impacts? All right. On the uh if you could draw a line like under your morale or or somehow we're going to I'm going to capture one other area here. Okay.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 193
Now we need to be able to talk about what constraints are in place, right? What are the known what boundaries or what realities are in place that shape this situation? >> Some things you just have to do because it's required legally. >> So legal requirements. Dorothy, I'm sorry. Did you have your hand up? >> That's what I was going to say. was like the minimum number of minutes that we have to teach certain things. We can't just a solution or an option can't just be give everybody four preps a day. Then we wouldn't meet the student minutes. So the legal requirements and that can be both uh state federal right IEP stuff. Okay, good. Um any other constraints or boundaries that are in place that we need to be thinking about? Daniel, >> um instructional constraints, right? So um the curriculum instruction department has like an outline of like what we as teachers need to be doing which requires x number of work and like our purview here is like non-instructional.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 194
So for example we couldn't have options that would significantly negatively impact instruction. We might be able to reshape things but like you know we can't pass something that would be oh no more social studies instruction or whatever. Right. >> Right. other potential realities that might shape this situation for us. >> Low staffing or staffing shortages. Is that okay? And that's not just teachers, right? That's all employee groups are impacted by this, right? It's there's a principal shortage, there's superintendent shortage, there's teacher shortage, sped teacher shortage, math teacher shortage, bus driver shortage, custodian I mean contracted services for I don't know if you're contracting out for any of those things, but very likely other constraints. Ally, >> something that was brought up in our group was um I guess like a concern around like making sure that if people did have more time it was used effectively.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 195
Um so potentially uh misuse of uh like additional planning time to get that work done. >> That's fair. So you can you might give it but it might be not intend not used as intended. Okay. All right Katie. >> Um I think financial constraints. We can't just hire 50 more people. >> Absolutely. >> Okay. So, I is 21 right now. I just want to make sure we're um I I want to put a break in because it took a little bit longer, but I think the time invested here because once we get going, the next time we do this, it won't take as long because you you've done it, you've seen it. So, what we're going to try to do is take all of this and put it into one story, not an essay, not a four paragraph uh paper, but just a few sentences about what we see here around working conditions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-08 Maricopa County, AZ YouTube / Creighton School District transcript source: youtube January 8th 2026 Meet and Confer · passage 196
So, I might ask Katie or anyone who's willing to to help uh take a try at this to see if we can come up with a a story statement or two about uh what we all contributed here. But we're going to do that after we come back together and see what we've come up with at 2. Let's come back at 2:30. It's 2:12. Okay. All right. Good work. You can cut the I'm going to read it out loud and it is up here for you as well. Currently workload essentials. I don't know where I got essentials. Is that on? Oh, essential work. Is that what that meant, Katie? You think? Essential. Sorry. Currently essential workload is impacting staff in all employee categories which has resulted in low morale retention issues lesser lower quality of work and may impact health and safety student outcomes and work life balances.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above