2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 80
Um we protect the rights, we call it individual rights when we talk about you know guns and and um you know even when we talk about 40B developers we're not protecting the rights of or getting helping people with housing. We're helping developers make >> profit, make money. And so we talk a lot about protecting rights and often if you really drill down it's uh we're not protecting individuals, we're protecting large companies and and profitm enterprises. >> Well, yeah. I I mean the only thing I want to say is that again I just want to emphasize I I think we talked about high school students being part of the forum but um you mentioned middle schoolers as well and I know middle schoolers in this community who are who have friends who are vaping using tobacco products. We it's very important that we hear from those folks too because I think if we hear I think to what Paul said earlier you know we're hearing a lot of voices but I think that's one voice that has not been heard in detail this evening and I think it's important for the community to understand you know understand impacts before decisions are made is a critical critical piece of that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 81
Um and that's been my goal for the past several oh man well years now as we start to redo some of these bylaws is how do we make them as clear as possible? And it's no easy task given that a lot of the bylaws is is a bit of a mess. So um but so uh if we go to so 8.1 is the purpose 8.2 um per was about the the open access units and the closed access units and I think I'll be looking at that text a little bit more but if I look at um okay so look let's look at 7.8.3 8.3 use limitations. It says the owner of record shall be an occupier of the structure which includes the in-law apartment. So that differs from an ADU because in an ADU both units can be owned by someone else who owns the property and they can both be rented out.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 81
So >> absolutely thank you Makita. First of all I'd like to thank everybody for being here this evening uh expressing your views and your concerns. It's it's a it's a matter it's a definitely a matter of health. It's definitely a matter that is going to affect a lot of people in many many ways. Um my my mom and dad were two pack smokers. My brother and I hated it. We hated smoking. Never smoked in my life. Ate, but that was that was my voice. Uh but being Italian, what the hell, you know? But I just want to say that uh I appreciate all your comments and um for those who are called zealots, you know, it's just really okay. Everybody has their Yep. they have their own opinions and everything and that's fine. We let them speak their speak their peace and um we didn't shut anybody out u because that's the right thing to do.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 82
Right? in an ADU, the the in-law apartment, the owner has to be in the main house and the relative um has to be in, you know, in the in-law apartment. So, um but it also says there shall be no other living unit on the lot. And I don't think we can say that. I think that that house with an in-law apartment has to be allowed to also have an ADU because by state law, every lot that is in a residential district can have an ADU. And if this is not an ADU, if an in-law apartment is not an ADU, then this lot can have one, too. You know what I mean? So, it can have a rental and it can have grandma living with you. Is that So, what I'm doing uh is folks is I'm going to point uh outline the sections and I'll meet with Lisa me um >> and have discussions with her about that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 82
Everybody needs to be heard on especially on a very serious concern like this. appreciate your coming forward and being honest with with with your with your addictions. U and it's a it's a daily battle and I appreciate that and I understand that completely. Um so thank you all for being here. Um, this this won't be the last time we discuss this matter for sure and uh I look forward to being uh maybe having a a meeting with the board of health if they get something moving forward and talking about people who would be willing to uh get a citizens petition to uh present this at the uh the town or maybe for that matter but we'll with that discuss that down the road. Okay. So, thank you very much for being here. appreciate it. >> Thank you very much. Um, we're gonna we're gonna we're going to take a two-minut break so that folks can leave if they want to leave so they don't interrupt us.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 83
>> Yeah. And Doug, we can go through this together, too. These are just things that I'm like, you know, that I'm like kind of pulling out. Um so um does anyone have any do they think I'm right about that? I think I'm right about that. >> Yeah. And that intern has that other section of disposal of sewage. How does that work if it is >> Yeah. So I don't think I think I think 8 7.8.4 disposal of sewage I don't think we even need. That's like building code, right? You have to get rid of your sewage. It's part of the main house. So why would we need to distinguish it as a separate? >> Because adding an adding a bedroom unit does impact your sewer. So if you have a fourbedroom house versus a five-bedroom house that you have to update your septic system. So >> but only in that case.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 83
If you don't mind Good evening and thank you. Uh we uh returned we're back in session. Uh we took a little break. Uh we had a very long discussion and uh very um dynamic discussion about a a very difficult topic. And next on our agenda >> is this sorry >> I would like to introduce uh Rob here. >> All right. >> Oh, okay. Susan, that's good. That's good. That's >> good. Very good. All right. >> It's a good thing we have an honest man up here. >> Yeah. Well, I checked. There was no cash in there. Rob is uh here representing u a group of individuals who uh came to uh a discussion about uh creating a subcommittee uh for a resolution regarding Elon Musk and uh the forum that they were going to present it in was we didn't think it was an appropriate form at at that time and they were uh willing and uh cooperative and um removed their petition from uh the fall town meeting and we greatly appreciate that and we thought that this would be a better forum to discuss matters and if it has to go further then we can we can take matters you know in another direction for a more positive way.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 84
So that's always true. No matter if I'm just adding a bedroom and not an in-law apartment, just a single bedroom, I still have to check with if I have a septic system, I still have to check. >> I don't think it hurts to leave it in. I don't think it hurts anything. But I would if you want to ask Lisa why she wants it in. I'm sure she put it in for protection. >> I don't think she put it in. I think it was leftover from the previous version that we had for years. Um so I think it has just been in there and wasn't requested. And if you add an ADU, >> would that whole >> system if it was a septic tank in that on that? And if you have an ADU as well added now, you increase the capacity of that particular lot.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 84
So Rob I will hand this over to you. Are you going to be the only spokesperson tonight or are there going to be others? >> People can come up as they feel. >> Okay. Yeah. >> Yeah. I I can make it depends what we end up doing, but I'm hoping this will be fairly quick procedural. Again, thank you. I'm Rob Shar and uh you know, I'm here with the other members of our ad hoc citizens group. And just Joe, you did a quick review. I'll just say, you know, I think we all remember that we had proposed citizens petition at special town meeting about town not doing business with the Musk and um also not using the X platform and also writing a letter to the um Middle Sex County Board of Retirement regarding the investments. And so at that time we had a number of kind of um individual discussions with various board members and also came to see you guys I think twice maybe.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 85
>> Um, >> and more, >> right? >> That's all separated out. >> Yeah. >> What Doug talked about before, you have to separate egresses, electrical, plumbing. >> It's an entirely new. Yeah. Yes. >> Correct. >> Yes. >> If you had to do a new septic system, it would it for all that it would probably take up most of your backyard. >> Yeah. >> It's all going to disappear. I I think it's it's in there just to um you know, like some some some things like in the building code in in in state ordinances and things like that. uh things to some things to put in there just to to catch to make be able to catch everything cuz you never you know some uh not everybody's not devious you know we get some pe some crazy people to come in with some crazy ideas and they well it doesn't say anything that I have to do anything I I should be fine and then you know and then things start to go sideways so deleting ing every little thing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 85
and um you know and agreed that um you you had a number of concerns but also um did indicate that there were might some actions you might be willing to take um not exactly maybe not exactly what's in the citizens petition but that you would try to address some of these issues. So, in good faith, we, you know, are taking you up on that offer. And I had made a proposal um that uh you appoint a subcommittee to meet with three of our folks. And we have uh we met last uh a few days ago and did select uh three people who were here tonight, Bethany Robertson, Ed Kirchburgger, and and Chuck Lids. And they're all here. Um and so our our proposal is that um um as we get into these kind of nuances and complexities, it's best to have a subcommittee that will maybe meet, you know, that will meet offline and kind of come up with recommendations, discuss and collaborate hopefully and come up with a set of recommendations to bring back to the full board over the next say few weeks and months, you know, prior to the annual town meeting.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 86
Uh probably not the best way to go. Not going to hurt anything. Um 90% of what we have in Ashland is [snorts] uh is pound sewer. Uh it's a small percentage in the outer banks of the of the town that uh they have septic. Um, but it's it's it's it's to just catch the the loose ends, you know, so somebody that's in the outer ends that wants to do something that it's there. Everybody knows this is how it's going to be. >> Yeah. >> And and we can go through some of these things later. I'm just kind of bringing up the questions about how again how do we how do we streamline this bylaw to be exactly what it needs um and and not contain you know the extra the extra stuff that we had when the in-law apartment and the ADU were were together right instead of separated into two things.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 86
Um and thing I think it would be useful for me to add is our own you know everchanging events and in some you know you could see that things seem to be getting even you know people have made a number of illusions tonight to rights and you know I think our concerns are even accelerating about what's going on and one thing that we are thinking are you know it's not just Musk it's kind of this whole kind of corporate and billionaire environment and their in their activities and that um perhaps you know one of the issues that came up with talk about one individual who's bad enough and is still misbehaving pretty badly. He's doing some things just recently. Um but maybe it's more like and I'm just throwing this out. Our thinking is maybe we need more like a a code of conduct or uh in you know ESG principles or um s you know what's ethical investing things like that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 87
Yeah, >> if I might, for example, uh I have a single family home and then if I were to add additional restrooms in the building, I have a limitation of how many I can add. I don't know how that count is derived. Um Doug, you may know it better, but that particular passage, I mean that uh 7.8.4 for actually make sure that that particular area can accommodate another two restrooms whether it's in the basement or not. I'm not sure how that calculation is done today, but if I have a four bed house, I have a three restrooms, I can only go add another one or two depending on I'm guessing the plumbing lines. I don't know how that logic is, but there's a limitation of how many restrooms I can add in my building. >> I don't. >> Yes, correct. is currently that's >> based upon it's based upon the the size of your septic system.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 87
So, you know, so maybe we're talking rather than singling out an individual, we're more defining conduct, our practices, our goals. And so that's kind of the direction that we're we've been moving in as a group. Um, so I just wanted to throw that out as a potential area of exploration for this subcommittee. Um, so that's pretty much um, you know, I don't I don't have too much more to add to that. I was just hoping that you've thought about the members have thought about it and you have at least two members are willing to work with us on this over the next say 8 weeks or so. Um and that's pretty much I don't know if folks had anything they wanted to add about that or well and looking at um your your proposition that you uh proposed um for tonight's meeting under tasks and goals.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 88
>> So adding that and if you're having an in-law apartment you have to probably make sure that that particular building can accommodate another two restrooms on that level. >> Yeah. I mean size of the amount of the size of the septic system is typically determined in my experience either by the number of bedrooms >> or most comm well I won't say most a lot of communities are going to a room count which doesn't include bathrooms because of the whole thing about it's an office it's a bedroom well call it whatever you want you're going to count a number of rooms and you divide by like four or something like that >> and that gives you your amount of of bedrooms like some communities are going >> last time I did a septic it was bedrooms and then there was a max so you three bedrooms eight rooms total >> yeah that's kind of how >> right so communities but are are going >> so I could have three bedrooms I could have 27 bathrooms three >> bedrooms exactly >> yeah because it's about the amount of people not about the amount of plumbing >> yes >> so >> exactly >> so does so going back to that paragraph does that help retaining that because It asks you to check.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 88
is the task is to review, discuss and formulate uh actions um to recommend to the select board and the goal is for mutual agreement as to specific actions by the select board uh addressed on uh the warrant article. But what I guess what value do we have other than our voices being raised? um no different than >> the citizens that are out there on Sunday morning on the sidewalks holding their signs uh you know expressing their their concerns and you know distrust with what's happening and it's just not here it's throughout our throughout our nation and and now it's looks like it may be global very shortly >> so um >> what's your role in this is what you're asking me >> yeah basically yeah that's I think that's a a great question. Well, the way I see it is that you are our elected leaders in this community.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 89
>> I think the paragraph probably is more for I I don't I'm I'm reading this for the first time. I want an in-law apartment. It never occurred to me because, you know, I flush my toilets, it goes away. It never occurred to me that I may have to change something of that. I think a lot of people don't realize that I've added two bedrooms. that could change something with my so I don't think it's a bad thing >> and I I read it as more someone who's trying to do this knowing nothing about ADUs they never looked up ADUs they don't know what that means um this is the first time >> it's an indirect way of it's a checklist of some sort >> well I could see that so I could look at it in that capacity >> it may be able to be simplified to just like >> check with the board of health on sewer requirements >> I can look at we can look at that and as far about how it's described as kind of a check because like I said, if you if you add um I'm just adding a master suite, one bedroom, one bathroom, and a closet, you have to think about the exact same questions as putting on an ADU, you know?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Select Board & Joint Meeting with Board of Health (January 7… · passage 89
And so, uh, and I think many of you feel that way that you have a leadership role to take and that and and that was kind of the discussion that we had that the select board has the power to do certain things or to make a statement or to take action to reflect the concerns of the community. And so that's why we're focusing on you guys. We're take we started with town meeting and we're willing to go back to town meeting because I think town meeting also has a role. You saw today you were discussing them doing the tobaccof free generation resolution. But so town meeting can have a role. But I think what we got up from talking to you folks um I don't know a few months ago during this was that you felt you had a role as well too and wanted to have a chance to perform that role or at least take some action >> um not the same as what we were proposing but something in that direction and I've suggested that maybe you know some cities and towns have ethical purchasing standards or ethical investment standards.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-09 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Planning Board (January 8th, 2026) · passage 90
So, that's why it's like and that's just under the building code. There's no there's nothing special about it, right? So, that's what I'm trying to distinguish that, you know, that really there's nothing special about this unit. So, >> let me throw a twist here. How are we handling those unit those properties that have campers? >> That's we'll have to get to that another time. >> Is that the whole totally different conversation? [laughter] >> Sorry, D. Let's not go down that route. >> Okay, I guess I'll keep quiet. [laughter] >> Okay, one of another question here and this is on the second page 8 7.8.7. the area limitation in the ADU the ADU regulations this this is from the state right that the the size of the >> what's that >> 900 square f feet >> yeah 900 square f feet um but it's um is not larger than 1/ half the gross floor area of the principal dwelling >> or 900 square feet whichever whichever is smaller Right.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above