You know, one thing, for example, I'm I'm trying to get a meeting with the state treasurer, uh, Dave Manyani, and I, you may know him, Joe, from somewhere, >> I think. So, >> uh, are going to try to meet with her. Well, she's done some really interesting things with the state pension fund. They have a stewardship and sustainability committee with goals, and I'm trying to remember, one is pay equity. The other is uh uh sustainability, climate sustainability. The other is um uh um oh forestry sustainable forestry. It's not all it's not super strong, but they have this kind of they're starting to develop this kind of screening for their investments, which I thought was really interesting. And to me, that's kind of a thing to encourage her and support her on and try to push her as an advocate to push her even more in that direction and the and the invest the prim board who you know.
So, you take half your house or 900 square ft, whichever one is smaller, that's the one you get to do in the in-law apartment the way it is now. And again, this is left over from what we had. It's 25% which makes sense because it's not an ADU, it's an in-laws. 25% of the floor area, 800 square feet or whichever is larger. >> Correct. >> Right. So that means if I have a that means if I have a 10,000 square foot house, I can have a 2500 square foot in-law apartment. >> And is that it? >> What? >> Have at it. >> And is that what we want to is that what we want to say? >> Well, I'll be honest with you. all the like the neighborhoods where the bigger homes are located, their basements are about 1,000 square ft, but they take out if you take out for the mechanical rooms and other areas that they're not going to use.
So that's to me that's an example of a role that folks can take and le you as community leaders can also take that position and we're willing to help with kind of the technical aspects like the the environmental, social and governance goals and stuff. I know everybody's pressed for time but we can help with those kinds of uh principles and standards that are that are being developed and you have a voice to say in that if you write to the Middle Sex County Retirement Board like we like this kind of thing. we think you should be pushing it and implementing it, for example. Um, so I'm just speaking kind of off the cuff about ideas that have occurred to me that this subcommittee could take on and develop. >> Yep. >> Well, you and I have had similar discussions uh not in depth, but with respect to county retirement and some of the things that >> we I have to be concerned about because I don't want to fall into an ethics issue because I am a member of the county retirement.
It's 800 square ft is typically in the town of Ashland is typically the size of the in-law apartments that I've seen. >> Yeah. Again, typically these are people that elderly people, they don't want to take care and maintain, you know, clean a big a big space. Uh kids, you got kids, you got grown kids or teenagers that you you don't want to give them any more space because they they're just going to trash more space. >> Yeah. So my question is my question is why wouldn't we just because I did I did some little diagrams for myself of a small house of a thousand square feet and a big house of 10,000 square feet and um and and what's 25% and how does that relate to 800 right and my conclusion kind of is maybe it's just about saying no matter how big your house is an in-law an in-laws apartment is 800 square feet you know maximum Because no problem if you have a small if you have a small house a quart say you have a thousand square foot house 250 square feet is going to give you a bedroom right not maybe maybe a bedroom and a bathroom but it's not going to give you an apartment maybe in New York City um >> good design >> very good design >> um but a 10,000 square foot house is going to give you a way bigger it's going to give you a whole house attached to your house as an ABU Fortunately, we don't have any 10,000 square foot homes.
>> Sure. I my retirement comes from that. So any actions that are taken if it benefits me then I affect I basically affected uh an ethical issue. >> So I would have to recuse myself from any and all of those discussions and anybody that's a member of the kind of retirement would s would have to do the same >> or if not they fall they they put themselves in a very difficult scenario. So >> well certainly that's something we should investigate. I'm a member of the state retirement system. I don't I feel I can advocate for whatever practices I feel like. So I'm I feel differently from you, but we can certainly >> Well, it's not that I can't discuss it. I just can't take a vote on it. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> Because that vote would affect >> Sure. >> my my actions in as a as a member.
>> Yeah. So, I'm just wondering, is this something where we just make it simple? If you're actually putting in a house for an adult child or a or a, you know, or a parent, um, can it just be a number, >> a maximum of 800 square feet? >> Um, yeah. And that could be the number. I'm not saying I'm saying >> whatever. >> Yeah. But but is that the >> should we have the same language as we had in ADU about the 900 plus the principal what are the principal home and percentage versus or should we differentiate so that we know as uh in commissioner when he walks in and he knows that the square footage is exactly as ADU would that create problems >> I I think that we should we should differentiate between the two u uses. you know, the ADU CA is is is is a specific size because uh actually to be to be honest with you, I'm not sure where the state came up with it, but um you know, when you want to build a single family ADU, I've just built uh two apartments that you side by side.
>> Well, I mean, I think we could get some clarification about that, you know, from >> Yeah. >> the ethics because potentially impact me too. So, I think we could get clarification. >> I think we're going to have to get clarification as it pertains to the three of you >> before, you know, we move forward, honestly. Um, but I I I I think just going back to what R was talking about in principle, um, you know, basically having an idea of like maybe putting a working group together. Sorry, I'm getting over a cold. um putting a working group together to just kind of look at um kind of kind of stepping away I'm just repeating what I'm hearing kind of stepping away from from talking about individual action but more or less like looking at how how the town could look at some guidelines around >> um you know purchasing etc.
It was a two It was two family um and they were going to be rented by apartments and they were each 900 square f feet. You could make two 12x 12 bedrooms >> in them or you could build one nice big 15 by 15 bedroom in them. And uh and I think that that's probably where because the two bedrooms is maxed out uh you know the you can't there's not a lot of room left over. Um, but I I think in a in a in an in-law situation, um, I think that uh 800 square ft is probably 90% of the of the town is probably about maximum >> of what you can fit in there. >> Um, and I and I think it would be good a wise thing to consider just keeping the two separated square footages. >> So, I agree with you completely.
you know, um, in various different areas, uh, that would obviously have impacts on some of the issues that you care about, but may go beyond that as well. Is that what I'm hearing? >> Yeah. And I, you know, use this as a basis, but understand that we >> events are changing. I think we're getting to be a little more sophisticated in our understanding of >> and and the issues that you folks brought up about, you know, not bearing arbitrary be defining, you know, what's what's proper conduct and what's not being objective. So, I think that's the kind of direction we want to go in. Um, and you folks, you know, um, and I know you're very busy, believe me, I remember that. Um um but it'd be great if at least, you know, if two of you were willing to work with us for hopefully a short period of time to put something together.
The way this is written, anyone can have 800 anyways, so you might as well just take out the percentage. Choose that square footage and that's your maximum. >> Yeah. I mean, um, >> you know, you're in a smaller >> house, you're going to likely upgrade to that anyways, so you might as well just say that that's sort of the maximum. And that prevents, you know, a larger house from making a fourbedroom apartment attached to it. >> Right. Right. Right. A fourbedroom ADU, you know, thing or four Yeah. fourbedroom in-law suite. Right. >> Yeah. Which defeats the purpose. [clears throat] I think it's really a two family house at that point. >> So, >> is 800 the right number? Do everybody feel that's the right not a thousand? I I actually recently working with Doug before our ADU law was changed, I did an ADU in Ashland right at 800 square feet, you know, and what it, you know, it was for um a grandma and it basically takes care of a a one bedroomedroom, onebedroom bath, kitchenet, living, dining.
>> So when this was first brought up, I I had no interest because you were to me you were looking at one person because of some of the things he did. But you've brought up an interesting point and I was able to just look >> the idea of looking at our procurement from an ethical perspective, >> right? So we're not just to your point talking about one person or one company, >> but looking at how do we as a town want to do our procurement just like we talk about being a green community and we make decisions when we're creating buildings or planning things to to take that all into consideration, right? We have our information about being a sustainability, you know, a sustainable community. >> And what does that mean? Well, it's not just about energy, but there's other things that you need to do to be sustainable.
It's a little apartment and 800 works. with 900. I think the difference is with the state um like I'm working on one now that I can put in a second bedroom, you know, so that you have an ADU that could be have an office or it could have parents and a child in an ADU. And I think that's the difference between 8 and 900. Not saying one is better, but if if we want it to be >> gets you an additional 10 by 10 room. >> It that's what it gets you. Yeah. So >> yeah, that sounds like a good one. >> So the 800 might be the right spot. >> Yeah. >> Okay. >> I mean, if it doesn't work, we obviously can review it if Yeah. things come up, but sounds like from square footage approximately if you look at a living, dining, kitchen.
>> So, I mean, I by no means am and stepping up to do this because that's not possible. But I would like to see the discussion go rather than toward one or two people because >> I mean business isn't in there people do businesses to be profitable, >> right? So, I was having this discussion with someone else. It's like, "Yes, but some people have so much money and how is that?" I'm like, "Because they've worked or whatever they do or people support that business so they're more profitable, so they're going to have more money." That's not a negative thing. Those of us who who work with nonprofits, we want people to make money so that they can donate that money to nonprofits. But if we want to look at how we are looking at our procurement from an ethical perspective, right >> and investments too >> and investments and things like that, what are we >> what are what do we want to use to support our community and how can we do that?
I think sounds like the right number. >> So what is the town missing out on a tax base on these property tax? Well, they I I'm not going to speak for Don the assessor, but he they they'll be they'll be charged the tax, but they're not going to be t taxed uh as it would be a single family home. >> So, I don't know what do you what's the average single family home tax? What? 8 grand between seven and 8,000 in Ashland. >> Uh sure. >> So, >> yeah. Well, let's just say $7,000. So, you know, you add a whole new uh single family home, an ADU in your backyard, you're going to get taxed substantially. May not be $7,000, but you're going to be taxed substantially because it's a single family home. If it's an in-law apartment, you're going to be taxed for however you tax for a bedroom and a kitchen with what, you know, an extra $500 to $1,000.
So I'd be interested from that perspective and like I said I just Googled it very quick and there are a lot there is a fair amount of information regarding that. So I think >> if we take it from that approach >> and then see what happens that would be my recommendation. >> I I would agree with you Yolanda and I think that was sort of the approach that I think the last time you all came through. I think that's what I was sort of pushing pushing for and when you came through. So I'm glad to see that you've sort of kind of evolved your thinking a little bit and kind of even kind of widened your your um your your analysis of of of of things. So, I mean, I I think there's room to explore uh putting some kind of uh putting something there's room to explore putting some guidelines around that kind of stuff.
So there's this big difference because when the ADUs came through, I went down and talked to Don who's our assessor and I said, "How are you want to how are you going to deal with uh the the these ADUs because the state wants them to be a single considered a single family home?" And he said, "I'm going to tax them like a single family home." and uh and then you know when he um gets copies of our permits uh he'll be notified that uh if somebody's building an in-law apartment. It's not a it's not in a it's not a it's not the same tax rate as a single family home. Substantially less than that. >> Yeah. Well, there's still the town's still going to get its its chunk of the chunk of the pie, but it's not going to be as great as it would be if it were an ADU.
Um I'm not exactly sure what the most appropriate mechanism to do that is, but I think that's something that we should we should p we should explore and I would be interested in being helpful. I don't know if like eight weeks is is going to be long enough honestly to kind of put together any kind of recommendations. It might be good for like kind of an initial sort of pass it what's going on. I don't think anything final um would come out of an 8week kind of you know uh exploration of this but I think this is something that in my opinion we should commit to exploring and and and putting something together eventually around it. >> Yeah. And I would just say just to just to piggyback on what Makita and Yolanda said. So the select board, if you go on the select board's web page, um we have we came up I guess it was probably about a year or so ago, we have the Ashlin Select Board and Town Management guiding values and principles.
Well, also I think the point is that as as we just saw in the other presentation u for the housing production plan is the population of Ashland ages um that people can be family members can be accommodated within a family's home and it's and and that frees up you know another another home for another family versus you know versus thinking about the the taxes you know on that it's going to go up anyway just because the assess assessed value, right? So, but the last thing I wanted to cover in here and there's lots of small points, but is the provision for parking. The ADU, if it's not a within a half a mile, I think, of a train station, the ADU has to provide one off- streetet parking space. Does an in-law apartment need an off- streetet a mandatory off- streetet parking space? >> An accessible parking space, I guess.
And I think, you know, that is kind of the, you know, you look at some of these things, it's like embrace our diversity and kind of defines that and build a true home. And so maybe there's something that we can include in there that would be sort of our guiding principles. And then obviously there's sort of more of the technical like nuts and bolts of specific things that we could do whether it's procurement or whatever. But I think like >> including it into our value system as as a town. I think like you know a broad a broad thing about how we um whether it's you know governance or whether it's um ethical behavior in some ways or whatever that looks like >> um that how our taxpayer dollars are spent. So, >> um, >> well, I do want to say that we did have some specific concerns having to do with >> with Elon Musk and now I think we're saying it could be broader because there's other corporate interests.
>> Yeah. Yeah. How do we I mean, how do we you know, how do we think of is that the same thing? >> Well, you can't park on the streets uh like in the winter time. These are these are the the people in an in an in-law apartment are more are more permanent because they're a family member than they are uh than an ADU is which could vary could be a family member but the ones people that are talked to me they want to rent them out rent them out and uh and and so they're more transient the people in the in the ADUs are more transient Um, you know, you don't the idea for an in-law apartment and and why some of the language is in there is we don't we want the single family home neighborhood to stay looking like a single family home neighborhood.