Um, if you get the two, I think you have to do the formal appointment and then it becomes a subcommittee and open meeting law and all. >> Does it have to be like one person at all times or could you have like people tag in and tag out? >> No, that's a qu No, I don't know that. I don't know that answer. >> I'm just thinking just Well, for instance, like you know, I'm kind of sick right now. >> Yeah. >> I mean, not terribly. I'm coming. I'm not contagious you guys. It's fine. But I but you know I'm just saying that like okay like I'm the you know the president's just like oh gosh I'm sick. Okay well then nothing really happens because the board representative isn't >> actually I think that would be fine because the working group aspect is nothing like official.
The only concern I would be is if you, you know, if you're trying to rent it to an outside person, um, that you don't know who they are, um, never seen met them before and you're trying to make a profit on it. So I guess to part of like let's say my best friend's in a car accident. >> Exactly. >> She has no family. I want her to come live with me. Yeah. >> I'm not planning to rent to her because she's [clears throat] my best friend and I'm just taking care of her because she has no one else. >> Would that be allowed under an in-law situation or does that kick it to an ADU? I guess is the question? >> No, I I I'll be honest with you. I I don't ask. So, >> well, I I think >> but I No, I don't I wouldn't have an issue with it.
Right. >> Right. I mean there there's certainly intent behind it. >> So if I'm not there then it's like oh hey Joe can you can you go to this meeting because I can't. >> Exactly. And that would that would be okay. >> Yes. >> But the both of us can't attend the meeting at the same time. Or can we? >> No, you can't attend the meeting at the same time >> unless we create a subcommittee and you post and take meetings. >> Yeah. You can't do the working group format to >> So I mean I don't know. Could you have >> sorry >> you know somebody who is doing it regularly and then have somebody else drop in to because you kind of want to stay informed. You know what I mean? So, it's would be great to have Makita be our point person, but you know, I know Joe and I know I would like to maybe attend once in a while and hear what's the conversation like so that we I'm sort of on board before, >> right?
>> Yeah, >> I'm not going to have an issue with it. I mean, you know, >> Yeah. I think in terms of making it clear, it's just really it's it it is just redefining this. I think we're all in agreement that it's not about blood family. It's about people who feel like family because they have access to the whole rest of your house. There's no locked door. So it's people that feel like family and so we will find the the correct term to use for them. So >> do you have something else Kate? >> I do the several. Um so I think just hearing this conversation I think this absolutely needs to have some grid of like what differentiates a a um I don't know what we're going to call it. Hopefully not inlaw, but maybe in law if it's defined. Um, not an ADU because I think that it's just it feels like it could be arbitrary and then not because I'm under the impression that an ADU can be in your single family house.
The only the only thing is I was going to say the only thing is >> is if because you're going to be discussing something that's going to come before our whole board, >> you can't >> both be there. >> Good point. >> If you were talking if you were talking about hanging out at the farmers market next weekend, that's a different thing, right? >> But if we'll be there, >> I know bring shovel >> all these people are going to show up at the farmers market next week. >> Um >> but but that but that's sort of the thing. If we're going to deliberate on something, it only can be one person or two people for a subcommittee. >> We're going to have to >> It can't be an appointment >> like an official appointment. You can do that. I like the point person raising.
It obviously has to meet the building code and think and then you said tonight it can't and I'm not sure I agree with that, but >> you know, I I don't think we said it can't. It can be embedded into the house. That's a part of the ADU bylaw, >> but it requires the same kind of separation as if it's a two family house, >> right? That according to the building code. >> So, that's what makes it different. >> And that might be the one thing, but I think there might be a couple things, a little grid to make it clear, like very clear. That's what we're trying to do is make our bylaws clear. >> Yeah. >> Um on 7.83, it says no borders or lodgers shall be allowed in either dwelling unit. So, let's say I have your scenario, my friend that doesn't have friends, and I have the financial wherewithal to have the friend come, but you want it to be nice, so it has a little separation, but then I'm going to travel the world because I got won the lottery and I'm going to rent my part of the house.
>> Okay. >> So, do we feel like we need to run that by I think we understand, right? If it's one person, it's a working group with three of them their members and then, you know, Makita can't be there so someone else goes, that's fine. But no votes to appoint right unless we want to make it a subcommittee and say okay two people are going to be there it'll be posted there'll be minutes taken so that if people want to know about it >> well maybe you start with the not it's not working and if you decide look it would be good to have two of us >> and maybe that's the first meeting maybe we just do a working group let's do a working group meeting and we let's kind of talk through not values but also structure and kind of figure that out and then we we come back we can figure out >> I have a feeling that that's the direction that we're probably going to be going.
Why can't I while my friend is in the uh in-law part of the house? That's a legal discussion I'd have to take up with Lisa. >> Yeah, that's a little tricky. Like now you because now you have two strangers now. Uh that now you have a it's not a family anymore. It's a you know it's a it's a paid tenant and a family. >> Well, okay, but like we're I think I mean by like >> we're in the US and we want property rights and I get my house and I get to rent it. So, like I don't know that you rent the whole house because because the because the in-law unit is a part of the house. That's what we're saying. It's not a separate unit. It's part of the house. >> But the way that's written doesn't cover what you're saying then. >> Well, the border or lodger.
>> Yeah, I was going to say I think at some point we're going to want this as a subcommittee so that the discussion and that happens becomes public record, right? So people can go back to it and say, "Well, what was talked about?" And rather than have it just show up at the select board meeting. >> You know what? I I actually now I'm kind of leaning just towards a subcommittee at this point because we want to make sure that we're being transparent about this and I don't want anybody to say that we're not. >> Yeah. >> So I think maybe that is the the right structure. Plus it allows other other um select board members to attend. It also allows other people if they want to go if they want a public meeting so people can >> they can hear what the discussion is and they can give their input >> and I think that's important.
Yeah. I mean, um, >> but I I understand what you're saying, but I don't what you said is not how that's written. Well, I'm not sure how it's written, but it's that the that there's no one in the that's paying rent to someone else, right? So, you can rent out your whole house, but then you can't I don't think you can separate out the two pieces, right? >> Because it's one piece. It's one, not two >> in this. There's there's one dwelling. Yeah. You can either rent out the dwelling or you cannot, but you can't rent out half a dwelling. So, um >> Okay. And I [clears throat] think we talked about that no other living unit. I think you have to have an ADU by allowed by the law. Um [clears throat] the ingress, egress, and attic provision. I think some of those it says that um building inspector, but I think it should be like shouldn't that be like building codes?
So you know I don't think we want to you know exclude or rather we want to be as transparent as possible during this process. So you know I think maybe that's that's probably the way to go. >> And I would say from my experience that we did appoint a number of subcommittees fairly routinely. It wasn't like a huge a huge deal. I my feeling is I'm not the town council, but you could pick two people and vote them in tonight and start this process as a public, you know, as a subcommittee. I mean, committee. >> Yeah. Regarding the transparency thing, I think you could think of it a couple of different ways and I don't know if this would help you. Um you if this is a policy that the board would take up and it would be a you know that would be where the vote ultimate vote would be taken you might you know especially consider having some of those meetings open in public just because >> the the virtue of how visible things are.
We again we have things to line up to. Yeah, I was skipping over that one because it I don't think this needs to go late into the night, but I think again that's another one that might be really covered in the building code and that we might not need for this single family dwelling, which is what we're talking about. >> Um the 7.8.8 it is. Are we asking like too much? like you have to do your floor plan but then show like 200 feet around the neighborhood like >> again this is left over from when this was the ad the in-law apartment bylaw >> and so it made sense at that time and so requiring floor plans that are different than what's required from for a normal building permit obviously it probably isn't needed in there >> um the parking I I heard lots of conversation which is good I I mean, we say don't park in the street, but street parking is allowed, right?
If you're looking at ultimately a town meeting vote for something which you know is very visible, right? You know, and and process uh process oriented, you know, you might lean more towards the working group format, you know, knowing the transparency >> would emerge kind of later in the process. >> Just a couple different ways to think about it. >> Audible sigh. Um, so audible side. Um, okay. Um, >> Rob, if we were to give this a a week for people to make their decisions, unless you know to think about it, you guys, I should say ladies, are you ready to make a decision tonight or do you want to give us some thought? >> Thinking >> like the about >> structure >> how it should be structured or >> like give it a day or two? Well, it sounds like it sounds like we're leaning towards a subcommittee.
Except the winter sort of stuff. So, I feel like it shouldn't be too kind of ownorous on that. Um, anyway, and I it sounds like there'll be another round, but those are my comments. >> Yeah, there'll be another round. Thank you. >> Thanks. All right. Um, like I said, this this is just kind of round one on this. I'm glad we finally got to tackle it because it's an important bylaw and we'll put it on we want to get it on the docket for the spring. Um, but there'll be a big revision and then we'll we'll look at it again probably I don't know about we'll have it on for the 22nd in case everything else drops off again. >> How does our bylaw compare to other towns near us? It's very similar to have an in-law and a ADU bylaw separate because it is a differential that only happens within the building department, but if you do not have it separated in your build in your zoning bylaw, the building commissioner cannot grant an in-law apartment if you don't expressly allow it.
>> That's what it sounds like to me. >> Is it >> so I would make a suggestion that we can discuss like who we who might be willing to do it. >> But if we're going to appoint a subcommittee, we actually have to put names on the agenda and >> like next >> meeting. Okay. >> That's the issue. We've appointed subcommittees without it being like when we've talked about grant programs like the BAA grant, we often talk about that and then appoint the subcommittee and the specifics like that. >> No, >> are not on the agenda if I'm correct. >> And and maybe we should maybe we should be doing that. >> Okay. >> Um you know, >> obviously there's going to be a little bit more eyes on a subcommittee related to this, I think, out of its origins than something like the BAA grant.
>> Yeah. And our our ADU bylaw came out of was modified from language that is provided by the state as a draft. You don't have to use it, but we we started with the base. We looked at some other things. We we put in some of our own things, but um so our bylaw, our ADU bylaw, excuse me, is related to everyone else's, but it's kind of unique there. >> When did this ADA ADU law start to manifest itself? What year did that >> About a year ago? About a year ago that it became I want to say February that it was that it became uh state law. So probably preceded by a year or two before that >> that they started to talk about it. >> Yeah. Because it does nothing happens overnight in in >> it was it was something that was issued at the state level and it was mandated that ADUs had to be allowed by rate and all towns had to update their bylaws within a certain amount.
So, you know, just >> bear that in mind out there. >> So, >> and I think I think I think Makita hit it on her head when she said, you know, transparency matter of this is uh is very important. >> Yeah. >> You know. >> Yeah. >> So, >> let's do it right. >> Yeah. Let's do it right. Yeah. >> So, are there people that So, I'm hearing Makita, you would be willing to >> Yes. >> and >> somebody else. >> So, you'll have to do the vote next meeting, correct? Is that what we're talking about? Yeah. Okay. >> All right. >> That at least gives you some time to think about it. >> All right. I would just, you know, we are concerned about the passage of time and I know everything takes time, but we appreciate you moving ahead on this. So, we expect next meeting you'll you'll appoint, it sounds like you'll take a formal vote and appoint a subcommittee or at least you're leaning in that direction.
>> I think I heard about it in late 2024. >> Yeah. But I can give you a history of it and it's all on the website. So >> yeah. So, >> but I think to Kate's point, I think some of the when you can just Google it, it's in-law or ADU. So, I think from that rental point of view, we have to be very clear on what language we put in. >> This language was chosen because this is how it's differentiated in the code. So, this language actually is important to keep because there is language on this in the building code and it's important to be consistent with it exists in the building code. >> So, we're we'll look at that and present that actually next time as well. Um >> maybe to the point of 7.8.3 we look at the language in the future >> language.
>> Yeah. And that's on the 21st. >> The 21st. >> That work. And is the general outight seem agreeable to people at this point like the structure u with the two and the three or would you prefer something a little different or any any thoughts on that? >> That's fine. Yeah. >> You don't want to make it too big. You know that, right? Too big of a committee and you don't want it too small. You don't want it too big. Yeah. Whatever. >> Do we know before the next meeting who's going to >> No. on. >> No, they're gonna they have to vote on at the next meeting. We'll put it on the agenda that we'll have a vote and people will determine who they want to do it and then we'll vote those people in >> and you'll need the names the proposed other members.
What do you mean >> well use limitations? >> What about >> because it's a little ambiguous? >> Oh that's a technical term I think. Um, is it as the term the term use limitations? Yes. I think that's >> that's a legal >> like >> is that approved by legal to use that? >> That's actually legal by our town council bylaw is written by town council. >> No way to amend it if we wanted to. >> You there that is it's a use limitation on the site. It is it that's exactly what it is. So there's no way to amend that because that's exactly what it is. You can we can amend the language following it, but it that the use limitation is just a Yeah. Everything else is no borders or lodgers. It's like >> talks like that. >> It's a limit of the use.