And I think um just hearing, you know, some of the conversation um I'll be honest, some of the the lack of conversation really kind of over I mean this it's been a little quiet and I was surprised and um I think um this is going to be an interesting discussion for the community to have. I would just caution you to just always check kind of like your motivations especially when you're engaging the public and you know like coming in like what what's the actual what are you trying to accomplish through that? I I know you know transparency obviously is is is the ultimate aim here and that's really really important and how does that relate to process and >> you know are you sure that you're giving everybody an equal opportunity to say something right >> or are things like intimidation and fear >> running through the community and keeping some voices from being >> heard which does happen and we know that happens everybody around this table knows that happens >> well that that's why we have to when we put the forums together we need to make sure that we're building them with that in mind.
But the whole point is to make sure that people have an I have an opportunity to ask questions, uh, voice their concerns, and get answers in a public forum. >> Yeah, the public forum is great unless you feel scared to say something. That's a problem. >> I'd like us to look at is um, our select board office hours >> in the next >> folks. I I I I'm not sure if I'm being heard here. Um, your biggest concern is not the budget right now. It is the fact that you have some people who are scared to say anything because they're afraid they'll be targeted. >> I think we have to provide many different avenues for people to provide feedback, >> right? >> So public forum is definitely one of those avenues >> as we're putting together, you know, when we're putting together our communications plan around this.
I mean there should be an email, there should be a this, there should be a that, but the public forum is also very important. And to your point, you know, things can things can happen in public forums. And and I'm not saying that they won't, but I think if we structure it correctly and make sure that we we do it respectfully, make sure that everybody that participates understands what the ground rules are. I don't think we have anything to to fear. We don't have anything to fear. I think are you concerned >> that people will try to intimidate or >> influence or harass one way or the other. >> I am concerned that if some people speak up and you know take certain positions that they will be targeted online I think they or you know through social media or you know some other way and made to feel like their voices don't count.
That's what I'm concerned about. >> It happens. It's been happening. >> It's been happening. Yeah. >> So I I don't see anything different. We just have to >> and the communications plan that you that you commissioned and signed on to last year actually says that you are responsible for ensuring a forum and community space that is safe, >> right, >> for everybody to speak. >> So that's what we're going to do. I mean, >> okay, >> you know, but I I think it's important to voice these concerns because, you know, as we go forward and we structure these events, there's going to be a way that we structure them that's going to make sure that we can adhere to those values. And that's why we're doing it. >> And I think we're going to have to be prepared. >> Yeah. >> To help people say to help people understand that we're going to be hearing from both sides.
>> That's right. Yeah. >> And our goal as part of this will be to keep the conversation civil >> and not let it get personal and not let it not let language get used like we heard tonight. >> Right. Talking about the zealots against smoking. >> Right. >> I think if we hear that language, we immediately have to say rethink how you're saying this, please. Because the conversation has to be kept civil. We're all in this community together and people have a right to have their voice heard but not in a way where you're attacking someone else. >> Yeah. >> Correct. We have to establish ground rules, >> rules of engagement, all these things. That's what I meant by structure, Yolanda. And that's been Michael, you know, I think if we we do that and and do, you know, do our pre-work, you know, we just don't go to a room and open a mic and let people speak into it.
That's not how that's going to be conducted. But if we structure it correctly, make sure that we're, you know, getting that feedback, reporting, recording that feedback, making sure that again that people >> feel safe, know that they can express their opinions. And people who don't, you know, they're going to they're they they they're going to have to figure out a way to share their opinions in a different way >> because that's not the forum >> if not in a public I'm sorry. Yeah. But yeah, so and we'll have to clearly communicate that before, during, and after. >> That's the preamble of of the special of a town meeting when Adam reads his >> pretty much >> his guidelines of how he wants the his meeting to run. >> That's right. >> No different than that. No different. Maybe more specificity around ground rules, but no different.
>> Then this will be a good discussion. This will be >> I think so. I think it'll be a very good I mean it's it's time for the community to have the discussion. >> Yes. >> There also has to be opportunities for people to um submit, you know, questions, ideas, thoughts. I mean, I think it can be as simple as as a survey of some sort or >> Yeah. uh form that gets sent out in your emails and gives people the opportunity to um you know anonymously >> um >> give feedback >> feedback >> but I think if if you know I would encourage folks to not be anonymous in their feedback if they're doing it >> if they're doing it in a non-public forum I think it's important that people uh do give who give their names because first off if they have questions or concerns we want to make sure that we can get back to and address that specifically.
>> U and the other thing is that we don't want to have like a barrage of bots or a barrage of automated, you know, people filling out forms or whatever, finding them online and stuffing the ballot box as it were with opinions that aren't real or >> No, I I don't think we if we don't, you know, if we make it anonymous so that people because some people won't respond if they have to provide an email, right? >> But why story? because they maybe because they think that, you know, we're going to share it or we're going to do something. They don't trust us, whatever. I mean, ideally, yeah, I'm in favor of okay, have people submit with email, but if they choose not to, we can certainly respond to those comments on a website. >> Yeah, I mean, we've had this question and this is the response to it.
So, >> I think Yeah, I think people do need to understand though if they're going to submit anonymously, that's how they're going to get their response. like we can't obviously go to them and address their specific >> concern. I agree. I agree. I understand the limitations. >> I think we might need to have a discussion about this because my feeling is I mean anonymity has some benefit, but I want to make sure that the people who are responding are people who live in our community who who >> just because somebody doesn't live here though and I understand why. Yeah, it would be valuable to understand that we got a hundred responses and 50 of and they were all from people that live in our community and 50 of them raised this concern and 40 of them had this. >> I mean, I don't we wouldn't have that kind of data if we do it anonymously, right?
Because we don't know who they are and why what their motivation is or anything else, but there's not that doesn't say that there isn't something that can be learned from that, right? that somebody put something out there that is >> similar similar again similar to what happened tonight right when we were talking about the nicotine free sure it was great to hear from all the different people but half of the people that spoke >> out of town >> we're not Ashland residents >> so I appreciate and I accept that information but in regards to for me personally regards to making a decision for Ashland as a community I give much more weight to people who live in our community who are going to be impacted by whatever decision we make. >> Yeah, I I certainly agree with you, but in terms of what somebody It's interesting to hear perspectives.
>> I agree it's interesting to hear perspectives, >> especially when they've gone through it already, >> right? The the one thing I will say and then maybe we talk about this another time is that I I hear you both. I I do lean towards folks identifying themselves so that we can actually and it's that's really in my opinion more of almost like a customer service issue, right? Like how are we going to address concerns if we don't know your concerns if we don't know who you are? Um but you know on the other hand I do know that there are individuals here in town who do feel very intimidated with their interactions here with town hall and even with us. you know, we don't we want to make sure that we we do hear all of these voices. So, I think we've got to figure out a way to capture all those different pockets and constituencies from within town and make sure people don't feel intimidated or feel like they can't participate because they're scared to whatever the forum happens to be.
>> The other thing also we got to think about is we also have to think about capacity. I'm hearing, you know, because there's, you know, in terms of being able to provide data and and things like that. So, yeah, this will be this will be interesting to navigate. Um, >> yeah. Well, we have to provide data. If people are asking something, we have to provide it. We have to find the capacity. We can't look like we've looked during the uh 40B hearing in >> I mean we can there are certain things that we know. The good news is is that we can probably anticipate a lot of those questions and be ready with a whole bunch of stuff. So it's not like we'd be starting from zero. >> Yeah. We're going to need to we're going to need to have sort of a basically >> you need like kind of a baseline sort of FAQ and like data you know >> I mean a lot of it you already putting together to even inform us.
So >> right. So if we could just get can kind of get like that base that foundational level sort of information and then people may have more specific drill down stuff from there. Yeah. >> Foundation. >> I just I I I think we have to, you know, I'm listening to all the the the conversation around anonymity and and things. And I think there's >> there's a we can take questions from anybody like it's it's not, you know, I I don't need to know if John Smith at such and such email address asks a question, he can just ask a question. But if somebody is I also don't want to necessarily give a mechanism for people to just throw hate out there either. So you know we need to figure out that that mechanism for >> for you know just just like when people come to our meetings we like to know who they are.
Um because I think it's I think it I think it is important to to have >> to have the community be in involved in this and not you know we're we're also probably going to hear about other communities going through this too. And so, you know, we're not going to be the only ones that are talking about sort of the the tough stuff, but I think the more the the clearer that we can be about how our budget currently is being spent, like if we talk about how much is healthare, how much is like the retirement benefits that we absolutely have to pay, how much of it is, >> you know, how much of it is negotiable, like how much do we really >> I mean, like those are the things because people say, "Oh, Well, you've got this huge budget. You can, you know, you have the money.
And it's like, well, no, we really don't. Like, really, >> you know, here's the breakdown. >> Here's the breakdown. Here's what it is. >> We can do that. >> So, stuff like that, I think, is really helpful. Like, the context for us to be able to say, >> right? >> What are the employees that we have? What are they doing to provide services to the community? >> Another way to look at it, you know, another perspective, >> I think. Um, you know, and also just in line with that, moving on to Item B, just an update on state aid. So they did have their consensus revenue hearing, the state did, I should say. Um, and so they're looking at revenue projections for 27 to be or tax collections at least to be 1.7% to 3.1% more. So that does kind of fall in our projections.
Um, we use about 2% for uh state aid, the different state aid accounts. uh >> a potential 2% increase over last year. >> Correct. So what what what the >> Yes. What the >> state is saying is what they're projecting is between 1.7 and 3.1%. So 2% is going to fall in line with that if everything holds true. >> So as we do our budgets, that's what we're going to we're going to look at what we got last year for state aid and we're going to do a 2% increase. >> Yeah. I'll um and that's what we've used so far. And so I'm just saying so far everything's tracking good on that. Uh where it's not tracking well is the health insurance. So we budget 8% or we budgeted 8% on our projections. Um GIC is looking right now at about 11%. So we'll have to factor that in.
Um, and I'm letting you know this because I think what I'll do is I'll do one round of overall budget revisions at the end of January when the governor's budget comes out and where we are with the GIC and we'll lock that in and that'll be our numbers going forward. Um, and I I'm hoping that if if something fluctuates between now and the end of January, I've got some room on the revenue side or somewhere else to kind of make adjustments so we don't have to revisit, you know, the the figures, the override figures and things like that. That would just be a mess. Um, but um but yeah, so we'll do we'll do one more kind of round of of revisions on that and then we'll lock it in. And those will be the numbers that we have to stick with going going forward through May.
Okay. And yeah, and then the MMA conference is coming up in a couple weeks and I think you know some of you have registered. Um, I was asked to do by the MMA kind of set up these regional well they're doing affinity groups I believe on Friday um where you know different interests and different regions are >> Friday or Thursday. >> I think it was Friday. Um and uh so MMA asked me to do the one for Metro West. So, I would encourage you if you're there to go come and pull you in and get to meet some of your colleagues you might not have had a chance to meet. So, want Katherine and Beth in I recruited them, too. So, um but yeah, just uh wanted to uh to let you know that. >> Great. >> That'd be fun. >> Just out of curiosity, who all is planning you're going?
I'm going to >> I haven't registered yet, but I'm planning on going. I actually booked a hotel. I just did it personally. So, >> if anyone wants to stay, I can make sure I have a two-bedroom >> because I'm planning on going in Thursday and staying through till Saturday. >> Oh, okay. >> Doing the Friday night and dinner and stuff. >> Okay. >> Been a while. Um, so I'm sorry I missed our dinner. I was sick at the beginning of December. I'm sick now in January, so hoping it doesn't continue throughout the year. Uh, coming up on January 15th, we have Metro Regional Collaborative meeting from 8 to 9:30 and then I'll be attending the MMA. Um, not really much else. Haven't been out doing much. as I'm going to a garden club meeting this Saturday and I am trying to set up a time to meet with Rob and Tony regarding the upper Charles Trail and I did have an interesting conversation from someone in Hopkin regarding their trail and they are going through some interesting stuff in Hopkin right now.
So if I hear anything more I'll keep you updated. That's it. Thanks, >> Makita. >> Hey everybody. Really quickly, uh was well enough to partake in a lot of the holiday celebrations around town in Ashland last month. Just incredible to see the whole town come out for great events like Illuminate Ashland and of course uh uh the Downtown Stroll and uh the cameo appearance by uh Mr. Certain Mr. Claus, etc., etc. That's always a it's it's one of these times a year where I feel like our community really shines. So, it was beautiful to be able to participate in those events and to see all the town folk come out. And uh I have to say that I saw some good Christmas shopping happen with lo local merchants and I did quite a bit of my Christmas shopping uh uh locally as well. So, that tradition will definitely continue.