Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
Um, there are variances. Milford, they're always a little bit higher elevation. So, sometimes they make different calls. Um, but you'll tend to see that we we we do collaborate on those as well. Um, just for the just for the ease of communication around around the area. So, um, just thought I would get that out before the next storm. Um, because there are always questions when those decisions have to be made and, uh, it is a multitude of factors that go into that. Okay. All right. Uh, and that's it. That's all I have for tonight. >> Okay. Thank you. Um, I'm going to since we're in the process still of putting our chairs for our committees in place during the month of January, I'm going to skip over committee uh reports for this month and we'll once we have everybody in place and we've actually had some meetings, then we'll come back to that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, and so they no longer were providing that and they basically let districts know that they needed to hire those positions um within the district. So that's another reason for for an increase in some of those >> ones that require the to fill it as you mentioned before. Mhm. >> because of the IEP, >> right? We have to provide those services um for IEPs. Yeah. So, the next slide again is a summary. Um I just put that cuz sometimes like folks prefer it written out and like looking at it on a bar graph. Do you want me to like read through that or >> It's basically saying the same thing just and then it shows the ratios again um for for that classification. Okay, the next one is classified operational support. So examples of these positions would be like are a maintenance operation and transportation secretary, accounts payable, food services, health aids, bus drivers, office managers, office assistants, those types of positions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So the city would put a survey out online and and invite people to engage it and would you like to see more of this or or you know have you thought of this and if you were prioritizing and and we could find some way of of uh gauging uh public input. Um, and this couldn't this might be several sort of surveys, but at least we could also then after the survey is completed, after people I have an idea about the options, we could then take the art commission kind of on the road for discussions. We could have our meetings in various places around the city to talk about this public art plan and um and find a shared priority. And again, it's not going to be just one meeting. Uh here's here's manhole covers. You know, when we first proposed manhole covers, the people that came up to me and said, "What are you nuts, John?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Okay. I'll second. Um, any other nominations? I would like to nominate Lisa Horn, board clerk. >> All right. Any other Do I need a second then? >> I'll second that nomination. >> Okay. So, um then I'll move to close nominations. >> Second. >> Steve can second. >> All in favor? I I >> So motion carries five to zero. Okay. So, we have Melissa. >> We'll um we'll need a motion to approve for Melissa. >> I move to approve Melissa for the position of board clerk. >> I second. >> It's fine. All in favor? I >> I all all oppose. >> Nay. Okay. So, we we have um the board the motion carries three to two. >> Yeah. >> Yes, we did. >> Okay. >> No, it's three. Three to two. Diane and Lisa. >> Did I click the wrong thing? >> Yeah, >> correct.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Again, that's purely opinion >> and I and I actually when I on my way driving yesterday, I said no opinions, keep it to the facts, but that could be something that drives some of those numbers. But I but I also think that, you know, that it has to that has to have something to do with what we're doing in grade seven and grade eight >> and and the state SG uh SGP 4, does that show the same trend? I mean, because that because that would that would lend credence to what you're talking about, right? If if uh the state overall is lower, the the four and five students when they go to six and seven are showing generally higher SGPS than than previously >> SGP always norms at 50. >> Yeah. Well, specifically this year, grade five, grade five specifically this year and the 2025 data shows that it's lower across the board for everyone.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And sometimes they have a warrant subcommittee. So there's lots of ways that one can do this. If you bring warrants into the budget and finance subcommittee, they meet once a month, maybe during budget time, then they don't always meet once a month. How are they going to administer the warrants? Also, the warrants are public. So you as taxpayers can go and view them. You can go into central office and look at them. When I went to training recently in November with you, I took a warrant subcommittee class and I learned that the warrants need to come in here. So, we need to look at the warrants as full school committee and vote on them. Because they come out every two weeks, I would think a better proposal would be to have a small warrant subcommittee that meets, I don't know, via Zoom or however we need to do to vote on it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And sometimes they have a warrant subcommittee. So there's lots of ways that one can do this. If you bring warrants into the budget and finance subcommittee, they meet once a month, maybe during budget time, then they don't always meet once a month. How are they going to administer the warrants? Also, the warrants are public. So you as taxpayers can go and view them. You can go into central office and look at them. When I went to training recently in November with you, I took a warrant subcommittee class and I learned that the warrants need to come in here. So, we need to look at the warrants as a full school committee and vote on them. Because they come out every two weeks, I would think a better proposal would be to have a small warrant subcommittee that meets, I don't know, via Zoom or however we need to do to vote on it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Okay. So, let's move on to the action items. Um, action item A, Lauren, can you do that for me, please? Sure. >> [clears throat] >> I make a motion that the board of education accept for first reading policy 5144.1 physical restraint slash seclusion/exclusionary timeout as recommended by the policy committee and in accordance with 26-05. Motion made by Lauren. Do I hear a second? >> Second by Al. All in favor? >> I.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
The next one is certificated staff slash sorry certificated student/ staff support. So examples of these positions would be our speech and language pathologists, our school psychologists. Previously before school psychologists, we had behavior health intervention interventions intervention uh BHIS um our educational program specialist and our district nurse. Again, things to consider here. I already mentioned um the speech and language pathologists were given back to districts from Madera County Superintendent of Schools. The district also used to contract with YUSD for nursing services and then when that discontinued um we went we had to hire our own. And then um part of the um uptick in this category is that the district um was focusing on mental health and responding to the increase in the district's special education percentages. The next classification is classified confidential management. So some of these positions are um chief business officer, chief technology officer, superintendent assistant, human resources, M director, T director, those types of those types of positions.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
You know, manhole covers is art." And you know, trying to describe the Japanese, you know, they you're just crazy. This is sewers. We don't have art on sewers and certainly not in the streets. uh and bike paths, you know, we we have now bike paths that um you know, when we first suggested it, I I talked with uh um Craig Hoopy and he said, "No, you can't have anything in the bike paths." And so, well, maybe we could. There's no question that we could if the community wants it. um shade canopies. You know, these are some wonderful examples of of just getting shade and as the planet's warming, this is going to be an important necessity for urban design and Ann Arbor, I'm sure, is going to develop it in some way and just be creative about it. So that uh first we educate people of the options.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Mhm. Are we good? >> Are you good? Wait a minute. Okay. Melissa did. >> It's okay. Okay. >> Perfect. >> This whole thing is crazy. >> Are we good? >> Okay, we're good that time, >> right? Okay. >> Okay. >> Are we ready to move on? Okay. 8.6 discussion and consider consideration of action to approve board member representative for the Combmes Education Foundation. Who Melissa, are you on that right now? >> I am. >> Okay. >> Um, is there anybody else that's interested in doing this? Because I mean, I think it's great for anybody that wants to do it. I >> It is. >> It's fun. >> And I mean, it's a great gladly give it up or do it with somebody or whatever. It's just a great >> It entails a couple of inerson meetings and a couple of Zoom meetings and then it entails up to you.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
I think the grade five test this year was incredibly difficult. Interesting. I wouldn't expect that. >> Yeah, it was. And there's there's data that that there's data out there that does show that across the state that's where the highest level of challenge was. >> Uh Ashton High School continues to to to succeed, although we did have a decrease in in ELA in all areas. Um we're still above well above the state average in meet succeeds, but we did dip. We we we we dipped in um meet succeeds. You see that little dip there from 2024 um in average skilled score as well as average SGP. It all went down in ELA. Um and in in math, we're we're kind of staying staying pat. you know, there's not wasn't much movement in math at the high school level. Um, I I think anecdotally, again, one of the reasons that the scores dipped a little in ELA is because that's where the students who are impacted by the change were impacted the most.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
It's really only a fiveminute issue um to have more eyes than just one on it. But to bog it down in budget and finance will do one thing that I think will damage the subcommittee. So let me rephrase this. When you look at warrants, you don't really know what you're looking at. It's just lines and lines of text like Amazon this amount of money, copy paper this amount of money, we paid for an oil change, we bought a van, whatever it is, it's all these different things that need to get paid. The only way that you can understand what you're looking at and know what a red flag is is if you look at them all the time. So over time you understand the trends and you can kind of pick out, oh, never seen that before or that's unusual. That only happens through experience.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
It's really only a fiveminute issue um to have more eyes than just one on it. But to bog it down in budget and finance will do one thing that I think will damage the subcommittee. So let me rephrase this. When you look at warrants, you don't really know what you're looking at. It's just lines and lines of text like Amazon this amount of money, copy paper this amount of money, we paid for an oil change, we bought a van, whatever it is, it's all these different things that need to get paid. The only way that you can understand what you're looking at and know what a red flag is is if you look at them all the time. So over time you understand the trends and you can kind of pick out, oh, never seen that before or that's unusual. That only happens through experience.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Any opposed? >> Okay. Motion passes. Um, action item B. Wanita, could you do that for me, please? >> onampus recruitment motion that the board of education accept for the first reading policy 5145.14 onampus recruitment as recommended by the policy committee and in accordance with 26-06 >> motion made by Wanita. Do I have a second? >> Second by Al. All in favor? I.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um things to consider. Two of these FTEES are not management. They are confidential positions. Um but they're grouped together in this classification. And then um you can see um part part of the uptick on from last year to this year was um we had for a long time we had one like director and then we split that into an M and a team. Okay. The last one is certificated management. So, um those positions are superintendent, principles, uh previously director of special programs and projects and special education and student services director. that's remain inconsistent. And then the last slide I did some calculations on what's called staffing staffing density. Um staffing density is a standard organizational metric used to measure how many employees you have relative to the population they serve. The calculation this calculates the number of staff members available for every 100 students. So you take the total FTE in the category or classification.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Uh second, we have an extensive discussion and with the idea of creating policy to memorialize the community's priorities that could entail a map, all kinds of other things that then could be uh integrated uh with the uh uh city's documents. So that's the idea of a public art plan as a vision document. major cities all have these uh that you know uh villages and small communities like saline may not uh that well I think it might be time for Ann Arbor to think about uh we do want a public uh um a uh art park uh maybe more than we want uh uh furniture. uh we do want playground and more than we want other things. So um so that's the idea. Uh this was proposed uh a few years ago and there really wasn't an interest in the commission uh nor in staff. So you know I just let it pass.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um so, for example, like Melissa came to uh uh to the January PD because we handed out the um uh the the many grants. And so if you want to go to that, you go to that uh at uh uh the staff excellence awards and at the scholarship nights. um they'll be up the person will be up there to help handing out awards there. So, so there's whatever you would desired if you wanted to go to the golf tournament when the golf tournament, but it's up to you. It's not like there's a mandatory of anything, but it's it's it's generally two inerson meetings and two Zoom meetings during the year and then everything else is up to the individual depending on what their schedule is and what their availability is. >> Okay. Do you have any >> you want to do it? >> Yeah, I'll do it.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Uh I I remember laughing when the state got on a a call with us in the beginning of the year to talk about the data and they said this is the year that they've seen more blank responses to open response questions or responses that were unrelated [clears throat] to the question including responses such as I'm not going to answer this right or or complete off-topic responses and some even um gave reasons why the MCCAST should no longer exist in their answers. So there were not necessarily happening in our town. We don't know. But and I also think it's worth note that worth noting that when I talked to Alisa Egan at the high school about the responses, she she felt like the scoring was way off this year as well. She she thought that many of the scores that that were given to us didn't seem to make a whole lot of sense.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So far I've been the only one signing warrants, just me and Glenn for the last few years. Um, I signed the one this week. We agreed to wait 24 hours for people to look at the warrants. I keep thinking if I wait and I wait and I wait, people are going to sign them. But I keep getting emails from Vera saying, "No one's signing them." So, I've been signing them. So, there has to be some way for people to see it and understand the trends and scroll through these payments and get an idea of what is correct and what is not. So, I think that putting it in budget and finance is not the way to go. >> Thank you. Okay, I'm happy to explain why I believe that warrants do belong in the budget and finance subcommittee. And I also want to address the comment about how often budget and finance meets.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above