So far I've been the only one signing warrants, just me and Glenn for the last few years. Um, I signed the one this week. We agreed to wait 24 hours for people to look at the warrants. I keep thinking if I wait and I wait and I wait, people are going to sign them. But I keep getting emails from Vera saying no one's signing them. So, I've been signing them. So, there has to be some way for people to see it and understand the trends and scroll through these payments and get an idea of what is correct and what is not. [snorts] So, I think that putting it in budget and finance is not the way to go. Thank you. Okay, I'm happy to explain why I believe that warrants do belong in the budget and finance subcommittee. And I also want to address the comment about how often budget and finance meets.
Any opposed? Okay. Action item C. Um Kate, would you mind doing that? I'll make a motion that the board of education accept for first reading policy 5145.511 sexual abuse prevention and education programs as recommended by the policy committee and in accordance with exhibit 26-07. >> Motion made by Kate. Do I have a second? >> Second by Lauren. All in favor? >> I I.
You divide it by student enrollment. You multiply it by 100. Okay. The reason for explaining staffing density is because percentage growth only looks at the staff count. Density looks at the staff to student relationship. Percentage graphs show you, for example, you hire four more teachers, that equals 9%. The density graph, for example, shows that because you have fewer students, the cost of those 48 teachers, I'm just using this as an example, it would apply to everything here on this graph, the cost of those 48 teachers impacts the budget 28% more than the 44 teachers did in 2018. We aren't just paying for more people. we are paying for more people with much less money per person. So I did those calculations and this graph is organized by the largest percentage of density and increase by classification to the lowest and then it shows the overall for the district.
I thought well maybe we'll bring it up again and see if anyone else uh is interested in it. Did you put this document together, John? >> Yes. >> It's amazing. I love it. >> Well, thank you. Yes. >> Great. I mean, I think it's definitely in line with our bylaws as far as like making recommendations and other assets of our bylaws. So, it's if I think if you can get a panel of group people together to work on it with you, John, so it's not just you. >> Yes. It will not be just me. I want you to know that right now. like I somebody else has to go I like this and take the lead. I I did this 10 years ago. I I put this this is a good blueprint, but I can't I can't be the only one doing this. So, I'm going to take a a second seat.
>> Okay. Oh, all I mean I wanted to make a motion. >> Go ahead. >> Not me though. >> I move to nominate Lisa Horn for the positions Education Foundation represent for 2026. Is that right? >> No, I think Diane wanted to >> Oh, sorry Diane. Go ahead. >> No. >> Okay. >> All right. >> Sorry, did I mess everything up? >> Yep. I'm going to make a motion to nominate Diane for the position of >> Sorry. J Combmes. >> I missed the memo. >> Um, education foundation. >> Second. >> All right. All in favor? >> I motion carries five to zero. >> Right. >> Yes. >> Okay. >> So then we have to >> So a motion to um approve Diane for the position of Combmes Education Foundation >> represent. Do we have to close it? No, >> we just did. >> That was the nomination.
Um, so interesting to to think about uh writing from that lens where there was a a discrepancy in scoring, especially when it comes to PE folks that we really trust. You know, our our English department is is pretty skilled at analyzing analyzing writing. Yeah, I think it's going to be interesting to see how kind of in the coming years what the state decides to do with this on a on a bigger picture because I think it's going to become a far less credible um measure of accountability um across the board given the fact that it's >> why take it? What's the point? It doesn't matter, right? >> And it it changed the trajectory of what it means for everything. And I think it was, not to share my opinion, but I'm gonna I think it was it was poorly done the way that it it's unfortunate the way that it rolled out because I think I'm I'm not in in disagreement that it needed to be made, but I think it's created a lot of complications for the way that it the way that the change was made.
So the current practice has been yes to meet monthly during budget season perhaps more often with individual assignments from what I understand to go off and have different discussions with either school councils or PTOs or with ELPACs or CPACs to get a better understanding of their priorities. So work does happen more often than than the once a month. I am also uh by virtue of charging this subcommittee with the responsibility for warrants expecting that they will meet more often in order to meet that responsibility. There's no rule that says we only meet once a month. Um that is up to each subcommittee about how they schedule their business. Um I also do agree that it is important to get more eyes on the warrants. Therefore, charging a three-person subcommittee with the responsibility for looking through them while vesting one person in my view that would be the chair of the budget and finance subcommittee with the responsibility for signing them.
So the current practice has been yes to meet monthly during budget season perhaps more often with individual assignments from what I understand to go off and have different discussions with either school councils or PTOs or with ELPAC or CPACS to get a better understanding of their priorities. So work does happen more often than than the once a month. I am also uh by virtue of charging this subcommittee with the responsibility for warrants expecting that they will meet more often in order to meet that responsibility. There's no rule that says we only meet once a month. Um that is up to each subcommittee about how they schedule their business. Um I also do agree that it is important to get more eyes on the warrants. Therefore, charging a three-person subcommittee with the responsibility for looking through them while vesting one person in my view that would be the chair of the budget and finance subcommittee with the responsibility for signing them.
Any opposed? >> Okay. Oh, so thank you for mentioning that. Um, so just in uh added today uh in the minutes is the for information is the proposed um next school year calendar and right now it's just on for information. So, we would just ask that you take some time to review it and if you there's any feedback or questions on it, uh that we have some time to discuss it between uh between now and um when we put it up for a final read. Okay. Okay. So, we're going to move on to the chairperson's report. Um I apologize if this is a little lengthy tonight. It's my first one, but I want to get some housekeeping stuff out of the way, especially because we have some new board members around the table. So, it was a good night to take care of some stuff.
So that's a lot to take in. I understand that this is not a conversation anybody wants to be having. Unfortunately, it's where we are and we have to have the conversation and the responsibility of the school board trustees is to provide directions for the district and the superintendent. So, we will be having those conversations and I can start now. Okay. All right. So, I'm going to start um because as I was looking at this, I had some questions and I got some clarification from the presentation just now. But um one of the questions that I have is have you examined the case loads of the certificated student and staff support to see what those ratios look like? because we have data on these other positions on on what that looks like. But the case loads is kind of in relationship to that I think is an important conversation to have.
And so, if anyone wants to step in, leadership is what I'm looking for. I am not interested in leading this. This is a massive project. Actually, this should be led by staff. This should be led by Christopher. I'm not putting it on you, Christopher. This is something that should come from staff with the input of the art commission. >> It shouldn't be the art commission driving this. This is a document, a public art plan that the, you know, that the city administrator and all the staff have to say we need one and use these experts on the commission to help us. So, >> so, so how about we do this? I I cannot speak on behalf of public service and I also can't speak on behalf of the city. What I can do is I can at least speak to my supervisors and see if there is a an interest and kind of gauge that interest and then uh report back to you guys.
We still need to close it. >> Oh, we Oh, you're right. always do I still have to close it. Okay, go ahead. You're right. I motion to close nominations for the Combmes Education Foundation representative for 2026. >> I second. >> All in favor? >> I This is going to go on the board review just so we're clear that we need to get our act together. Motion. [laughter] Okay. So, um, now we'll do we'll we're going to actually motion to approve Diane for the position of Combmes Education Foundation representative for 2026. >> Okay. So, I move to approve Diane for the position of >> No, I just did. >> Okay. You just did that, so I second it. >> There you go. All in favor? >> Who's on first? >> No one. We don't know. Okay. I >> Motion carries five to zero. I think I >> I don't really understand because I'm going to just say that we've never voted on the Combmes education like had a vote.
But >> in terms >> Sorry, I'll get off myself. >> No, no, [laughter] it's a fair valid point. And in terms of science, you're going to see that there was an increase in meets needs, meets exceeds and average skill score in grade five, which we're really happy about. Uh there was a decrease in meets succeeds in grade 8 and at the high school. Again, not sure if that is related to the uh changes in the accountability structure. Uh, >> so [clears throat] >> do you do you anticipate having data or do you have data that's yet to be looked at that that allows you at least to make your own educated assessment as to whether or not the the change in the the requirement around the test impact those scores? Like would will you get data that's enough to see whether people are writing responses like that on the ELA?
Um helps to make sure that it is getting taken care of in a timely fashion by the people who are also supposed to be monitoring our our bigger budget on the dayto-day as well um or at least on the monthtomonth. So that was my rationale for putting it there so that it wasn't just resting with either me or whichever member happens to have the time but that that it is actually a a design a designated responsibility for a core group of folks um on the committee. So that was my rationale. Um I'm happy to hear other opinions on that as well. Um but thank you for for providing your input. Yes, Mory. I'm glad it's going to be a subset of people that are looking at it. Um, I I actually I I never signed the school one because I signed them on the mayor's side at the end the warrant, but um, you know, just like we bring things up here in to to Andy in this meeting, it's a little um it's a little less formal in a subcommittee.
Um, helps to make sure that it is getting taken care of in a timely fashion by the people who are also supposed to be monitoring our our bigger budget on the dayto-day as well um or at least on the monthtomonth. So that was my rationale for putting it there so that it wasn't just resting with either me or whichever member happens to have the time but that that it is actually a a design a designated responsibility for a core group of folks um on the committee. So that was my rationale. Um I'm happy to hear other opinions on that as well. Um but thank you for for providing your input. Yes, Mayor Deser. I'm glad it's going to be a subset of people that are looking at it. Um I I [clears throat] actually I I never signed the school one because I signed them on the mayor's side at the end the warrant, but um you you know just like we bring things up here in to to Andy in this meeting.
Uh, first thing I want to talk about is emails. We all should have our district emails. Um, and we'll probably go into this more as we go on. Just um be aware of what you're putting out in your emails. Um, but also if you get emails from constituents, which you will probably get as we move forward, um, I do not have an issue with you just acknowledging receipt of the email. You could say, "Thank you. You know, thank you for re reaching out. I will forward this to the appropriate person." Um, I would refrain from engaging any back and forth with constituents, especially on matters that we really don't know about. So, we'll let superintendent and we'll let her team take care of those. Okay. Good, Kim. Okay, good. All right. Um, uh, visiting school protocol. I know we've started scheduling some visits with the schools.
Yes, I have a table created. Um I sometimes am pretty good with a crystal ball. Been doing this for a while. I um knew that based on this conversation and what's been presented and our the direction that I'll receive tonight um would mean that I would need to know the answers to those questions. And so I have created a table for all of the support staff um to populate with things like let me give you some examples. Um, what is the case load for an RSP teacher currently for all of them? What is the case load currently for each of our speech and language pathologists? Um, how many psychoeducational assessments have our school psychologists completed? Um, how many students are receiving one-to-one counseling? How many students are receiving group counseling? Those are the types of things that will be important to know when making the decisions that are going to be made in the very near future.
Uh so just just to make sure that I'm understanding at least the vision is to create something kind of like vision zero where it's a plan for how the city of Ann Arbor aims to pursue public art. So maybe if the goal is to increase public art in the city by 2050, then there will be some metrics and there'll be some some kind of a plan that the the city can reference back. Um, okay. Let's >> there there was a a preamble to this and I will send you and it lays out exactly what you're asking for so you can use it. >> Yeah. Yeah. If you could send that to me, uh, that would be great. Uh, let me uh let me do some research and see see what I can uh bring to bring to this commission. Okay, >> great. >> Thank you, John.
We just nominated we just like appointed somebody. >> So that was kind of throwing me. But it's fine. It's fine. >> We could keep it legal. >> It's my last six months. So I just want to watch you guys struggle up here. >> Yeah, it's okay. >> You did a great job. Yeah, you did it great. And um for future >> anybody like in the future, what I'm gonna just tell you right now after these nominations close, we are supposed to switch seats. So that's why I don't really like to do it till the very end because it's so weird. Do you see what I'm saying? It's just kind of a weird thing. But since I'm not the one that's like I'm still going to because like that means that whoever if somebody else was as somebody else was president they would have to now take over from this position on.
It's all right. Well, we know that doesn't really reflect anything. Yeah, we we we can look at the direct some of the direct responses to see Yeah. >> Yeah. I assume where you'll see that is, you know, the students that aren't graduating uh you know, but the earlier students when they come and you're like, "Okay, you need help in this area." And you're like, "Wait, you don't need help in this area. You you just basically, you know, >> you decide whether you're going to play along or not." >> Exactly. [clears throat] And and and again, I think it's fair to say that we're we're we're achieving at a pretty high rates at the high school, even though even though that the data show that there was a dip, I'm still pretty pleased with the level of achievement success at the high school in terms of our science data.