So, um I I'm assuming that everybody looks through them, but I think it's great to have a subcommittee, you know, or in ways and means or finance or whichever the name of it, that you're looking at it together, so you're actually going through them. Um that's just my thoughts. Any other comments or questions about the subcommittee assignments as presented? >> Yes. Member Den, >> are you requesting that we email you whether or not we wish to take up this work that you've assigned? Um, I would I guess I would ask in the interest of getting these subcommittees approved this evening one way or the other that you either say that now. Although of course if you would rather not then you are free to email me afterwards if you don't want these assignments. But I think it would be actually important to know that now because if you don't want one, then that requires to keep with a threeperson subcommittee.
It's a little um it's a little less formal in a subcommittee. So, um I I'm assuming that everybody looks through them, but I think it's great to have a subcommittee, you know, or in ways and means or finance, whichever the name of it, that you're looking at it together, so you're actually going through them. Um it's just my thoughts. Any other comments or questions about the subcommittee assignments as presented? >> Yes. Member Denife, >> are you requesting that we email you whether or not we wish to take up this work that you've assigned? Um I would I guess I would ask in the interest of getting these subcommittees approved this evening one way or the other that you either say that now although of course if you would rather not then you are free to email me afterwards if you don't want these assignments but I think it would be actually important to know that now because if you don't want one then that requires to keep with a three-person subcommittee um and to try to balance because I did do a bit of thinking about how to to make sure that assignments were equitably distributed as well.
Um, and I thank Wanita for helping with some of the new people. Um, if you want to schedule a visit with the school, please go through Cara Pomp Pompano. Um, before you schedule, she knows what's happening in the school. She knows best days. She knows what's what when is a good time so we're not too disruptive. I know that we want to be welcomed there, but we just want to make sure that you guys are doing your job and we're not just, you know, taking uh away from the students. Um so again, if you want to have any visits with the schools, go through Cara. Okay. Um also attendance for committee meetings and board meetings. So if you uh when you get the calendar invites, please respond so we can confirm that we have a quorum for our uh committee meetings and also for our board meetings.
So the answer is that is ready to be populated. That's getting sent out to those folks this week. That will be populated and that will be examined. I'll just >> the sorry to interrupt the directors involved in that are aware of that graph or of that um it's a it's a Google doc with like a table is the word I'm looking for that that's going to be sent out to folks and they are going to be expected to fill that out um and and give it back in a in a you know we're going to give them probably I'll have that information by next week or probably the middle of next week. >> That's going to be helpful. >> A lot of that um can be pulled from safe too. So some of that's going to be very easy to get and others will be a little >> Sorry, can you repeat that?
>> Go ahead, Jenna. >> Oh, I was just going to say that I I think it's a great idea and I'd be happy to be part of it. I'm not I'm not volunteering to lead it. I agree that I think it should come from the city and that's how I've experienced these types of plans in my professional life, too. It's coming from the city perspective. But I if we move forward, I'd be happy to be part of the committee that's reviewing. So, >> well, Jenna has experience with this kind of thing. So, so great, you can help guide uh Christopher that this is really city planning, you know, I mean, uh uh that are you a are you an urban planner, Jenna? That an architect or >> landscape architect? >> Exactly. Exactly. So this Jenna, you know, makes uh uh places out of spaces. So uh and that's what the city wants to do.
No, it's fine. No, I'm just saying just for future reference that that's what would happen. You can keep it there, but that means there's like a lot of awkward like moving and stuff or whatever. So anyway, all right. So, information discussion items 9.1 discussion information on 2526 district student enrollment numbers. >> Um, I gave you the report uh I think it was last week on the numbers uh came out pretty decent uh over the break. Lost about 10 kids um is what the numbers look like. Um [clears throat] and then I will let you know that uh uh Mr. Brambert did do a presentation to Queen Creek this week. they were about a week week and a half ahead of us in terms of the study. >> So we're anticipating they asked for some more data. I think it was yesterday or today. So we would anticipate that we will get at least a rough of the demographic applied economics demographic study in the next couple weeks and that we would we would plan to present at February unless something unless something unique comes up.
Yeah, it seems like this is one of those places where the percentage over state average um if it varies might be indicator because I assume that the the types of responses they're going to be scattered throughout the state, right? They're not going to be localized to Ashlin or Hopin or any one place. They're going to be kids here and there decide to do something. Um, that doesn't mean that the data that's on the slide where the 6% decrease in meats and seeds, you know, I don't know what that means, but the 19% over state average in this context might at least indicate. >> Yeah. But I think it's worth concerning that the the there is a downward trend right right now in our science data. I mean, it is showing a downward trend over the course of the last three years, right? Actually, the last four years, it's continuing to go down.
Um, and to try to balance because I did do a bit of thinking about how to make sure that assignments were equitably distributed as well. Um, >> I'll email you. Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you. Any further discussion? Okay, seeing none. Oh, yes. >> I just wanted to say that I am perfectly fine with where I am for subcommittees. >> Great. Thank you. >> Yes, member. >> I am also happy with my subcommittee assignments. >> Great. Thank you. >> Okay. Are we Sorry. Did you have something, Mayor Dwer? >> I am as well. I'm happy with where I am. Thank you. >> Okay. All right. Um, with that, I think are we ready to proceed to a vote? Okay. All in favor of the subcommittee and uh representative assignments as written, please. Uh, and I think uh, Secretary, I think we should do a roll call on this one.
Um, >> I'll email you. Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you. >> Any further discussion? Okay, seeing none. Oh, yes. >> I just wanted to say that I am perfectly fine with where I am for subcommittees. >> Great. Thank you. Yes, member. >> I am also happy with my subcommittee assignments. >> Great. Thank you. >> Okay. Are we Sorry. Did you have something, Mayor Dwer? >> I am as well. I'm happy with where I am. Thank you. >> Okay. All right. Um, with that, I think are we ready to proceed to a vote? Okay. All in favor of the subcommittee and uh representative assignments as written, please. Uh and I think uh secretary, I think we should do a roll call on this one. >> Thank you. >> Vice Chair Childs, >> yes. >> Member Denive, >> no. >> Member Doder, >> yes. >> I'm struggling with this.
Um, if you have to change and something comes up, which is understandable, reach out to your committee chair and let them know. If you can't make that particular meeting, um, if it's a board meeting, just reach out to me or Cara and let us know so we can just plan accordingly. Okay. All right. Um, I am working with Cara as well on the PTO liaison list. I'm trying to get a master schedule spreadsheet together that'll have all contacts names, who's to what school, and who is the contact person at that school. I'm working with citywide PTO to put that together. We've got some gaps in there, and we're trying to fill the gaps. Um, I'm going to give it another week. If I don't have that full, I'm just going to send out what we have and you can start making your contacts with the schools that you're assigned to.
Pulled from where? >> Safe, which is the student information system for um special education students. There's reports. Yeah, there's reports that can be pulled out of there that will be able to populate a good portion of what I've created. Um, okay, I'm going to just keep going my questions. Um, can you quantify the impact of of raises that have been given on the budget since 2018? And we've talked about onetime money versus ongoing money is I I know this is coming, you know, all this kind of came a little bit, you know, um just the timing of this this coming to us. So I didn't have a lot of time to give these questions to you in advance, but if if those are conversations that we're going to have, I'm curious because I know we did give a decent raise a couple years ago and I'm not saying that you're funded to the level that you should be as professionals.
That's exactly what the DDA uh is uh uh is doing. Great. >> Well, what's happening with Liberty Plaza? I mean, another way to do this is also like pilot something, right? where we have like, you know, a strategy around where this could occur because having a kind of encyclopedia of methods and ideas is great and I'm not against it, but I certainly think having like a place to suggest something occurs. I mean, the bike path is a good idea for sure. [snorts] Um, but if you can pilot something right and make it happen, then there gets more velocity to to it actually occurring. >> I mean, that that was the argument. That was the argument that most commissioners said, "We're not interested in this big plan, John. We want art. So, let's get a piece of art and we'll choose it and we'll put it on that street." Well, that's fine.
So, that will give us a uh at least an updated look at the potential impact um of some of these new subdivisions that are going in. There's a new one going in in the fields uh across the street from uh Olive Olive Mill as an example um that's not been accounted for. Um and then there's a couple of these rent lease down here at the end of Kenworthy and Oatil that's going in. So hopefully some of these new ones that maybe weren't on the older one be on this one. Whether that translates to kids or not, we'll just wait and see. But but uh hopefully in February we'll have a better idea on that. >> Okay. Uh 9.2 discussion information regarding conflict of interest. >> Are we signing those today? >> Yes, ma'am. >> Okay. >> Um discussion 9.2 is to comply with governing board policy BCB and Arizona revised statute 80 38503.
um while the state has sort of maintained at the same level. So, we certainly need to look at what might be impacting that. >> Um but I I would be lying if I said that wasn't my biggest concern right now. I think we're about to get to my biggest concern. >> Well, let's get to it. >> So, there's there's your lead. uh when we talk about our subgroup data. Okay, so uh and and again when we talk about going down rabbit holes, I I could have done a subgroup analysis by each grade level and know that we've done that uh and Christy and I have talked about even taking some access data and comparing that to the specific MCCAST data to see any correlations. But what I wanted to just give you was more of an overview. Um really >> to really know what access state is >> really because of the the the time that we're allotted here.
>> Thank you. >> Vice Chair Childs, >> yes. >> Member Deniv, >> no. Member Doder. >> Yes. >> I'm struggling with this. Member Dyman. >> Abstain. >> Member Goodwin. >> Yes. >> Chair Ston. >> Yes. >> Member Webb. I'm a Yes. >> Okay. Can you read out if it passed and with how many yeses? >> Sorry, I'm new at this. Um, it passed with one, two, three, four, five yeses, one absention, and one no vote. >> Great. Thank you. Okay, I think with that we are ready to move on to new business. Superintendent, would you like to present this? >> Yes, thank you. Um, I'm presenting this to you this evening, not necessarily for a vote tonight. Um, this is more to get the information in front of you right now so you would have time to either do some homework on it or, you know, digest it and come back the next month and do it or you can take a vote tonight.
Member Dyman, >> abstain. >> Member Goodwin, >> yes. >> Chair Ston, >> yes. Member Webb, I'm a yes. >> Okay. Can you read out if it passed and with how many yeses? >> Sorry, I'm new at this. Um, it passed with one, two, three, four, five yeses, one abstension, and one no vote. >> Great. Thank you. Okay, I think with that we are ready to move on to new business. Superintendent, would you like to present this? >> Yes. Thank you. Um, I'm presenting this to you this evening, not necessarily for a vote tonight. Um, this is more to get the information in front of you right now so you would have time to either do some homework on it or, you know, digest it and come back the next month and do it or you can take a vote tonight. So, this is in front of you and you've we were mailed mailed this to you.
Okay. Um okay. Um okay. Couple of things. Um I wanted to announce um in wanted to have one board member that would be um bringing information to and from uh the board um on a state education level and I know that was brought up tonight. Um so our decided to have a legislative liaison uh from the board and um thank you Kate for taking on the role. Um and this will be our one board person that will have the contact with all things state education related. She will get the information from them bring it back to the board and and let us know and really keep us updated on things that we need to know state level. Okay. Um, and as we go on, these are all new things, so they might switch and change and we might be tweaking as we go. So, uh, just know that these are all kind of new things that we're we're trying.
However, um I know that there was discussion on whether that money was onetime money or whether it was ongoing money. And so, um just trying to figure out the impact of those raises over the years and to our budget and how we're handling that. We do need to be careful. There is some information we can share about that, but this is a public meeting open to the public and negotiations are a confidential >> situation. Okay. Um so we need to be careful with um what we say. However, we will say what we know to be true that we can share in this setting. That doesn't mean that some of that could be shared closed. Yeah. But this is a public forum. We need to be mindful of that. >> Okay. >> But all the raises we mostly have done have been ongoing. Okay. And with um having declining enrollment and we haven't recreed increased funding, it's pretty much using our reserve or fund balance each year.
But if it you know you don't build a house with with with without kind of plants and you know that you know you might build a shed that way but if this you really want something to be integrated with into the into the city's infrastructure you've got to get the transportation department you've got to get all of these departments first of all educated to the possibilities. Um, you know, the um, uh, Craig Hoopy, you know, told me had he knew that there were interesting kind of handrails or lights, he would have suggested them for the bridge across uh, State Street on Stadium Boulevard. He just said, "I never knew." Well, that's that's one big gaping hole in it that you know that people just don't know the options, the possibilities and residents don't even know that. You know, the argument was, you know, benches, they're not art, John.
Arizona 38503 of conflict of interest states any board member or employee of the district who has or who has relatives has a substantial interest in any contract sale purchase or service to the district. shall make known that interest in an official record of the district and shall refrain from voting upon or otherwise participating in any manner as a board member or employee such in a contract sale or purchase. It defines a relative as hang on spouse, child, grandchild, parent, grandparent, any siblings and their spouses and the spouse's parents, siblings and children. That's a lot. Refrain from participating in any manner is more than just refraining from making the final decision. It includes participating in any way in the process leading up to the decision. An employee or governing board member with a conflict of interest must not make recommendations, give advice, or otherwise communicate in any manner with anyone regarding the decision-making process.