We can't say we're not going to have our legal support, right? >> Um, but there are maybe different things like uh applications, which we have reduced. We were spending around 300,000 on applications a few years ago because of the CO funds and now we're spending around 140,000. So, um we've reduced a lot of areas that we can, but we might just have to sit down and look what's in each of those categories. It could even be fuel for the buses. That's not something we can, you know, really reduce. We need to have the bus roads that we have. So, it makes it pretty challenging um looking at those budgets and trying to see really what what could be reduced. Um I don't have a good answer for that. >> No, it's okay. I just when if it's in that my right and it's like 337 what over 338,000 that's in the my then you're you're looking ahead and and going to plan for those reductions however they look whether >> and it's also based on a lot of factors like the current budget you know so if there's um less expenditures this year which usually isn't the case but if there's less than our getting balances higher starting next year and maybe the budgets can don't have to be reduced as much.
Yeah, >> that would be great to circle back and hear about that again. I'd be really interested. >> Yes. And then the other project is the elevating history mural project that the DDA is putting putting forward. Um I am representing um our group on that panel. There were 26 I think there were over 250 applicants from across the nation. They whittleled it down to 26. And um it is probably one of the most challenging jury assignments I've ever had. There is just absolutely astounding work that I'm looking at. And to think that some of these muralists could come here to Ann Arbor and grace us with their incredible just blows my mind. Not to mention um at least six Detroit artists apply uh have made it into that final selection and um just really blowing my mind. So um those submissions or my my top six and the rest of my the committee I'm working with are due tomorrow.
>> The high school ranch. >> Uhhuh. >> Okay. All right. And then I don't know why I'm writing this down. Okay. Um, so then you you want the middle school though, Lisa? >> I'll just do the middle school. Okay. >> Okay. And then we have um Harmon Comb Center for Success and Combs Traditional Academy um >> and elsewhere >> and else Yeah, we have Yeah. Um I'll be happy to take um Combmes Center for Success in the Traditional Academy, Stephen. >> Okay. And then so that's that one. >> Okay. What are you taking? Sorry, Shel. You're taking home center for success on the traditional. Okay. >> So, we have Harmon and Ellsworth >> and and Simington. Oh, yeah. Right here. I was I had scratched something out. So, we have three others. >> And I'm open to taking two. >> Okay. You have Harmon, Ellsworth, Simington.
Does does do we have is that our growth from the non the not the MCCAST data but our other measures in contrast or do they support the MCCAST? Uh >> so that that's exactly why Christy and I want to do some correlation data between the access and the MCCAST to take a take a deeper dive look into that >> because that that it's striking to me that we've talked a lot about the the progress we've made in that particularly in that space since since the things that Chris's been doing to sort of see it see it at the state level I I want to understand it is that does that state data contrast >> so I'll be honest with you the only reason I bring up MCCAST data for ELS is because that's how we are judged based on our accountability structure in the state of Massachusetts.
These were mostly included. As an FYI, we were not I was not planning to discuss or vote on these. >> Yes. >> Sorry. Point of order. Is the chair soliciting new business for the next meeting from its members? >> So, sorry, I was scrolled down and completely missed that item. Thank you, member Deniv. Yes, I am sub uh soliciting new business from members. Are there agenda items for the next month's meeting? Yes, member Den. >> I have two items of new business. I would like uh to create a motion to create a position for a non- voting student member of the committee and then my let me know when you're ready for my second. >> Ready. >> Okay. My second is I'd like a motion to create a procedure for meeting with the student advisory council every other month in order to follow Massachusetts general law part one title 12 chapter 71 section 38mm.
>> Nope. This is a voluntary opportunity that we must do annually. Um but it is our choice to to have a cap or not. Yeah. >> Thank you. Yes. Member Den. The state has a cap of 2% and it is up to us to decide whether or not we want to lower it or not. >> I'm sorry. Can you clarify that it's up to us to decide if we want to lower the state? >> The state has a cap of 2%. If we choose to have less than 2%, we can. >> Yes. Yes. Thank you. Okay. Last call. Any others? Okay. Again, if a question comes to you between now and next meeting, please send it to the superintendent. Um, and we'll look forward to revisiting this next month. All right. Moving on. Um, old business included the re review of the year-long agenda and strategic plan review.
>> Thank you Sean. I'd >> like to congratulate Heather and the fellow teachers for the capstone uh projects as well as the presentations today. You uh did a great job of bringing together the community. You had the fire department here, the police department, you had city council members, you had state representatives, you had city departments, you had a state senator here. It was neat to see the people collaborate and work with the students in this beautiful brand new building. I'd also like to congratulate Dr. Roco and um her fellow staff, Kelly, for coming to the meeting on evaluations and professional development. It was really neat to watch them work together for what's best for the kids, what's best for the teachers so that they can do their job. So, I congratulate you on a great collaboration. >> Anybody else? >> Sherry. >> Yes. I just wanted to say that uh Cindy and I attended the Westside Middle School um history project judge and it was awesome just to see how hard all these kids worked and how excited they were and I just feel like this is going to be a wonderful perk about being on the board of ed getting to be a part of all these cool things.
But it's usually the opposite where we spent more and we're having to look at where else we can cut and move things around. Last year a big thing we did was move um a lot of our instructional applications like I Ready um and Amplify. We moved them to restricted lottery which you can use for textbooks or digital curriculum. So it's things like that. Okay, take that out of our main budget and put in this restricted bucket and try to get creative in ways that we can reduce things, but sometimes it's um with restricted it's you can only use it for that. So, it is but it is tough. >> Okay. Okay. I guess I'm just saying that you you came up with these numbers, right? Like the 220 and the 117, right? So, you you had what that was, right? No, it was based on meeting the reserve and I have to um adjust each each category by a little bit after um after I looked at the positions that were one time.
Um so I guess we'll be getting updates on that in the coming months as well. So that's very exciting. That's um slated to begin the execution of the murals I believe is in 2027 if I understand correctly. But um getting that process going three large locations including city hall um would get one of these murals. The back of the fire station downtown um and um the parking garage, the Maynard parking garage. Those are the three locations. Any other updates from the commission members? Any anything else happening that we should be aware of in the coming months? Um, okay. The next order of business is reports from working groups. I feel like a lot of um working group reports were kind of woven into tonight's meeting. Um I'm not going to go group by group, but are there any is there anything that anybody would like to add to the conversation that we didn't already discuss this evening?
>> I'll do Simington. >> Okay. So, >> then you then um Diane, you'll have Harmon and Ellsworth. Okay. >> All right. Do we have that? Um, okay. All right. >> And there is a there is a link to the site visitation and what you're did you see the link there? Yes. About what's the expectations that kind of thing. Okay. >> All right. Um. All right. So, now we're to um I guess we're to any uh Oh, well, I just lost it. Oh, okay. Um, I think we're at anybody future agenda items. Is that where we're at? [clears throat] >> So, anybody have anything that they would like to put on a future agenda? >> I would like to revisit um accepting ESA funds for classes, programs, and so forth. >> Okay. And then, um, anything else? Anybody else? Anything you're interested in? No. >> Right.
In my opinion, again, which we should probably avoid, the real measure of our of our students success in English learning is based on our access scores. And and that's why we need to do a dive into are our access scores showing us the types of improvement that we want to see relative to the progress made by our English learners. Um, that doesn't mean that we shouldn't continue to strive to get students to meet or exceeds at the MCCAST, but your your point is well taken in that what's a be what's a better measurement stick for us here in Ashland. >> Yeah. And I'm not even saying which one's better from measure. It's more data points, right? this is a data point and and if our access data shows one thing and this thing shows something drastically different understanding why that is is still a valuable thing I don't think either is you know we we should never just hang our hat on a data point or or a singular thing either way uh but just looking at this it's like wow that it was it's a little shocking just based on um the positive things we've been saying about the the progress we've been we thought we've been uh over the last few years.
>> Excellent. Thank you so much. Those items will be added to next month's agenda. If you have um if you could send that language in an email, that would be great. Thank you very much. >> Can I please be added to that email? >> Yes, N. >> All right. Any other items of new business to consider for next month? Okay. Seeing none, um revisiting, moving on again to old business. Um, so yes, I just included this year-long agenda and strategic plan review um, mostly for the benefit of our new members to make sure that you did have these documents available, that you knew where to find them. Um, I was not intending for us to to get into a whole long discussion or have a vote about these, but we will be talking about these next month. So, study up, come with your questions, comments, concerns um, and we can be talking about them moving forward.
These were mostly included. As an FYI, we were not I was not planning to discuss or vote on these. >> Yes. >> Sorry. Point of order. Is the chair soliciting new business for the next meeting from its members? >> So, sorry, I was scrolled down and completely missed that item. Thank you, member Deniv. Yes, I am sub uh soliciting new business from members. Are there agenda items for the next month's meeting? Yes, member Den. >> I have two items of new business. I would like uh to create a motion to create a position for a non- voting student member of the committee and then my let me know when you're ready for my second. >> Ready. >> Okay. My second is I'd like a motion to create a procedure for meeting with the student advisory council every other month in order to follow Massachusetts general law part one title 12 chapter 71 section 38mm.
>> Great. Thank you. Anything else? >> No. Okay. >> Okay. Go ahead. >> I know uh I acknowledged you before the meeting started, but I just wanted to acknowledge uh Minnie uh and and uh winning this seat on the board. Thank you very much for your volunteerism and your service, and we're happy to have you on board. So, just wanted to make sure for the record, we are happy to have you. very quiet. >> Okay. If there is nothing else, >> uh, excuse me. Could I sort of, if I'm out of order, I'll be quiet. I would like for the, um, associate superintendent to sort of answer a question for me. When you provide this data for the board, would that data for the elementary schools include the present reading and and um writing scores of our elementary schools. So the data that will be presented is the accountabil the state accountability data that came out in November that showed how we performed as a district uh for the 2425 school year.
>> Okay. So, this is going to be something that you're going to you're going to pull this stuff out of the closet after we have these discussions and look at everything and go, >> yeah, look at what we're potentially vendor service. >> Okay. >> Try to find savings. do you know we're looking we are lined up right now at PG& to do um there they'll come out and check your energy effic efficiency of your lights and thermostats and they'll do like on bill financing um to change up some things and make them more energy efficient so that your bills go down and we're trying to get creative and look at all different things like I said we switched the gas um we're limited in this area with some of the services you know the sewer lines through the county or the um waters through American water so there aren't other options so It's tough when those prices are going.
No, the CIP Allison sent out an email. We're going to be scheduling a meeting. We're going to be reviewing the CIP. Um, and we'll be working on our annual plan fundraising workg group. We are going to re-engage the Annabber Community Foundation to kind of find out where this um fund, the money that we're able to draw from um how we can actually extract that money from the community foundation, get it into a bank account in at the city, and then um really begin planning that miniigrant process. Anything any other updates from working groups that we haven't heard yet tonight? Any new agenda items for next month before we adjourn that folks can think of? Um we'll be working on the plan. We'll be um wrapping up the CIP recommendations. Uh, we've got the Golden Paintbrush Awards moving forward to city council. Anything I'm missing that we could that we need to be kind of continually working on?
>> Okay. Then where are we at then? Um I'll make a motion to adjourn at 6:39. >> Second. >> All in favor? I >> I motion carries five to zero. Well, you're going to have to vote for me because I just got out of everything.
Y >> so in the last few slides we've talked a lot about things that we found as challenges. I think it's important to note that our in our high needs population, our low-income students uh made a significant increase uh at the at the middle school level in ELA uh going up 8% from the 2024 data. So, another another thing to celebrate at the middle school is the fact that we we saw a rise in our ELA performance by low-income students. Uh, at at the high school, >> just a clarification when when you the very beginning of the program, you talked about >> the different subgroups. >> I thought you said high needs was a combination of a number of different things. Yeah. Number group different groups. So, remind me again which who's included. So, so high need students encompass our low-income students, our our students who are considered English learners as well as our students with disabilities.
And I do just want to say like our strategic plan is set uh at this time. We are sort of right in the middle of it. Um but I can anticipate us looking forward in the next year or two to restarting that process. Um and making sure that we are developing a strategic plan that actually is that is in line with what we want and is uh uh presented in a way that is digestible to us. Um, okay. With that, I've got to read the whole thing. Um, I will be looking for a uh motion to enter into executive session pursuant to Mass General Law, Chapter 3A, subsection 21A3, to discuss strategy with respect to collective bargaining or litigation if an open meeting may have a detrimental effect on the bargaining or litigating position of the public body. and the chair so declares and I do.
>> Excellent. Thank you so much. Those items will be added to next month's agenda. If you have um if you could send that language in an email, that would be great. Thank you very much. >> Can I please be added to that email? >> Yes, N. >> All right. Any other items of new business to consider for next month? Okay. Seeing none, um revisiting, moving on again to old business. Um, so yes, I just included this year-long agenda and strategic plan review um, mostly for the benefit of our new members to make sure that you did have these documents available, that you knew where to find them. Um, I was not intending for us to to get into a whole long discussion or have a vote about these, but we will be talking about these next month. So, study up, come with your questions, comments, concerns um, and we can be talking about them moving forward.