Reader
Browse passages, annotate evidence, and export with full provenance for citation.
ly because like we have more staff, right? So if you have more staff, probably going to have to be gone and there's going to be an increase in in sub costs, but um those have gone up quite a bit. And so we're looking into, you know, it might not be an initial savings, but maybe we look into some sort of incentive or we just like attendance incentive for like our staff. And also just by letting people know and making them aware of the the significant increase. I mean just quickly in the classified side of things in 1920 our um spending for substitutes was almost 28,000 and last year it was um almost 96,000. Certificated in 1920 was 61,000 and last year was at 192,000. So there's some reasons in there that are >> good >> not to be discussed in this like that makes sense.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, one of the things that we always talk about is how are our students performing over time? So, I I did a longitudinal outlook for every single grade level that took the MCCAST last year from grade 8 down. I did not include our our sophomores. I wanted to keep this K to8 longitudinally. So, what you're looking at right now is the snapshot of the class of 2029, which are our current freshmen. Last year's >> What's that? >> This isn't what was sent to us. >> No, because you added a couple slides. >> I added slides. Yeah. Yep. Yep. So, based on questions that came, I did add some slides and I actually adjusted some slides as well. So, >> we're all looking at our our version and going, "Okay, where is that?" Well, >> it's linked. [clears throat] Go ahead, >> Mike. So this this to me show it paints a pretty good picture.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> No, even like the IEP meetings, there's been more of those. So there's been subs for more of the IEP need for cover. So because our special ed population went up I'd say about half of that could be due to that. >> And then of course, you know, there's other reasons, but still it's it's quite significant. So I think if we just let like we're not going shame on you. Like that's certainly not what I'm trying to convey here. I think it's just we're all in this together. We all understand what's going on. So I think as transparent as we can be and just explain like it is what it is and if people know then, you know, we can all work together to um to get through these tough times. >> Um I I wish we weren't here >> and show up and have savings from them, >> right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So what you're going to see is that in ELA in 20121 when they were grade four students they were performing at a really high level. uh they they were up over 60% uh meets or exceeds and then there was a there was a pretty big dip uh in in in grade five and then they slowly rose little grade seven had a small dip slowly rose in grade six had a small dip in grade seven but then look where they they got back to that original point in grade eight. So, it it's what it's telling me is that it could be a lot of different things. The tests could get a little bit harder. Um, but we are getting to the point where our students are maintaining where they were, but not necessarily rising each year. So, we've got to figure out what's happening there. So grade five through seven based on this data that's where our primary year of growth is is is but grade seven data this year was pretty strong but that was grade seven data from 2024 based on this specific cohort.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So happy. >> Well, to kind of go alongside that is when you're looking at the utilities, you know, I go to the high school and they come on the weekends and you hear the air conditioners or the heaters going, no one's at school. So, just even just putting it out there that I mean it costs a lot of money to run those things. When you walk out the door, hit the button. >> Yeah. And that's why I was just speaking to some of those incentives. They were talking about the motion sensor light switches, the thermostats that our MO director could control from his phone. So on the weekends and breaks, we've totally changed this year where we're shutting a lot of that stuff off more on the weekends and the breaks and just being more mindful of that. Plus, a lot of our lights are the older lights.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So I have the cohort data from from that from that 2030 as well just not in a a slide format. Uh again real strong performance in those transition grades. Grade four tremendously strong performance grade eight tremendously strong performance. But what is it telling us we need to do, right? What are our implications? How are we going to make sure that we're taking this data and actually making it useful as we move forward? And I think that it shows us that our tier one is function is it's functioning, right? But we might not be sufficiently meeting the needs of all of our learners, particularly in grades five and grade seven. So what can we do to improve that tier one instruction? We need to make sure that we have proper coherence and we need to make sure we're differentiating for all of our students. And we've we've begun those data team meetings at the elementary school level.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So changing out to the LEDs. Um so James and I have been working with PG& and talking about the on financing would be no cost to the district. They just any savings you have that stays on their side and then you pay your bill as is. Um, and then you see savings over time. >> Yeah. >> Because that last year was over budget. >> I know. Like 100 grand, right? >> Yeah. For the electricity. So, and but it's not because maybe we used more. The rates when I first started here were 26 cents a kilowatt. Now they are up to, you know, 60 cents. So, >> you're paying more per per use. >> Yeah. >> Um, this is going back to the SAR report and maybe you can look into this um, you know, when you're looking into other stuff. If you go back to like the last page on it, it talks about the fiscal year uh 2324 teacher and administrative salaries and if you look at our district amount and there's you know the column there that talks about the teacher salaries, principles, you know, superintendent and then there's the state average.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We need to move that forward now to the middle school. Um and I think it's important to note that we can't just continue to rely on intervention, right? It's not just about intervention. It's about what are we doing at the tier one level to ensure that everybody is getting what they need. I feel like you we focus so much on intervention strategies and what are we doing for tier 2, but we also need to take a good hard look at what we're doing in our in our tier one curriculum. Like if um I've always had this thought in my head that if we'll just use ELA [clears throat] because you have it up on the board, but it applies to, you know, all areas. If if 60% SGP right in grade four and you're able to >> Well, this is meat succeeds. >> I'm sorry.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Um, I don't quite understand why like if you look at like, you know, beginning teacher salary 49, state average 55, you know, and you go through principal 114, state average 133, superintendent 169, state average 155. But when you go down to the bottom and it says percentage of budget for teacher salaries, it says ours like is 49%. And the state average is 25%. But they're spending more. Like I don't understand how that pencils out. And then also like percentage for teacher uh for admin staff it says we we do 8%. Whereas state average is 6%. So I mean it says in one hand it says we're spending more but when you look at comparisons we're less. So I don't I don't get that. Like I'm not a math person. So maybe >> comes in from the data comes in from the state. So I'm not sure how that's calculated either.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> There is an SGP slide. >> I'll hold the I'll hold the point to that. >> Okay. >> Yeah. >> So So I just had a question. You know, do you do you look at how close we how many we have that are close to the line that impacts this and then be able to correlate dips? you know, if there's a general dip uh across the state and we had a significant number that were closer to line that their score didn't dip all that much, but they just there if we had a bunch that are hovering by the line that that could significantly change our number, our percentage numbers >> just by a little bit of a of a dip, right? It doesn't mean that >> it's not saying that 10% of that everybody went crashed that with that 10% you could have a a co a large cohort that was right above the line and they just >> three points lower >> and and you're it's like you read my slides that I didn't give you Paul because what one of the things that we're talking about that we want to make sure that we are focusing on are those students that are right in the line and how do we ensure that our students who are right there at partially meets are are getting the appropriate interventions to get them over that hump and we've got to we I think we have to focus a little a little bit more on those students.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
That doesn't make sense. I understand. So maybe >> I think some of it is because of of like you have giant districts that are in there like LA Unified that have you know giant budgets and lots of students and enrollment. So it's going to be a less percentage of their budget just because they have a bigger budget. Does that make sense? >> They have San Francisco Unifi is going to be in there. You have all of California. We're very small district. I when I was doing that MIG training, we were the second to smallest district, I mean, everybody had districts that were like 13,000 students, 15,000 students, you know, and we're like three schools and they're comparing one less. >> It's not apples to apples. >> Yeah. So, I think it's just that it's a percentage of our budget because we have a smaller budget and so it's a bigger percentage.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Identify students close to proficiency. You you you you read my mind, Paul. So, this is again scaled score uh by year and grade. And you can see it's it's taking that same class of 2029. It's so close. It's so close to meet succeeds, right? you know, so so you'll notice that it it barely dips below the 500 uh in in grades five in in grade six. In grade eight, it finally gets over the hump, right? We're going from 499 to 506. So, we are continually right there in terms of our average scaled score. This to me does indicate that we are aligned instructionally, but we still have improvements that we have to make. Um and we have so many students that are so close to that proficiency threshold. So we need to determine are we going to make a a concerted effort to ensure that those students who are at that proficiency threshold are given additional tools to cross over to that next level.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
>> Okay. and everybody else in that category like all other districts. Yeah, >> that's good. >> I was curious if the board had any um preference as far as uh a number that we would like to um direct the superintendent to uh look at in our budget. Um, I'll just offer up kind of what I was thinking. Um, when I hear that our reserve isn't even one month of our expenditures, that's concerning. It has been, but I also know that we've just been trying to like keep legal with our 4%. So, um, I was reminded tonight by Superintendent Townsen that our board policy is 10% 10 to 14%. And so, um, when I'm looking at, um, the numbers that were presented tonight and trying to keep our district fiscally responsible, um, I was thinking that if we just had one month of um, expenditures in our reserve that that might be a good place to start.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
We want the students who are right at the edge of meets exceeds to get to exceeds. But I think we need to really think hard about those students who are at partially meets and get them into that meets category. Um, and I and I and I believe that's where you were going with that, Paul. >> Yeah, exactly. And I think you're targeting [clears throat] something to say almost like figuring out how to get them stable, right? It's it's like, hey, you're >> you're you're right here and it's not about our percentage numbers. It's about, hey, how do we get you so you're just in the middle of that band as opposed to the bottom of the band? And and I think that these two these two slides together, right, the slide that we just showed you um why while the meets or exceeds data shows a big dip, it it also shows you how there were probably more kids that were right on that threshold that year that did just drop down slightly.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And I just wanted to open this up to discussion. So I do have a I have a question about um so I'm trying to find it on your slide. Oh, okay. So yeah, if we go back to the very beginning on page two, you know, projected reserve and then you said we only meet our reserve in outline years because you deducted this bottom part, right? I just put adjustments on on the multi-year projection. there's a space where you can make adjustments for salary and benefits. And then for the other categories like supplies and services, you'd put in the number of what your budget's going to be. So I just I made it less because I was trying to meet the reserve. Um because otherwise when everything was loaded in there as it was, it said no, you're short. So, and then it was the main thing for the salary and benefits was the one-time positions because those were um but that doesn't mean it's that exact position, but the funding for those positions because that funding is going away.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So again, longitudinal data I think tells a better story than the story that is told by simply looking grade grade every year. >> I guess there's there's one thing I I feel like I I need to say about sort of that that group that's close to the line trying to get them over is I mean for me, you know, I know we're we're here largely to have a report from you, but we've we've always talked the whole group has talked about really getting every kid as far along as they can be. Right. So the the data points will trigger somebody going from one category to another. But we've always really focused on the growth of each student being as much as it can be. And I don't want to I don't think you mean to suggest anything else than that. But I I I also want to I want to say that because I think if I were listening to this without that context, I might say, well, isn't that just worried about getting kids from >> this this just over the line and then the rest of the people are below row?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
So, whether that replaces something else that is going away or what, it's a lot of uh kind of shuffling around to see >> that's why correct me if I'm wrong, but that's why that number is very close to the 430 >> that I mentioned in >> that's the one time. Yeah. which is the onetime fund. >> Mhm. >> Right. Only >> that's because 430 is using 2627 step and call on rates. Yes. >> Yeah. Cuz we project so like the number on slide on slide two was what she was >> projecting as what we would what we need to cut right to meet the reserve. And then this 430 is let's just like the like the positions that are currently funded there. If you look at that what their total compensation is with keeping in mind what what would that be for the upcoming year with steps and column increase, right?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And I don't think that's that's certainly not the message. appreciate the comment. I I think what what I'm what I'm trying to articulate is that we often times are focused on students who are struggling immensely and and that's where our interventions focus. I think we need to understand that we need to improve our focus area to include all students that might be performing at a at a level that is commensurate with an on-grade level ability and we've got to get them higher. So, and we and we need to ensure that all truly means all in this in this context and that one year growth is really got to be the measure for everybody. And that might mean we're doing specific differentiation for students who are right on grade level to get them to to truly make that jump. >> Yeah. And I I appreciate the point too, Mark.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
Like they might that that position is going to make more money next year like because of the salary schedule. So that's why those numbers are off slightly, but that's basically what that category is, right, Tara? That >> Yeah, because on the multi-year projection, I just use the current numbers for the onetime positions. >> Yeah, the current cost is the 394. So um I know you're looking for board direction. So again, I'm if I go back to that page two, and again, I'm sorry if I'm confused, but so if we take those, you know, you you put in cuts to get us, you know, to where we're solve it. So, let's just say it's almost, you know, like $700,000. Okay. So then if we work towards that, but then like Julie is saying, if we need to have like at least one month so we can make payroll >> in case deferrals come or in case we don't have like especially I guess in December, there's a couple of times a year where we don't have like the money we need to pay our bills and we would have to borrow money to pay payroll, that kind of thing.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
And my context was if you looked at just the the the data that said, hey, from this grade to this grade, they they dropped 10%. Well, that that might be alarming. And I think my point was looking at it there, it's not an alarming dip. It's saying, okay, those they were right at the line and it's more of an indication of where they were on the scale and how do we continue that growth above and keep them growing above that. Right. >> Yeah. I I I wasn't I certainly wasn't taking issue with anybody's point. It I I I heard as an outsider what was being discussed and I thought there was a context that was missing. I just didn't want that to be >> No, I appreciate that. >> That's all. >> And this last one, uh, it shows ELASGP over time. So grade seven uh there was a particular strong year for SGP almost at 60.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above