Well, what do you do? You want a summary of how would you like to receive your directive? Superintendent Delta, >> why don't you start throwing it out there and if I have clarifying questions, I'll ask them. >> Okay. >> What have you heard us say? Why don't you summarize for us? >> We've been here for three hours. You really want me to summarize it? >> Just the last few minutes. I think in the last few minutes what we've come up with is that we're going to use a number somewhere between $800 and $850,000 that we're going to ask them to go back um to the drawing board pull everything out. I really want you to look at those supplies and services budgets, those things that are away from personnel, children, and and see what you can come up with to find money so that we can um we can cut the budget.
Again, you can see that we've declined in a few different areas. Uh, and it's it's areas that we we are not surprised about. It's the areas that we've been discussing throughout throughout the night. Uh, high need students, English learners, students with disabilities. we we need to make sure that we are improving practices there for those students and this is at the uh SGP again for math. I'm flying through this now but it's really the same data that we've seen. positive thing I take from it is the low lowest performing on all of these the SGP seems to be you know several points above 50 um uh on all these that means the ones that needed to make more than a year's growth seems to be making more than a year's growth >> well and this is a great slide >> Paul the answer to your question here right about what's the next category 61% is exceeded typical growth right >> yeah and and this is I pointed this out within the context of our of our MCAT slides that I shared earlier, our lowincome students, look at that growth rate, right?
>> That sounds great. >> And then you you bring it back to us and then we might have to make some tough decisions. And then once you have more information, if things change, you know, we plan for the worst so you can get what you need to do. And then if we have, you know, hopefully things will change and then we can maybe re reress it again. And you know, >> as an additional comment to your summary, we would like for them to keep in mind in addition to keeping it away from personnel and students, but keeping it aligned with our LCAP goals. Correct. >> Correct. >> And is there anything with slide 19? Is there one area versus another or you want us to look at all areas in terms of staffing in terms of the onetime funds? >> Because you're not going to find it all in supplies and services, >> right?
Exceeded typical growth. They were at a 60.8 growth percentile. So, we're really proud of of what happened with our low-inccome students at the high school level in math. Okay. Um, that brings us to the Dibbles data. Again, I I think that we could we could go through this another day unless unless you want me to keep on going. I'll go all night, but that that's up to you folks. uh to decide. I know there was a lot. Um >> does it tell a different story? >> It it doesn't necessarily tell a different story, but you'll learn more about what's happening at the K to2 level when you take a look at some of that data. >> Nuance. >> Yeah, it's a little bit more nuanced and and it provides the opportunity to see what was happening not just three through three through 10, but now K to 2 as well.
No, no, I know. I know you're not going to um >> but just kind of looking at all >> Well, yeah, when you were looking at last one. Yeah, with the density. Yeah, I do think you need to look and go from the top down because it looks like that's where we're a little heavy, if you can call it heavy. But yeah, I think you should look from the top down. What do you guys think? Is that >> I think so, too. And I would also like to um draw on Ann's comments earlier about um disregulated behaviors and um you know the special ed department is crucial and vital and very important and um occupying a large part of our budget. So, I just want it to be looked at critically to make sure that we are making the best decisions and we're the most efficient without, you know, um overloading the people that don't need to be overloaded, >> right?
uh the the story that it that it tells is that at the 3 through8 level our I ready data is pretty indicative of how we are doing on MCCAST. So we need to be looking closely at our I Ready data because it's telling us the correct story of our performance on the Massachusetts assessment system. and and if we're looking closely at our at our student achievement rate there, it's going to help us predict how kids are going to do in the spring on that test. So I I think we have to understand that while sometimes taking those assessments can be seen as a burden, it's providing us with information that should change the way we're instructing students and and we have to use that formatively to ensure that students are getting what they need because it is a true indicator of student success in terms of what our achievement data is showing us.
>> Well said. >> Which we already do. >> Yeah. I say it's tough. We need the supports. >> Double check. That's it. Double check. >> Just double check. >> Triple check. >> Triple again. Double check again. >> Okay. So, do you feel like you have your your direction? >> Yeah. Can I repeat it to you? >> Okay. >> The number is between 800 850,000. Um, take a look at supplies. Stay as far away from the students as possible, direct impact to students. u make sure when we're looking at things we're um considering the alignment with the LCAP goals and um our disregulated behaviors and making sure I'm paying attention to the special education department >> and the density >> the density top >> sorry I knew there was something else >> top down >> um yes that Um, >> I will pay very close attention to that to that last slide.
Um, and I would assume or you don't have MCCAST at K to2, it's going to be it it would work the same way, right? That that I Ready data is providing us with the data that we need to ensure students are getting what they need. Um, you know, I I I'll forward right here just to the very last slide. >> Before you leave that point, I'm just throw this out there for whatever it's worth. So, I know, you know, as a parent who had kids go through the MCCAST every year when it was still a graduation requirement, we always tried to downplay it and just sort of like, don't worry about it. Like, this is certainly not something that's worth stressing over. And I think most part of kids did okay with that. But um one of the things I think about is you know the point you just made which is I really think where the value of MCCAST data is and all these other things we use is it helps us inform changes that we need to make right it helps us understand how kids are learning um in an more I guess I'll call it objective way or at least standardized way and I'm curious as to whether or not we have in the past or thought about in the future any kind of building basic communication to parents to say, "Look, please encourage your kids to take the test, you know, to take it seriously.
>> Okay. >> Report I have to say this just before and report back next month and be extremely thorough and extremely brief. >> I think it's important. I know it's a long meeting and I know we still have things to cover, but this is important to spend time on and to make sure that we're considering everything and we're and we're taking the time that it deserves. Um, we're going to have several meetings. We're going to likely need to call a special board meeting um because it's important. And I'm not saying that you're saying that it's unimportant. I just um I I I think that this is going to continue to take some time because it deserves time. >> Yeah. >> Okay. All right. I got it. >> So, I think we're ready to move on. Um so, is that coming to our next meeting then?
We don't know that there's a problem there, you know, in that issue here, but we don't want the the response that says I think MCAST is silly." That might be the correct answer for a lot of questions, but it it in terms of being helpful to us. >> Yeah. >> Um people participating in the process is helpful. Whether parents say that to the kids and whether kids will actually do that, I don't know. Um, I don't know if we have enough data to assess whether that's a point of concern or not, but it's a thought. Um, because you're you're saying things that I think are important for everybody to understand as a community in terms of what we're getting out of this, what we're getting from Ready, what we're getting from CAS, they are helping us become a better district. And I think that's a very different mindset than most people would think about the MCAST generally, right?
We're going to have a special board meeting. >> We'll talk about that to that part. >> Okay. >> Um Okay. So 9C is off the table. Um, so the enrollment and ADA reports. >> Sorry, I was doing some calculations. That's okay. >> She must be the CDF. Want you to do that. >> Um, oh, so the ADHO enrollment is the one we provide there to look at the attendance percentages compared to enrollment. That hasn't changed much as far as the enrollment goes. Uh the last meeting we had is it 760. Now it's 763. So up a little bit. Um just small changes in each site. A couple more kids were in the list because that was 19 that went up to 23. Oh yeah, the sites each of them some of them went down a little and then that was offset with >> Okay. Um, moving on to 9E.
Most people think it's just a waste of money, waste of time, you know, and there's lots of words about >> Yeah, there's lessons to be learned from that data and and it helps to to drive our instructional practices, you know, >> I just I don't want to sidetrack the conversation on that, but I guess I'd put it out to you as, you know, to both of you, something to think about. And >> to your point, Mark, I I would be more concerned about not the data in terms of MCCAST from, you know, through grade eight, right? I I'd be more concerned about what's going to happen this year again with our sophomores >> when they take the exam. Right? That's the concern in terms of I I think the folks who are taking the exams below, you know, from grade 8 below are taking it seriously.
Uh, since our last board meeting, we've had one introdist transfer from Wasuma to OCI. >> That's correct. >> And let's move on to item 10, accomplishments and other reasons to celebrate from throughout the district. Wasuma Elementary, Taran Hopkins. Thank you. >> All right. MPR. >> Yeah, you stop it. Let's stop dead. Okay, perfect. All right. Well, we have been very busy and having a lot of fun. So, this um this presentation takes place pretty much from October to December. Left off um from our last one. So in October um we have our elective class called leadership and in leadership it encompasses a few different things. ASP is one of them child development and then students just working on um the leadership skills. So they um came together ASP and leadership and decided we need a unity day. Um so we encouraged everyone to wear orange um and it was just a day to remember that kindness counts.
I I don't think there's um a significant amount of of change compared to what we saw at the high school, right? In terms of the dip. Uh I'll be curious to see how uh folks um perform this year two of of not making it a graduation requirement. >> Sure. >> Yeah. And an anecdot anecdotally again I'll just say uh throughout like when once you get to high school you really don't you see everything as a means to graduating and like before that it's not really you don't say oh the MCAST is a graduation requirement so I have to do it. I have to try my best. It's it's kind of a thing that you you either do and you don't do and that that's kind of going to stay steady, but it's really at the high school when you see see kids that really see something as a means to graduating or not where they're actually going to make a change.
Um and so we had great participation in that. The kids were great at promoting it. Um so here are some pictures from it. And then after that came Halloween. Um this was an incredibly fun day. Um the turnout at school was amazing with all the different creative costumes from kindergarten all the way up through 8th grade. Um so we did our um costume parade where our kindergarten through third graders got to walk around and everyone got to look at their costumes. Um, but it was such a fun day that it takes two slides. There were so many people who participated, so it was great. Um, so the staff dressed up as ice cream and as you can see here, our office staff wore the bananas for our banana split. >> so that was really fun. >> Um, and then early November, we um, our PTC sponsored our fall festival.
>> Thank you. Thanks. Have a try. So, where where do we go from here, you know, the next steps? And while I have some, you know, some oneliners there on the slide, I wanted to take some time to sort of just this last slide to talk about, you know, what we actually need to do in and why we think we may have some of the issues that we talked about in terms of achievement. So, you know, in particular, ELA and math performance at the elementary and middle levels. Uh, we we out we outperformed the state, but there was a decline. There's a decline in early ELA and math proficiency. So that suggests that we could have a gap in in our in our instruction in our curriculum alignment uh and in instructional consistency. There's a potential gap there. Uh it could be because there's an inconsistent use of evidence-based instructional practices.
Um, it was an amazing event. They did an amazing job planning it and running it. Um, early November was kind of a different thing for us. It was a little bit chilly out by the end of the event, but um, everyone had a great time and we raised a decent amount of money. Okay. And then we had Veterans Day and our, um, cadet core class um, it's our elective got to go down to Fresno and um, march in the Veterans Day parade in downtown Fresno. So that was a really special thing for them. Um so our wonderful PTC sponsored our first assembly um the steam assembly. And so what it was is um they come out and they put up different stations for the kids to go to. So you can kind of see in some of those stations um the one with like the baby gate is they're moving a car using um like an iPad and then they have a VR headset.
Right? It could be because we are not right now uh [clears throat] using the right materials and and we need to take a good hard look at that and we are going to um there could be gaps in our our math instruction most specifically conceptual development and problem solving. Those are areas that we continually see as issues. Um problem solving is something that we we always come up and talk about. Uh we talked about geometry and fractions as well. So those are areas that we see consistent gaps. Are we using the real-time data that we get uh from I Ready and from our assessments to inform our instructional practices effectively? Are we are we really using that beginning of year, middle of year data and looking at it in [clears throat] a way that is allowing us to make real time improvements to our practices.
Um the buzzwire thing is trying to get it through without it buzzing. There was a dino day. Um so the kids enjoyed this so much. It was offered a best experience. Um and then our wonderful parents came and helped volunteer and run the different centers. Okay. And then in November, our kindergarten through 2 grade class um classes came together and they did a beautiful performance for their families um and friends. Um our kindergarten through second grade teachers worked extremely hard on this presentation. Um so what they did is they mixed the kids together, kindergarten, first and second. Some of the kids were telling jokes, some were reading a poem, some were singing a song, and then they all came together at the end and did one big song. So our teachers worked really really hard on it. It was wonderful performance. Um while they were doing that, our leadership class um they were in the back um cooking everybody breakfast.
I believe that we're doing a great job at the ele early elementary level and at Mendes in terms of taking specific data during data teams and having targeted plans for students, but I don't think we're doing that across grades and we have to improve those practices. We have extreme gaps for our ELS and for our students with disabilities. We know this. Um it could be because there's a a variability in the implementation of our of our instructional practices. uh we have to take a look at our co-eing practices. What are we doing? Are we are we being fully inclusive in terms of doing the right thing and and providing the right opportunities for students to receive good inclusion support across all grade levels? Uh are we scaffolding the right way? Are we using our language supports and math appropriately for all of our students? Are we making it rigorous enough for our special education students?