2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 118
So that's what our hope is and and this should be pretty quick because it's actually a lot of just basically saying those comments are acknowledged and we're going to make those changes to the plans and we're not disputing or questioning what they're asking for. So um if we can proceed with that that would be fantastic. >> Yeah why don't we go ahead and proceed. >> Thank you. So again Mark Garno with GD consulting senior soil scientist. So just a walk through. So the the commission reviewed this delineation um as part of a sitewalk and there was one flagging change that was requested during that sitewalk. In addition there were two locations that the commission requested Data sheets be provided to document whether or not that wetland line was accurate per mass D's delination guideline from 2022. We submitted those information uh along with a supplemental WVR in December of last year.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 119
So, thank you. >> All right. My only comments are thank you for everybody that's been kind of writing the emails and what's important to them in particular as was mentioned before the students. I really appreciate that as well. U and then for the time and deliberation that this um order and everything that they do um on a slightly anecdotal I find it fun like my son was one of those both of them were that had the kind of went in his credits. So I got the same conversation with my son in like his junior like his sophomore year was like I'm a junior now right same kind of thing. Then your university went yeah you're metriculated bing added extra charges on top of everything because she's now in his degree program. So >> I mean I'll say all right one last comment but I will say like my daughter now is enjoying her college experience >> so much like oh gez year and a half.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 119
So the commission has that information documenting that and to date we've not heard any comments from Beiel and Thomas or this commission about that data being inaccurate to document the wetland line being accurate. in in in supplemental uh uh consequence, Beiel and Thomas was actually went out and actually reviewed these locations um and they um actually made two flagging changes along with an additional flagging change. Um one flagging change was between um S4 and S5. It basically just kind of red it better defines the bank based on the topo. That flagging change is fine. You'll see that updated on the plan. We're not we're not suggesting any changes besides complying with what Bills of Thomas is suggesting at that location. The next question was at uh A46. Um Bills and Thomas recommended a change there as well. Um we looked at it. We dispute the fact that that is accurate.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 120
>> You better slow down a little bit here so you know she's almost exploring ways where she could have that fourth year. Yeah. No. Yeah, >> that will be a conversation. >> Neither of mine managed to get out early. >> Yes. >> And my oldest one is graduating in June. >> Law school. So, it's been a long time, you know. So, so thank you to everybody for all the time and effort it takes to pull these presentations together to not only educate us, but anybody that happens to be watching or listening or anything else. Um and so um and then you know the only other thing I would say is and and it kind of hit me a little bit when um one of our student ambassadors, our student ambassadors mentioned it's like their last semester and to hold your little ones close while you have them while you can um and for them to enjoy but not forget that they're still in school for the next three months.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 120
However, we're willing to concede and let it be the wetland line for the project. We're updating the plans to show that point being part of the wetland line connecting appropriately and the plans will be reflecting that we're still staying outside the 25 foot buffer zone from that. again our Data sheets that we did submit document that that area is upland. However, um rather than you know doing a lot more field data and you know going out in 10° this weekend um we decided just to like just let the wetland line be where Bill and Thomas says they think it might be. So that's what we're going to do. So we're going to concede that point. So again basically we're going to use that flag point for our wetland delineation and tie it into our other flags which were not um questioned. uh at GCA35. There was also a question there of of hydrarology.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 121
So thank you everybody for the time. Um that concludes our regular meeting. Um, we will be coming back, but we have no other action items um at the end of this. So, we're going to be adjourning to a close session. So, I will um the board is going to go into close session. We'll not have any any action items. As I said before, you are welcome to stay if you like. Thank you. But if you do decide to leave, we want to thank you for coming out this evening. Um the time is 8:46 and I will entertain a motion to move to a closed session as allowed under the open meetings act for the purposes of exceptions 5 LCS 12C5 and one >> so moved by Raquel second by Katie city please lead roll call vote >> yes >> Thomas >> yes >> meadows >> yes Gilbert.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 121
Um again, our D sheets demonstrate that that area is not uh a wetland per the mass D guidelines. Um you may see soil colors in pictures, but unless you pull out your Mensel color book and you actually walk through the manual to document whether or not it actually conforms to the definitions of hydric soils, you can say it's hydric, but does it meet the definition of hydric soils? That's the question. And so again, this point was was hung. Um we are willing to concede that point and let it be uh part of the wetland line. So again, we're going to remove our previous flag, add in this new flag, tie it in, update the plans to show we're not working within 25 ft of these new flags, and and and go from there. So again, um just letting you know that's that's basically our conclusion.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Kane County, IL YouTube / BPS Communications transcript source: youtube Batavia Public School District 101 Board of Education Meetin… · passage 122
>> Yes. >> Right. Thank you. >> Right. Thanks, folks. >> Yeah. Let's head in there.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 122
You'll see this information in the information we'll be submitting to you shortly. Um so the plans will be updated to reflect all these changes. Um and lastly just to to cover um this intermittent stream swale. So the team has never disputed there may that wetland connection. There's a wetland connection. It goes off site and and from our understanding of again the wetlands protection act and this performance standards is a question of are we adversely impacting the wetlands on site and or directly offsite where the water might be going. And so that's the purpose of your review of GCG, which is if we comply with the mass DP storm water standards, there's no adverse impacts to storm water um from the site, which would also contribute to any impacts to to downgrading areas. So therefore, anything that's hundreds of feet downstream would need to be delineated anything else.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 123
The question is if not adversely impacting the wetlands on site or directly off site. Um that's there and that's what Mr. Park was walking you through earlier, which was basically the fact that we're not increasing the peak rates to comply with the performance stands for the two and 10ear storms. Um, and also comparing the fact that we have a large area that's already contributed to that area. For example, the fact that you have a lot of scour happening because there's a street that was never there in 100 200 years ago and now we've se we're seeing scour from, you know, unregulated discharges from the town streets into the wetland system. And as Mr. Park showed, the the rates from our site are not going to be contributing to those peak rates in the two and 10 year storm to comply with the mass DP storm water standards, which again performance standards required to confirm no adverse impact to the wetlands.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 124
So um at at this point, we believe we've received all comments and questions about the wetland delineation from Bills and Thomas um from your agent and from the board. Um we do want to confirm that there are no more comments from that. We believe this delination has had a very thorough review now the at this point. Um and so we wanted to make sure that was the case because as we update plans um it impacts you know multiple efforts on our part. So we're hoping that at least tonight we can have at least clarity that the questions that were raised by the delination are those that are currently there and really there shouldn't be any more because there's nothing else to really look at in terms of we've looked at everything. Um, but if we could get confirmation of that tonight, we'd appreciate at least confirmation that there's no more comments on the wetland delineation besides what has been provided to us in the record.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 125
>> So, if I get you, you're basically accepting all the comments made by Beiel and Thomas in >> in terms of the wetland delineation. Um, yes, the other comments are also being addressed. I can't say that because I'm not the one doing that. That's Mr. Park. But I believe we are basically addressing all those comments. Um I don't think there were actually any really issues with what they've written so far in terms of just making updates to the plans. I have a question on the Bills and Thomas peerreview that's not related to the wetland delineation and and correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't didn't we ask them to weigh in getting back to our original topic of of blasting is whether uh this rock removal would uh either increase or decrease uh the amount of water in the wetland. Are they going to speak to that?
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 126
uh to the commission. My understanding is that they do plan to speak to that. um from what was explained to me with Beiel and Thomas and how they understood um the order of operations for lack of a better term to go is they would do the review of the delineation first as that may um alter some of the effects on compliance with other regulations. And then once that was shown on a plan with the corrected delineation, then they would uh actually look at the compliance with the wetlands protection act regulations and with the blasting effect on the wetlands. >> Okay. Mr. Norton um may want to be present for that discussion as well if if we're going to talk about that again. the whole impact of blasting with regard to uh the volume in the um in case there are questions. I mean, I'm not suggesting that you represent, but if Beals and Thomas has an issue, uh someone that's versed in that may be want to be present to respond to >> acknowledged >> or it could be online.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 127
Doesn't have to be in person. >> Well, just present one way or another. >> Yeah. Just as >> Okay. So, so you want us to uh We'd like we'd like confirmation. I mean, the comm several members of this commission and the agent have walked the wetland line and and reviewed it and they made comments and asked for data. We provided that data um to those locations where we provided data. Bees and Thomas updated the flags and we've we're letting those flags stand and let and use those flags for aation. The other flagging location that Bill and Thomas asked for is just a minor change. Again, we're conceding that point. So at this point, we don't believe there's locations where there's questions about delineation flags being accurate. And so we're hoping we can, you know, close at least the matter that we won't have to go back in two meetings and revise the wetland line again because a comment came up two months after a sitewalk or three months after a sitewalk about the delineation.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 128
So that's what we're we we'd request that respectfully that this matter be kind of closed up in terms of the delineation, not the review of the project and supporting standards, but just the delineation because that really impacts it. It it drives multiple things like even the calculations and our limited work plans. We want those to be accurately reflected consistently in the future and make it easy for this commission as they review the project's performance. Well, given that I I haven't seen what they've changed and and you didn't really show us what changed and I don't know that that would have mattered because it's lines on a plan. Um, you know, I'd want to see it in the field to see what the differences were between the different locations. But since you're conceding to it, I mean, Bills and Thomas, I mean, they're not going to change their mind after they're they said this is where it should be.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 129
You're saying okay. >> Yeah. [clears throat] >> What are we going to say? So, um I don't see a problem with that. I the only thing and I think what you're getting to is that this is going to change all the plans >> because the line is going to be different on this. >> It's it's it's almost inconsequential. >> It's it's it's it's you in terms in terms of that. So the the plan the plan the plans will be the plans are being have already been updated and you can see on this plan here we've actually already updated the grading plan and the limit of work plan to reflect these changes. >> Can I just clarify that by in con it is extremely consequential >> Mike >> sorry uh it's extremely consequential for the purposes of us being able to advance all of the design and I think that's the the main point >> well that's what I'm getting at is just want to make sure you understand that.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 130
Yeah. Okay. our our goal our goal to resolve this is is consequential to the project's whole design and that's what we're hoping to resolve and so again yeah so we've we've already we've already looked at all these things on the plans we're updating the map that way the new submitt is reflected that so and and and and to the members comment again I understand if you want to go out and look at the flag and talk about it that's totally fine I'm just making sure there's nothing else currently floating around because we we want to feel relatively confident that we have something that's relatively locked in place because again it does drive a lot of of of of everything else and I think it will be helpful to >> we clearly can't go out and do any investigations with the existing field conditions. So that's you know the fact that you're accepting it without contesting it then you know that's fine for me.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 131
I I would say this is a great example of why it's nice to have an ANRAD filing before the other filings and and then it's already taken care of and off the table and there's no reason that couldn't have been done before the beginning of the ZBA process. But that's uh lots of water under the bridge in the culvert. Does the commission agree to this? >> Yeah. Yeah. >> Yeah. Sounds reasonable at this time. >> Yeah. Again, again, we're not going to hold you to the perfectly to this. But again, it's it's good to have consensus at at this time that we feel like we're basically there unless there's something crazy that again that you guys see about Beles and Thomas line. Maybe you think it's too high. I don't know. Um but uh at this point, we're just going to use those points. um which I think is just it just makes it easy for everybody just to move forward and also to ensure that Beals and Thomas' review can also can also proceed because at this point again besides some lines changing the the work isn't substantially changing anyway.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 132
We're not moving buildings significant grading. So in terms of performance standard review the project isn't changing a lot. Um although we'll be submitting some supplementation, we're hoping that the review is already in progress because the changes are are again I think from what we'll be showing is they're more just scrivener updates and and tweaks that just clarify what particularly what GCG is is driving at which again you're you're looking to them to make sure that there's no adverse impact to the wetlands and the storm water. >> Thank you. >> Okay. Thank you Mr. Arnold. to the commission. I would just add not to do with the wetlands delineation line but in comments in general. Um while I have not reviewed the full ZBA's final decision and all the conditions on there, I know there are some conditions that relate to the erosion control and a 25 foot vegetated buffer strip around the wetlands that has to be kept vegetated.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above
2026-01-21 Middlesex County, MA YouTube / WACA-TV Ashland transcript source: youtube Conservation Commission (January 20th, 2026) · passage 133
It may be in your best interest to make sure those are called out on the plans that you submit as well as they're not on the current plans as well as anything else from those conditions that may affect layout phasing of the construction anything like that. >> We are talking about the 25 foot which is part of the local bylaw. Is that something that was conceded by the applicant that they that they would follow in the ZBA hearing a >> as so at the ZBA hearing we were going to respect the 25 of buffer off the wetland line and our project will continue to do so even as shown here we've already pulled the limit of work back to be 25 ft off the Beals and Thomas' plant. So as I as I stated previously there is no that we're respecting the 25 foot buffer.
⚗ AI-reconstructed · cite from original above